Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-gxg78 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-23T05:42:41.112Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

ALCOHOL AND POLITICS IN TWENTIETH-CENTURY BRITAIN

Part of: Historiographical Reviews

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  28 September 2018

RYOSUKE YOKOE
RYOSUKE YOKOE*
Affiliation:
University of Sheffield
*
Department of History, Jessop West, 1 Upper Hanover Street, Sheffield, s3 7ra[email protected]
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

This review surveys recent developments in the historiography of the politics of alcohol in twentieth-century Britain. The ‘drink question’ has undergone a set of tumultuous shifts, beginning with the decline of the temperance movement after the First World War, diminished conflict in the interwar and post-1945 periods, and the revived concerns over consumption and harm in the late twentieth century. Historians have traditionally presented the drink question as a binary conflict between advocates and opponents of the liberal distribution of drink. Newer narratives question the assumed ‘rationality’ of modern approaches to alcohol, especially concerning the post-1970s public health model which has been increasingly understood as an indirect manifestation of the temperance movement. The concept of ‘moral panics’ has been frequently employed to frame the formation of public attitudes towards drink. The article argues that these multifarious developments illustrate how alcohol offers a unique vantage point into various social developments in modern Britain, including that of the changing role of the state, the contested nature of scientific knowledge, and the formation of public opinion. It also suggests that the historiography should overcome its narrow focus on alcohol in modern Britain by juxtaposing it with other substances, regions, and periods.

Type
Historiographical Review
Information
The Historical Journal , Volume 62 , Issue 1 , March 2019 , pp. 267 - 287
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 2018 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Footnotes

The author thanks Medical Humanities Sheffield and the Department of History at the University of Sheffield for providing financial assistance for the completion of this review. The author is additionally grateful to Adrian Bingham, Sarah Kenny, Miklós Kürthy, Alex Taylor, Mary Vincent, and Phil Withington for comments and feedback.

References

1 The standard texts on the Victorian temperance movement include Harrison, Brian, Drink and the Victorians: the temperance question in England, 1815–1872 (London, 1971)Google Scholar; and Shiman, Lilian Lewis, Crusade against drink in Victorian England (London, 1988)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

2 Duncan, Robert, Pubs and patriots: the drink crisis in Britain during World War One (Liverpool, 2013)CrossRefGoogle Scholar, p. 3.

3 Anti-alcohol temperance movements were politically influential in most countries in North America and northern Europe. Among them, Britain, Ireland, and Sweden did not undergo total prohibition.

4 Baggott, Rob, Alcohol, politics and social policy (Aldershot, 1990)Google Scholar; Thom, Betsy, Dealing with drink: alcohol and social policy from treatment to management (London, 1999)Google Scholar; Greenaway, John, Drink and British politics since 1830: a study in policy-making (Basingstoke, 2003)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

5 Nicholls, James, The politics of alcohol: a history of the drink question in England (Manchester, 2009), p. 132CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

6 Gutzke, David W., Pubs and progressives: reinventing the public house in England, 1896–1960 (DeKalb, IL, 2005)Google Scholar; Yeomans, Henry, Alcohol and moral regulation: public attitudes, spirited measures and Victorian hangovers (Bristol, 2014)Google Scholar.

7 Woiak, Joanne, ‘“A medical Cromwell to depose King Alcohol”: medical scientists, temperance reformers, and the alcohol problem in Britain’, Social History/Historie Sociale, 27.54 (1994), pp. 337–65Google Scholar; Kneale, James and French, Shaun, ‘Moderate drinking before the unit: medicine and life assurance in Britain and the US, c. 1860–1930’, Drugs: Education, Prevention and Policy, 22 (2015), pp. 111–17Google Scholar.

8 Nicholls, The politics of alcohol, pp. 107, 116–17, 257–9.

9 Ibid., p. 116.

10 Ibid., pp. 116–20.

11 Joyce, Patrick, The state of freedom: a social history of the British state since 1800 (Cambridge, 2013)CrossRefGoogle Scholar, p. 6.

12 Ibid., p. 39.

13 Schrad, Mark Lawrence, Vodka politics: alcohol, autocracy, and the secret history of the Russian state (Oxford, 2014)Google Scholar, p. xiii.

14 Courtwright, David T., Forces of habit: drugs and the making of the modern world (Cambridge, MA, 2002), p. 5Google Scholar.

15 Yeomans, Alcohol and moral regulation.

16 Gourvish, T. R. and Wilson, R. G., The British brewing industry, 1830–1980 (Cambridge, 1994)Google Scholar; Weir, Ronald B., The history of the Distillers Company, 1877–1939: diversification and growth in whisky and chemicals (Oxford, 1995)Google Scholar; Mutch, Alistair, Strategic and organizational change from production to retailing in UK brewing, 1950–1990 (Abingdon, 2006)Google Scholar.

17 Jennings, Paul, The local: a history of the English pub (2nd edn, Brimscombe, 2011)Google Scholar.

18 Gutzke, Pubs and progressives. Gutzke describes ‘progressivism’ as a transatlantic phenomenon. The term, generally unfamiliar in the British political context, is associated with the progressive era (1890s–1920s) of the United States where the government implemented sweeping social reforms to mitigate the problems of rapid industrialization, urbanization, and political corruption.

19 Ibid., p. 5.

20 Nicholls, The politics of alcohol, pp. 181–3.

21 Gutzke, David W., Women drinking out in Britain since the early twentieth century (Manchester, 2014)Google Scholar.

22 Nicholls, The politics of alcohol, pp. 158–9.

23 Woiak, ‘“A medical Cromwell”’, pp. 360–4. The term ‘moderationist’ was first used in the nineteenth century by prohibitionists and teetotallers as a pejorative for more moderate temperance campaigners who went only as far as to oppose drunkenness and the consumption of spirits while tolerating ‘moderate’ drinking.

24 The argument derives from Anon., Alcohol: its action on the human organism (New York, NY, 1918), pp. 125–32.

25 Woiak, ‘“A medical Cromwell”’, p. 362.

26 Green, S. J. D., The passing of Protestant England: secularisation and social change, c. 1920–1960 (Cambridge, 2011), pp. 142–6Google Scholar.

27 Kneale and French, ‘Moderate drinking before the unit’, p. 111.

28 Ibid., pp. 111–17

29 Ibid., pp. 113–14.

30 Nicholls dedicates only a chapter for the entire period between 1918 to the 1970s, in The politics of alcohol, pp. 180–98. While Yeomans highlights the emergence of new campaigns against drunk driving and underage drinking in Alcohol and moral regulation, p. 158, he was also inclined to admit that these efforts were relatively tame compared to that of other periods.

31 Nicholls, The politics of alcohol, p. 188; Yeomans, Alcohol and moral regulation, p. 139.

32 Glover, Brian, Brewing for victory: brewers, beer and pubs in World War II (Cambridge, 1995)Google Scholar; Nicholls, The politics of alcohol, p. 190.

33 Malleck, Dan, Try to control yourself: the regulation of public drinking in post-prohibition Ontario, 1927–1944 (Vancouver, BC, 2013)Google Scholar.

34 The possible exception to this is Burnett's, John Liquid pleasures: a social history of drink in modern Britain (London, 1999)Google Scholar, exploring a myriad of alcoholic and non-alcoholic beverages, though the account on beer, wine, and spirits in the twentieth century is still predominantly driven by a top-down narrative.

35 Quoted in Gutzke, Women drinking, p. 1.

36 Marshall, Mac, ed., Beliefs, behaviors, and alcoholic beverages: a cross-cultural survey (Ann Arbor, MI, 1979)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Douglas, Mary, ed., Constructive drinking: perspectives on drink from anthropology (Cambridge, 1987)Google Scholar.

37 Criblez, Adam [review], ‘David W. Gutzke, Pubs and progressives: reinventing the public house in England, 1896–1960 (DeKalb, IL, 2005)’, History: Reviews of New Books, 34 (2006), p. 51Google Scholar; Fenton, Laura [review], ‘David W. Gutzke, Women drinking out in Britain since the early twentieth century (Manchester, 2014)’, Women's History Review, 26 (2016), pp. 308–10CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

38 Brennan, Thomas, Public drinking and popular culture in eighteenth-century France (Princeton, NJ, 1988)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Tlusty, B. Ann, Bacchus and civic order: the culture of drink in early modern Germany (Charlottesville, VA, 2001)Google Scholar; Withington, Phil, ‘Intoxication and the early modern city’, in Hindle, Steve, Shepard, Alexandra, and Walter, John, eds., Remaking English society (Woodbridge, 2013), pp. 135–65Google Scholar; Hailwood, Mark, Alehouses and good fellowship in early modern England (Woodbridge, 2014)Google Scholar.

39 Jones, Colin and Porter, Roy, ‘Introduction’, in Jones, Colin and Porter, Roy, eds., Reassessing Foucault: power, medicine and the body (London, 1994), pp. 1–3Google Scholar.

40 Greenaway, Drink and British politics, p. 112; Marwick, Arthur, The deluge: British society and the First World War (London, 1965), pp. 62–8Google Scholar.

41 Duncan, Pubs and patriots; Yeomans, Alcohol and moral regulation, pp. 97–127.

42 Yeomans, Alcohol and moral regulation.

43 Jordanova, Ludmilla, ‘The social construction of medical knowledge’, Social History of Medicine, 8 (1995), pp. 361–81CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed.

44 Jennings, The local, p. 183.

45 Nicholls, The politics of alcohol, pp. 155–8.

46 French, David, ‘The rise and fall of business as usual’, in Burk, Kathleen, ed., War and state: the transformation of British government, 1914–1918 (London, 1982), pp. 7–31Google Scholar.

47 Duncan, Pubs and patriots.

48 Greenaway, Drink and British politics, p. 112.

49 Nicholls, The politics of alcohol, pp. 150–9.

50 Duncan, Pubs and patriots, p. 101.

51 Ibid., p. 133.

52 Greenaway, Drink and British politics, p. 141.

53 Duncan, Pubs and patriots, p. 121.

54 Older accounts have disputed whether state purchase should be deemed a genuine ‘temperance’ solution. See Turner, John, ‘State purchase of the liquor trade in the First World War’, Historical Journal, 23 (1980), p. 614CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

55 Duncan, Pubs and patriots, pp. 185–6.

56 Gutzke, Pubs and progressives, p. 67.

57 Yeomans, Alcohol and moral regulation, p. 121. Older accounts framed the significance of the wartime controls within the hindsight of the eventual demise of the temperance movement and the failure to implement prohibition in interwar Britain, allegedly caused by the demonstrated effectiveness of the CCB's alcohol controls.

58 Jennings, Paul, A history of drink and the English, 1500–2000 (Abingdon, 2016), p. 24CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

59 Nicholls, The politics of alcohol, p. 196.

60 Jennings, A history of drink, pp. 169–70.

61 An account of this intellectual shift can be found in Valverde, Mariana, Diseases of the will: alcohol and the dilemmas of freedom (Cambridge, 1998)Google Scholar.

62 Foucault, Michel, Security, territory, population: lectures at the Collège de France, 1977–1978, trans. Macey, David (London, 2003), pp. 253–63Google Scholar.

63 Yeomans, Alcohol and moral regulation, pp. 226–31.

64 Virginia Berridge discusses how the field of alcohol and drugs history has expanded considerably since the 1980s, in ‘History and its contribution to understanding addiction and society’, Addiction, 110 (2015), pp. 23–6.

65 Nicholls, The politics of alcohol, pp. 1–4; Yeomans, Alcohol and moral regulation, pp. 1–3.

66 Kneale and French are geographers, Greenaway is a political scientist, Yeomans is a criminologist, and Nicholls is a prominent researcher in alcohol and public health policy. Rob Baggott and Betsy Thom are also experts in health policy.

67 Baggott, Alcohol, politics and social policy.

68 Ibid., p. 13.

69 Thom, Dealing with drink.

70 Ibid., p. 15.

71 Beck, Ulrich, Risk society: towards a new modernity (New Delhi, 1992)Google Scholar; Giddens, Anthony, ‘Risk and responsibility’, Modern Law Review, 62 (1999), pp. 1–10CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

72 Yeomans, Alcohol and moral regulation, p. 228.

73 Ibid., p. 229.

74 Greenaway, Drink and British politics, pp. 178, 182; Courtwright, Forces of habit, p. 205; Berridge, Virginia, Demons: our changing attitudes to alcohol, tobacco, & drugs (Oxford, 2013), p. 226Google Scholar.

75 Room, Robin, ‘Alcohol control and public health’, Annual Review of Public Health, 5 (1984), p. 295CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed.

76 Yeomans, Alcohol and moral regulation, p. 226.

77 Bruun, Kettil, Edwards, Griffith, Lumio, Martti, Mäkelä, Klaus, Pan, Lynn, Popham, Robert E., Room, Robin, Schmidt, Wolfgang, Skog, Ole-Jørgen, Sulkunen, Pekka, and Österberg, Esa, Alcohol control policies in public health perspective (Helsinki, 1975)Google Scholar.

78 Ibid., pp. 12–13.

79 Yeomans, Alcohol and moral regulation, p. 219.

80 Ibid., pp. 137, 222.

81 Ibid., p. 233.

82 Nicholls, The politics of alcohol, p. 206.

83 Ibid., pp. 206–7.

84 Jennings, A history of drink, p. 170.

85 One of the earliest scholars to explore the impact of social and cultural factors in the construction of scientific knowledge was Fleck, Ludwik in Entstehung und entwicklung einer wissenschaftlichen tatsache (Basel, 1935)Google Scholar. Ludmilla Jordanova places social constructionism within the context of the history of medicine, in ‘The social construction of medical knowledge’, pp. 361–81.

86 Jones and Porter, ‘Introduction’, pp. 1–3.

87 Berridge, Virginia and Edwards, Griffith, Opium and the people: opiate use in nineteenth-century England (London, 1981), pp. 150–72Google Scholar.

88 Pancaldi, Giuliano, ‘Rational/irrational’, in Heilbron, J. L., Bartholomew, James, Bennett, Jim, Holmes, Frederic L., Laudan, Rachel, and Pancaldi, Giuliano, eds., The Oxford companion to the history of modern science (Oxford, 2003), p. 709Google Scholar.

89 Baggott, Alcohol, politics and social policy, p. 13.

90 Beckingham, David, ‘Gender, space, and drunkenness: Liverpool's licensed premises, 1860–1914’, Annals of the Association of American Geographers, 102 (2012), pp. 647–66CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

91 Berridge, Demons, p. 226.

92 Woiak, ‘“A medical Cromwell”’, p. 360.

93 Yeomans, Alcohol and moral regulation, pp. 13–16.

94 Cohen, Stanley, Folk devils and moral panics: the creation of Mods and Rockers (3rd edn, London, 2011), p. 9CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

95 Ibid., pp. 150–65.

96 Moss, Stella, ‘“An abnormal habit”: alcohol policy and the control of methylated spirit drinking in England in the 1920s and 1930s’, Drugs: Education, Prevention and Policy, 22 (2015), pp. 118–24Google Scholar.

97 Bentley, Michael, Modern historiography: an introduction (Abingdon, 2005), pp. 129–38CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

98 Cohen, Folk devils, p. vii.

99 Yeomans, Alcohol and moral regulation, p. 16.

100 Ibid., p. 16.

101 Duncan, Pubs and patriots, p. 13.

102 Rowe, David, ‘The concept of the moral panic: a historico-sociological positioning’, in Lemmings, David and Walker, Claire, eds., Moral panics, the media and the law in early modern England (Basingstoke, 2009), pp. 31Google Scholar, 34.

103 Berridge, Demons, p. 5.

104 Ibid., p. 5.

105 Gusfield, Joseph R., Contested meanings: the construction of alcohol problems (Madison, WI, 1996), p. 12Google Scholar.

106 Edwards, Griffith, Matters of substance: drugs, and why everyone's a user (New York, NY, 2004), p. xxxviiGoogle Scholar.

107 Dingle, A. E., The campaign for prohibition in Victorian England: the United Kingdom Alliance, 1872–1895 (London, 1980)Google Scholar; Harrison, Drink and the Victorians; Shiman, Crusade against drink.

108 Nutt, David J., King, Leslie A., and Phillips, Lawrence D., ‘Drug harms in the UK: a multicriteria decision analysis’, The Lancet, 376.9752 (2010), pp. 1558–65CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed.

109 Sherratt, Andrew, ‘Introduction: peculiar substances’, in Goodman, Jordan, Lovejoy, Paul E., and Sherratt, Andrew, eds., Consuming habits: global and historical perspectives in how cultures define drugs (London, 2007), p. 34Google Scholar; Withington, Phil, ‘Introduction: cultures of intoxication’, Past and Present, 222 (2014), pp. 9–33CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

110 Malleck, Try to control yourself; Schrad, Vodka politics; McGirr, Lisa, The war on alcohol: prohibition and the rise of the American state (New York, NY, 2015)Google Scholar.