Article contents
Ancient Mythology and Revolutionary Ideology in Ireland, 1878–1916
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 11 February 2009
Extract
Perhaps some justification is needed for yet another study on the literary background of the Easter 1916 Rising. Certainly the ‘high’ literature, represented by such writers as Yeats, AE, Synge and the three insurrection poet-fighters (Pearse, MacDonagh and Plunkett) has already been extensively analysed by a number of scholars. However, it is usually forgotten that numerous ‘popular’ authors were also writing in the forty years before 1916; authors who might be expected, if only by virtue of their numbers, to command a considerable readership. Names such as Joseph Campbell, Ethna Carberry, Nora Hopper, Seumas MacManus, Alice Milligan and Seumas O’Sullivan are unknown today except in occasional references by literary critics, yet these writers produced a great deal of verse on national topics, and were close to the general public and its preoccupations. Their work deserves the attention of historians; for only by identifying common ground between the ‘high’ and the ‘low’ literature can one explore with any confidence the complex relationship between that literature as a whole and Irish society during this period. This I hope to do in the following pages.
- Type
- Articles
- Information
- Copyright
- Copyright © Cambridge University Press 1983
References
1 I should like to thank Dr Brendan Bradshaw of Queens’ college for much valuable advice, encouragement and criticism, and Dr Sheila Lawlor of Sidney Sussex college for reading and commenting on the manuscript.
2 E.g. Thompson, W. I., The imagination of an insurrection(New York, 1967)Google Scholar; Loftus, R. J., Nationalism in modern Anglo-Irish poetry(Madison and Milwaukee, 1964)Google Scholar; Nicholas, Mansergh, The Irish question 1840–1921(London, 1965), ch. viGoogle Scholar; Lyons, F. S. L., Ireland since the famine(London, 1973 edn), pp. 329–39Google Scholar; Lyons, F. S. L., Culture and anarchy in Ireland 1980–1939(Oxford, 1979), ch. iv.Google Scholar
3 For example the Aisling tradition, depicting Ireland as a beautiful woman mourning past glories, was developed by eighteenth-century Irish poets and recurs frequently right up to 1916. See Daniel, Corkery, The hidden Ireland(Dublin, 1925).Google Scholar
4 For a summary of the saga and critical comments see Douglas, Hyde, Literary history of Ireland(London, 1899), ch. xiiiGoogle Scholar; Gerard, Murphy, Saga and myth in ancient Ireland(Dublin, 1961).Google Scholar
5 Hyde, Literary history, p. 293.
6 Hyde, Ibid., ch. xiv; Blacam, Aodh de, Gaelic literature surveyed(Dublin, 1973 edn), ch. ii.Google Scholar
7 The ancient Irish epic tale Tain Bo Cuailnge, tr. Joseph, Dunn (London, 1914), p. 71.Google Scholar
8 de Blacam, Gaelic literature, p. 36.
9 For the Fenians, see Hyde, Literary history, ch. xxix; de Blacam, Gaelic literature, ch. iii; Gerard, Murphy, Ossianic lore(Cork, 1955)Google Scholar. For a full translation, Duanaire Firm(2 vols., London, 1908 and 1933), tr. Eoin MacNeill (I) and Gerard Murphy (II).Google Scholar
10 Gerard, Murphy, Duanaire Finn(Dublin, 1953), introduction.Google Scholar
11 Cuchulain goes over to Scathach, a warrior queen in Scotland, to learn the art of warfare, and another Scottish queen, Aoife, bears his son; in neither case is a serious distinction made between Scottish and Irish.
12 Augusta, Gregory, Cuchulain of Muirthemru(Gerrards Cross, 1970), dedication.Google Scholar
13 According to Douglas Hyde writing in the 1890s, when the subject ‘Deirdre’ was set for the vice chancellor's prize in Trinity college Dublin ‘a few years ago’, the students did not know who or what Deirdre was. Hyde, Literary history, p. 303, footnote.
14 O’Grady, S. J., History of Ireland(2 vols., London, 1878 and 1880).Google Scholar
15 There were sporadic signs before O’Grady that popular interest in the myths was reviving slightly. From 1858 the Fenian movement looked back in its title to the conception of the Fianna as the national militia. In 1865 Sir Samuel Ferguson published Lays of the western Gael, including poems on the death of Diarmuid, the lament of Deirdre and the abdication of Fergus Mac Roy; in 1877 R. D. Joyce's Deirdrecame out in Boston. But these were isolated developments which had little impact in Ireland. Those Fenians interested in ancient Irish were almost all based in America-R. D. Joyce, for example. Irish Fenians concentrated on violent revolution. And Ferguson's work, though ultimately seen as a significant precursor of the Literary Revival, never achieved wide popular acclaim, being scholarly and in somewhat pedantic verse.
16 Related in Ernest, Boyd, Ireland's literary renaissance(Dublin, 1916), p. 27.Google Scholar
17 O’Grady, History,1, 23.
18 Ibid. 11, 267.
19 Ibid. 1, xiv (introduction).
20 Tain,(above note 7), p. 144.
21 Ibid. p. 144.
22 O’Grady, History, 1,148–9
23 AE (George, Russell), Some Irish essays(Dublin, 1906), p. 21.Google Scholar
24 E.g. Eleanor, Hull, The Cuchulain saga in Irish literature(London, 1898)Google Scholar, and Cuchulain the hound of Ulster(London, 1909), quoted passages verbatim from O’Grady's work.Google Scholar
25 O’Grady, S. J., Cuchulain: an epic(London, 1892)Google Scholar; The coming of Cuchulain(London, 1894)Google Scholar; Finn and his companions(London, 1894)Google Scholar; In the gates of the north(London, 1901).Google Scholar
26 Augusta, Gregory, Cuchulain of Muirthemne(Dublin, 1902)Google Scholar; Gods and fighting men(Dublin, 1904).Google Scholar
27 Yeats, W. B., Autobiographies(London, 1961 edn), p. 220Google Scholar; AE, The living torch(London, 1938), p. 145; Boyd, Literary renaissance, p. 51.Google Scholar
28 For examples of Young Ireland and Fenian poetry, see Casey, J. K., The rising of the moon(Glasgow, 1869)Google Scholar; James, Clarence Mangan, Poems(Dublin, 1903 edn)Google Scholar; Kelly, Mary E., Poems of ‘ Eva of the Nation’(Dublin, 1909).Google Scholar
29 Thomas, Davis, Essays and poems with a centenary memoir,(Dublin, 1945), pp. 93–118, 183–230.Google Scholar
30 E.g. Fahy, F. A., Irish songs and poems(Dublin, 1887)Google Scholar; Sullivan, T. D., Selected poems(Dublin, 1899)Google Scholar; Martin, MacDermott (ed.), Poems and ballads of Young Ireland(Dublin, 1896).Google Scholar
31 Alice, Milligan, Hero lays(Dublin, 1908).Google Scholar
32 Thomas, Boyd, Poems(Dublin, 1908).Google Scholar
33 Augusta, Gregory (ed.), Ideals in Ireland(London, 1901), p. 25.Google Scholar
34 Ibid. p. 39.
35 Lyons, Culture,(above note 2). Lyons observes that many protestant, Trinity-educated men were in the forefront of cultural revivalism - notably Ferguson, Davis, and later Douglas Hyde. The Anglo-Irish initiative brought them close to the native Irish view of themselves as a great and heroic people. Thus the two sides could temporarily co-operate in seeking a distinctive national culture.
36 Yeats, , AE, , Larminie, , John, Eglinton, Literary ideals in Ireland(London, 1899), p. 87.Google Scholar
37 Gregory, Ideals, p. 16.
38 For good examples of religious mysticism, see Darrell, Figgis, A vision of life(London, 1909)Google Scholar; The crucible qftime(London, 1911)Google Scholar; The mount of transfiguration(Dublin, 1915). For Young Ireland, above notes 28 and 30.Google Scholar
39 Katharine, Tynan, Louise de la Valliere(London, 1885), ‘Waiting’.Google Scholar
40 Milligan, Lays,‘The Horsemen of Aileach’.
41 Ella, Young, Poems(Dublin, 1906).Google Scholar
42 Seumas, O’Sullivan, The twilight people(Dublin, 1905).Google Scholar
43 Shane, Leslie, Songs of Oriel(Dublin, 1908), ‘Ireland today’.Google Scholar
44 Lionel, Johnson, Poems(London, 1895), ‘Ways of war’.Google Scholar
45 Joseph, Campbell, The rushlight(Dublin, 1906), ‘The beggar's wake’.Google Scholar
46 McEntee, J. F., Poems(London and Dublin, 1917), ‘Shadows of song’.Google Scholar
47 William, Larminie, Fand(Dublin, 1892), ‘Moytura’.Google Scholar
48 Terence, MacSwiney, Despite fools laughter(Dublin, 1944), ‘The prophecy of Fionn’.Google Scholar
49 Seumas, MacManus, Ballads of a country boy(Dublin, 1905), ‘Tyrconnel’.Google Scholar
50 Cousins, James H., Collected poems(Madras, 1940).Google Scholar
51 Seumas, O’Sullivan, The earth lover(Dublin, 1909), ‘At sunset’.Google Scholar
52 Edward, Martyn, Maeve(London, 1899).Google Scholar
53 Among the versions were Douglas, Hyde, The three sorrows of story telling(Dublin, 1895)Google Scholar; John, Todhunter, Three Irish bardic tales(London, 1896)Google Scholar; AE, , Deirdre(Dublin, 1906)Google Scholar; Yeats, W. B., Deirdre(in Collected Plays(London, 1956))Google Scholar; Synge, J. M., Deirdre of the sorrows(in Collected Works(4 vols., London, 1968), iv).Google Scholar
54 Synge, Deirdre, p. 237.
55 Eva, Gore-Booth, Unseen kings(London, 1904).Google Scholar
56 Milligan, Lays.
57 O’Sullivan, Earth lover,(above note 51).
58 Ethna, Carberry, The four winds of Eirinn(Dublin, 1902)Google Scholar, ‘The shadow house of Lugh.’
59 Lionel, Johnson, Ireland and other poems(London, 1897).Google Scholar
60 Dora, Sigerson Shorter, Love of Ireland(Dublin, 1916).Google Scholar
61 William, Larminie, Glanlua(London, 1899), ‘The return of the gods.’Google Scholar
62 Pearse, P. H., The story of a success, ed. Desmond, Ryan, (Dublin, 1917), p. 7.Google Scholar
63 Desmond, Ryan (ed.), The 1916 poets(Dublin, 1963), p. 196.Google Scholar
64 Boyd, Poems, and Gore-Booth, Kings.
65 Nora, Hopper, Ballads in prose(London, 1894).Google Scholar
66 Joseph, Campbell, The mountainy singer(Dublin, 1909), ‘Fragment’.Google Scholar
67 Susan, Mitchell, The living chalice(Dublin and London, 1913), ‘The army of the voice.’Google Scholar
68 Cousins, James H., Etain the beloved(Dublin, 1912), ‘A schoolboy plays Cuchulain.’Google Scholar
69 Thomas, MacDonagh, Through the ivory gate(Dublin, 1903), ‘To Cuchulain.’Google Scholar
70 Campbell, Singer,‘I am the Man Child.’
71 Yeats, Plays.
72 Joseph, Campbell, Irishry(Dublin, 1913), ‘The antiquary’.Google Scholar
73 Carberry, Four winds,‘ For Lord Edward Fitzgerald’.
74 Pearse, Success, p. 75.
75 Ryan (ed.), Poets, p. 132, ‘Wishes for my son’.
76 Graves, A. P., Irish poems(Dublin, 1908).Google Scholar
77 ‘Clare's Dragoons’ is a good example of Davis's poetry: When on Ramillies’ bloody field The baffled French were forced to yield, The victor Saxon backward reeled Before the charge of Clare's dragoons. The flags we conquered in that fray Look lonely in Ypres’ choir they say, We’ll win them company today Or bravely die like Clare’s dragoons.
78 ‘Did that play of mine send out/Certain men the English shot?’ Yeats, , Collected poems(London, 1961), ‘The man and the echo’.Google Scholar
79 O’Sullivan, Earth lover,‘The onlooker’.
80 For full analyses of Pearse's thought, see Thompson, , Imagination, Loftus, Nationalism, and also Ruth Dudley Edwards, Patrick Pearse-the triumph of failure(London, 1977)Google Scholar. We are still awaiting a satisfactory general outline and analysis of sanguinary themes in European literature just before the First World War. Clarke, I. F., Ancestral voices prophesying war 1783–1984(Oxford, 1966), has interesting details on the ‘realistic’ military writers.Google Scholar
81 Quoted in Martin, F. X. (ed.), The Irish Volunteers(Dublin, 1963), p. 129.Google Scholar
82 Ibid. pp. 81–2, 135.
83 Ella, Young, Flowering dusk(London, 1947), p. 71.Google Scholar
84 Bulmer, Hobson, Ireland yesterday and tomorrow(Tralee, 1968), p. 1.Google Scholar
85 Pearse, Success, p. 90.
86 See ‘Easter 1916’, ‘The rose tree’, ‘The O’Rahilly‘, ‘The statues’, in Yeats, Poems.
87 AE, , Collected poems(London, 1926), ‘Michael’.Google Scholar
88 James, Stephens, Collected poems(London, 1926), ‘Spring’.Google Scholar
89 Joseph, Campbell, Poems, ed. Austin, Clarke (Dublin, 1963), ‘Raven's rock’.Google Scholar
90 Seumas, O’Sullivan, Collected poems(Dublin, 1940), ‘Requiem’.Google Scholar
91 Maeve, Cavanagh, A voice of insurgency(Dublin, 1916), p. 22.Google Scholar
92 Padraic, Gregory, Complete collected ballads 1912–32(London, 1935), ‘Ave Hibernia! Morituri te salutant!’.Google Scholar
93 Pearse, P. H., Collected works-plays, stories and poems(London and Dublin, 1917), introduction by P. Browne.Google Scholar
94 Clery, A. E. (ed.), Poets of the insurrection(Dublin, 1918), ‘P. H. Pearse’ by Cathaoir O Braonain, pp. 2–3.Google Scholar
95 Ibid. ‘J. M. Plunkett’, by P. McBrien, p. 26.
96 McEntee, Poems,‘To R. C’.
97 Cousins, Poems,‘In memory of Francis Sheehy Skeffington’, footnote.
98 Cavanagh, A voice, p. 52.
99 See Luing, Sean O, I die in a good cause(Tralee, 1970), ch. iv.Google Scholar
100 Ibid. Appendix i, p. 212.
101 See above, note 48.
102 MacSwiney, Despite fools,‘A prayer’. See also ‘The dawn’, ‘Strength’.
103 Ernie, O’Malley, On another man's wound(London, 1936), p. 44.Google Scholar
104 Andrews, C. S., Dublin made me(Dublin and Cork, 1979), p. 109.Google Scholar
105 Ibid. p. 241.
106 Ibid. p. 201.
107 Dan, Breen, My fight for Irish freedom(Dublin, 1924), p. 153.Google Scholar
108 Frank, Gallagher (pseudonym David Logan), The four glorious years(Dublin, 1953).Google Scholar
109 Faolain, Sean O, Vive moi(London, 1965), p. 149.Google Scholar
110 See above, note 65.
- 1
- Cited by