Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-fscjk Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-27T08:08:19.504Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Program design, implementation and performance: the case of social health insurance in India

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  27 July 2018

Dayashankar Maurya Open the ORCID record for Dayashankar Maurya [Opens in a new window]  and
M. Ramesh
Dayashankar Maurya*
Affiliation:
Chairperson Healthcare Management, T.A. Pai Management Institute, Karnataka, India
M. Ramesh
Affiliation:
UNESCO Chair on Social Policy Design in Asia, Lee Kuan Yew School of Public Policy, National University of Singapore, Bukit Timah, Singapore
*
*Correspondence to: Dayashankar Maurya, Assistant Professor and Chairperson Healthcare Management, T.A. Pai Management Institute, P B. No. 9 Manipal, Karnataka 576104, India. Email: [email protected]
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Published works on health insurance tend to focus on program design and its impact, neglecting the implementation process that links the two and affects outcomes. This paper examines the National Health Insurance [Rashtriya Swasthya Bima Yojana (RSBY)] in India with the objective of assessing the role of implementation structures and processes in shaping performance. The central question that the paper addresses is: why does the performance of RSBY vary across states despite similar program design? Using a comparative case study approach analyzing the program’s functioning in three states, it finds the answer in the differences in governance of implementation. The unavoidable gaps in design of health care program allow abundant scope for opportunistic behavior on the part of different stakeholders. The study finds that the performance of the program, as a result, depends on the extent to which the governance mechanism is able to contain and channel opportunistic behavior during implementation. By opening up the black box of implementation, the paper contributes to improving the performance of national health insurance in India and elsewhere.

Type
Articles
Information
Health Economics, Policy and Law , Volume 14 , Issue 4 , October 2019 , pp. 487 - 508
Copyright
© Cambridge University Press 2018 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Agyepong, I. A. and Richard, A. N. (2011), ‘We charge them; otherwise we cannot run the hospital front line workers, clients and health financing policy implementation gaps in Ghana’, Health Policy, 99(3): 226–233.Google Scholar
Amar Ujala (2014), Healthcard scandal opens, 11 January, http://www.amarujala.com/lucknow/health-card-scandal-opens [19 February 2015].Google Scholar
Amirkhanyan, A. A., Kim, H. J. and Lambright, K. T. (2011), ‘Closer than “arms length”: understanding the factors associated with collaborative contracting’, The American Review of Public Administration, 42(3): 341–366.Google Scholar
Asher, M., Vora, Y. and Maurya, D. (2015), ‘An analysis of selected pension and health care initiatives for informal sector workers in India’, Social Policy & Administration, 49(6): 738–751.Google Scholar
Atuoye, K. N., Siera, V., Roger, A., Sylvester, Z. G. and Isaac, L. (2016), ‘Financial sustainability versus access and quality in a challenged health system: an examination of the capitation policy debate in Ghana’, Health Policy and Planning, 31(9): 1240–1249.Google Scholar
Bali, A. S. and Ramesh, M. (2015), ‘Mark Time: India’s March to universal health care coverage’, Social Policy & Administration, 49(6): 718–737.Google Scholar
Bansak, C. and Raphel, S. (2007), ‘The effects of state policy design features on take-up and crowd-out rates for the State Children’s Health Insurance Program’, Journal of Policy Analysis and Management, 26(1): 149–175.Google Scholar
Báscolo, E. and Natalia, Y. (2009), ‘Governance and the effectiveness of the Buenos Aires public health insurance implementation process’, The Journal of Ambulatory Care Management, 32(2): 91–102.Google Scholar
Bearing Point (2008), Private voluntary health insurance in India: promise and reality. United States Agency for International Development, http://transition.usaid.gov/in/our_work/pdfs/promise_reality.pdf [7 March 2014].Google Scholar
Bertone, M. P. and Bruno, M. (2013), ‘Studying the link between Institutions and Health System Performance: a framework and an illustration with the analysis of two performance-based financing schemes in Burundi’, Health Policy and Planning, 28(8): 847–857.Google Scholar
Brown, T. L., Potoski, M. and Slyke, D. V. (2015), ‘Managing complex contracts: a theoretical approach’, Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory, 26(2): 294–308.Google Scholar
Bhat, R. (2005), ‘Prelimany analysis of claims data to understand relationship between disease patterns and quality of care and its implication for health insurance in India’ Working Paper, Ahmedabad, http://www.iimahd.ernet.in/publications/data/2005-09-03ramesh.pdf [22 March 2015].Google Scholar
Caniëls, M. C. J., Gelderman, C. J. and Vermeulen, N. P. (2012), ‘The interplay of governance mechanisms in complex procurement projects’, Journal of Purchasing and Supply Management, 18(2): 113–121.Google Scholar
Carey, G., McLoughlin, P. and Crammond, B. (2015), ‘Implementing joined-up government: lessons from the Australian Social Inclusion Agenda’, Australian Journal of Public Administration, 74(2): 176–186.Google Scholar
Chandrashekhar, H. (2009), ‘Challenges in Health Insurance in India’, National Summit Indian Insurance the Way Forward, ASSOCHAM, New Delhi.Google Scholar
Deccan Herald (2013), ‘Insurance firms told to settle RSBY claims’. 26 October 2013, http://www.deccanherald.com/content/365545/insurance-firms-told-settle-rsby.html [22 March 2015].Google Scholar
Desai, S. (2009), ‘Keeping the “health” in health insurance’. Economic and Political Weekly, 18–21.Google Scholar
Ekman, B., Liem, N. T., Duc, H. A. and Axelson, H. (2008), ‘Health insurance reform in Vietnam: a review of recent developments and future challenges’, Health Policy and Planning, 23: 252–263.Google Scholar
Feder, J. M. (1977), ‘Medicare implementation and the policy process’, Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law, 2(2): 173–189.Google Scholar
Fernandez, S. (2009), ‘Understanding contracting performance: an empirical analysis’, Administration & Society, 41(1): 67–100.Google Scholar
Frazier, G. L., Spekman, R. E. and O’Neal, C. R. (1988), ‘Just-in-time exchange relationships in industrial markets’, The Journal of Marketing, 52(4):52–67.Google Scholar
Gilson, L., Helen, S. and Marsha, O. (2014), ‘Practice and power: a review and interpretive synthesis focused on the exercise of discretionary power in policy implementation by front-line providers and managers’, Health Policy and Planning, 29(3): iii51–iii69.Google Scholar
Gow, H. R., Deborah, H. S. and Johan, F. M. (2000), ‘How private contract enforcement mechanisms can succeed where public institutions fail: the case of Juhocukor as’, Agricultural Economics, 23(3): 253–265.Google Scholar
Government of Uttar Pradesh (2011), ‘Rashtriya Swasthya Bima Yojana’, http://rsby.up.nic.in/ [11 April 2014].Google Scholar
Grzymala-Busse, A. (2010), ‘The best laid plans: the impact of informal rules on formal institutions in transitional regimes’, Studies in Comparative International Development, 45(3): 311–333.Google Scholar
Hadfield, G. K. (2005), ‘The Many Legal Institutions That Support Contractual Commitments’, in Menard, Claude, Shirley, Mary M. (eds), Handbook of New Institutional Economics. Boston, MA: Springer, 175–203.Google Scholar
Hanson, K. (2014), ‘Achieving the promise of universal coverage – the role for strategic purchasing’, BMC Health Services Research, 14(2): O14.Google Scholar
Hart, O. and Moore, J. (1999), ‘Foundations of incomplete contracts’, The Review of Economic Studies, 66(1): 115–138.Google Scholar
Hart, O., Shleifer, A. and Vishny, R. (1997), ‘The proper scope of government: theory and an application to prisons’, Quarterly Journal of Economics, 112(4): 1127–1161.Google Scholar
Hawkins, T. G., Wittmann, C. M. and Beyerlein, M. M. (2008), ‘Antecedents and consequences of opportunism in buyer-supplier relations: research synthesis and new frontiers’, Industrial Marketing Management, 37(8): 895–909.Google Scholar
The Hindu (2011), ‘Health-card scheme: Rs.70 lakh dues to general hospital pending’, 13 June 2011, http://www.thehindu.com/news/cities/Kochi/healthcard-scheme-rs70-lakh-dues-to-general-hospital-pending/article2100643.ece [20 March 2015].Google Scholar
The Indian Express (2011a), ‘To boost RSBY implementation, govt to hire independent agency’, 22 August 2011, http://archive.indianexpress.com/news/to-boost-rsby-implementation-govt-to-hire-independent-agency/835225/ [23 March 2015].Google Scholar
The Indian Express (2011b), ‘UP: Now “bungling” of insurance scheme funds’, 29 August 2011, http://archive.indianexpress.com/news/up-now--bungling--of-insurance-scheme-funds/838535/ [23 March 2015].Google Scholar
Jain, N. (2013), ‘Rashtriya Swasthya Yojana data analysis and more’, 5th RSBY National Workshop Trivendrum Kerala, http://www.rsby.gov.in/Presentation5.aspx [23 March 2015].Google Scholar
Jowett, M., Maria Petro, B., Gabriela, F. and Jonathan, C. (2016), ‘Spending targets for health: no magic numbers’, Health Financing Working Paper-1, World Health Organization, Geneva.Google Scholar
King, G., Keohane, R. O. and Verba, S. (2004), ‘The Importance of Research Design’, in H. Brady and D. Collier (eds), Rethinking Social Inquiry: Diverse Tools, Shared Standards. Lanham, MD: Rowman & Littlefield Publishers, 111–122.Google Scholar
Kumaranayake, L., Lake, S., Mujinja, P., Hongoro, C. and Mpembeni, R. (2000), ‘How do countries regulate the health sector? Evidence from Tanzania and Zimbabwe’, Health Policy and Planning, 15(4): 357–367.Google Scholar
Kwon, S. (2009), ‘Thirty years of National Health Insurance in South Korea: lessons for achieving universal health care coverage’, Health Policy and Planning, 24(1): 63–71.Google Scholar
La Forgia, G. and Nagpal, S. (2012), Government-Sponsored Health Insurance in India: Are You Covered?, Washington, DC: World Bank Publications.Google Scholar
Lambe, C. J., Spekman, R. E. and Hunt, S. D. (2000), ‘Interimistic relational exchange: conceptualization and propositional development’, Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, 28(2): 212–225.Google Scholar
Liu, K., Qiaobing, W. and Junqiang, L. (2014), ‘Examining the association between social health insurance participation and patients’ out-of-pocket payments in China: the role of institutional arrangement’, Social Science & Medicine, 113: 95–103.Google Scholar
Lloyd-Sherlock, P. (2006), ‘When social health insurance goes wrong: lessons from Argentina and Mexico’, Social Policy & Administration, 40(4): 353–368.Google Scholar
Lu, J. R. and William, C. H. (2003), ‘Does universal health insurance make health care unaffordable? Lessons from Taiwan’, Health Affairs, 22(3): 77–88.Google Scholar
Mathauer, I. and Carrin, G. (2011), ‘The role of institutional design and organizational practice for health financing performance and universal coverage’, Health Policy, 99(3): 183–192.Google Scholar
Maurya, D. (2015), ‘Inter-organizational relations in public-private partnerships: National Health Insurance in India’. Unpublished thesis, National University of Singapore.Google Scholar
McIntyre, D. and Kutzin, J. (2016), Health Financing Country Diagnostic: A Foundation for National Strategy Development, Geneva: World Health Organization.Google Scholar
Ministry of Labour and Employment Government of India (2012a), ‘RSBY Connect Issue No 10’. New Delhi.Google Scholar
Ministry of Labour and Employment Government of India (2012b), ‘RSBY Connect Issue No 1’. New Delhi.Google Scholar
Ministry of Labour and Employment Government of India (2013a), ‘RSBY Connect Issue No. 17’. New Delhi.Google Scholar
Ministry of Labour and Employment Government of India (2013b), ‘RSBY Connect Issue No 20’. New Delhi.Google Scholar
Ministry of Labour and Employment Government of India (2013c), ‘RSBY Connect Issue No 16’. New Delhi.Google Scholar
Ministry of Labour and Employment Government of India (2014), ‘RSBY Connect Issue No. 24’. New Delhi.Google Scholar
Nandi, A., Ashok, A. and Laxminarayan, R. (2013), ‘The socioeconomic and institutional determinants of participation in India’s health insurance scheme for the poor’, PloS One, 8(6): e66296.Google Scholar
Nayak, D. K. and Behera, N. B. (2014), Changing Household Size in India: An Inter-State Comparison. Transactions, India: Institute of Indian Geographers.Google Scholar
O’Flynn, J., Blackman, D. and Halligan, J. (2013), Crossing Boundaries in Public Management and Policy: The International Experience, Abingdon, Oxon: Routledge.Google Scholar
Penteli, D. and Ginneken, E. van (2016), ‘Defining Healthcare Benefit Package: How Sufficientarian is Current Practice ?’ in C. Fourie and A. Rid (eds), What is Enough?: Sufficiency, Justice, and Health. New York, NY: Oxford University Press, 247–266.Google Scholar
Political and Business Daily (2010), ‘HP achieves distinction in RSBY implementation’, 30 October 2010.Google Scholar
Press Trust of India (2013), ‘Protect women from unscrupulous hysterectomies: NCDRC to Govt’, 29 September 2013, Business Standard, https://www.business-standard.com/article/pti-stories/protect-women-from-unscrupulous-hysterectomies-ncdrc-to-govt-113092900070_1.html [11 November 2017].Google Scholar
Reddy, S., Selvaraj, S., Rao, K. D., Chokshi, M., Kumar, P., Arora, V., Bhokare, S. and Ganguly, I. (2011), ‘A critical assessment of the existing health insurance models in India’, A Report Submitted to the Planning Commission of India, January, New Delhi.Google Scholar
Reich, M. R., Harris, J., Ikegami, N., Maeda, A., C. Cashin, E. C. Araujo, K. Takemi, T. G. Evans (2016), ‘Moving towards universal health coverage: lessons from 11 country studies’, The Lancet, 387: 811–816.Google Scholar
Ridde, V. (2008), ‘The problem of the worst-off is dealt with after all other issues’: the equity and health policy implementation gap in Burkina Faso’, Social Science & Medicine, 66(6): 1368–1378.Google Scholar
Robinson, J. C. (2001), ‘Organizational economics and healthcare markets’, Health Services Research, 36(1 Pt 2): 177–189.Google Scholar
Romzek, B. S. and Johnston, J. M. (2005), ‘State social services contracting: exploring the determinants of effective contract accountability’, Public Administration Review, 65(4): 436–449.Google Scholar
Sanderson, M., Allen, P., Gill, R. and Garnett, E. (2017), New models of contracting in the public sector: a review of alliance contracting, prime contracting and outcome-based contracting literature. Social Policy & Administration, https://doi.org/10.1111/spol.12322 Google Scholar
Sato, M. and Gilson, L. (2015), ‘Exploring health facilities’ experiences in implementing the Free Health-Care Policy (FHCP) in Nepal: how did organizational factors influence the implementation of the user-fee abolition policy?’, Health Policy and Planning, 30(10): 1272–1288.Google Scholar
Selvaraj, S. and Karan, A. K. (2009), ‘Deepening health insecurity in India: evidence from National Sample Surveys since 1980s’, Economic and Political Weekly, 44(40): 55–60.Google Scholar
Sheikh, K., Saligram, P. S. and Krishna, H. (2015), ‘What explains regulatory failure? Analysing the architecture of health care regulation in two Indian states’, Health Policy and Planning, 30(1): 39–55.Google Scholar
Srivastava, R. (2012), ‘Interview with Raji Srivastava’. Managing Director Punjab Health System Corporation Government of Punjab, 1 November 2011.Google Scholar
Swarup, A. (2012), ‘Interview with Swarup Anil’. Director General Ministry of Labour of Employment GOI, 1 November 2011.Google Scholar
The Times of India (2012), ‘Govt aims to control health rot, appoints 2 top officials’, 11 May 2012, http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/lucknow/Govt-aims-to-control-health-rot-appoints-2-top-officials/articleshow/13089125.cms [23 March 2015].Google Scholar
The Times of India (2013), ‘Commissioner smells a rat in Rashtriya Swasthya Bima Yojna’, 10 March 2013, https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/varanasi/Commissioner-smells-a-rat-in-Rashtriya-Swasthya-Bima-Yojna/articleshow/18886753.cms [25 March 2015].Google Scholar
Vaishnav, M. and Khosla, S. (2016), The Indian Administrative Service Meets Big Data, Washington, DC: Carnegie Endowment for International Peace.Google Scholar
Vega, J. (2013), ‘Universal health coverage: the post-2015 development agenda’, The Lancet, 381(9862): 179–180.Google Scholar
Witter, S. and Garshong, B. (2009), ‘Something old or something new? Social health insurance in Ghana’, BMC International Health and Human Rights, 9(1): 20.Google Scholar
Witter, S., B. Garshong and V. Ridde (2013), ‘An exploratory study of the policy process and early implementation of the free NHIS coverage for pregnant women in Ghana’, International Journal for Equity in Health, 12(1): 16. Google Scholar
Williamson, O. E. (2005), ‘The economics of governance’, The American Economic Review, 95(2): 1–8.Google Scholar
Wong, H. K. (2008), ‘Reforming social services in Hong Kong: the role of contracting and performance management in the non-profit sector’, Australian Journal of Public Administration, 67(1): 97–105.Google Scholar
Zee News (2014), ‘Delhi HC raps UP govt for “inaction” on RSBY scam’, 17 February 2014, http://zeenews.india.com/news/nation/delhi-hc-raps-up-govt-for-inaction-on-rsby-scam_912144.html [23 March 2015].Google Scholar