Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-q99xh Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-24T02:31:26.403Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

The Search for the Real Homer1

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  05 January 2009

Extract

I am not of course going to talk about a very concrete person, a little bearded man who lived in Chios or Smyrna. Yet that there was someone called Homer, who was primarily responsible for the creation of the Iliad at least, I take for granted, and accordingly spare you the old jokes. They applied to an entirely different situation in scholarship from the one we have today, and the cause of the difference is the realization that the Homeric poems are in essence oral rather than written poetry.

Type
Research Article
Copyright
Copyright © The Classical Association 1973

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

page 124 note 2 Fenik, B., Typical Battle Scenes in the Iliad (Hermes Einzelschriften xxi, Wiesbaden, 1968), especially 6 f.Google Scholar

page 125 note 1 See e.g. my Homer and the Epic (paperback, Cambridge, 1965), ch. 1.Google Scholar

page 126 note 1 Homer and the Epic, 19 ff.Google Scholar

page 127 note 1 Homer and the Epic, 192–7.Google Scholar

page 128 note 1 Iliad ix. 308429Google Scholar; cf. Parry, Adam, ‘The Language of Achilles’, in Kirk, G. S. (ed.), The Language and Background of Homer (Cambridge [Heffer], 1964), 48 ff.Google Scholar

page 129 note 1 Odyssey xiv. 115408.Google Scholar

page 130 note 1 Od. xiv. 457506.Google Scholar

page 130 note 2 Il. xiv. 153360; xv. 4–99.Google Scholar

page 130 note 3 Il. xix. 154237.Google Scholar

page 131 note 1 Il. ix. 527–99.Google Scholar

page 132 note 1 Fenik, , op. cit. 200 f.Google Scholar

page 132 note 2 Il. xvi. 666–83Google Scholar, cf. 453–7 (Sleep and Death); 459–61, cf. xi. 53–5 (bloody rain).

page 133 note 1 Il. xvi. 502Google Scholar, cf. 855, xxii. 361.

page 133 note 2 Il. xvi. 698 ff.Google Scholar

page 133 note 3 Il. xvi. 756 ff.Google Scholar

page 134 note 1 Il. xvi. 856 f.Google Scholar, xxii. 362 f.

page 134 note 2 Fenik, , 216.Google Scholar

page 134 note 3 Il. xxii. 5 f.Google Scholar

page 134 note 4 Il. xxii. 179–81 = xvi. 441–3Google Scholar; moira, xvi. 434.Google Scholar

page 135 note 1 Il. xxii. 355–66; xvi. 843–61.Google Scholar

page 136 note 1 Il. xvi. 693; xxii. 297.Google Scholar

page 137 note 1 The effects I have in mind are discussed in relation to the whole of Iliad xvi in my ‘Verse-structure and Sentence-structure in Homer’, Yale Classical Studies xx (1966), 105–52.Google Scholar

page 137 note 2 Il. xxii. 93–7.Google Scholar

page 137 note 3 Il. xxii. 308–11, 317–21.Google Scholar

page 138 note 1 Il. xxii. 139–44, 2532.Google Scholar

page 138 note 2 Fenik, , 203.Google Scholar