No CrossRef data available.
Article contents
GREEK CULTURE IN AFGHANISTAN AND INDIA: OLD EVIDENCE AND NEW DISCOVERIES*
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 16 September 2016
Extract
In 1888 Rudyard Kipling published a collection of short-stories entitled The Phantom Rickshaw and Other Eerie Tales. Perhaps the most famous of these stories, ‘The Man Who Would Be King’, recounted the adventures of two British military veterans, Peachy Carnahan and Daniel Dravot Esq., played by Michael Caine and Sean Connery in John Huston's 1975 film of the same name. Both men have seen India's cities and jungles, jails and palaces, and have decided that she is too small for the likes of they. So, they set out to become kings of Kafiristan, a mountainous, isolated, and unstudied country beyond the Hindu Kush in north-eastern Afghanistan. They confide their plan to their recent acquaintance Rudyard Kipling (Christopher Plummer), then editor of the Northern Star, who calls them mad. No man, he says, has made it to Kafiristan since Alexander the Great, to which Peachy replies ‘If a Greek can do it, we can do it.’ What they find in north-eastern Afghanistan are the last remnants of Alexander the Great's empire, a local culture and religion part-Greek and part-Kafiri. The story is fiction, but aspects of its historical context are true. Alexander spent most of the years 330–325 campaigning in Afghanistan, Pakistan, and India, and he left behind Greek kingdoms and culture that flourished throughout the Hellenistic period and even later. Traces of these Greek kingdoms are continually coming to light and the archaeological, artistic, and epigraphic evidence coming out of Afghanistan, Pakistan, and India reveals a prosperous and culturally diverse kingdom.
- Type
- Research Article
- Information
- Copyright
- Copyright © The Classical Association 2016
Footnotes
*
Earlier versions of this article were presented at Trinity College Dublin and the University of Cyprus. Andrew Erskine and Michael Iliakis kindly read the article and offered their comments. Remaining errors are my own. All dates, unless noted, are bc and will inevitably change as new finds come to light.
References
1 The Greco-Bactrian kingdom existed from roughly the mid-third century to the mid-second, and encompassed most of modern Afghanistan as well as portions of north-western Pakistan, Tajikistan, southern Uzbekistan, and even parts of north-eastern Turkmenistan. The Indo-Greek kingdom existed from roughly the mid-second century to the end of the first century and encompassed northern Pakistan, parts of northern Afghanistan, and parts of north-western India.
2 Arora, U. P., Greeks on India. Skylax to Aristoteles (Bareilly, 1996)Google Scholar; Nichols, A. G., Ctesias. On India. Translation and Commentary (Bristol, 2011)Google Scholar.
3 Tarn, W.W., The Greeks in Bactria and India (Cambridge, 1938)Google Scholar; Narain, N. K., The Indo-Greeks (Oxford, 1957)Google Scholar; Narain, N. K., ‘The Greeks of Bactria and India’, in Astin, A. E., Walbank, F. W., Frederiksen, M. W., and Ogilvie, R. M. (eds.), The Cambridge Ancient History. VIII. Rome and the Mediterranean to 133 bc (Cambridge, 1989), pp. 388–421 Google Scholar; Coloru, O., Da Alessandro a Menandro. Il regno greco di Battriana (Pisa, 2009)Google Scholar; Widemann, F., Les Successeurs d'Alexandre en Asie centrale et leur héritage culturel (Paris, 2009)Google Scholar; Mairs, R., The Hellenistic Far East. Archaeology, Language, and Identity in Greek Central Asia (Berkeley, CA, 2014)Google Scholar; M. Iliakis, The Bactrian Mirage. Iranian and Greek Interaction in Western Central Asia (Edinburgh, forthcoming).
4 Kosmin, P., The Land of the Elephant Kings. Space, Territory, and Ideology in the Seleucid Empire (Cambridge, MA, 2014)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
5 Cohen, G. M., The Hellenistic Settlements in the East from Armenia and Mesopotamia to Bactria and India (Berkeley, CA, 2013)Google Scholar.
6 P. Grierson, Numismatics (Oxford, 1975), 16; Thonemann, P., The Hellenistic World. Using Coins as Sources (Cambridge, 2016), 96–103 Google Scholar.
7 Holt, F., Lost World of the Golden King. In Search of Ancient Afghanistan (Berkeley, CA, 2012), 141–2Google Scholar.
8 Holt, F., Alexander the Great and Bactria. The Formation of a Greek Frontier in Central Asia (Leiden, 1988)Google Scholar; Holt, F., Thundering Zeus. The Making of Hellenistic Bactria (Leiden, 1999)Google Scholar; Holt, F., Into the Land of Bones. Alexander the Great in Afghanistan (Berkeley, CA, 2005)Google Scholar; Holt (n. 7). Note also Bopearachchi, O., Monnaies gréco-bactriennes et indo-grecques. Catalogue raisonné (Paris, 1991)Google Scholar; Bopearachchi, O., Catalogue of Indo-Greek, Indo-Scythian and Indo-Parthian Coins of the Smithsonian Institution (Washington, DC, 1993)Google Scholar; Bopearachchi, O., Sylloge Nummorum Graecorum. The Collection of the American Numismatic Society IX. Graeco-Bactrian and Indo-Greek Coins (New York, 1998)Google Scholar.
9 de Rossi, F. Canali, Iscrizioni dello estremo oriente greco. Un repertorio (Bonn, 2004), 194–233 Google Scholar.
10 Naveh, J. and Shaked, S., Aramaic Documents from Ancient Bactra (Fourth Century b.c.e.) from the Khalili Collections (London, 2012)Google Scholar.
11 Mairs, R., The Archaeology of the Hellenistic Far East. A Survey. Bactria, Central Asia and the Indo-Iranian Borderlands, c.300 bc–ad 100 (Oxford, 2011)Google Scholar; Holt (n. 7). Updates and annual supplements to Mairs's work can be found online at <https://hellenisticfareast.wordpress.com>, accessed 26 May 2016.
12 Cohen (n. 5), 252–60.
13 Iliakis, M., ‘Greek Mercenary Revolts in Bactria: A Re-appraisal’, Historia 62 (2013), 182–95Google Scholar.
14 Cohen (n. 5), 223–88. A mint was probably founded at Ai Khanoum during the reign of Antiochos I: see B. Kritt, Seleucid Coins of Bactria (Lancaster, 1996); Holt (n. 8 [1999]), 113–15; Holt (n. 7), 102–3.
15 Wheatley, P., ‘Seleukos and Chandragupta in Justin XV 4’, in Hauben, H. and Meeus, A. (eds.), The Age of the Successors and the Creation of the Hellenistic Kingdoms (323–276 b.c.) (Leuven, 2014), 501–15Google Scholar.
16 Austin, M., The Hellenistic World from Alexander to the Roman Conquest. A Selection of Ancient Sources in Translation (Cambridge, 2006)Google Scholar, no. 178a–b; Burstein, S. M., The Hellenistic Age from the Battle of Ipsus to the Death of Kleopatra VII (Cambridge, 1985), no. 50Google Scholar; Thapar, R., Aśoka and the Decline of the Mauryas (New Delhi, 1997), 40–1, 255–61Google Scholar; Carratelli, G. Pugliese, Gli editti di Asoka (Milan, 2003)Google Scholar.
17 We know of Seleucid and Ptolemaic economic and diplomatic connections with the Mauryan empire. For the Seleucids, see Strabo 2.1.9; Ath. 14.652e–653a; Sherwin-White, S. M. and Kuhrt, A., From Samarkhand to Sardis. A New Approach to the Seleucid Empire (London, 1993), 65–7Google Scholar. For the Ptolemies, see Plin. HN 6.21.58; Mairs, R., ‘Glassware from Roman Egypt at Begram (Afghanistan) and the Red Sea Trade’, British Museum Studies in Ancient Egypt and Sudan 18 (2012), 1–14 Google Scholar.
18 BNJ 715; Kosmin (n. 4), 31–58.
19 BNJ 428; Kosmin (n. 4), 61–7.
20 BNJ 712; Kosmin (n. 4), 67–74.
21 This account, open to debate, follows Lerner, J. D., The Impact of Seleucid Decline on the Eastern Iranian Plateau (Stuttgart, 1999), 13–31 Google Scholar.
22 MacDowell, D. W., ‘The Role of Demetrius in Arachosia and the Kabul Valley’, in Bopearachchi, O. and Boussac, M.-F. (eds.), Afghanistan. Ancien carrefour entre l'est et l'ouest (Turnhout, 2005), 197–206 Google Scholar.
23 Narain (n. 3 [1989]).
24 Parker, G., The Making of Roman India (Cambridge, 2008), 49 Google Scholar.
25 Boardman, J., The Diffusion of Classical Art in Antiquity (London, 1994), 75–153 Google Scholar; The Greeks in Asia (London, 2015); Abe, S. K., ‘Inside the Wonder House: Buddhist Art and the West’, in Lopez, D. (ed.), Curators of the Buddha. The Study of Buddhism under Colonialism (Chicago, IL, 1995), 63–106 Google Scholar; Allchin, R., Allchin, B., Kreitman, N., and Errington, E. (eds.), Gandharan Art in Conext. East–West Exchanges at the Crossroads of Asia (New Delhi, 1997)Google Scholar; Seldeslachts, E., ‘Greece, the Final Frontier? The Westward Spread of Buddhism’, in Heirman, A. and Bumbacher, S. P. (eds.), The Spread of Buddhism (Leiden, 2007), 131–66Google Scholar.
26 Sims-Williams, N. and Cribb, J., ‘A New Bactrian Inscription of Kanishka the Great’, Silk Road Art and Archaeology 4 (1996), 75–142 Google Scholar.
27 Translation from Hollis, A., ‘Greek Letters from Hellenistic Bactria’, in Obbink, D. and Rutherford, R. (eds.), Culture in Pieces. Essays on Ancient Texts in Honour of Peter Parsons (Oxford, 2011), 110 Google Scholar, lightly adapted.
28 Bernard, P., Pinault, G. J., and Rougemont, G., ‘Deux nouvelles inscriptions grecques de l'Asie centrale’, JS (2004), 333–56Google Scholar.
29 Employed only rarely after the fourth century and very sporadically in inscribed poems, the metre is found, however, in tragedy and Attic comedy: see West, M. L., Greek Metre (Oxford, 1982), 160, 182Google Scholar.
30 Lerner (n. 21), 45–62.
31 Ma, J., Antiochos III and the Cities of Western Asia Minor (Oxford, 1999), 272–6Google Scholar.
32 It is, therefore, similar to the mid-third to mid-second-century dedication to Hermes and Herakles made by the brothers Triballos and Straton, sons of Straton, in the gymnasium at Ai Khanoum (IK 65 [Estremo oriente], 381).
33 Goudriaan, K., Ethnicity in Ptolemaic Egypt (Amsterdam, 1988)Google Scholar.
34 IK 65 (Estremo oriente), 311 = SEG xxxi.1381.
35 The bibliography on Ai Khanoum is huge – the Fouilles d'Aï Khanoum, published since 1973 is the most comprehensive and important – but for short introductions see Bernard, P., ‘Ai Khanoum on the Oxus: A Hellenistic City in Central Asia’, PBA 53 (1967), 71–95 Google Scholar; Bernard, P., ‘The Greek colony at Ai Khanum and Hellenism in Central Asia’, in Cambon, P. (ed.), Hidden Afghanistan (Washington, DC, 2008), 45–55 Google Scholar; Rapin, C., ‘Greeks in Afghanistan: Ai Khanoum’, in Descoeudres, J.-P. (ed.), Greek Colonists and Native Populations (Oxford, 1990), 329–42Google Scholar.
36 Holt (n. 8 [1999]), 44: ‘finds include a Macedonian palace, Rhodian porticoes, Coan funerary monuments, an Athenian propylaea, Delian houses, Megarian bowls, Corinthian tiles, and Mediterranean amphorae’.
37 Other copies of the Maxims exist from Miletopolis in Mysia (Syll.3 1268) and Thera (IG xii.3.1020).
38 Translation from Austin (n. 16), no. 186.
39 Hollis (n. 27), 109: ἀρίγνωτος is Homeric, as is Πυθοῖ ἐν ἠγαθέῃ, which appears in the Odyssey (8.80), the Homeric Hymns (24.2), and Hesiod (Theog. 499). Τηλαυγής is used by Pindar (Ol. 6.4; Pyth. 2.6, 3.75; Nem. 3.64, fr.52g.12).
40 Hollis (n. 27), on the appearance of ἐπιϕραδέως here and at Ap. Rhod. Argon. 1.1021, 1336, 2.1134, 3.83.
41 Yailenko, V.-P., ‘Les maximes delphiques d'Ai Khanoum et la formation de la doctrine du dhamma d'Asoka’, DHA 16 (1990), 239–56CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
42 Mairs, R., ‘The Founder's Shrine and the Foundation of Ai Khanoum’, in Mac Sweeney, N. (ed.), Foundation Myths in Ancient Societies. Dialogues and Discourses (Philadelphia, PA, 2015), 103–28Google Scholar.
43 Mairs (n. 42), 122.
44 L. Robert, ‘De Delphes à l'Oxus: Inscriptions grecques nouvelles de la Bactriane’, CRAI (1968), 443–54.
45 OCD 3, s.v. Clearchus (3), and s.v. Cineas (1); Yailenko (n. 41); Walbank, F., The Hellenistic World (Cambridge, 1993), 60–1Google Scholar; Chamoux, F., Hellenistic Civilization (Oxford, 2001) 322 Google Scholar; Potter, D., ‘Hellenistic Religion’, in Erskine, A. (ed.), A Companion to the Hellenistic World (Oxford and Malden, MA, 2003), 421 Google Scholar; Bosworth, A. B., ‘Alexander the Great and the Creation of the Hellenistic Age’, in Bugh, G. (ed.), The Cambridge Companion to the Hellenistic World (Cambridge, 2006), 18 Google Scholar; Kosmin (n. 4), 347, n. 84. Other authors are less categorical: Fraser, P., Cities of Alexander the Great (Oxford, 1996), 155, n. 99Google Scholar: ‘probably’; Holt (n. 8 [1999]), 158: ‘perhaps’; Austin (n. 16), 336: ‘plausibly identified’.
46 Lerner, J. D., ‘Correcting the Early History of Āy Kānom’, Archäologische Mitteilungen aus Iran und Turan 35–6 (2003–4), 393–4Google Scholar.
47 Ibid., 383–90; Narain, N. K., ‘On Some Greek Inscriptions from Afghanistan’, AION 47 (1987), 281–7Google Scholar, dates the inscription to the third quarter of the third century.
48 Mairs (n. 42).
49 Bernard, Pinault, and Rougement (n. 28), 227–332.
50 Translation from Hollis (n. 27), 113.
51 Hollis (n. 27), 114–15: ἐριθηλέα (l.2) appears in the Iliad (5.90, 10.467, 17.53), as does Ἑκάτου (l.6) as a title of Apollo. ἰῶν εἰς ἄστεα πολλὰ (l.10) may refer to Odyssey 1.3: πολλῶν δ’ἀνθρώπων ἴδεν ἄστεα καὶ νόον ἔγνω (‘he saw the cities and learned the minds of many men’). Words such as εὖνις (‘deprived’; l.5), κοκύαι (‘ancestors’; l.2), τυννός (‘so small’; l.4), and ϕυρτός (‘mixed’; l.7), are rare and archaizing, while τεκνοϕόρον (‘child-bearing’; l.9) and ἀλωβήτος (‘unblemished’; l.13) were hitherto unattested before late antiquity.
52 Hollis (n. 27), 114, highlighting κοκύαι (‘ancestors’; l.1) and τυννός (‘tiny’; l.3).
53 The only other Sophytos known is the probable Satrap of Bactria (c.315–305), who minted silver didrachms with his own image: see Bopearachchi, O., ‘Sophytes, the Enigmatic Ruler of Central Asia’, Nomismatika Khronika 15 (1996), 19–32 Google Scholar. Sophytos son of Naratos may have been a descendant: see Bernard, Pinault, and Rougement (n. 28), 282–317.
54 Mairs (n. 3), 106–17.
55 Bernard, Pinault, and Rougement (n. 28), 249–59.
56 Narain (n. 3 [1957]), 118–20.
57 Irwin, J., ‘The Heliodorus Pillar at Besnagar’, Purātattva 8 (1975–6), 166–76Google Scholar; Mairs (n. 3), 117–33.
58 Translation from Salomon, R., Indian Epigraphy. A Guide to the Study of Inscriptions in Sanskrit, Prakrit, and the Other Indo-Aryan Languages (Oxford, 1998), 265–7Google Scholar.
59 IK 65 (Estremo oriente), 459; Rea, J., Senior, R. C., and Hollis, A. S., ‘A Tax Receipt from Hellenistic Bactria’, ZPE 104 (1994), 261–80Google Scholar; Mairs (n. 3), 53–4. For two other Greek parchment texts from Hellenistic Bactria, see Clarysse, W. and Thompson, D. J., ‘Two Greek Texts on Skin from Hellenistic Bactria’, ZPE 159 (2007), 273–9Google Scholar.
60 Rapin, C., ‘Les inscriptions économiques de la trésorerie d'Aï Khanoum (Afghanistan)’, BCH 107 (1983), 315–72; Narain (n. 47)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
61 Lerner, J. D., ‘A Reappraisal of the Economic Inscriptions and Coin Finds from Aï Khanoum’, Anabasis 2 (2011), 103–47; Mairs (n. 3), 46–52Google Scholar.
62 Ivanchik, A. I., ‘New Greek Inscriptions from Takht-i Sangin and the Question as to the Emergence of the Bactrian Written Language’, Bulletin of Miho Museum 11 (2011), 59–77 Google Scholar.