Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-gb8f7 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-25T18:41:10.739Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Afghanistan's humanitarian crisis and its impacts on the mental health of healthcare workers during COVID-19

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  18 February 2022

Zarmina Islam Open the ORCID record for Zarmina Islam [Opens in a new window] ,
Aiman Rija Open the ORCID record for Aiman Rija [Opens in a new window] ,
Parvathy Mohanan Open the ORCID record for Parvathy Mohanan [Opens in a new window] ,
Khulud Qamar Open the ORCID record for Khulud Qamar [Opens in a new window] ,
Kainat Jahangir Open the ORCID record for Kainat Jahangir [Opens in a new window] ,
Faisal A. Nawaz  and
Mohammad Yasir Essar Open the ORCID record for Mohammad Yasir Essar [Opens in a new window]
Zarmina Islam
Affiliation:
Faculty of Medicine, Dow Medical College, Dow University of Health Sciences, Karachi, Pakistan
Aiman Rija
Affiliation:
Faculty of Medicine, Dow Medical College, Dow University of Health Sciences, Karachi, Pakistan
Parvathy Mohanan
Affiliation:
Faculty of Medicine, Medical University Sofia, Sofia, Bulgaria
Khulud Qamar
Affiliation:
Faculty of Medicine, Dow Medical College, Dow University of Health Sciences, Karachi, Pakistan
Kainat Jahangir
Affiliation:
Faculty of Medicine, Dow Medical College, Dow University of Health Sciences, Karachi, Pakistan
Faisal A. Nawaz
Affiliation:
College of Medicine, Mohammed Bin Rashid University of Medicine and Health Sciences, Dubai, United Arab Emirates
Mohammad Yasir Essar*
Affiliation:
Faculty of Dentistry, Kabul University of Medical Sciences, Kabul, Afghanistan
*
Author for correspondence: Mohammad Yasir Essar, E-mail: [email protected]
Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Afghanistan's humanitarian crisis has severely impacted the mental health of frontline workers. With the introduction of the Taliban government, ongoing civil unrest, and other forms of violent attacks, healthcare workers (HCWs) continue to provide patient care despite minimal resources. A severe contraction in the economy, poor supply of medications, political turmoil, and insufficient humanitarian aid have added to pre-existing problems. High levels of insecurity and instability as well as decades of traumatic experiences have contributed to increasing mental health challenges amongst frontline workers. Despite the scarcity of mental health services, HCWs continue to persevere with their service to the community. However, inadequate interventions may have serious implications for HCWs bearing the brunt of multiple traumas. Thus, governmental and international involvement is needed to address both the economic and psychological needs of HCWs in Afghanistan.

Keywords

Afghanistanburnoutcoronaviruseconomic crisishealth care workershumanitarian crisismental health
Type
Commentary
Information
Global Mental Health , Volume 9 , 2022 , pp. 61 - 64
Check for updates
Creative Commons
Creative Common License - CCCreative Common License - BY
This is an Open Access article, distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution licence (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted re-use, distribution and reproduction, provided the original article is properly cited.
Copyright
Copyright © The Author(s), 2022. Published by Cambridge University Press

Introduction

The ‘War on Terror’ is estimated to cost more than US$ 2 trillion, impacting over 40 000 civilian lives in Afghanistan (Knickmeyer, Reference Knickmeyer2021; Reality Check Team BBC, 2021). The increasing number of civilian casualties and worsening national insecurities are major factors that influence this current state of crisis. However, despite such loss, international relief efforts amidst this humanitarian crisis continue to be insufficient for healthcare workers (HCWs), being the most vulnerable targets of violence and mental health issues in Afghanistan (Lucero-Prisno III et al., Reference Lucero-Prisno, Ahmadi, Essar, Lin and Adebisi2020a, Reference Lucero-Prisno, Ahmadi, Essar, Lin and Adebisi2020b; Essar et al., Reference Essar, Hasan, Islam, Riaz, Aborode and Ahmad2021; Leahy, Reference Leahy2021).

Afghanistan's humanitarian crisis involves multiple converging systems which makes it particularly challenging during a pandemic to address widening gaps in mental health needs (Essar et al., Reference Essar, Hasan, Islam, Riaz, Aborode and Ahmad2021). Among these are inflation, social and civil unrest, reduced healthcare capacity, infrastructural damage, rampant Coronavirus Disease 2019 (COVID-19) delta variant, and violent attacks, collectively resulting in high levels of stress in the general population (Essar et al., Reference Essar, Hasan, Islam, Riaz, Aborode and Ahmad2021). As of 11 January 2022, over 158 452 COVID-19 cases and 7374 deaths have been registered (Worldometer, 2022).

Moreover, questions on international relations with the Taliban government have created ambiguity for security and stability in the country. Conversely, the provision of women's rights has been a mainstream concern with ongoing protests. These interdependent factors are impairing the implementation of public health measures, thus creating a vacuum for conflict, instability, and burden on the healthcare system (Essar et al., Reference Essar, Hasan, Islam, Riaz, Aborode and Ahmad2021). Consequently, HCWs are in a vulnerable position. This is evident by the gender gap in the workforce with female HCWs representing merely 22% of doctors and 21% of nurses in Afghanistan (International Organization for Migration, 2020). Additionally, the United Nations Assistance Mission in Afghanistan (UNAMA) reported 75 violent incidents in 2019 against HCWs in comparison to 65 in 2018 (Lucero-Prisno III et al., Reference Lucero-Prisno, Ahmadi, Essar, Lin and Adebisi2020a, Reference Lucero-Prisno, Ahmadi, Essar, Lin and Adebisi2020b). The current national turmoil has collectively increased the workload on frontline workers resulting in rising mental health concerns (Leahy, Reference Leahy2021).

Since 1978, repeated cycles of war coupled with the impacts of poverty and displacement have contributed to depression, anxiety, and post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) in half the population of Afghanistan (Pedneault, Reference Pedneault2019). Subsequently, a fragile health framework that is ill-equipped to provide mental healthcare predisposes this nation to a large mental health crisis (Kovess-Masfety et al., Reference Kovess-Masfety, Keyes, Karam, Sabawoon and Sarwari2021a, Reference Kovess-Masfety, Keyes, Karam, Sabawoon and Sarwari2021b). Husna Safi, an Afghan Canadian psychotherapist, states that generations of Afghans have been born amid the struggle and many have never known peace, detailing the role of intergenerational trauma (Kovess-Masfety et al., Reference Kovess-Masfety, Keyes, Karam, Sabawoon and Sarwari2021a, Reference Kovess-Masfety, Keyes, Karam, Sabawoon and Sarwari2021b). A recent nationwide study including 4445 citizens found a high portion of exposure to trauma is evident in Afghans, with 86% of respondents either having personally experienced or seen at least one traumatic occasion in their lives. Moreover, 47% of the population have experienced mental distress with women reporting higher levels of distress. The PTSD predominance was comparable to what was detailed in nations that have experienced war (Islam et al., Reference Islam, Gangat, Mohanan, Rahmat, Chbib, Marfani and Essar2021b). Astoundingly, the study mentioned that PTSD cases were not as recognizable to therapists in Afghanistan. This may be because traumatic experiences have been normalized and hence do not incite any mental health consultations, which is an important consideration for HCWs dealing with mental health issues (Kovess-Masfety et al., Reference Kovess-Masfety, Keyes, Karam, Sabawoon and Sarwari2021a, Reference Kovess-Masfety, Keyes, Karam, Sabawoon and Sarwari2021b). With <1% of medical training allocated to mental health, 0.5 mental health facilities per 100 000 people, and only 320 hospital beds available for mental health patients, major roadblocks in access to mental health services continue to persist (World Health Organization, Health and Ministry of Public Health Afghanistan, 2006). Thus, this paper aims to comment on the ever-increasing mental health concerns for HCWs in Afghanistan and provide scalable recommendations.

Discussion

Challenges in maintaining a stable healthcare infrastructure have chronically plagued Afghanistan. This is seen by the ratio of nine HCWs and two physicians per 10 000 people in the region (Lucero-Prisno III et al., Reference Lucero-Prisno, Ahmadi, Essar, Lin and Adebisi2020a, Reference Lucero-Prisno, Ahmadi, Essar, Lin and Adebisi2020b). Furthermore, access to healthcare services is aggravated by existing respiratory health issues (Essar et al., Reference Essar, Hasan, Islam, Riaz, Aborode and Ahmad2021; Shah et al., Reference Shah, Essar, Qaderi, Rackimuthu, Nawaz, Qaderi and Shah2021). Failure to document cases and halt the spread of the delta variant is exposing HCWs to constant physical and psychological risks (International Organization for Migration, 2020; Essar et al., Reference Essar, Hasan, Islam, Riaz, Aborode and Ahmad2021). Extended working hours, insufficient funding, suboptimal preparedness, and multiple traumatic experiences have worsened the pre-existing mental health struggles among HCWs (International Organization for Migration, 2020; Leahy, Reference Leahy2021). Moreover, lack of adequate gear, supplies, or preparation during the pandemic has added to this crisis. According to the Ministry of Public Health in Afghanistan, HCWs are bearing the brunt of uncontrolled transmission with 10% of all affirmed cases among healthcare staff, and 53 workers have died as a result of this catastrophe (International Organization for Migration, 2020). Afghanistan's remarkable advances in public health celebrated over the past two decades were vastly conceivable due to the efforts of women, including doctors, nurses, midwives, and community health laborers. Four out of 100 extraordinary nurses and midwives leaders over the world in 2020 have been recognized from Afghanistan (Parray et al., Reference Parray, Dash, Ullah, Inam and Kaufman2021). At the same time, female HCWs continue to struggle between the expanding health needs of the population amidst ongoing political conflict (Parray et al., Reference Parray, Dash, Ullah, Inam and Kaufman2021).

Among this, the impact of war and consequences of the pandemic are primary negative contributors to the frontline workforce, according to a study done in 2020 (Lucero-Prisno III et al., Reference Lucero-Prisno, Ahmadi, Essar, Lin and Adebisi2020a, Reference Lucero-Prisno, Ahmadi, Essar, Lin and Adebisi2020b). Chronic funding issues have led to the suspension of salaries resulting in financial distress (Nemat et al., Reference Nemat, Asady, Raufi, Zaki, Ehsan, Noor and Zeng2021). Moreover, the limited number of functioning hospitals, shortage of active working staff, and restricted humanitarian aid exacerbate such working conditions (Essar et al., Reference Essar, Hasan, Islam, Riaz, Aborode and Ahmad2021; Nemat et al., Reference Nemat, Asady, Raufi, Zaki, Ehsan, Noor and Zeng2021). Afghanistan's political circumstances have halted the availability of female literacy for years, resulting in the lesser numbers of female HCWs. Furthermore, emerging conflicts have caused additional problems for female HCWs including travel, access to resources, and continued professional development. Moreover, in a place where it is customary for a female patient to be seen by a female HCW, access to women's health needs has become extremely scarce (Hashemi, Reference Hashemi2012; Ghebreyesus and Al-Mandhari, Reference Ghebreyesus and Al-Mandhari2021). Ultimately, this has led to poor outcomes in the performance of the health system, and loss of trust arising from increasing violence which is reported to affect over 15% of HCWs (Essar et al., Reference Essar, Hasan, Islam, Riaz, Aborode and Ahmad2021). Multifactorial causes, such as mass displacements and immigration needs, losing loved ones, and bearing the emotional needs of patients, continue to impact workplace efficacy (Kovess-Masfety et al., Reference Kovess-Masfety, Keyes, Karam, Sabawoon and Sarwari2021a, Reference Kovess-Masfety, Keyes, Karam, Sabawoon and Sarwari2021b). Whilst dealing with an increase of patient inflow and emotional needs, there happens to be no psychological support for HCWs resulting in severe exhaustion, stress, and higher rates of HCW burnout (Lucero-Prisno III et al., Reference Lucero-Prisno, Ahmadi, Essar, Lin and Adebisi2020a, Reference Lucero-Prisno, Ahmadi, Essar, Lin and Adebisi2020b). Figure 1 depicts the various socio-economic factors that contribute to worsening HCW burnout in the country.

Fig. 1. Contributing factors to healthcare worker burnout in Afghanistan.

The implications of ignoring this calamity include workplace detachment and lower self-efficacy which hinders provision of optimal quality patient care and decreases resilience amongst HCWs (Islam et al., Reference Islam, Rocha, Mohanan, Jain, Goyal, dos Santos Costa, Ahmad, Mehedi Hasan and Essar2021a). In countries such as Yemen and Lebanon, reports of HCWs leaving the country due to working conditions and stress levels have been reported (Islam et al., Reference Islam, Rocha, Mohanan, Jain, Goyal, dos Santos Costa, Ahmad, Mehedi Hasan and Essar2021a, Reference Islam, Gangat, Mohanan, Rahmat, Chbib, Marfani and Essar2021b). A similar situation is observed in Myanmar during the military coup, where HCWs were arrested, terminated from work, and constantly endangered due to ongoing conflict (Rocha et al., Reference Rocha, Cedeño, Pelayo, Ramos and Victoria2021).

Amidst these concerns, gender inequality is prevalent in HCWs, with Afghanistan ranked as 171st among 188 countries in the Gender Inequality Index (Najafizada et al., Reference Najafizada, Labonté and Bourgeault2014; Parray et al., Reference Parray, Dash, Ullah, Inam and Kaufman2021). Despite this, an optimistic attitude and continual resilience demonstrated by community care workers, of which half are women, continues to help in the delivery of essential healthcare services (Najafizada et al., Reference Najafizada, Labonté and Bourgeault2014; Parray et al., Reference Parray, Dash, Ullah, Inam and Kaufman2021). The diligence needed to stay motivated during the pandemic emerges from a sense of service and empowerment for female HCWs.

Efforts and recommendations

A major advancement took place recently when Taliban urged women HCWs to return to work, stating there will be no impediments to them while performing professional duties in attempts to re-establish basic services across the country (Reuters, 2021). In Afghanistan, mental health units are active in six hospitals in order to provide psychosocial support to HCWs and COVID-19 patients (World Health Organization, 2020b). This is supported by more than 60 operational hotlines in the country that are providing mental health support and awareness, coupled with referrals to specialized services. Efforts to educate the masses are an essential tool in combating critical situations. Therefore, the World Health Organization (WHO) and the Inter-Agency Standing Committee (IASC) mental health support guidelines were translated into local languages (World Health Organization, 2020b). Awareness programs intending to promote self-care and well-being have been developed for different groups, including HCWs and children (World Health Organization, 2020a). Moreover, the availability of remote mental health services was advertised on social media, COVID-19 hospitals, and public places, such as mosques and markets (World Health Organization, 2020a).

To better advance mental health care in Afghanistan, the allotment of finances and funds for mental health services, and undergraduate training are highly recommended. Devising national health policies and increased research in this area can help navigate the country through this ordeal. Furthermore, trainings to provide suitable psychological first aid and stress management workshops added to undergraduate and graduate-level curriculums could increase community well-being and support. In order to positively cope with the pandemic, several mechanisms and measures must be taken by preparing the HCWs through peer support programs and helping them recognize future challenges through supportive mentoring (Greenberg et al., Reference Greenberg, Docherty, Gnanapragasam and Wessely2020). Furthermore, religion and fatalism also play a role in the context of a Muslim-majority country that values humanitarian efforts as a service to God. Educational programs and institutional training for HCWs could assist them in handling stressful working conditions by employing the use of a meaning-focused approach (Islam et al., Reference Islam, Rocha, Mohanan, Jain, Goyal, dos Santos Costa, Ahmad, Mehedi Hasan and Essar2021a). On a global scale, the supply of protective personal equipment, vaccines, and medical equipment to support HCWs is vital. International organizations including the WHO need to coordinate with Afghan authorities to negotiate novel ways to provide aid as well as ease restrictions on female HCWs (Essar et al., Reference Essar, Hasan, Islam, Riaz, Aborode and Ahmad2021).

Conclusion

In conclusion, the political instability in Afghanistan is contributing to an impending mental health crisis for HCWs along with the incursion of the COVID-19 pandemic, economic complications, and ongoing civil unrest. As a result, reduced access to mental health has affected the workplace efficacy of HCWs in Afghanistan. Further research is warranted on understanding the impact of conflict on HCWs and help implement vital measures in devising healthcare policies, allocation of finances, and national training focused on mental health recovery.

Author contributions

Zarmina Islam conceived the idea and design, wrote the introduction, edited the revised draft, and organized references; Parvathy wrote the discussion and some of the introduction; Aiman Rija wrote the efforts and recommendations; Khulud Qamar wrote the discussion; Kainat Jahangir wrote the discussion and conclusion; and Mohammad Yasir Essar and Faisal Nawaz added critical comments for revision. All authors revised and approved the final draft.

Conflict of interest

None.

Consent for publication

All authors agreed to the publication of this manuscript.

References

Essar, MY, Hasan, MM, Islam, Z, Riaz, MMA, Aborode, AT and Ahmad, S (2021) COVID-19 and multiple crises in Afghanistan: an urgent battle. Conflict and Health 15, 1–3.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Ghebreyesus, TA and Al-Mandhari, A (2021) Acute health needs in Afghanistan must be urgently addressed and health gains protected. Available at https://www.who.int/news/item/22-09-2021-acute-health-needs-in-afghanistan-must-be-urgently-addressed-and-health-gains-protected (Accessed 24 October 2021).Google Scholar
Greenberg, N, Docherty, M, Gnanapragasam, S and Wessely, S (2020) Managing mental health challenges faced by healthcare workers during covid-19 pandemic. British Medical Journal 368. doi: 10.1136/BMJ.M1211.Google ScholarPubMed
Hashemi, A (2012) Afghanistan Health Care System. The Daily Outlook Afghanistan. Available at http://outlookafghanistan.net/topics.php?post_id=6049 (Accessed 24 October 2021).Google Scholar
International Organization for Migration (2020) Afghanistan's frontline healthcare workers continue fight against COVID-19 at great personal risk. Reliefweb. Available at https://reliefweb.int/report/afghanistan/afghanistan-s-frontline-healthcare-workers-continue-fight-against-covid-19-great (Accessed 22 September 2021).Google Scholar
Islam, Z, Rocha, ICN, Mohanan, P, Jain, S, Goyal, S, dos Santos Costa, AC, Ahmad, S, Mehedi Hasan, M and Essar, MY (2021 a) Mental health impacts of humanitarian crisis on healthcare workers in Yemen. Medicine, Conflict and Survival 37, 112–117. doi: 10.1080/13623699.2021.1950519CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Islam, Z, Gangat, SA, Mohanan, P, Rahmat, ZY, Chbib, DE, Marfani, WB and Essar, MY (2021 b) Mental health impacts of Lebanon's economic crisis on healthcare workers amidst COVID-19. The International Journal of Health Planning and Management hpm.3324. doi: 10.1002/HPM.3324.Google ScholarPubMed
Knickmeyer, E (2021) Costs of the Afghanistan war, in lives and dollars. AP News. Available at https://apnews.com/article/middle-east-business-afghanistan-43d8f53b35e80ec18c130cd683e1a38f (Accessed 22 September 2021).Google Scholar
Kovess-Masfety, V, Keyes, K, Karam, E, Sabawoon, A and Sarwari, BA (2021 a) A national survey on depressive and anxiety disorders in Afghanistan: a highly traumatized population. BioMed Central Psychiatry 21, 314. doi: 10.1186/S12888-021-03273-4CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Kovess-Masfety, V, Keyes, K, Karam, E, Sabawoon, A and Sarwari, BA (2021 b) Access to care for mental health problems in Afghanistan: a national challenge. The International Journal of Health Planning and Management 1–9. doi: 10.34172/ijhpm.2021.46.Google ScholarPubMed
Leahy, S (2021) As fighting rages in Afghanistan, health workers are struggling. Al Jazeera News. Available at https://www.aljazeera.com/opinions/2021/8/8/as-fighting-rages-in-afghanistan-health-workers-are-struggling. (Accessed 22 September 2021).Google Scholar
Lucero-Prisno, DE III, Ahmadi, A, Essar, MY, Lin, X and Adebisi, YA (2020 a) Addressing COVID-19 in Afghanistan: what are the efforts and challenges? Journal of Global Health 10, 1–3.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Lucero-Prisno, DE III, Ahmadi, A, Essar, MY, Lin, X and Adebisi, YA (2020 b) Conflict and COVID-19: a double burden for Afghanistan's healthcare system. Conflict and Health 14, 1–3.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Najafizada, SAM, Labonté, R and Bourgeault, IL (2014) Community health workers of Afghanistan: a qualitative study of a national program. Conflict and Health 8, 1–16.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Nemat, A, Asady, A, Raufi, N, Zaki, N, Ehsan, E, Noor, NAH and Zeng, Q (2021) A survey of the healthcare workers in Afghanistan during the COVID-19 pandemic. The American Journal of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene 104, 537–539.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Parray, AA, Dash, S, Ullah, MIK, Inam, ZM and Kaufman, S (2021) Female community health workers and health system navigation in a conflict zone: the case of Afghanistan. Frontiers in Public Health 9. doi: 10.3389/FPUBH.2021.704811/FULL.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Pedneault, J (2019) Afghanistan's silent mental health crisis – human rights watch. Available at https://www.hrw.org/news/2019/10/07/afghanistans-silent-mental-health-crisis (Accessed 10 October 2021).Google Scholar
Reality Check Team BBC (2021) Afghanistan: What has the conflict cost the US and its allies? BBC News. Available at https://www.bbc.com/news/world-47391821 (Accessed 22 September 2021).Google Scholar
Reuters (2021) Taliban say Afghan women health service staff should go back to work. Reuters. Available at https://www.reuters.com/world/asia-pacific/taliban-say-afghan-women-health-service-staff-should-go-back-work-2021-08-27/ (Accessed 24 October 2021).Google Scholar
Rocha, IC, Cedeño, TD, Pelayo, MG, Ramos, K and Victoria, HOH (2021) Myanmar's coup d’état and its impact on COVID-19 response: a collapsing healthcare system in a state of turmoil. British Medical Journal Mil Health. doi: 10.1136/BMJMILITARY-2021-001871.Google Scholar
Shah, J, Essar, MY, Qaderi, S, Rackimuthu, S, Nawaz, FA, Qaderi, F and Shah, A (2021) Respiratory health and critical care concerns in Afghanistan. The Lancet Respiratory Medicine. doi: 10.1016/S2213-2600(21)00583-X.Google ScholarPubMed
World Health Organization (2020 a) Afghanistan: mental health and psychosocial support during #COVID19. World Health Organization. Available at http://www.emro.who.int/mnh/news/afghanistan-mental-health-and-psychosocial-support-during-covid19.html (Accessed 10 October 2021).Google Scholar
World Health Organization (2020 b) Afghanistan ensures continuity of mental health and psychosocial support services during the COVID-19 pandemic. World Health Organization. Available at http://www.emro.who.int/mnh/news/afghanistan-ensures-continuity-of-mental-health-and-psychosocial-support-services-during-the-covid-19-pandemic.html (Accessed 10 October 2021).Google Scholar
World Health Organization, and Health and Ministry of Public Health Afghanistan (2006) WHO-AIMS Mental Health in Afghanistan. World Health Organization. Available at https://www.who.int/mental_health/evidence/Afghanistan_WHO_AIMS_Report.pdf (Accessed 23 September 2021).Google Scholar
Worldometer (2022) Afghanistan COVID Coronavirus Statistics. Worldometer. Available at https://www.worldometers.info/coronavirus/country/afghanistan/ (Accessed 9 January 2022).Google Scholar
Figure 0

Fig. 1. Contributing factors to healthcare worker burnout in Afghanistan.