Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-dh8gc Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-05T09:33:36.189Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Opposing abortion in a feminist paradise: Conservative rhetoric in Iceland

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  03 March 2022

Gunnar Sigvaldason Open the ORCID record for Gunnar Sigvaldason [Opens in a new window]  and
Silja Bára Ómarsdóttir Open the ORCID record for Silja Bára Ómarsdóttir [Opens in a new window]
Gunnar Sigvaldason*
Affiliation:
Faculty of Political Science, University of Iceland
Silja Bára Ómarsdóttir*
Affiliation:
Faculty of Political Science, University of Iceland
*
*Corresponding author. Email: [email protected]; [email protected]
*Corresponding author. Email: [email protected]; [email protected]
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

This article addresses the conservative opposition to Iceland’s recently liberalised abortion laws. It argues that the opposition belongs to a long and rich history of conservatives willing to employ diverse measures to oppose progress. It further claims that the rhetoric employed has strong roots in the conservative tradition. This is demonstrated by the fact that the discourse in Iceland fits within Hirschman’s analytical framework, through which he analyses the main arguments of conservatives in the past. Icelandic conservatives argued that the proposed legislation would lead to the perverse effect that healthy foetuses would be aborted, that the legislation was futile, as the system was already well-functioning, and that it would jeopardise women by giving them the sole responsibility of deciding whether to terminate a pregnancy. The article sheds light on the underlying resistance to women’s bodily autonomy and right to self-determination. It also illustrates the importance of hierarchy and conservatism’s opposition to equality that is perceived to be taken too far. In light of global trends, where conservatives have tried to implement policies that are hostile towards women and women’s interests, it is important to explore national contexts where legislative success has been achieved despite global backlash.

Keywords

abortionconservatismIcelandpolitical rhetoricreproductive rights
Type
Research Article
Information
Global Constitutionalism , Volume 11 , Issue 3: Populist Challenges to Global Governance: Feminist Perspectives , November 2022 , pp. 430 - 449
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2022. Published by Cambridge University Press

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Alþingi. 1975. ‘Lög um ráðgjöf og fræðslu varðandi kynlíf og barneignir og um fóstureyðingar og ófrjósemisaðgerðir’. Available at: <https://www.althingi.is/lagas/148c/1975025.html>..>Google Scholar
Alþingi. 2018. ‘Þungunarrof’. Available at: <https://www.althingi.is/thingstorf/thingmalalistar-eftir-thingum/ferill/?ltg=149&mnr=393>..>Google Scholar
Alþingi. 2019. ‘Atkvæðagreiðsla’. Available at: <https://www.althingi.is/thingstorf/thingmalin/atkvaedagreidsla/?nnafnak=57254>..>Google Scholar
Andrews, Molly. 2004. ‘Opening to the Original Contributions: Counter-narratives and the Power to Oppose’. In Considering Counter-narratives: Narrating, Resisting, Making Sense, edited by Bamberg, Michael and Andrews, Molly, 1–6. Amsterdam: John Benjamins.Google Scholar
Bamberg, Michael. 2005. ‘Master Narrative’. In Routledge Encyclopedia of Narrative Theory, edited by Herman, David, Jahn, Manfred and Ryan, Marie Laure, 287–88. New York: Routledge.Google Scholar
Bennett, Andrew and Elman, Colin. 2007. ‘Case Study Methods in the International Relations Subfield’. Comparative Political Studies 40(2):170–95.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bloomer, Fiona K. and O’Dowd, Kellie. 2014. ‘Restricted Access to Abortion in the Republic of Ireland and Northern Ireland: Exploring Abortion Tourism and Barriers to Legal Reform’. Culture, Health & Sexuality 16(4): 366–80.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Bloomer, Fiona K., Pierson, Claire and Claudio, Sylvia Estrada. 2018. ‘Abortion Discourses: Religion, Culture, Nation’. In Reimagining Global Abortion Politics: A Social Justice Perspective, edited by Bloomer, Fiona, Pierson, Claire and Claudio, Sylvia Estrada, 51–68. Bristol: Policy Press.Google Scholar
Brynjólfsson, Ari. 2019. ‘Greinilegur kynslóðamunur á afstöðu til þungunarrofs’. Fréttablaðið, 14 May. Available at: <https://www.frettabladid.is/frettir/greinilegur-kynsloamunur-a-afstou-til-ungunarrofs>..>Google Scholar
Burke, Edmund. 2001 [1790]. Reflections on Revolution in France, edited by Clark, J.C.D.. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.Google Scholar
Calkin, Sydney and Browne, Kath. 2020. ‘Introduction: Research’. In After Repeal: Rethinking Abortion Politics, edited by Browne, Kath and Calkin, Sydney, 1–18. London: Zed Books.Google Scholar
Chicago Tribune . 1994. ‘AUH20 IN ‘94’, 23 October. Available at: <https://www.chicagotribune.com/news/ct-xpm-1994-10-23-9410230239-story.html>..>Google Scholar
Coakley, John and Gallagher, Michael (eds). 2018. Politics in the Republic of Ireland, 6th ed. London: Routledge.Google Scholar
Dahlqvist, Anna. 2012. I det tysta: Resor på Europas abortmarknad. Stockholm: Atlas.Google Scholar
de Londras, Fiona and Enright, Máiréad. 2018. Repealing the 8th: Reforming Irish Abortion Law. Bristol: Policy Press.Google Scholar
Directorate of Health. 2019. ‘Fréttabréf landlæknis um heilbrigðisupplýsingar’. Talnabrunnur 13(6). Available at: <https://www.landlaeknir.is/servlet/file/store93/item37499/Talnabrunnur_Juli_2019_.pdf>..>Google Scholar
Fairclough, Norman and Wodak, Ruth. 1997. ‘Critical Discourse Analysis’. In Discourse as Social Interaction, edited by van Dijk, Teun A., 258–84. London: Sage.Google Scholar
Ferriter, Diarmaid. 2004. The Transformation of Ireland, 1900–2000. London: Profile Books.Google Scholar
Field, Luke. 2018. ‘The Abortion referendum of 2018 and a Timeline of Abortion Politics in Ireland to Date’. Irish Political Studies 33(4): 608–28.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Friðriksson, Ásmundur. 2019. “Þungunarrof.” 149th session of Alþingi, 103rd meeting. Alþingi, 13 May. Available at: <https://www.althingi.is/altext/raeda/149/rad20190513T182721.html>..>Google Scholar
Friðriksson, Hanna Katrín, 2019. “Þungunarrof.” 149th session of Alþingi, 98th meeting. Alþingi, 2 May. Available at: <https://www.althingi.is/altext/raeda/149/rad20190502T182703.html>..>Google Scholar
George, Alexander L. and Bennett, Andrew. 2005. Case Studies and Theory Development in the Social Sciences. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.Google Scholar
Gerring, John. 2004. ‘What is a Case Study and What is It Good for?’ American Political Science Review 98(2): 341–54.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gerring, John. 2011. ‘The Case Study: What It Is and What It Does’. In The Oxford Handbook of Political Science, edited by Goodin, Robert E., 645–84. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Girvin, Brian. 2008. ‘Church, State, and Society in Ireland since 1960’. Éire-Ireland 43(1&2): 74–98.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gíslason, Ingólfur V. and Símonardóttir, Sunna. 2018. ‘Mothering and Gender Equality in Iceland: Irreconcilable Opposites?’ Social Policy & Society 17(3): 457–66.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Goldberg, Robert Alan. 1995. Barry Goldwater. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.Google Scholar
Goldwater, Barry. 2007 [1960]. The Conscience of a Conservative. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Government of Iceland. 2018. ‘Facts About Down’s Syndrome and Pre-natal Screening in Iceland’. Available at: <https://www.government.is/diplomatic-missions/embassy-article/2018/03/26/Facts-about-Downs-syndrome-and-pre-natal-screening-in-Iceland>..>Google Scholar
Government of Iceland. 2019. Termination of Pregnancy Act. Available at: <https://www.government.is/Publications/Legislation/Lex/?newsid=8e37d105-0b91-11ea-9453-005056bc4d74>..>Google Scholar
Grzebalska, Weronika. 2015. ‘Poland’. In Gender as Symbolic Glue: The Position and Role of the Conservative and Far Right Parties in the Anti-gender Mobilizations in Europe, edited by Kováts, Eszter and Põim, Maari, 83–103. Brussels: Foundation for European Progressive Studies.Google Scholar
Grzebalska, Weronika and Pető, Andrea. 2017. ‘The Gendered Modus Operandi of the Illiberal Transformation in Hungary and Poland’. Women’s Studies International Forum 68: 164–72.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gunnlaugsson, Sigmundur Davíð. 2019. ‘Þungunarrof’. 149th session of Alþingi, 103rd meeting. Alþingi, 13 May. Available at: <https://www.althingi.is/altext/raeda/149/rad20190513T174010.html>..>Google Scholar
Gústafsdóttir, Guðný. 2013. ‘Kvenleiki sem orðræða’. In Söguþing 2012: Ráðstefnurit. Reykjavík: Sagnfræðistofnun.Google Scholar
Halpern, Sue. 2018. ‘How Republicans Became Anti-Choice’. The New York Review of Books, 8 November. Available at: <https://www.nybooks.com/articles/2018/11/08/how-republicans-became-anti-choice>..>Google Scholar
Hayek, Friedrich A. 1944. The Road to Serfdom. London: Routledge.Google Scholar
Hirschman, Albert O. 1991. The Rhetoric of Reaction: Perversity, Futility, Jeopardy. Cambridge, MA: The Belknap Press of Harvard University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Honderich, Ted. 2005. Conservatism : Burke, Nozick, Bush, Blair?, rev. ed. London: Pluto Press Google Scholar
Howarth, David. 2005. ‘Applying Discourse Theory: The Method of Articulation’. In Discourse Theory in European Politics: Identity, Policy and Governance, edited by Howarth, David and Torfing, Jacob, 316–50. Houndmills: Palgrave Macmillan.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Inglis, Tom. 1998. Moral Monopoly: The Rise and Fall of the Catholic Church in Modern Ireland. 2nd ed. Dublin: University College Dublin.Google Scholar
Jakobsdóttir, Katrín. 2019. “Um atkvæðagreiðslu”. 149th session of Alþingi, 103rd meeting. Alþingi (13 May). Available at: <https://www.althingi.is/altext/raeda/149/rad20190513T172527.html>..>Google Scholar
Kekes, John. 1998. A Case for Conservatism. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.Google Scholar
King, Martin Luther Jr. 1986 [1963]. ‘Letter from Birmingham City Jail’. In A Testament of Hope: The Essential Writings and Speeches of Martin Luther King, Jr, edited by Washington, James M., 289–302. New York: HarperCollins.Google Scholar
Kirk, Russell. 1957. The Intelligent Woman’s Guide to Conservatism. New York: Devin-Adair.Google Scholar
Kristinsson, Guðmundur Ingi. 2019. ‘Þungunarrof’. 149th session of Alþingi, 101st meeting. Alþingi (7 May). Available at: <https://www.althingi.is/altext/raeda/149/rad20190507T170745.html>..>Google Scholar
Lavakas, Paul J. 2008. Encyclopedia of Survey Research Methods. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Maistre, Joseph Marie, comte de. 1994 [1797]. Considerations on France, translated and edited by Lebrun, Richard A.. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Mbl.is. 2019. ‘Segir lýðræðið hætt að virka sem skyldi’, 9 November. Available at: <https://www.mbl.is/frettir/innlent/2019/11/09/segir_lydraedid_haett_ad_virka_sem_skyldi>..>Google Scholar
Müller, Jan-Werner. 2006. ‘Comprehending Conservatism: A new framework for analysis’. Journal of Political Ideologies 11(3): 359–65.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
National Institute for Health and Welfare. 2019. Statistical Report Induced Abortions in the Nordic Countries 2017. Available at: <https://www.julkari.fi/bitstream/handle/10024/137803/Tr04_19.pdf?sequence=5&isAllowed=y>..>Google Scholar
Oakeshott, Michael. 1962. Rationalism in Politics and Other Essays. London: Methuen.Google Scholar
Olund, Eric. 2020. ‘Repealing a “Legacy of Shame”: Press Coverage of Emotional Geographies of Secrecy and Shame in Ireland’s Abortion Debate’. In After Repeal: Rethinking Abortion Politics, edited by Kath Browne and Sydney Calkin, 174–88. London: Zed Books.Google Scholar
Ólason, Bergþór. 2019. ‘Þungunarrof’. 149th session of Alþingi, 103rd meeting. Alþingi, 13 May. Available at: <https://www.althingi.is/altext/raeda/149/rad20190513T173316.html>..>Google Scholar
Ómarsdóttir, Alma. 2019a. ‘Aldrei veitt undanþága vegna félagslegra þátta’. RÚV, 21 May. Available at: <https://www.ruv.is/frett/aldrei-veitt-undanthaga-vegna-felagslegra-thatta>..>Google Scholar
Ómarsdóttir, Alma. 2019b. ‘Erfitt að vera kallaður morðingi’. RÚV, 12 May. Available at: <https://www.ruv.is/frett/erfitt-ad-vera-kalladur-mordingi>..>Google Scholar
Ómarsdóttir, Silja Bára and Rögnvaldsdóttir, Steinunn. 2015. Rof: frásagnir kvenna af fóstureyðingum. Reykjavík: Háskólaútgáfan.Google Scholar
Perlstein, Rick. 2014. The Invisible Bridge: The Fall of Nixon and the Rise of Reagan. New York: Simon & Schuster.Google Scholar
Pierson, Claire. 2018. ‘One Step Forwards, Two Steps Back: Women’s Rights 20 Years After the Good Friday Agreement’. Parliamentary Affairs 71: 461–81.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Pierson, Claire and Bloomer, Fiona. 2017. ‘Macro- and Micro-Political Vernaculizations of Rights: Human Rights and Abortion Discourses in Northern Ireland’. Health and Human Rights Journal 19(1): 173–85.Google ScholarPubMed
Pierson, Claire and Bloomer, Fiona. 2018. ‘Anti-Abortion Myths in Political Discourse’. In Crossing Troubled Water: Abortion in Ireland, Northern Ireland, and Prince Edward Island, edited by MacQuarrie, Collen, Bloomer, Fiona, Pierson, Claire and Stettner, Shannon, 184–203. Charlottetown, PEI: Island Studies Press.Google Scholar
Pincus, Ingrid. 2009. ‘Men, Power and the Problem of Gender Equality Policy Implementation’. In The Political Interests of Gender Revisited: Redoing Theory and Research with a Feminist Face, edited by Jónasdóttir, Anna G. and Jones, Kathleen B.. Manchester: Manchester University Press.Google Scholar
Reidy, Theresa. 2020. ‘The 2018 Abortion Referendum: Over Before It Began!’ In After Repeal: Rethinking Abortion Politics, edited by Browne, Kath and Calkin, Sydney, 21–35. London: Zed Books.Google Scholar
Robin, Corey. 2018. The Reactionary Mind: Conservatism from Edmund Burke to Donald Trump, 2nd ed. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Rossiter, Ann. 2009. Ireland’s Hidden Diaspora: The Abortion Trail and the Making of a London–Irish Underground 1980–2000. London: IASC Publishing.Google Scholar
Scruton, Roger. 2001. The Meaning of Conservatism, 3 rd ed. Houndmills: Palgrave Macmillan.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Sigurhansdóttir, Gunnhildur. 2014. Þá er hrópað hátt um líf og synd og glæp: Um rauðsokkur, frjálsar fóstureyðingar og andstöðu. Unpublished master’s thesis. Reykjavík: University of Iceland.Google Scholar
Szelewa, Dorota. 2014. ‘The Second Wave of Anti-feminism? Post-crisis Maternalist Policies and the Attack on the Concept of Gender in Poland’. Gender, rovné příležitosti, výzkum 15(2): 33–47.Google Scholar
World Economic Forum (WEF). 2020. Global Gender Report 2020. Geneva: WEF. Available at: <http://www3.weforum.org/docs/WEF_GGGR_2020.pdf>..>Google Scholar
Venker, Suzanne and Schlafly, Phyllis. 2010. The Flipside of Feminism: What Conservative Women Know – and Men Can’t Say. Washington, DC: WND Books.Google Scholar
Williams, Daniel K. 2010. God’s Own Party: The Making of the Christian Right. Oxford: Oxford University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Wodak, Ruth. 2008. ‘Critical Discourse Analysis: Theory and Interdisciplinarity’. In Intertwinings: Interdisciplinary Encounters with Merleau-Ponty, edited by Gail Weiss, 302–16. Albany, NY: State University of New York Press.Google Scholar
Wodak, Ruth. 2009. ‘Critical Discourse Analysis: History, Agenda, Theory, and Methodology’. In Methods for Critical Discourse Analysis, edited by Ruth Wodak and Michael Meyer, 1–33. London: Sage.Google Scholar
Yin, Robert K. 2014. Case Study Research: Design and Methods, 5 th ed. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.Google Scholar
Þórarinsson, Birgir. 2019. ‘Þungunarrof’. 149th session of Alþingi, 98th meeting. Alþingi (2 May). Available at: <https://www.althingi.is/altext/raeda/149/rad20190502T185652.html>..>Google Scholar
Ævarsdóttir, Þórhildur Sunna. 2019. ‘Þungunarrof’. 149th session of Alþingi, 98th meeting. Alþingi, 2 May. Available at: <https://www.althingi.is/altext/raeda/149/rad20190502T214104.html>..>Google Scholar