Article contents
Goodies and Baddies: The Presentation of German Police and Criminals in East and West Television Drama
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 06 March 2019
Extract
Criminal Justice is never only about identifying and sentencing unwanted and thus, outlawed behaviour. As one of the closest contacts between state and citizens, Criminal Justice implies also a system of values and more or less subtle messages which the state wants to transmit to the people. In all modern legal systems, Criminal Law is about society as a whole being deterred from crime, educated and moreover ensured of the state's power, its efficiency and above all its benevolence. In other words, Criminal Justice does not only deal with offenders and victims but additionally with its own presentation in public and the citizens’ perception of it.
- Type
- Articles
- Information
- Copyright
- Copyright © 2005 by German Law Journal GbR
References
1 Steve Greenfield & Guy Osborn, Film, Law and the Delivery of Justice: The case of Judge Dredd and the disappearing courtroom, 6 Journal of Criminal Justice and Popular Culture, 35 (1999).Google Scholar
2 Some of these 153 episodes are lost today but I could not find out which ones and how many in total.Google Scholar
3 Erwin Lautsch & Frank von der Heide, Entwicklung der Straftaten und der Aufklärungsquote in der DDR von 1985-1989, Neue Justiz, 12 (1991).Google Scholar
4 Interviews with former GDR lawyersGoogle Scholar
5 Broadcast 1959-1968Google Scholar
6 Inga Markovits, Last Days, 80 California Law Review, 73, 98 (1992).Google Scholar
7 There was a separate police investigating, a separate prosecutor charging, a separate court trying with separate defence lawyers, and a separate prison executing; Markovits, supra, at 97.Google Scholar
8 §§ 142, 215, 216 StGB-DDRGoogle Scholar
9 Exception episode “Holzwege” (“Wrong Tracks”) episode no. 51Google Scholar
10 Hoff, Peter, Polizeiruf 110 – Filme, Fälle, Fakten, 76 (2001)‥Google Scholar
11 It was stressed that many stories were based on real cases. Guder, supra, note 15 at 6Google Scholar
12 Guder, Andrea & Wehn, Karin, Polizeiruf 110: the Transition from Socialism to Capitalism, 8 HALMA. Hallische Medienarbeiten, 12, (1998) available at: http://www.medienkomm.uni-halle.de/forschung/publikationen/halma8.pdf Google Scholar
13 Hoff, Peter, GDR-TV meets USA, Die vereinigten Staaten von Amerika im unterhaltenden DDR-Fernsehspiel und – Film der fünfziger bis siebziger Jahre, in Jeans, Rock & Vietnam. Amerikanische Kultur in der DDR. (Hörnig, Therese/Stephan, Alexander Eds., 2002)Google Scholar
14 Television of the GDRGoogle Scholar
15 For example, they did not want the police shown having a cake and coffee break on duty, which would be quite normal in real life but would undermine the official picture of the hard-working never-resting police.Google Scholar
16 The police superiors liked the programme (and one actor remembers drinking vodka with the police chief, who also offered him protection in small offences, like speeding).Google Scholar
17 Guder, & Wehn, , (note 12), 13.Google Scholar
18 Guder, Andrea, Das Kriminlgenre im Fernsehn der DDR: Aktueller Forschungsstand und auswahlbiographie, 3 HALMA. Hallische Medienarbeiten, 6 (1996) available at: http://www.medienkomm.uni-halle.de/forschung/publikationen/halma3.pdf Google Scholar
19 Guder, (note 18), 18.Google Scholar
20 Hoff, (note 10), 93 .Google Scholar
21 German Television and RadioGoogle Scholar
22 Ostdeutscher Rundfunk (East German Broadcasting); Mitteldeutscher Rundfunk (Middle German Broadcasting)Google Scholar
23 Allgemeiner Rundfunk Deutschland (General Broadcasting Germany)Google Scholar
24 Guder & Wehn, (note 12), 13.Google Scholar
25 Besides the children series Sandmännchen Google Scholar
26 Guder & Wehn, (note 12), 12.Google Scholar
27 Guder, (note 18), 6.Google Scholar
28 Sometimes there are even contradictions, i.e. a detective has a family in one episode and is single in the next one.Google Scholar
29 Another reason why the characters remained often superficial is that frequently when the authors wrote an episode they did not know yet which policeman would take the main part.; Guder, (note 18), 17.Google Scholar
30 Lieutenant. Whereas in the FRG the detectives have administrative ranks (inspector) the GDR used military ranks, because the police was an armed state force, too.Google Scholar
31 “Fuchs” means foxGoogle Scholar
32 “Prejudice?” episode no. 42Google Scholar
33 Guder & Wehn, (note 12), 15.Google Scholar
34 Only in one episode, no. 107 ('Kein Tag wie jeder andere’ ‘Not a day like any other'), a policeman has a crush on a female colleague and the police work is endangered. This is one of the very rare cases where a detective is strongly criticised by his superior, but this incident is presented as an absolute exception.Google Scholar
35 Hoff, (note 10), 52.Google Scholar
36 Even when they use gloves, they take them off at one point in time and touch something.Google Scholar
37 “The broken Mirror” episode no. 101Google Scholar
38 So it might be realistic that in this episode three colleagues were all wearing the same kind of jacket.Google Scholar
39 Of course scientific excellence also contributes to the entertainment of the audience, who has always been fascinated by this since Sherlock Holmes until CSI.Google Scholar
40 “Quick Money” episode no. 87Google Scholar
41 “The Crossword Case” episode no. 123Google Scholar
42 That shows that there is information collected about where people work and the police had access to their files.Google Scholar
43 Dominick, Joseph R., Crime and Law Enforcement on Prime-Time television, 37 Public Opinion Quarterly, 241, 246 (1973).Google Scholar
44 One of my interviewees said that he would not bring a charge as long as he had no confession by the accused.Google Scholar
45 § 109 Criminal Procedure Code of the GDRGoogle Scholar
46 § 87 Criminal Procedure Code of the GDRGoogle Scholar
47 Greenfield and Osborn, (note 1), 38.Google Scholar
48 Greenfield and Osborn, (note 1), 40.Google Scholar
49 The case “Der Mann im Baum” ends in a manhunt for a rapist; when the police finally get him the police woman who had been attacked earlier (as part of the trap to catch him) indeed slaps him. But this was a spontaneous reaction by the actress who had identified too much with the role. However, the scene was not cut.Google Scholar
50 Guder, (note 18), 15.Google Scholar
51 Guder, (note 18), 16.Google Scholar
52 Brück, Ingrid & Viehoff, Reinhold Crime genre and television. From Stahlnetz to Tatort: a realistic tradition .8 HALMA Hallische Medienarbeiten, 3, 6 (1998), available at: http://www.medienkomm.unihalle.de/forschung/publikationen/halma8.pdf Google Scholar
53 Hoff, (note 10), 43.Google Scholar
54 However, often criminals in Polizeiruf 110 have not finished their school education; Hoff, (note 10), 74.Google Scholar
55 Dominick, (note 43), 250.Google Scholar
56 Brück & Viehoff, (note 47), 7.Google Scholar
57 Dominick, (note 43), 250.Google Scholar
58 “The Broken mirror” episode no. 101Google Scholar
59 For example “Der Mann in Baum”, where the problems and prejudices, which a rape victim has to face, are shown.Google Scholar
60 “Minutes too late” episode no. 9 for example the extremely oppressive education by the child abuser's mother.Google Scholar
61 For example, jealousy or greed has to be sufficient for the viewer to explain, why somebody commits a murder.Google Scholar
62 The high number of episodes in which at some point in time somebody is blackmailed implied the message that one should always be ‘clean'Google Scholar
63 For example, episodes no. 1 “Der Fall Lisa Murnau”, no. 38 “Schwarze Ladung”, or no. 43 “Bitte Zahlen”.Google Scholar
64 “The Devil made the Liquor” episode no. 69Google Scholar
65 In the late 1980s, however, state control became much harsher and the unusually short length of some episodes strongly indicates that censorship cut out critical scenes.Google Scholar
66 Dominick, (note 43), 242.Google Scholar
67 Hoff, (note 10), 94.Google Scholar
68 “The Case Lisa Murnau” episode no. 1Google Scholar
69 Episodes no. 21 “Per Anhalter” (“Per Hitchhiker”), no. 64 “Der Einzelgänger” (“The Loner”), no. 29 “Nachttaxi” (“Night Taxi”), no. 94 “Inklusive Risiko” (“Risk Inclusive”)Google Scholar
70 “Miscalculation” episode no. 25Google Scholar
71 Hoff, (note 10), 70.Google Scholar
72 “Guilty” episode no. 55Google Scholar
73 Hoff, (note 10), 85.Google Scholar
74 Some channels produce for Tatort and Polizeiruf.Google Scholar
75 Guder & Wehn, (note 12), 20.Google Scholar
76 Karin Wehn, Deutsche Krimitraditionen im Überblick: Der deutsche Fernsehkrimi im dualen Rundfunksystem, 9 HALMA. Hallische Medienarbeiten, 1, 7 (1998) avaialable at: http://www.medienkomm.unihalle.de/forschung/publikationen/halma9.pdf Google Scholar
77 Guder & Wehn, (note 12), 21.Google Scholar
78 Guder & Wehn, (note 12), 20.Google Scholar
79 For example new technique, new products; Wehn, (note 78), 7.Google Scholar
80 Guder & Wehn, (note 12), 22.Google Scholar
81 In “Unter Brüdern” (Between Brothers”) Grawe and Fuchs are seen absolutely drunk.Google Scholar
82 “Roter Kaviar” (“Red Caviar”) episode no. 177Google Scholar
83 Wehn, (note 78), 35.Google Scholar
84 “Mit dem Anruf kommt der Tod” (“The Death comes with the Call”) episode no. 151Google Scholar
85 Guder & Wehn, (note 12), 20.Google Scholar
86 Guder & Wehn, (note 12), 9.Google Scholar
87 A noteworthy exception is the post GDR Polizeiruf 110.Google Scholar
88 Dominick, (note 43), 250.Google Scholar
- 4
- Cited by