¹ Transgender or trans is an umbrella terms which refers to a person who does not self-identify with the legal sex that was assigned to them at birth.Google Scholar

² See, e.g., Nandi, Jacinta, Germany Got It Right by Offering a Third Gender Option on Birth Certificates, The Guardian (Nov. 10, 2013), https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2013/nov/10/germany-third-gender-birth-certificate; Friederike Heine, ‘Third Gender’ Official in Germany from November, Spiegel Online (Aug. 16, 2013), http://www.spiegel.de/international/germany/third-gender-option-to-become-available-on-german-birth-certificates-a-916940.html; Germany to Become First European State to Allow ‘Third Gender’ Birth Certificates, RT (Aug. 17, 2013), https://www.rt.com/news/third-gender-birth-germany-592/; Amanda Scherker, Germany To Offer Third Gender Option On Birth Certificates, Huffington Post (Aug. 17, 2018), www.huffingtonpost.co.uk/entry/germany-third-gender_n_3769055. According to the (former) Intersex Society of North America, “intersex” “is a general term used for a variety of conditions in which a person is born with a reproductive or sexual anatomy that doesn't seem to fit the typical definitions of female or male.” Intersex Society of North America, What is Intersex?, http://www.isna.org/faq/what_is_intersex (last visited Jan. 9, 2018).Google Scholar

³ Marjolein van den Brink & Jet Tigchelaar, Gender Identity and Registration of Sex by Public Authorities, 2 Eur. Equality L. Rev. 29 (2015); Marjolein van den Brink, Philipp Reu & Jet Tigchelaar, Out of the Box? Domestic and Private International Law Aspects of Gender Registration: A Comparative Analysis of Germany and the Netherlands, 17(2) Eur. J. of L. Reform 282 (2015).Google Scholar

⁴ See id.; Zwischengeschlecht.org, STOP Intersex Genital Mutilations in Children's Clinics, stop.genitalmutilation.org/post/Intersex-3rd-gender-in-Germany-Silly-season-fantasies-vs-reality-of-genital-mutilations (last visited Jan. 9, 2018).Google Scholar

⁵ Nina Dethloff & Susanne Gössl, Country Report for Germany, in M/V en Verder; Sekseregistratie door de Overheid en de Juridische Positie van Transgenders 137, 139 (Marjolein van den Brink & Jet Tigchelaar ed., 2014).Google Scholar

⁶ Nov. 1 2013, No. 21.4.3 Allgemeine Verwaltungsvorschrift zum Personenstandsgesetz [General Administrative Regulation on the Personal Status Law].Google Scholar

⁷ Personenstandsgesetz [PStG] [Law on Civil Status], Feb. 19, 2007, BGBl I at § 22 para. 3 (Ger.).Google Scholar

⁸ Bundesverfassungsgericht [BVerfGE] [Federal Constitutional Court], Case No. 1 BvR 2019/16 (Oct. 10, 2017), https://www.bundesverfassungsgericht.de/SharedDocs/Entscheidungen/DE/2017/10/rs20171010_1bvr201916.html.Google Scholar

⁹ Transgender or trans is an umbrella terms which refers to person who do not self-identify with the legal sex that was assigned to them at birth.Google Scholar

¹⁰ The complainant prefers gender neutral “They/Them” pronouns, which the authors respect in this article.Google Scholar

¹¹ Grundgesetz [GG] [Basic Law], arts. 1(1), 2(1), translation at https://www.btg-bestellservice.de/pdf/80201000.pdf.Google Scholar

¹² Id. at art. 3(3).Google Scholar

¹³ Judgment of Oct. 10, 2017 at paras. 38–40.Google Scholar

¹⁴ See judgment of Oct. 10, 2017 at para. 42.Google Scholar

¹⁵ See judgment of Oct. 10, 2017 at paras. 45–54.Google Scholar

¹⁶ See judgment of Oct. 10, 2017 at paras. 56–60.Google Scholar

¹⁷ See judgment of Oct. 10, 2017 at para. 65.Google Scholar

¹⁸ Bundesverfassungsgericht [BVerfGE] [Federal Constitutional Court], 1 BvR 16/72, BVerfGE 49, 286 (Oct. 11, 1978).Google Scholar

¹⁹ Transsexuellengesetz [TSG] [Transsexuality Act], Sept. 10, 1980, BGBl I at 1654, last amended by art. 1 of the Act, July 17, 2009, BGBl I at 1978 (Ger.).Google Scholar

²⁰ See, e.g., Bundesverfassungsgericht [BVerfGE] [Federal Constitutional Court], 1 BvL 1/04, BVerfGE 116, 243 (July 18, 2006) (detailing the nationality requirement); Bundesverfassungsgericht [BVerfGE] [Federal Constitutional Court], 1 BvR 938/81, BVerfGE 60, 123 (Mar. 16, 1982) (describing the minimum age requirement of 25-year-old); Bundesverfassungsgericht [BVerfG] [Federal Constitutional Court], 1 BvL 3/03, BVerfGE 115, 1 (Dec. 6, 2005) (discussing the loss of the changed name after marriage).Google Scholar

²¹ Bundesverfassungsgericht [BVerfG] [Federal Constitutional Court], 1 BvL 10/05, BVerfGE 121, 175 (May 27, 2008).Google Scholar

²² Bundesverfassungsgericht [BVerfG] [Federal Constitutional Court], 1 BvR 3295/07, BVerfGE 128, 109 (Jan. 11, 2011).Google Scholar

²³ Chris Ambrosi, Die Dritte Option: Für wen?, VerfBlog (Nov. 29, 2017), https://verfassungsblog.de/die-dritte-option-fuer-wen; Bundesverfassungsgericht [BVerfG] [Federal Constitutional Court], 1 BvL 10/05, BVerfGE 121, 175 (May 27, 2008).Google Scholar

²⁴ See judgment of May 27, 2008 at para. 26.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

²⁵ Berit Völzmann, Gleiche Freiheit für alle!, VerfBlog (Nov. 17, 2017), http://verfassungsblog.de/gleiche-freiheit-fuer-alle-zur-freiheitsrechtlichen-begruendung-des-bverfg-in-der-entscheidung-zur-dritten-option; Sarah Elsuni, “Harter oder weicher Sexit”?, VerfBlog (Nov. 17, 2017), http://verfassungsblog.de/harter-oder-weicher-sexit/.Google Scholar

²⁶ Bundesverfassungsgericht [BVerfG] [Federal Constitutional Court], 1 BvF 1/01, BVerfGE 205, 313 (July 17, 2002).Google Scholar

²⁷ Anne E.H. Sanders, When, if not Now? An Update on Civil Partnership in Germany, 17 German L.J. 487 (2016); Nora Markard, Dropping the Other Shoe: Obergefell and the Inevitability of the Constitutional Right to Equal Marriage, 17 German L.J. 509 (2016).Google Scholar

²⁸ Jule Mulder, EU Non-Discrimination law in the Courts: Approaches to Sex and Sexuality Discrimination in EU law 120–39 (2017).Google Scholar

²⁹ See generally Adamietz, Laura, Geschlecht als Erwartung (2011).Google Scholar

³⁰ Bundesverfassungsgericht [BVerfGE] [Federal Constitutional Court], Case No. 1 BvR 2019/16, paras. 50, 58 (Oct. 10, 2017), https://www.bundesverfassungsgericht.de/SharedDocs/Entscheidungen/DE/2017/10/rs20171010_1bvr201916.html.Google Scholar

³¹ Ambrosi, supra note 23.Google Scholar

³² Nora Markard, Struktur und Teilhabe: zur gleichheitsdogmatischen Bedeutung der “dritten Option”, VerfBlog (Nov. 14, 2017), https://verfassungsblog.de/struktur-und-teilhabe-zur-gleichheitsdogmatischen-bedeutung-der-dritten-option/. For the English translation, see Markard, Nora, Symposium on the ‘Third Option’, ‘Not Man, Not Woman, Not Nothing’: Structure and Participation: On the Significance of the ‘Third Option’ for the Equality Guarantee, Blog of the IACL, AIDC (Feb. 3, 2018), https://iacl-aidc-blog.org/2018/02/03/symposium-on-the-third-option-not-man-not-woman-not-nothing-structure-and-participation-on-the-significance-of-the-third-option-for-the-equality-guarantee/.Google Scholar

³³ Case C-13/94 P v. S & Cornwall Cty. Council, 1996 E.C.R. I-2143 paras. 17–21.Google Scholar

³⁴ Case C-117/01 K.B. v. Nat'l Health Serv. Pensions Agency, 2004 E.C.R I-541.Google Scholar

³⁵ Alex Harris, Non-binary Gender Concepts and the Evolving Legal Treatment of UK Transsexed Individuals, 13(6) J. Int'l. Women's Stud. 57 (2012).Google Scholar

³⁶ See Case C-423/04 Richards v. Sec'y of State for Work and Pensions, 2006 E.C.R. I-3585; see also Opinion of Advocate General Bobek, Case C-451/16 M.B. v. Sec'y of State for Work and Pensions (Dec. 5, 2017).Google Scholar

³⁷ Mulder, supra note 28, at 47–54.Google Scholar

³⁸ For an overview, see Mulder, supra note 28, at 122–23.Google Scholar

³⁹ Dorian Needham, A Categorical Imperative? Questioning the Need for Sexual Classification in Québec, 52(1) Les Cahiers de droit 71, 73 (2011); Sonia Katyal, The Numerous Clausus of Sex, 84 U. Chi. L. Rev. 389, 405 (2017). See generally Valentine, Vic, Non-Binary People's Experiences in the UK (2016), https://www.scottishtrans.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/08/Report-final.pdf.Google Scholar

⁴⁰ Jack Monroe, I'm a Little Bit Female and a Little Bit Male. Finally, I Fit in my Skin, The Guardian (May 19, 2016), https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2016/may/19/jack-monroe-little-bit-male-little-bit-female; Siobhan Fenton, “A Hole in Your Chest Where Gender Used to Be”: Being Non-binary in the UK, The Independent (Sept. 21, 2016), http://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/what-does-non-binary-mean-what-its-like-to-not-have-a-male-female-gender-a7317086.html.Google Scholar

⁴¹ James, Sandy E. et al., The Report of the 2015 U.S. Transgender Survey 44 (2016).Google Scholar

⁴² Terry S Kogan, Transsexuals and Critical Gender Theory: The Possibility of a Restroom Labelled “Other”, 48 Hastings L.J. 1223, 1224 (1996); Murray Couch et al., Tranznation: A Report on the Health and Wellbeing of Trans People in Australia and New Zealand 69 (2007).Google Scholar

⁴³ Genny Beemyn & Susan Rankin, The Lives of Transgender People 152 (2011).Google Scholar

⁴⁴ Megan Davidson, Seeking Refuge under the Umbrella: Inclusion, Exclusion, and Organising within the Category Transgender 4(4) Sexuality Res. and Soc. Pol'y 60, 66 (2007); Amy McCrea, Under the Transgender Umbrella: Improving ENDA's Protections 15 Geo. J. Gender and L. 543, 556 (2014).Google Scholar

⁴⁵ Patricia Gagne, Richard Tewksbury & Deanna McGaughey, Coming Out and Crossing Over: Identity Formation and Proclamation in a Transgender Community 11 Gender and Soc. 478, 501 (1997).Google Scholar

⁴⁶ Cisgender—derived from the Latin word, “cis”, meaning “on this side of”—refers to persons who self-identify with the legal sex that is assigned to them at birth.Google Scholar

⁴⁷ Case C-13/94 P v. S & Cornwall Cty. Council, 1996 E.C.R. I-2143 para. 20.Google Scholar

⁴⁸ Identoba & Others v. Geor., 39 Eur. Ct. H.R. 510 (2015).Google Scholar

⁴⁹ U.N. Human Rights Comm., G v. Austral., no. 2172/2012.Google Scholar

⁵⁰ See generally European Union Agency for Fundamental Rights, The Fundamental Rights Situation of Intersex People (2015), http://fra.europa.eu/sites/default/files/fra-2015-focus-04-intersex.pdf.Google Scholar

⁵¹ Identoba 39 Eur. Ct. H.R. at para. 96.Google Scholar

⁵² Goodwin v. U.K, 35 Eur. H.R. Rep. 18 (2002); L v. Lith., 46 Eur. H.R. Rep. 22 (2008).Google Scholar

⁵³ A.P., Garcon & Nicot v. Fr., App. Nos. 79885/12, 52471/13 & 52596/13 (April 6, 2017), http://hudoc.echr.coe.int/eng?i=001-172913.Google Scholar

⁵⁴ See, e.g., Hamalainen v. Fin., 1 FCR 379 (2015) (Sajo, J., Keller, J. & Lemmens, J. dissenting).Google Scholar

⁵⁵ U.N. Human Rights Comm., G v. Austral., no. 2172/2012 at paras. 7.11–15.Google Scholar

⁵⁶ See id. at para 7.2; Goodwin, supra note 52, at para. 90.Google Scholar

⁵⁷ U.N. Human Rights Comm., G v. Austral., no. 2172/2012 at para. 7.2; Goodwin, supra note 52, at para. 90.Google Scholar

⁵⁸ See U.N. Human Rights Comm., G v. Austral., no. 2172/2012 at para. 7.2; Goodwin, supra note 52, at para. 90; see also Schlumpf v. Switz., App. No. 29002/06 (Jan. 8, 2009); L, supra note 52; AP, Garcon & Nicot, supra note 53.Google Scholar

⁵⁹ See, e.g., Intersex Society of North America, Does ISNA Think Children With Intersex Should Be Raised Without a Gender, or in a Third Gender?, http://www.isna.org/faq/third-gender (last visited Dec. 30, 2017); Grietje Baars, The Politics of Recognition and the Limits of Emancipation Through Law, VerfBlog (Nov. 29, 2017), http://verfassungsblog.de/the-politics-of-recognition-and-the-limits-of-emancipation-through-law/.Google Scholar

⁶⁰ Ghattas, Dan C., Human Rights Between the Sexes: A Preliminary Study on the Life Situations of Inter individuals 47 (2013).Google Scholar

⁶¹ 4th International Intersex Forum – Media Statement, OII Eur. (Apr. 26, 2017), https://oiieurope.org/4th-international-intersex-forum-media-statement/.Google Scholar

⁶² 3rd International Intersex Forum, ILGA Eur. (Dec. 1, 2013), https://www.ilga-europe.org/what-we-do/our-advocacy-work/trans-and-intersex/intersex/events/3rd-international-intersex-forum.Google Scholar

⁶³ Anne Tamar-Mattis, Exceptions to the Rule: Curing the Law's Failure to Protect Intersex Infants, 21 Gender, Berkeley J., L. & Justice 59 (2006); Elisabeth McDonald, Intersex People in Aotearoa New Zealand: The Challenges for Law and Social Policy: Part I: Critiquing Gender Normalising Surgery, 46 Wellington, Victoria U. L. Rev. 705 (2015); Aileen Kennedy, Fixed at Birth: Medical and Legal Erasures of Intersex Variations, 39 U. New South Wales L.J 813 (2016); Jo Bird, When Sex Means Condition or Impairment: Evaluating the Human Rights of Transgender and Intersex Peoples, 5 Southern Cross U. L. Rev. 1 (2001).Google Scholar

⁶⁴ German Institute for Human Rights, Gender Diversity in Law: The Status Quo and the Development of Regulatory Models for Recognizing and Protecting Gender Diversity 15 (2017), http://tbinternet.ohchr.org/Treaties/CAT/Shared%20Documents/DEU/INT_CAT_NGO_DEU_47_8558_E.pdf.Google Scholar

⁶⁵ See, e.g., Association of Intersexual People / XY Women, Parallel Report to the 5^th Periodic Report of the Federal Republic of Germany on the Convention against Torture, and Other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment (CAT), http://tbinternet.ohchr.org/Treaties/CAT/Shared%20Documents/DEU/INT_CAT_NGO_DEU_47_8558_E.pdf (last visited May 8, 2018); Amnesty International, First, Do No Harm: Ensuring the Rights of Children Born Intersex, https://www.amnesty.org/en/latest/campaigns/2017/05/intersex-rights/ (last visited May 8, 2018).Google Scholar

⁶⁶ Corte Constitucional [C.C.] [Constitutional Court], SU-337/99 (May 12, 1999) (Colom Corte Constitucional [C.C.] [Constitutional Court], T-551/99 (Aug. 2, 1999) (Colom.); see also Hupf, Robert, Allyship to the Intersex Community on Cosmetic, Non-Consensual Genital “Normalising Surgery”, 22 Wm. & Women, Mary J. and L. 73, 98–100 (2015); Julie A Greenberg & Cheryl Chase, Background of Colombia Decisions, Intersex Society of North America (1999), http://www.isna.org/node/21.Google Scholar

⁶⁷ Gender Identity, Gender Expression and Sex Characteristics Act, s. 14 (2015) (Malta).Google Scholar

⁶⁸ German Institute for Human Rights, supra note 64, at 5.Google Scholar

⁶⁹ Studies from around Europe and the United States have—in the past decade—consistently shown that the number of individuals—either trans or otherwise—who identify as non-binary are consistently growing. See, e.g., Valentine, Vic, Non-Binary People's Experiences in the U.K. (2016); Christina Richards et al., Non-binary or Genderqueer Genders, 28 Int'l Rev. of Psychiatry 95 (2016).Google Scholar

⁷⁰ See S.B. 179, 2017 Leg. (Cal. 2017), https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/billNavClient.xhtml?bill_id=201720180SB179.Google Scholar

⁷¹ Information about Changing Sex/Gender Identity, Identity and Passports (Sept. 29, 2016) https://www.passports.govt.nz/what-you-need-to-renew-or-apply-for-a-passport/information/.Google Scholar

⁷² See Bundesverfassungsgericht [BVerfGE] [Federal Constitutional Court], 1 BvR 3295/07, BVerfGE 128, 109 (Jan. 11, 2011); see also Dutta, Anatol, The Legal Status of Transgender and Transsexual Persons in Germany, in The Legal Status OF Transgender and Transsexual Persons 207–21 (Jens M Scherpe ed., 2015).Google Scholar

⁷³ See Bundesverfassungsgericht [BVerfGE] [Federal Constitutional Court], 1 BvR 3295/07, BVerfGE 128, 109 (Jan. 11, 2011).Google Scholar

⁷⁴ Alice Newlin, Should a Trip from Illinois to Tennessee Change a Woman into a Man? Proposal for a Uniform Interstate Sex Reassignment Recognition Act, 17 Colum. J. Gender & L. 461, 465 (2008); Olga Tomchin, Bodies and Bureaucracy: Legal Sex Classification and Marriage-Based Immigration for Trans* People, 101 Calif. L. Rev. 813, 843 (2013); Stephanie Markowitz, Change of Sex Designation on Transsexuals' Birth Certificates: Public Policy and Equal Protection, 14 Cardozo J.L. & Gender 705, 707, 710 (2008); Harper Jean Tobin, Against the Surgical Requirement for Change of Legal Sex, 38 Case Western Res. J. Int'l L. 393, 401 (2006); Robyn Brammer & Ginicola, Misty M., Counselling Transgender Clients, in Affirmative Counselling with LGBTQI+ People 186 (Ginicola, Misty M., Cheri Smith, Filmore, Joel M. eds., 2017).Google Scholar

⁷⁵ AP, Garcon & Nicot, supra note 53.Google Scholar

⁷⁶ Supreme Court of Nepal, Writ No. 917, 2064 BS (2007 AD) (Dec. 21, 2007).Google Scholar

⁷⁷ National Legal Services Authority (NALSA) v Union of India et al., (2014) Supreme Court of India, Writ Petition (Civil) No. 400 of 2012 (Apr. 15, 2014).Google Scholar

⁷⁸ Supreme Court of Pakistan, Constitution Petition No. 43 of 2009 (Mar. 22, 2011).Google Scholar

⁷⁹ Surya Monro, Beyond Male and Female: Poststructuralism and the Spectrum of Gender, 8 Int'l J. Transgenderism 3, 18 (2005); Theodore Bennett, “No Man's Land”: Non-Binary Sex Identification in Australian Law and Policy, 37 U. New South Wales L.J. 847, 858 (2014).Google Scholar

⁸⁰ Maria Pahl, Immutability of Identity, Title VII, and the ADA Amendment Act: How Being “Regarded As” Transgender Could Affect Employment Discrimination, 3 De Women, Paul J., Gender & L. 63, 68 (2014); Sarah Marsh, The Gender-fluid Generation: Young People on Being Male, Female or Non-binary, The Guardian (Mar. 23, 2016), https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2016/mar/23/gender-fluid-generation-youngpeople-male-female-trans. Chau and Herring write that where current gender standards “unreasonably restric[t] people's identity into one of two sexes, it becomes hard to deny that restricting people to three identities is open to identical objections.” See P-L Chau & Jonathan Herring, Defining, Assigning and Designing Sex, 16 Int'l J.L., Pol'y & Fam. 327, 356 (2002).Google Scholar

⁸¹ Scottish Government, Review of the Gender Recognition Act 2004 – A Consultation, 7.23–.29 (2017) https://consult.gov.scot/family-law/review-of-the-gender-recognition-act-2004/user_uploads/sct1017251758-1_gender_p4–3-.pdf (last visited May 8, 2018).Google Scholar

⁸² Riki Anne Wilchins, Read My Lips: Sexual Subversion and the end of Gender 16 (1997); Martine Rothblatt, The Apartheid of Sex: Manifesto on the Freedom of Gender 103 (1996).Google Scholar

⁸² Elizabeth Reilly, Radical Tweak – Relocating the Power to Assign Sex – From Enforcer of Differentiation to Facilitator of Inclusiveness: Revising the Response to Intersexuality, 12 Cardozo J.L. & Gender 297, 332 (2005); Susan Stryker, Undoing Sex Classification can Provide Justice, N.Y. Times (Oct. 19, 2014), http://www.nytimes.com/roomfordebate/2014/10/19/is-checking-the-sex-box-necessary/undoing-sex-classification-can-provide-justice;_Miqqi Alicia Gilbert, Defeating Bigenderism: Changing Gender Assumptions in the Twenty-first Century, 24 Hypatia 93, 103 (2009).Google Scholar

⁸³ Government of Australia, Australian Government Guidelines on the Recognition of Sex and Gender 8 (2015) https://www.ag.gov.au/Publications/Documents/AustralianGovernmentGuidelinesontheRecognitionofSexandGender/AustralianGovernmentGuidelinesontheRecognitionofSexandGender.PDF; Anna James Neuman Wipfler, Identity Crisis: The Limitations of Expanding Government Recognition of Gender Identity and the Possibility of Genderless Identity Documents, 39 Harv. J.L. & Gender 491, 539 (2016); Linda C McClain, Categorizing by Sex is a Remedy for Discrimination, N.Y. Times (Oct. 20, 2014), http://www.nytimes.com/roomfordebate/2014/10/19/is-checking-the-sex-box-necessary/categorizing-by-sex-is-a-remedy-for-discrimination; Judith Lorber, Using gender to Undo Gender: A Feminist Degendering Movement, 1 Feminist Theory 79, 90 (2000).Google Scholar

⁸⁴ Marie Gustafsson Sendén, Emma Aurora Bäck & Anna Lindqvist, Introducing a Gender-neutral Pronoun in a Natural Gender Language: The Influence of Time on Attitudes and Behavior, 6 Frontiers in Psychol. (2015), http://journal.frontiersin.org/article/10.3389/fpsyg.2015.00893/full. According to Vade, “[i]f we act as if gender does not exist, then we act as if sexism and transphobia do not exist and so reinforce the privilege of … in particular, male genders.” Dylan Vade, Expanding Gender and Expanding the Law: Toward a Social and Legal Conceptualization of Gender that is more Inclusive of Transgender People, 11 Mich. J. Gender & L. 253, 277–78 (2005).Google Scholar

⁸⁵ Government of Australia, supra note 83, at 5.Google Scholar

⁸⁶ House of Commons Select Committee on Women and Equalities, Transgender Equality (2016).Google Scholar

⁸⁷ Verfassungsgerichtshof [VfGH] [Austrian Constitutional Court] Mar. 14, 2018, E 2918/2016-29, https://www.vfgh.gv.at/downloads/VfGH_Pruefungsbeschluss_E_2918-2016_unbest_Geschlecht_ano.pdf.Google Scholar