Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-gbm5v Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-24T01:02:07.215Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Reply to Dewey and Ryan Comment on Searle, MP (2021) ‘Tectonic evolution of the Caledonian orogeny in Scotland: a review based on the timing of magmatism, metamorphism and deformation’

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  05 September 2022

Michael P. Searle Open the ORCID record for Michael P. Searle [Opens in a new window]
Michael P. Searle*
Affiliation:
Department of Earth Sciences, Oxford University, South Parks Road, OxfordOX13 AN, UK Oxford University Museum of Natural History, Parks Road, OxfordOX1 3PW, UK Camborne School of Mines, University of Exeter (Cornwall campus), Penryn, CornwallTR10 9EZ, UK
*
Author for correspondence: Michael P Searle, Email: [email protected]
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

I welcome the comment from Dewey and Ryan on my paper (Searle, 2021), and the chance to clarify some conflicting Caledonian tectonic models and new ideas. As outlined in the paper, my review was based on the geology of Scotland, not Ireland, Newfoundland or the rest of the Caledonian orogeny beyond, mainly because of length constraints, and the fact that my personal field experience lies mainly in Scotland. The Great Glen fault and the Moine Supergroup are not exposed at all in Ireland, so critical parts, and half of the Caledonian orogeny are missing in Ireland. I argue that the Caledonian geology of Scotland can be explained by a Laurentia – Midland valley arc-microcontinent collision, progressing from NW-directed ophiolite obduction in the Late Cambrian to crustal thickening and regional metamorphism during the Ordovician and Silurian, across the Dalradian and Moine metamorphic rocks. Caledonian structures do continue north into Greenland, as summarized by Leslie et al. (2008), but the geological evolution of the Scottish Caledonides does not require any collision with Baltica. The Dewey and Ryan comment raises major tectonic questions, which this reply addresses.

Keywords

Caledonian orogenyScotlandGreat Glen faultgranitesmetamorphism
Type
Discussion - Reply
Information
Geological Magazine , Volume 159 , Issue 10 , October 2022 , pp. 1837 - 1845
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2022. Published by Cambridge University Press

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Ali, MY, Watts, AB, Searle, MP Keats, B, Pilia, S and Ambrose, T (2020) Geophysical imaging of ophiolite structure in the United Arab Emirates. Nature Communications 11, 1–10. doi: 10.1038/s41467-020-16521-0.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Archibald, DB, Murphy, JB, Fowler, M, Strachan, RA and Hildebrand, RS (2022) Testing petrogenetic models for contemporaneous mafic and felsic to intermediate magmatism within the “Newer granite” suite of the Scottish and Irish Caledonides. Geological Society of America Special Paper 554. doi: 10.1130/2021.2554(15).Google Scholar
Ashley, KT, Thigpen, JR and Law, RD (2015) Prograde evolution of the Scottish Caledonides and tectonic implications. Lithos 224–225, 160–78.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Atherton, MP and Ghani, AA (2002) Slab breakoff: a model for Caledonian, Late Granite syn-collisional magmatism in the orthotectonic (metamorphic) zone of Scotland and Donegal, Ireland. Lithos 62, 65–85.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Baxter, EF, Ague, JJ and DePaolo, DJ (2002) Prograde temperature-time evolution in the Barrovian type locality constrained by Sm/Nd garnet ages from Glen Clova, Scotland. Journal of the Geological Society, London 159, 71–82.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bird, AF, Thirlwall, MF, Strachan, RA and Manning, CJ (2013) Lu-Hf and Sm-Nd dating of metamorphic garnet: evidence for multiple accretion events during the Caledonian orogeny in Scotland. Journal of the Geological Society, London 170, 301–17.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Brueckner, HK and van Roemund, H (2004) Dunk tectonics: a multiple subduction/eduction model for the evolution of the Scandinavian Caledonides. Tectonics 23, TC2004. doi: 10.1029/2003TC001502.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Cawood, PA, Nemchin, AA, Smith, M and Loewy, S (2003) Source of the Dalradian Supergroup constrained by U/Pb dating of detrital zircon and implications for the East Laurentian margin. Journal of the Geological Society, London 160, 231–46.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Chew, DM, Daly, JS, Magna, T, Page, LM, Kirkland, CL, Whitehouse, MJ and Lam, R (2010) Timing of ophiolite obduction in the Grampian orogeny. Geological Society of America Bulletin 122, 1787–99.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Corfield, RI and Searle, MP (2000) Crustal shortening estimates across the north Indian continental margin, Ladakh, NW India. In Tectonics of the Nanga Parbat Syntaxis and the Western Himalaya (eds Khan, MA, Treloar, PJ, Searle, MP and Jan, MQ), pp. 395–410. Geological Society of London, Special Publication no. 170.Google Scholar
Corfu, F, Ravna, E and Kullerud, K (2003) A Late Ordovician U-Pb age for the Trømso nappe complex, uppermost allochthon of the Scandinavian Caledonides. Contributions to Mineralogy and Petrology 145, 502–13.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Cutts, KA, Kinney, PD, Strachan, RA, Hand, M, Kelsey, DE, Emery, M, Friend, CRI and Leslie, AG (2010) Three metamorphic events recorded in a single garnet: integrated phase modelling, in situ LA-ICP-MS and SIMS geochronology from the Moine Supergroup, Scotland. Journal of Metamorphic Geology 28, 249–67.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Dewey, JF (2005) Orogeny can be very short. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 102, 15286–93.Google ScholarPubMed
Dewey, JF, Dalziel, IWD, Reavy, RJ and Strachan, RA (2015) The Neoproterozoic to Mid-Devonian evolution of Scotland: a review and unresolved issues. Scottish Journal of Geology 51, 5–30.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Dewey, JF and Shackleton, RJ (1984) A model for the evolution of the Grampian tract in the early Caledonides and Appalachians. Nature, 148, 137–80.Google Scholar
Dewey, JF and Strachan, RA (2003) Changing Silurian- Devonian relative plate motion in the Caledonides: sinistral transpression to sinistral transtension. Journal of the Geological Society, London 160, 219–29.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Fettes, DJ (1979) A metamorphic map of the British and Irish Caledonides. In The Caledonides of the British Isles – Reviewed (eds Harris, AL, Holland, CH and Leake, BE), pp. 307–20. Geological Society of London, Special Publication no. 8.Google Scholar
Fowler, MB, Kocks, H, Darbyshire, DPF and Greenwood, PB (2008) Petrogenesis of high Ba-Sr plutons from the Northern Highlands terrane of the British Caledonian Province. Lithos 105, 129–48.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Fox, R and Searle, MP (2021) Structural, petrological and tectonic constraints on the Loch Borralan and Loch Ailsh alkaline intrusions, Moine Thust zone, NW Scotland. Geosphere 17. doi: 10.1130/GES02330.1.Google Scholar
Froitzhelm, N, Miladinova, I, Janák, M, Kullerud, K, Ravna, EK, Majka, J, Foncesca, ROC, Münker, C and Nagel, TJ (2016) Devonian subduction and syncollisional exhumation of continental crust in Lofoten, Norway. Geology 44, 223–6.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Glodny, J, Kuhn, A and Austrheim, H (2008) Geochronology of fluid induced eclogite and amphibolite metamorphic reactions in a subduction collision system, Bergen Arcs, Norway. Contributions to Mineralogy and Petrology 156, 27–48. doi: 10.1007/s00410-0070272-y.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Goodenough, KM, Millar, I, Strachan, RA, Krabbendam, M and Evans, JA (2011) Timing of regional deformation of the Moine Thrust zone in the Scottish Caledonides: constraints from the U-Pb geochronology of alkaline intrusions. Journal of the Geological Society London 168, 99–114. doi: 10.1144/0016-76492010-020.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gordon, SM, Whitney, DL, Teyssier, C, Fossen, H and Kylander-Clark, A (2016) Geochronology and geochemistry of zircon from the northern Western Gneiss region: insights into the Caledonian tectonic history of western Norway. Lithos 246–247, 134–48.Google Scholar
Halliday, AN and Stephens, WE (1984) Crustal controls on the genesis of the 400 Ma old Caledonian granites. Physics of the Earth and Planetary Interiors 35, 89–104.Google Scholar
Hanmer, S, Williams, ML and Kopf, C (1995) Modest movements, spectacular fabrics in an intracontinental seep-crustal strike-slip fault: Striding-Athabasca mylonite zone, NW Canadian Shield. Journal of Structural Geology 17, 493–507.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hutton, DHW and Reavy, RJ (1992) Strike-slip tectonics and granite petrogenesis. Tectonics 5, 960–7.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kennedy, WQ (1946) The Great Glen fault. Quarterly Journal of the Geological Society of London 102, 41–72.Google Scholar
Kylander-Clark, ARC, Hacker, BR, Johnson, CM, Beard, BL, Mahlen, NJ and Lapen, TJ (2007) Coupled Lu-Hf and Sm-Nd geochronology constrains prograde and exhumation histories of high- and ultra-high pressure eclogites from Western Norway. Chemical Geology 242, 137–54.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Labrousse, L, Hétenyi, G, Raimbourg, H, Jolivet, L and Andersen, TB (2010) Initiation of crustal scale thrusts triggered by metamorphic reactions at depth: insights from a comparison between Himalayas and Scandinavian Caledonides. Tectonics 29, TC5002. doi: 10/1029/2009TC002602.Google Scholar
Leggett, JK, McKerrow, WS and Eales, MH (1979) The Southern Uplands of Scotland: a lower Paleozoic accretionary prism. Journal of the Geological Society, London 136, 755–70.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Leslie, AG, Smith, M and Soper, NJ (2008) Laurentian margin evolution and the Caledonian orogeny: a template for Scotland and East Greenland. Geological Society of America Memoir 202, 307–43. doi: 10.1130/2008.1202(13).Google Scholar
Mako, CA, Law, RD, Caddick, MJ, Thigpen, JR, Ashley, KT, Cottle, JM and Kylander-Clark, A (2019) Thermal evolution of the Scandian hinterland, Naver nappe, north Scotland. Journal of the Geological Society, London 176, 669–88.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Marston, RJ (1967) Newer granites of Foyers and Strontian and the Great Glen fault. Nature 214, 159–60.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Marston, RJ (1971) The Foyers granite complex, Inverness-shire, Scotland. Quarterly Journal of the Geological Society, London 126, 331–68.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
McKerrow, WS, Leggett, JK and Eales, MH (1977) Imbricate thrust model for the Southern Uplands of Scotland. Nature 267, 237–9.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Miles, AJ, Woodcock, NH and Hawkesworth, CJ (2016) Tectonic controls on post-subduction granite genesis and emplacement: the late Caledonian suite of Britain and Ireland. Gondwana Research 39, 250–60.Google Scholar
Mitchell, AHG and McKerrow, WS (1975) Analagous evolution of the Burma orogeny and Scottish Caledonides. Geological Society of America Bulletin 86, 305–15.2.0.CO;2>CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Morley, CK, Naing, TT, Searle, M and Robinson, SA (2020) Structural and tectonic development of the Indo-Burma Ranges. Earth-Science Reviews 200, 102992.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Neilson, JG, Kokelaar, BP and Crowley, QG (2009) Timing, relations and cause of plutonic and volcanic activity of the Siluro-Devonian post-collision magmatic episode in the Grampian terrane, Scotland. Journal of the Geological Society, London 166, 545–61.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Oliver, GJH, Wilde, SA and Wan, Y (2008) Geochronology and geodynamics of Scottish granitoids from the late Neoproterozoic break-up of Rodinia to Paleozoic collision. Journal of the Geological Society, London 165, 661–74.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Pattison, DRM and Goldsmith, SA (2022) Metamorphism of the Buchan type area, NE Scotland and its relationship to adjacent Barrovian domain. Journal of the Geological Society, London 179. doi: 10.1144/jgs2021-040.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Phillips, ER, Evans, JA, Stone, P, Horstwood, M, Floyd, JD, Smith, RA, Akhurst, MC and Barron, HF 2003. Detrital Avalonian zircons in the Laurentian Southern Uplands terrane, Scotland. Geology 31, 625–8.2.0.CO;2>CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Phillips, RJ, Parrish, RR and Searle, MP (2004) Age of ductile deformation and long-term slip rates along the Karakoram fault zone, Ladakh. Earth and Planetary Science Letters 226, 305–19.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Phillips, RJ and Searle, MP (2007) Macrostructural and microstructural architecture of the Karakoram fault: relationship between magmatism and strike-slip faulting. Tectonics 26, TC3017. doi: 10.1029/2006TC001946.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Pitcher, WS (1978) The anatomy of a batholith. Journal of the Geological Society, London 135, 157–82.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Pitcher, WS (1987) Granites and yet more granites forty years on. Geologische Rundschau 76, 51–79.Google Scholar
Rock, NMS (1984) Nature and origin of calc-alkaline lamprophyres, minettes, vogestites, kersantites and spessartites. Transactions of the Royal Society of Edinburgh, Earth Sciences 74, 193–227.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Rock, NMS and Hunter, RH (1987) Late Caledonian dyke swarms of northern Britain: spatial and temporal intimacy between lamprophyric and granitic magmatism around the Ross of Mull pluton, Inner Hebrides. Geologische Rundschau 76, 805–26.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Rogers, G and Dunning, G (1991) Geochronology of appinitic and related granite magmatism in the W Highlands: constraints on the timing of transcurrent fault movement. Journal of the Geological Society, London 148, 17–27.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Schmid, SM, Pfiffner, OA, Froitzheim, N, Schönborn, G and Kissling, E (1997) Geophysical and geological transect and tectonic evolution of the Swiss-Italian Alps. Tectonics 15, 1036–64.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Searle, MP (2007) Structural geometry, style and timing of deformation in the Hawasina Window, Al Jabal al Akhdar and Saih Hatat culminations, Oman Mountains. GeoArabia 12, 99–130.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Searle, MP (2021) Tectonic evolution of the Caledonian orogeny in Scotland: a review based on the timing of magmatism, metamorphism and deformation. Geological Magazine 159, 125–52. doi: 10.1017/S0016756821000947.Google Scholar
Searle, MP, Cornish, SB, Heard, A, Charles, J-H and Branch, J (2019) Structure of the Northern Moine Thrust zone, Loch Eriboll, Scottish Caledonides. Tectonophysics 752, 35–51.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Searle, MP, Law, RD, Dewey, JF and Streule, MJ (2010b) Relationships between the Loch Ailsh and Borralan alkaline intrusions and thrusting in the Moine Thrust zone, southern Assynt Window. In Continental Tectonics and Mountain Building: The Legacy of Peach and Horne (eds Law, RD et al.), pp. 383–404. Geological Society of London, Special Publicationno. 335. doi: 10.1144/SP335.18.Google Scholar
Searle, MP and Phillips, RJ (2004) A Comment on “Large-Scale geometry, offset and kinematic evolution of the Karakoram Fault, Tibet” by R.Laccassin et al. Earth and Planetary Science Letters 229, 155–8.Google Scholar
Searle, MP and Phillips, RJ (2007) Relationships between right-lateral shear along the Karakoram fault and metamorphism, magmatism, exhumation and uplift: evidence from the K2-Gasherbrum-Pangong ranges, north Pakistan and Ladakh. Journal of the Geological Society , London 164, 439–50. doi: 10.1144/0016-76492006-072.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Searle, MP, Roberts, NMW, Chung, SL, Lee, Y-H, Cook, K, Weller, OM, St-Onge, MR, Xu, X-W, Tan, X-B and Li, K (2016) Age and anatomy of the Gongga Shan batholith, eastern Tibetan Plateau, and its relationship to the active Xianshui-He Fault. Geosphere 12, 948–70. doi: 10.1130/GES01244.1.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Searle, MP, Yeh, M-W, Lin, T-H and Chung, S-L (2010a) Structural constraints on the timing of left-lateral shear along the Red River shear zone in the Ailao Shan and Diancang Shan Ranges, Yunnan, SW China. Geosphere 6, 316–38 doi: 10.1130/GES00580.1.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Storetvedt, KM, Tveit, E, Deutsch, ER and Murthy, GS (1990) Multicomponent magnetizations in the Foyers Old red sandstones (northern Scotland) and their bearing on lateral displacements along the Great Glen Fault. Geophysical Journal International 102, 151–63.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Strachan, RA, Alsop, GI, Ramezani, J, Frazer, RE, Burns, IM and Holdsworth, RE (2020) Patterns of Silurian deformation and magmatism during sinistral oblique convergence, northern Scottish Caledonides. Journal of the Geological Society, London 177, 893–910.Google Scholar
Tanner, PWG (2007) The role of the Highland Border ophiolite in the ∼470 Ma Grampian Event, Scotland. Geological Magazine 134, 597–602.Google Scholar
Tanner, PWG (2008) Tectonic significance of the Highland Boundary Fault, Scotland. Journal of the Geological Society, London 165, 915–21.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Thigpen, JR, Law, RD, Loehn, CL, Strachan, RA, Tracy, RA, Lloyd, GE, Roth, BL and Brown, SL (2013) Thermal structure and tectonic evolution of the Scandian orogenic wedge, Scottish Caledonides: integrating geothermometry, deformation temperatures and kinematic thermal modelling. Journal of Metamorphic Geology 31, 813–42.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Viete, DR and Lister, GS (2016) On the significance of short-duration regional metamorphism. Journal of the Geological Society, London 174, 377–92.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Waldron, JF, Floyd, JD, Simonetti, A and Hearman, LA (2008) Ancient Laurentian detrital zircon in the closing Iapetus ocean, Southern Uplands terrane, Scotland. Geology 36, 527–30.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Winchester, JA (1974) The zonal pattern of regional metamorphism in the Scottish Caledonides. Journal of the Geological Society, London 130, 509–24.CrossRefGoogle Scholar