Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-dlnhk Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-24T23:56:11.342Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

No, Prime Minister: PhD Plagiarism of High Level Public Officials

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  06 September 2017

Theodor Tudoroiu
Theodor Tudoroiu*
Affiliation:
Department of Political Science, The University of the West Indies at St. Augustine, Trinidad & Tobago, West Indies.
*
Email: [email protected]
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Based on a public office definition of corruption, this article uses the case studies of doctoral plagiarism of German Minister of Defence Karl-Theodor zu Guttenberg, Hungarian President Pàl Schmitt, Romanian Prime Minister Victor Ponta, and Russian President Vladimir Putin in order to show that, by shattering citizens’ confidence in and respect for political class, political parties, state institutions and rule of law, academic plagiarism of high-ranking politicians intertwines with and enforces the most serious democratic failures in their respective countries: degeneration of political culture in Germany, nationalist authoritarian trends in Hungary, a culture of corruption in Romania, and outright dictatorship in Russia. As such, this specific type of plagiarism goes far beyond academia. It represents a direct, aggressive, and effective threat against democracy itself.

Type
Articles
Information
European Review , Volume 25 , Issue 4 , October 2017 , pp. 623 - 641
Copyright
© Academia Europaea 2017 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

References and Notes

1. Sherwin, A. (2011) Gaddafi son ‘plagiarised his degree thesis’ at LSE. The Independent, 2 March, http://www.independent.co.uk/news/education/education-news/gaddafi-son-plagiarised-his-degree-thesis-at-lse-2229620.html; emphasis added.Google Scholar
2. Vasagar, J. and Sweney, M. (2011) LSE plans Libya scholarship fund with Gaddafi donation. The Guardian, 1 March, http://www.theguardian.com/education/2011/mar/01/lse-libya-scholarship-fund.Google Scholar
3. Baram, M. (2011) Gaddafi son’s book plans dropped amid plagiarism charges. Huffington Post, 2 March, http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2011/03/02/gaddafi-son-book-plagiarism-charge_n_830540.html Google Scholar
4. Vitzthum, T. (2008) Gutes Geschäft mit gekauften Doktortiteln. Die Welt, 12 March, http://www.welt.de/politik/article1792387/Gutes_Geschaeft_mit_gekauften_Doktortiteln.html Google Scholar
5. Ameijeiras, P. (2009) La venta de tesis doctorales, con precios en torno a los 50.000 euros, se convierte en un lucrativo negocio en Portugal. El Periodico de Catalunya, 28 May, http://www.elperiodico.com/es/noticias/mundo/venta-tesis-doctorales-con-precios-torno-los-50000-euros-convierte-lucrativo-negocio-portugal-96113.Google Scholar
6. Klußmann, U. (2007) The Russian parliament’s intellectual giants. Spiegel Online, 21 November. http://www.spiegel.de/international/world/duma-s-dubious-degrees-the-russian-parliament-s-intellectual-giants-a-518754.html.Google Scholar
7. McElroy, D. and Vahdat, A. (2013) Iranian President Hassan Rouhani ‘plagiarised Ph.D. thesis at Scottish university’. The Telegraph, 26 June, http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/middleeast/iran/10143799/Iranian-president-Hassan-Rouhani-plagiarised-Ph.D.-thesis-at-Scottish-university.html.Google Scholar
8. Marsh, B. (2007) Plagiarism: Alchemy and Remedy in Higher Education (Albany: State University of New York Press), p. 31.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
9. Treppoz, L. (1894) Droit romain: le Concept du vol dans le droit romain. Droit français: Étude théorique et pratique sur les condamnations conditionnelles (loi Bérenger) (Paris: Chevalier-Marescq), p. 29.Google Scholar
10. Weber-Wulff, D. (2014) False Feathers. A Perspective on Academic Plagiarism (Berlin and Heidelberg: Springer), p. 3.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
11. Nodier, C. (1812) Questions de littérature légale. Du plagiat, de la supposition d’auteurs, des supercheries qui ont rapport aux livres. Ouvrage qui peut servir de suite au Dictionnaire des anonymes et à toutes les bibliographies (Paris: Barba), p 17. for more recent but not necessarily different definitions and for their discussion see B. Marsh (2007) Plagiarism: Alchemy and Remedy in Higher Education (Albany: State University of New York Press), pp. 31–38.Google Scholar
12. Giuriati, D. (1903) Il plagio. Furti letterari, artistici e musicali, 2nd edn (Milano: Ulrico Hoepli)Google Scholar
13. Bloch, J. (2008) Plagiarism across cultures: Is there a difference? In: C. Eisner and M. Vicinus, (Eds.) Originality, Imitation, Plagiarism: Teaching Writing in the Digital Age (Ann Arbor: The University of Michigan Press), pp. 220–221.Google Scholar
14. For details see, Lei, J. and Hu, G. (2014) Chinese ESOL lecturers’ stance on plagiarism: Does knowledge matter? ELT Journal, 68(1), pp. 41–42.Google Scholar
15. Angelo, A. (2013) Crime and punishment: Calixthe Beyala’s manic writing of Femme nue, femme noire . In F. Chevillot and C. Trout, (Eds.) Rebelles et criminelles chez les écrivaines d’expression française (Amsterdam, New York: Rodopi), pp. 183–198.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
16. Bouville, M. (2008) Plagiarism: Words and ideas. Science and Engineering Ethics, 14(3), p. 311.Google Scholar
17. Rosamond, B. (2002) Plagiarism, academic norms and the governance of the profession. Politics, 22(3), p. 168.Google Scholar
18. Philp, M. (1997) Defining political corruption. Political Studies, 45(3), p. 440.Google Scholar
19. Quoted in, Gardiner, J.A. (2007) Defining corruption. In: A.J. Heidenheimer and M. Johnston, (Eds.) Political Corruption. Concepts and Contexts, 3rd edn (New Brunswick, New Jersey: Transaction Publishers), p. 26.Google Scholar
20. Lovell, D.W. (2005) Corruption as a transitional phenomenon: Understanding endemic corruption in postcommunist states. In: D. Haller and C. Shore, (Eds.) Corruption: Anthropological Perspectives (London: Pluto Press), p. 71.Google Scholar
21. Warren, M.E. (2015) The meaning of corruption in democracies. In P.M. Heywood (Ed.), Routledge Handbook of Political Corruption (New York: Routledge), p. 49.Google Scholar
22. Wolf, S. (2013) Bribe and cheat to get a doctoral degree in Germany? In: Transparency International (Ed.), Global Corruption Report: Education (New York: Routledge), pp. 178–184 p. 178. http://www.transparency.org/whatwedo/publication/global_corruption_report_education Google Scholar
23. Müller, E. (2013) Un nuevo escándalo por el plagio de una tesis salpica al presidente del Bundestag. El País, 31 July, http://internacional.elpais.com/internacional/2013/07/31/actualidad/1375296421_261293.html Google Scholar
24. Pidd, H. (2011) German defence minister resigns in PhD plagiarism row. The Guardian, 1 March, http://www.theguardian.com/world/2011/mar/01/german-defence-minister-resigns-plagiarism Google Scholar
25. BBC (2011) Germany’s Guttenberg ‘deliberately’ plagiarised. 6 May. http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-13310042 Google Scholar
26. BBC (2011) German defence minister Guttenberg resigns over thesis. 1 March. http://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-12608083 Google Scholar
27. BBC (2011) German defence minister Guttenberg resigns over thesis. 1 March. http://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-12608083; H. Pidd (2011) German defence minister resigns in PhD plagiarism row. The Guardian, 1 March, http://www.theguardian.com/world/2011/mar/01/german-defence-minister-resigns-plagiarism Google Scholar
28. BBC (2011) Germany’s Guttenberg ‘deliberately’ plagiarised. 6 May. http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-13310042 Google Scholar
29. Le Monde, 23 February 2011, Le titre de docteur retiré au ministre allemand accusé de plagiat, http://www.lemonde.fr/europe/article/2011/02/23/le-titre-de-docteur-retire-au-ministre-allemand-accuse-de-plagiat_1484411_3214.html Google Scholar
30. BBC (2013) German minister Annette Schavan stripped of doctorate. 5 February. http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-21347510 Google Scholar
31. Müller, E. (2014) El ministro de Cooperación alemán, acusado de plagiar su tesis doctoral. El País, 10 April. http://internacional.elpais.com/internacional/2014/04/10/actualidad/1397141438_648808.html Google Scholar
32. McKay, J. (2003) Political corruption in Germany. In: M.J. Bull and J.L. Newell (Eds.), Corruption in Contemporary Politics (New York: Palgrave Macmillan), pp. 54–55.Google Scholar
33. Bull, M.J. and Newell, J.L. (Eds.) (2003) Corruption in Contemporary Politics (New York: Palgrave Macmillan), p. 51.Google Scholar
34. Transparency International (2014) Corruption Perceptions Index 2014. http://files.transparency.org/content/download/1857/12438/file/CPI2014_DataBundle.zip Google Scholar
35. Transparency International (2013) National results. Global Corruption Barometer 2013, http://www.transparency.org/gcb2013/results Google Scholar
36. Facsar, F. (2012) Hungary’s president quits over alleged plagiarism. CNN, 2 April. http://edition.cnn.com/2012/04/02/world/europe/hungary-president-resigns/index.html Google Scholar
37. Karasz, P. (2012) Hungarian president resigns amid plagiarism scandal. The New York Times, 2 April. http://www.nytimes.com/2012/04/03/world/europe/hungarian-president-pal-schmitt-resigns-amid-plagiarism-scandal.html Google Scholar
38. Corriere della Sera (2012) Il presidente Schmitt copia la tesi di dottorato, 2 April. http://www.corriere.it/esteri/12_aprile_02/scandalo-tesi-copiata-ungheria_08e323ac-7cbc-11e1-b9fa-a64885bf1529.shtml Google Scholar
39. Beliczay, L. (2012) Hungary president Pal Schmitt quits in plagiarism scandal. NBC, 2 April. http://worldnews.nbcnews.com/_news/2012/04/02/10981451-hungary-president-pal-schmitt-quits-in-plagiarism-scandal?lite.Google Scholar
40. The Economist (2012) Schmitt quits. 7 April. http://www.economist.com/node/21552258 Google Scholar
41. La Repubblica (2012) Ungheria, si dimette il presidente Schmitt. 2 April. http://www.repubblica.it/esteri/2012/04/02/news/ungheria_dimissioni_schmitt-32623351/ Google Scholar
42. Kornai, J. (2015) Hungary’s U-Turn: Retreating from democracy. Journal of Democracy, 26(3), p. 35.Google Scholar
43. Freedom House (2015) Nations in transit 2015 – Hungary. https://freedomhouse.org/report/nations-transit/2015/hungary Google Scholar
44. Burai, P. (2013) Youth, integrity and anti-corruption work in Hungary. In: Transparency International. (Ed.), Global Corruption Report: Education (New York: Routledge), p. 375; http://www.transparency.org/whatwedo/publication/global_corruption_report_education Google Scholar
45. Schiermeier, Q. (2012) Romanian prime minister accused of plagiarism. Nature, 486. 18 June, p. 305. http://www.nature.com/news/romanian-prime-minister-accused-of-plagiarism-1.10845 Google Scholar
46. Schiermeier, Q. (2012) Conflicting verdicts on Romanian prime minister’s plagiarism. Nature News, 20 July. http://www.nature.com/news/conflicting-verdicts-on-romanian-prime-minister-s-plagiarism-1.11047 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
47. Pantazi, R. (2014) Mihnea Costoiu, la doi ani de la semnalarea cazului: Ioan Mang a plagiat. HotNews.ro, 19 December. http://www.hotnews.ro/stiri-esential-18873030-mihnea-costoiu-doi-ani-semnalarea-cazului-ioan-mang-plagiat.htm Google Scholar
48. Prisacariu, C. (2015) Ponta, încă doctor la opt luni de la ordonanța de urgență de renunțare la doctorat, România Liberă. 18 August. http://www.romanialibera.ro/special/dezvaluiri/ponta--inca-doctor-la-opt-luni-de-la-ordonanta-de-urgenta-de-renuntare-la-doctorat-389646 Google Scholar
49. Sercan, E. (2015) A sasea lucrare de doctorat suspectata de plagiat, coordonata de Gabriel Oprea. Chestor-sef de politie Dumitru Parvu si-a obtinut doctoratul la Academia de Politie. HotNews.ro, 5 October. http://www.hotnews.ro/stiri-esential-20474669-exclusiv-sasea-lucrare-doctorat-plagiata-coordonata-gabriel-oprea-chestor-sef-politie-dumitru-parvu-obtinut-doctoratul-academia-politie.htm Google Scholar
50. Garaiman, R. (2015) Ministrul Economiei îngroaşă rândurile demnitarilor acuzaţi de plagiat, Adevărul. 19 August. http://adevarul.ro/news/eveniment/ministrul-economiei-ingroasa-randurile-demnitarilor-acuzati-plagiat-1_55d4b526f5eaafab2cba790e/index.html Google Scholar
51. Pantazi, R. (2015) Dezbaterea Plagiatul ca stare a natiunii. Hotnews.ro, 8 September. http://m.hotnews.ro/stire/20408573 Google Scholar
52. Gallagher, T. (2009) Romania and the European Union. How the Weak Vanquished the Strong (Manchester: Manchester University Press).Google Scholar
53. Friedman, G. (2014) Borderlands: First moves in Romania. Stratfor, 27 May. https://www.stratfor.com/weekly/borderlands-first-moves-romania Google Scholar
54. BBC (2014) Romania election surprise as Klaus Iohannis wins presidency. 17 November. http://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-30076716 Google Scholar
55. Tran, M. (2015) Bucharest nightclub fire: PM and government resign after protests. The Guardian, 4 November. http://www.theguardian.com/world/2015/nov/04/romanian-government-resigns-nightclub-fire-victor-ponta Google Scholar
56. Freedom House (2015) Nations in transit 2015 – Romania. https://freedomhouse.org/report/nations-transit/2015/romania Google Scholar
57. Khvostunova, O. (2013) Plagiarism-gate. Institute of Modern Russia. 8 May. http://imrussia.org/en/society/453-plagiarism-gate Google Scholar
58. The Washington Times (2006) Researchers peg Putin as a plagiarist over thesis. 24 March. http://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2006/mar/24/20060324-104106-9971r/ Google Scholar
59. Shuster, S. (2013) Putin’s Ph.D.: Can a plagiarism probe upend Russian politics? World Time, 28 February. http://world.time.com/2013/02/28/putins-phd-can-a-plagiarism-probe-upend-russian-politics/ Google Scholar
60. Knyazev, E. (2004) The Russian Federation. In: J. Sadlak (Ed.), Doctoral Studies and Qualifications in Europe and the United States: Status and Prospects (Bucharest: UNESCO), pp. 155.Google Scholar
61. Putin, V. (2015) Biography. Personal Website, http://eng.putin.kremlin.ru/bio Google Scholar
62. Osipian, A.L. (2010) Le Bourgeois Gentilhomme: Political corruption of Russian doctorates. Demokratizatsiya, 18(3), p. 262. S. Shuster (2013) Putin’s Ph.D.: Can a plagiarism probe upend Russian politics? World Time, 28 February. http://world.time.com/2013/02/28/putins-phd-can-a-plagiarism-probe-upend-russian-politics/ Google Scholar
63. Wayne Merry, E., quoted by The Washington Times (2006) Researchers peg Putin as a plagiarist over thesis. 24 March. http://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2006/mar/24/20060324-104106-9971r/ Google Scholar
64. Raiklin, E. (2009) Continuity in Russian corruption through changing societal forms. The Journal of Social, Political, and Economic Studies, 34(4), p. 413.Google Scholar
65. Shlapentokh, V. (2013) Corruption, the power of state and big business in Soviet and post-Soviet regimes. Communist and Post-Communist Studies, 46(1), p. 151.Google Scholar
66. Freedom House (2015) Nations in transit 2015 – Russia. https://freedomhouse.org/report/nations-transit/2015/russia Google Scholar
67. Hatcher, T. (2011) Becoming an ethical scholarly writer. Journal of Scholarly Publishing, 42(2), pp. 148–149.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
68. Ruscior, C. (2012) Răzvan Theodorescu: Dacă Ponta a plagiat, să-şi ceară scuze! Radio France Internationale-Romanian Service, 29 June. http://m.rfi.ro/articol/stiri/politica/ac-razvan-theodorescu-rfi-dizolvarea-comisiei-ce-analizeaza-plagiatul-este Google Scholar
69. Freedom House (2015) Freedom in the world 2015. https://freedomhouse.org/report/freedom-world/freedom-world-2015#.VivlwcuFMpw; Freedom House (2015) Nations in transit 2015 – Hungary. https://freedomhouse.org/report/nations-transit/2015/hungary; Freedom House (2015) Nations in transit 2015 – Romania. https://freedomhouse.org/report/nations-transit/2015/romania; Freedom House (2015) Nations in transit 2015 – Russia. https://freedomhouse.org/report/nations-transit/2015/russia Google Scholar