Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-jn8rn Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-23T13:14:09.391Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

‘Bringing Common Sense Back In’: some neglected assumptions in status inconsistency theory and research

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  28 July 2009

Ekkart Zimmermann
Get access

Extract

In recent years status inconsistency theory and research has come under attack for at least three major reasons:

(a) It has been shown that the effects of status inconsistency, if there are any (cf. under (c)), cannot be detected by following the prevailing procedures of analysis, i.e. tabular analysis (camparisons-of-sums method; cf. Lenski 1954 (1)) or linear equation models (regression approach). By now the criticism in the works of Blalock (1966a, 1966b, 1967a, 1967b, 1967c), Mitchell (1964) and Hyman (1966) is well-known (2).

Type
Le prix moral de l'égalité
Information
European Journal of Sociology / Archives Européennes de Sociologie , Volume 19 , Issue 1 , May 1978 , pp. 52 - 73
Copyright
Copyright © Archives Européenes de Sociology 1978

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Abelson, Robert P. 1959. Modes of Resolution of Belief Dilemmas, Journal of Conflict Resolution, III, 343–52.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Abelson, Robert P. 1968. Comment: Uncooperative Personality Variables, pp. 648–51, in Abelson, Robert P. et al. (eds.) Theories of Cognitive Consistency. (Chicago, Rand McNally).Google Scholar
Abelson, Robert P., Aronson, E., McGhire, W.J., Newcomb, T.M., Rosenberg, M.J., and Tannenbaum, P.H. (eds.), 1968. Theories of Cognitive Consistency: A sourcebook (Chicago, Rand McNally).Google Scholar
Adams, J.S. 1965. Inequity in Social Exchange, pp. 267–299, in Berkowitz, Leonard (ed.), Advances in Experimental Social Psychology. Vol. II (New York, Academic Press).Google Scholar
Adams, J.S. 1968. A Framework for the Study of Modes of Resolving Inconsistency, pp. 655–60, in Abelson, Robert P. et al. (eds.), Theories of Cognitive Consistency (Chicago, Rand McNally).Google Scholar
Aniself, P. and Basson, P. 1968. Status Consistency and Anxiety, Cornell Journal of Social Relations, III, 71–83.Google Scholar
Anderson, B., Berger, J., Zelditch, M. and Cohen, B.P.. 1969. Reactions to Inequity, Acta Sociologica, XII 1–12.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Appley, Mortimer H. and Trumbull, Richard. 1967, Psychological Stress (New York, Appleton-Century-Crofts).Google Scholar
Baer, Linda, Eitzen, D. Stanley, Duprey, Charles, Thompson, Norman J. and Cole, Curtis. 1976. The Consequences of Objective and Subjective Status Inconsistency, Sociological Quarterly, XVII, 389–400.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bauman, K.E. 1968. Status Inconsistency, Satisfactory Social Interaction and Community Satisfaction in an Area of Rapid Growth, Social Forces, XLVII, 45–54.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Benoit-Smullyan, Emile. 1944. Status, Status Types, and Status Interrelations, American Sociological Review, IX, 151–61.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Berger, Joseph, Conner, Thomas L. and Fisek, M. Hamit (eds.) 1974, Expectation States Theory: A theoretical research program (Cambridge, Winthrop).Google Scholar
Berry, Kenneth J. and Martin, Thomas W.. 1973. A Methodological Note on Typological Analysis in Status Inconsistency Research, Sociological Methods and Research, II, 21–37.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Blalock, H.M. Jr, 1966a. The Identification Problem and Theory Building: The case of status inconsistency, American Sociological Review, XXXI, 52–61.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Blalock, H.M. Jr, 1966b. Comment: Status Inconsistency and the Identification Problem, Public Opinion Quarterly, XXX, 130–132.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Blalock, H.M. Jr, 1967a. Status Inconsistency, Social Mobility, Status Integration and Structural Effects, American Sociological Review, XXXII, 790–801.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Blalock, H.M. Jr, 1967b. Status Inconsistency and Interaction: some alternative models, American Journal of Sociology, LXXIII, 305–15.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Blalock, H.M. Jr, 1967c. Tests of Status Inconsistency Theory: A note of caution, Pacific Sociological Review, X, 69–74.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Blalock, H.M. 1975. The Confounding of Measured and Unmeasured Variables: The case of social status, Sociological Methods and Research, III, 355–83.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Blau, Peter M. 1974. Parameters of Social Structure, American Sociological Review, XXXIX, 615–35.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bloombaum, Milton. 1964. The Mobility Dimension in Status Inconsistency, Sociology and Social Research, XLVIII, 340–47.Google Scholar
Borher, J.T. 1965. A Theory of Incongruent Experience, Pacific Sociological Review, VIII, 89–95.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Box, S. and Ford, J.. 1969. Some Questionable Assumptions in the Theory of Status Inconsistency, Sociological Review, XVII, 187–201.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Brandon, Arlene C. 1965. Status Congruence and Expectations, Sociometry, XXVIII, 272–88.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Broom, Leonard and Jones, F. Lancaster. 1970. Status Consistency and Political Preference: The Australian case, American Sociological Review, XXXV, 989–1001.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Broom, Leonard and Jones, F. Lancaster. 1977. Problematics in Stratum Formation: an Australian example. American Journal of Sociology, LXXXII, 808–825.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Dodge, David L. and Martin, Walter T.. 1970. Social Stress and Chronic Illness (Notre Dame, University of Notre Dame Press).Google Scholar
Dohrenwend, Barbara and Dohrenwend, Bruce (eds.) 1974. Stressful Life Events: their Nature and Effects (New York, Wiley).Google Scholar
Doreian, Patrick and Stockman, Norman. 1969. A Critique of the Multidimensional Approach to Stratification, Sociological Review, XVII, 47–65.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Eitzen, D.S. 1970. Status Inconsistency and Wallace Supporters in a Midwestern City, Social Forces, XLVIII, 493–498.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Eitzen, D. Stanley. 1970a. Social Class, Status Inconsistency and Political Attitudes, Social Science Quarterly, LI, 602–609.Google Scholar
Geschwender, J.A. 1967. Continuities in Theories of Status Consistency and Cognitive Dissonance, Social Forces, XLVI, 160–71.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gibbs, J.P. and Martin, W.T.. 1964. Status Integration and Suicide: A sociological study (Eugene, University of Oregon Press).Google Scholar
Glass, D.G. 1968. Individual Differences and the Resolution of Cognitive Inconsistencies, pp. 615–23, in Abelson, Robert P. et al. (eds.), Theories of Cognitive Consistency (Chicago, Rand McNally).Google Scholar
Goertzel, T. 1970. A Note on Status Crystallization and Urbanization, Social Forces, XLIX, 134–36.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Goffman, E. 1959. The Presentation of Self in Everyday Life (New York, Doubleday).Google Scholar
Goffman, I.W. 1957. Status Consistency and Preference for Change in Power Distribution, American Sociological Review, XXII, 275–81.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gordon, M. and Wilson, S.R.. 1969. Status Inconsistency and Satisfaction with Sorority Membership, Social Forces, XLVIII, 176–83.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Greene, Thomas H. 1974. Comparative Revolutionary Movements (Englewood Cliffs, Prentice-Hall).Google Scholar
Hartman, Moshe. 1974. On the Definition of Status Inconsistency, American Journal of Sociology, LXXX, 706–21.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hesser, Garry William. 1972. Status Inconsistency, Identity Incongruity, Stress, and Behavior Modification Among Protestant Clergymen [Ph.D. dissertation, University of Notre Dame].Google Scholar
Himmelfarb, Samuel and Senn, David. 1969. Forming Impressions of Social Class: two tests of an averaging model, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, XII (1), 38–51.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hodge, R.W. 1962. The Status Consistency of Occupational Groups, American Sociological Review, XXVII, 336–43.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hodge, Robert W. and Siegel, Paul M.. 1970. Nonvertical Dimensions of Social Stratification, pp. 512–20, in Laumann, Edward O., Siegel, Paul M. and Hodge, Robert W. (eds.) The Logic of Social Hierarchies (Chicago, Markham).Google Scholar
Homans, G.C. 1961. Social Behavior: its elementary forms (New York, Harcourt, Brace & World).Google Scholar
Hope, Keith. 1975. Models of Status Inconsistency and Social Mobility Effects, American Sociological Review, XL, 322–43.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hornung, Carlton Albert. 1972. Status Consistency: A method of measurement and empirical examination [Ph. D. dissertation, Syracuse University].Google Scholar
Hornung, Carlton A. 1977. Social Status, Status Inconsistency and Psychological Stress, American Sociological Review, XLIII 623–638.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
House, James S. and Harkins, Elizabeth Bates. 1975. Why and When is Status Inconsistency Stressful?, American Journal of Sociology, LXXXI, 395–412.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hunt, Larry L. and Crushing, Robert G.. 1970. Status Discrepancy, Interpersonal Attachment and Right-Wing Extremism, Social Science Quarterly, LI, 587–601.Google Scholar
Hyman, M.D. 1966. Determining the Effects of Status Consistency, Public Opinion Quarterly, XXX, 120–29.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hyman, M.D. 1967. The Unpleasant Consequences of Rank Inconsistency: suggestions for a reorientation of theory and research, Sociological Quarterly, VIII, 383–96.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Jackson, E.F. 1962. Status Consistency and Symptoms of Stress, American Sociological Review, XXVII, 469–80.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Jackson, E.F. and Burke, P.J.. 1965. Status and Symptoms of Stress: additive and interaction effects, American Sociological Review, XXX, 556–64.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Jackson, Elton F. and Curtis, Richard F.. 1972. Effects of Vertical Social Mobility and Status Inconsistency: A body of negative evidence, American Sociological Review, XXXVII, 701–13.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kelly, K. Dennis and Chambliss, William J.. 1966. Status Consistency and Political Attitudes, American Sociological Review, XXXI, 375–82.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kelman, H.C. and Baron, R.M.. 1968. Determinants of Resolving Inconsistency Dilemmas: A functional analysis, pp. 670–83, in Abelson, Robert P. et al. (eds.), Theories of Cognitive Consistency: A sourcebook (Chicago, Rand McNally).Google Scholar
Kenkel, William F. 1956. The Relationship Between Status Consistency and Politico-Economic Attitudes, American Sociological Review, XXI, 365–68.Google Scholar
Kimberly, J.C. 1967. Status Inconsistency: A reformulation of a theoretical problem, Human Relations XX, 171–79.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kleiner, R. and Parker, S.. 1963. Goal-Striving, Social Status, and Mental Disorder: A research review, American Sociological Review, XXVIII, 189–203.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Knoke, David. 1972. Community and Consistency: The ethnic factor in status inconsistency, Social Forces, LI, 23–33.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Knoke, David. 1973. Intergenerational Occupational Mobility and the Political Party Preferences of American Men, American Journal of Sociology, LXXVIII, 1448–68.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Landecker, W.S. 1970. Status Congruence, Class Crystallization, and Social Change, Sociology and Social Research, LIV, 343–55.Google Scholar
Laumann, Edward O. 1966. Prestige and Association in an Urban Community: An analysis of an urban stratification system (Indianapolis, Bobbs-Merrill).Google Scholar
Laumann, E.O. 1969a. The Social Structure of Religious and Ethnoreligious Groups in a Metropolitan Community, American Sociological Review, XXXIV, 182–97.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Laumann, E.O. 1969b. Friends of Urban Men: An assessment of accuracy in reporting their socio-economic attributes, mutual choice, and attitude agreement, Sociometry, XXXII, 54–69.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Laumann, Edward O. 1973. Bonds of Pluralism: The form and substance of urban social networks (New York, Wiley & Sons).Google Scholar
Laumann, Edward O. and Segal, David R.. 1971. Status Inconsistency and Ethnoreligious Group Membership as Determinants of Social Participation and Political Attitudes, American Journal of Sociology, LXXVII, 36–61.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lazarus, Richard S. 1966. Psychological Stress and the Coping Process (New York, McGraw-Hill).Google Scholar
Lenski, G.E. 1954. Status Crystallization: A non-vertical dimension of social status, American Sociological Review, XIX, 405–13.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lenski, G.E. 1956. Social Participation and Status Crystallization, American Sociological Review, XXI, 458–64.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lenski, G.E. 1964. Comment, Public Opinion Quarterly, XXVIII, 326–30.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lenski, G.E. 1967. Status Inconsistency and the Vote: A four-nation test, American Sociological Review, XXXII, 298–301.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Levi, Lennart. 1967. Stress: sources, management and prevention (New York, Liveright).Google Scholar
Levine, Sol and Scotch, Norman A.. 1970. Social Stress (Chicago, Aldine).Google Scholar
Lopreato, Joseph and Lopreato, Sally Cook. 1975. Theoretical Needs of Status Inconsistency Research [Paper Presented to the International Sociological Association, Research Committee on Social Stratification] (Geneva).Google Scholar
Lystad, M. 1969. Status, Status Incongruence, and Symptoms of Stress, Journal of Health and Social Behavior, X, 237–44.Google Scholar
Malewski, A. 1963. The Degree of Status Incongruence and Its Effects, Polish Sociological Bulletin, I, 9–19.Google Scholar
Mayer, Karl-Ulrich. 1975. Ungleichheit und Mobilität im sozialen Bewußtsein. Untersuchungen zur Definition der Mobilitätssituation (Opladen, Westdeutscher Verlag).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
McCranie, Edward W. and Kimberly, James C.. 1973. Rank Inconsistency, Conflicting Expectations and Injustice, Sociometry, XXXVI, 152–76.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
McGrath, J.E. 1970. Social and Psychological Factors in Stress (New York, Holt, Rinehart & Winston).Google Scholar
Meile, Richard L. and Haese, Philip N.. 1969. Social Status, Status Incongruence and Symptoms of Stress, Journal of Health and Social Behavior, X, 237–44.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Meyer, John W. and Hammond, Phillip E.. 1971. Forms of Status Inconsistency, Social Forces, L, 91–101.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Mitchell, R.E. 1964. Methodological Notes on a Theory of Status Crystallization, Public Opinion Quarterly, XXVIII, 315–25.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Muller, Edward N. 1975. Relative Deprivation and Aggressive Political Behavior [Paper Presented at the Annual Meeting of the American Political Science Association] (San Francisco).Google Scholar
Nagi, S.Z. 1963. Status Profile and Reactions to Status Threats, American Sociological Review, XXVIII, 440–43.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Nelson, Edward E. 1973. Status Inconsistency: its objective and subjective components, Sociological Quarterly, XIV, 3–18.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Olsen, Marvin E. and Tully, Judy Corder. 1972. Socio-economic Status Inconsistency and Preference for Political Change, American Sociological Review, XXXVII, 560–74.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Parker, S. 1963. Status Consistency and Stress, American Sociological Review, XXVIII, 131–132.Google Scholar
Pearlin, Leonard I. 1975. Status Inequality and Stress in Marriage, American Sociological Review, XL, 344–57.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Pettigrew, T.F. 1969. Racially Separate or Together, Journal of Social Issues, XXV, 43–69.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ploch, Donald R. 1968. Status Inconsistency: A method of measurement and substantive evaluation [Ph.D. dissertation, University of North Carolina].Google Scholar
Portes, Alejandro. 1972. Status Inconsistency and Lower-class Leftist Radicalism, Sociological Quarterly, XIII, 361–82.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Rohter, Ira S. 1969. Social and Psychological Determinants of Radical Rightism, pp. 193–237, in Schoenberger, Robert A. (ed.), The American Right Wing: readings in political behavior (New York, Holt, Rinehart and Winston).Google Scholar
Runciman, W.G. 1967, Congruence and Professor Homans, Archives européennes de sociologie, VIII, 115–28.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Runciman, W.G. and Bagley, C.R.. 1969. Status Consistency, Relative Deprivation, and Attitudes to Immigrants, Sociology, III, 359–75.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Rush, G.B. 1967. Status Consistency and Right-Wing Extremism, American Sociological Review, XXXII, 86–92.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Salopek, Philipp A. and Vanderpool, Christopher K.. 1976. Status Inconsistency and Democratic Party Preference: A replication and Critique, Journal of Political and Military Sociology, IV, 29–38.Google Scholar
Sampson, E.E. 1963. Status Congruence and Cognitive Consistency, Sociometry, XXVI, 146–62.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Sampson, E.E. 1969. Studies of Status Congruence, pp. 225–270, in Berkowitz, Leonard (ed.), Advances in Experimental Social Psychology, Vol. IV (New York, Academic Press).Google Scholar
Sampson, E.E. and Bunker, G.L.. 1966. The Effects of Power and Congruity on Small Group Behavior [Unpublished Report. University of California].Google Scholar
Segal, D.R. 1969. Status Inconsistency, Cross Pressures, and American Political Behavior, American Sociological Review, XXXIV, 352–59.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Segal, David R. and Knoke, David. 1968. Social Mobility, Status Inconsistency and Partisan Realignment in the United States, Social Forces, XLVII, 154–157.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Segal, David R. and Knoke, David. 1971. Class Inconsistency, Status Inconsistency, and Political Partisanship in America, Journal of Politics, XXXIII, 939–54.Google Scholar
Segal, D.R., Segal, M.W. and Knoke, D.. 1970. Status Inconsistency and Self-Evaluation, Sociometry, XXXIII, 347–57.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Smith, Thomas S. 1969. Structural Crystallization, Status Inconsistency and Political Partisanship, American Sociological Review, XXXIV, 907–21.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Starnes, Charles E. and Singleton, Royce Jr, 1977. Objective and Subjective Status Inconsistency: A search for empirical correspondence, Sociological Quarterly, XVIII, 253–266.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Stehr, Nico. 1971. Statuskonsistenz, Kölner Zeitschrift für Soziologie und Sozial psychologie, XXIII, 34–54.Google Scholar
Steiner, I.D. 1968. Responses to Inconsistency, pp. 641–47, in Abelson, Robert P. et al. (eds.), Theories of Cognitive Consistency: A sourcebook (Chicago, Rand McNally).Google Scholar
Steiner, I.D. and Rogers, E.D.. 1963. Alternative Responses to Dissonance, Journal of Abnormal and Social Psychology LXVI, 128–36.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Taylor, Howard F. 1973. Linear Models of Consistency: some extensions of Blalock's strategy, American Journal of Sociology, LXXVIII, 1192–1215.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Thibaut, J.W. and Kelley, H.H.. 1959. The Social Psychology of Groups (New York, Wiley).Google Scholar
Thompson, Kenneth H. 1971. A Crossnational Analysis of Intergenerational Social Mobility and Political Orientation, Comparative Political Studies, IV, 3–20.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Treiman, Donald J. 1966. Status Discrepancy and Prejudice, American Journal of Sociology, LXXI, 651–64.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Tuckman, J. and Kleiner, R.. 1962. Discrepancy Between Aspiration and Achievement as a Predictor of Schizophrenia, Behavioral Science, VII, 443–47.Google Scholar
Vorwaller, Darrel J. 1970. Social Mobility and Membership of Voluntary Association, American Journal of Sociology, LXXV, 481–95.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Wilkinson, D.Y. 1970. Political Assassins and Status Incongruence: A sociological interpretation, British Journal of Sociology, XXI, 400–12.Google Scholar
Williams, Robin M. Jr, 1975. Relative Deprivation, pp. 355–78 in Coser, Lewis Lewis A. (ed.), The Idea of Social Structure: Papers in Honor of Robert K. Merton (New York, Harcourt Brace Jovanovich).Google Scholar
Wilson, Kenneth L. and Zurcher, Louis A.. 1976. Status Inconsistency and Participation in Social Movements: An application of Goodman's hierarchical modeling, Sociological Quarterly, XVII, 520–533.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Zimmermann, Ekkart. 1977. Political Violence, Crises, and Revolutions: theories and research [Trend Report to Appear as a Special Number in Current Sociology].Google Scholar