Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-mkpzs Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-26T20:35:04.228Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

RESEARCH ARTICLE: Collaborative Environmental Governance and Indigenous Peoples: Recommendations for Practice

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  30 April 2015

Suzanne von der Porten ,
Rob de Loë  and
Ryan Plummer
Suzanne von der Porten*
Affiliation:
Hakai Institute, Simon Fraser University
Rob de Loë
Affiliation:
University of Waterloo
Ryan Plummer
Affiliation:
Brock University.
*
Address correspondence to: Suzanne von der Porten, Hakai Institute, Simon Fraser University; (e-mail) [email protected].
Get access

Abstract

Collaborative environmental governance scholars have increasingly recognized the need to engage Indigenous peoples in environmental decision-making processes. Barriers to doing so effectively are well known. Recognizing these barriers, some scholars have discussed recommendations from practice in regions where Indigenous lands have been colonized and where there are complex environmental problems. This article explores assumptions regarding Indigenous engagement in the practice of collaborative environmental governance and contextualizes these assumptions relative to the perspectives of Indigenous peoples. Concrete advice for environmental practitioners is offered that builds on findings from a previously published systematic review and empirical multi-case study of governance for water in British Columbia, Canada. Recommendations for practice offered here include the following: approach or involve Indigenous peoples as self-determining nations rather than as one of many collaborative stakeholders or participants; identify and engage with existing or intended environmental governance processes and assertions of self-determination by Indigenous nations; create opportunities for relationship building between Indigenous peoples and policy or governance practitioners; choose venues and processes of decision making that reflect Indigenous rather than Eurocentric venues and processes; provide resources to Indigenous nations to level the playing field in terms of capacity for collaboration or for policy reform decision making; and find ways to support Indigenous nations in their own continued environmental decision making and self-determination.

Environmental Practice 00: 1–11 (2015)

Type
Features
Information
Environmental Practice , Volume 17 , Issue 2 , June 2015 , pp. 134 - 144
Copyright
© National Association of Environmental Professionals 2015 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Alfred, T. 2005. Wasase: Indigenous Pathways of Action and Freedom. Broadview Press, Toronto.Google Scholar
Alfred, T. 2009. Peace, Power, Righteousness: An Indigenous Manifesto, 2nd edition. Oxford University Press, Don Mills.Google Scholar
Ansell, C., and Gash, A.. 2007. Collaborative Governance in Theory and Practice. Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory 18(4):543–571.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Assembly of First Nations. 2010. Nation Building and Re-building ~ Supporting First Nations Governments’ Capacity. Fall 2010 Planning and Dialogue Forum: Report to the AFN December 2010 Special Chiefs Assembly. Available at http://www.bcafn.ca/files/documents/6-November2010PolicyandDialogueForumwrap-uppaper_FINAL.pdf (accessed December 18, 2012).Google Scholar
Bark, R.H., Garrick, D.E., Robinson, C.J., and Jackson, S.. 2012. Adaptive basin governance and the prospects for meeting Indigenous water claims. Environmental Science and Policy 19(20):169–177.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Boelens, R., Getches, D., and Guevara-Gil, A., eds. 2010. Out of the Mainstream: Water Rights, Politics and Identity. Earthscan, London.Google Scholar
Booth, A.L., and Skelton, N.W.. 2004. First Nations Access and Rights to Resources. In Resource and Environmental Management in Canada, B. Mitchell, ed., 3rd edition. Oxford University Press, Don Mills, 80–103.Google Scholar
Booth, A.L., and Skelton, N.W.. 2011. Improving First Nations’ Participation in Environmental Assessment Processes: Recommendations from the Field. Impact Assessment and Project Appraisal 29(1):49–58.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Borrows, J. 2005. October 15. Crown and Aboriginal Occupations of Land: A History & Comparison. In Ipperwash Inquiry, Ontario.Google Scholar
British Columbia Ministry of Environment. 2008. Water Stewardship Division Strategic Plan. Victoria, British Colmbia. Available at http://www.env.gov.bc.ca/wsd/water_rights/cabinet/WSDstratplan.pdf (accessed March 3, 2015).Google Scholar
Brown, H.C.P. 2009. Climate Change and Ontario Forests: Prospects for Building Institutional Adaptive Capacity. Mitigation and Adaptation Strategies for Global Change 14:513–536.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Carlson, J.A. 2010. Avoiding Traps in Member Checking. The Qualitative Report 15(5):1102–1113.Google Scholar
Cimo, L.F., and Dobson, T.. 2004. Evaluation of the Effectiveness of Court-Ordered Fisheries Management Policies. Fisheries Management 29(5):10–18.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Corntassel, J., and Witmer, R.C.. 2008. Forced Federalism: Contemporary Challenges to Indigenous Nationhood. University of Oklahoma Press, Norman, Oklahoma.Google Scholar
Coulthard, G. 2008. Beyond Recognition: Indigenous Self-Determination as Prefigurative Practice. In Lighting the Eighth Fire: The Liberation, Resurgence, and Protection of Indigenous Nations, L. Simpson, ed. Arbeiter Ring Press, Winnipeg, 188–199.Google Scholar
Council of Australian Governments, Working Group on Climate Change and Water. 2008. March. Report to Council of Australian Governments. Council of Australian Governments, Canberra.Google Scholar
Cronin, A.E., and Ostergren, D.M.. 2007. Democracy, Participation and Native American Tribes in Collaborative Watershed Management. Society and Natural Resources 20:527–542.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Cullen, D., McGee, G., Gunton, T.I., and Day, J.C.. 2010. Collaborative Planning in Complex Stakeholder Environments: An Evaluation of a Two-Tiered Collaborative Planning Model. Society and Natural Resources 23:332–350.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Deloria, V., and Wildcat, D.R.. 2001. Power and Place: Indian Education in America. Fulcrum Resources, Colorado.Google Scholar
Ellis, S.C. 2005. Meaningful Consideration? A Review of Traditional Knowledge in Environmental Decision Making. Arctic 58(1):66–77.Google Scholar
Erazo, J. 2010. Constructing Indigenous Subjectivities: Economic Collectivism and Identity in the Ecuadorian Amazon. Development and Change 41(6):1017–1039.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Fish, R.D., Ioris, A.A.R., and Watson, N.M.. 2010. Integrating Water and Agricultural Management: Collaborative Governance for a Complex Policy Problem. Science of the Total Environment 408(23):5623–5630.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Fortier, J.F., Wyatt, S., Natcher, D.C., Smith, M.A., and Hébert, M.. 2013. An Inventory of Collaborative Arrangements between Aboriginal Peoples and the Canadian Forest Sector: Linking Policies to Diversification in Forms of Engagement. Journal of Environmental Management 119:47–55.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Frame, T.M., Gunton, T., and Day, J.C.. 2004. The Role of Collaboration in Environmental Management: An Evaluation of Land and Resource Planning in British Columbia. Journal of Environmental Planning and Management 47(1):59–82.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Fraser Basin Council. 2011. About the Fraser Basin Council. Available at www.fraserbasin.bc.ca (accessed April 10, 2011).Google Scholar
Fraser, E.D., Douglas, A.J., Mabee, W., Reed, M., and McAlpine, P.. 2006. Bottom Up and Top Down: Analysis of Participatory Processes for Sustainability Indicator Identification as a Pathway to Community Empowerment and Sustainable Environmental Management. Journal of Environmental Management 78:114–127.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Gibbs, L. M. 2010. ‘A Beautiful Soaking Rain’: Environmental Value and Water Beyond Eurocentrism. Environment and Planning D: Society and Space 28:363–378.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Godden, L., and Gunther, M.. 2010. Realising Capacity: Indigenous Involvement in Water Law and Policy Reform in South-Eastern Australia. Water Law 20(5/6):243–253.Google Scholar
Gunningham, N. 2009. The New Collaborative Environmental Governance: The Localization of Regulation. Journal of Law and Society 36(1):145–166.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Heaney, A., Dwyer, G., Beare, S., Peterson, D., and Pechey, L.. 2007. Third-Party Effects of Water Trading and Potential Policy Responses. The Australian Journal of Agricultural and Resource Economics 59:277–293.Google Scholar
Hickey, C.G., and Nelson, M.. 2005. Partnerships Between First Nations and the Forest Sector: A National Survey. Sustainable Forest Management Network, Edmonton, Alberta, Canada.Google Scholar
Huitema, D., and Meijerink, S.. 2009. Transitions in Water Management: Positioning This Book. In Water Policy Entrepreneurs: A Research Companion to Water Transitions around the Globe, D. Huitema and S. Meijerink, eds. Edward Elgar Publishing Limited, Cheltenham, UK, 3–22.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hunt, J. 2008. Between a Rock and a Hard Place: Self-Determination, Mainstreaming and Indigenous Community Governance. In Contested Governance: Cultura, Power and Institutions in Indigenous Australia, J. Hunt et al., eds. Australian National University Press, Canberra, 27–53.Google Scholar
Innes, J.E., and Booher, D.E.. 2010. Planning With Complexity: An Introduction to Collaborative Rationality for Public Policy. Routledge, New York.Google Scholar
Jackson, S., and Robinson, C.. 2009. Indigenous Participation in Water Planning and Management. In Northern Australia Land and Water Science Review. CSIRO, Sydney, Austrialia.Google Scholar
Jackson, S., Tan, P.L., Mooney, C., Hoverman, S., and White, I.. 2012. Principles and Guidelines for Good Practice in Indigenous Engagement in Water Planning. Journal of Hydrology 474:57–65.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Jones, R., Rigg, C., and Lee, L.. 2010. Haida Marine Planning: First Nations as a Partner in Marine Conservation. Ecology and Society 15(1):1–12.Google Scholar
Ladner, K. 2004. Up the creek: Fishing for a new constitutional order. 76th Annual Conference of the Canadian Political Science Association, Winnipeg, Canada.Google Scholar
LaDuke, W. 2005. Recovering the Sacred: The Power of Naming and Claiming. South End Press, Cambridge, Massachusetts.Google Scholar
Lane, M.B., and Hibbard, M.. 2005. Doing It for Themselves: Transformative Planning by Indigenous Peoples. Journal of Planning Education and Research 25(2):172–184.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
McGregor, D. 2004. Traditional Ecological Knowledge and Sustainable Development: Towards Coexistence. In In the Way of Development: Indigenous Peoples, Life Projects and Globalization. M. Blaser, H. A. Feit, and G. McRae, eds. Zed Books, London and New York, 72–91.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Morton, C., Gunton, T.I., and Day, J.C.. 2012. Engaging Aboriginal Populations in Collaborative Planning: An Evaluation of a Two-Tiered Collaborative Planning Model for Land and Resource Management. Journal of Environmental Planning and Management 55(4):507–523.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ortiz, S.J. 2011. Indigenous Continuance: Collaboration and Syncretism. American Indian Quarterly 35(3):285–293.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Paci, C., Tobin, A., and Robb, P.. 2002. Reconsidering the Canadian Environmental Impact Assessment Act: A Place for Traditional Environmental Knowledge. Environmental Impact Assessment Review 22:111–127.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Petticrew, M., and Roberts, H.. 2006. Systematic Reviews in the Social Sciences: A Practical Guide. Blackwell Publishing, Oxford, UK.Google Scholar
Phare, M.A. 2011. Restoring the Lifeblood: Water, First Nations and Opportunities for Change. Walter and Duncan Gordon Foundation, Toronto, Canada.Google Scholar
Pierotti, R., and Wildcat, D.R.. 2000. Traditional Ecological Knowledge: The Third Alternative (Commentary). Ecological Applications 10(5):1333–1340.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Pigram, J.J. 1999. Tradeable Water Rights: The Australian Experience. Water Resources Development 15(4):493–509.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Robins, L. 2009. Insiders versus Outsiders: Perspectives on Capacity Issues to Inform Policy and Programmes. Local Environment 14(1):45–59.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Shmueli, D.F., and Khamaisi, R.. 2011. Bedouin Communities in the Negev: Models for Planning the Unplanned. Journal of the American Planning Association 77(2):109–125.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Simpcw First Nation. 2010. Simpcw Water Declaration, Signed August 16, 2010. Unpublished.Google Scholar
Simpson, L. 2008. Lighting the Eighth Fire: The Liberation, Resurgence, and Protection of Indigenous Nations. Arbeiter Ring Publishing, Winnipeg, Canada.Google Scholar
Singleton, S. 2009. Native People and Planning for Marine Protected Areas: How “Stakeholder” Processes Fail to Address Conflicts in Complex, Real-World Environments. Coastal Management 37:421–440.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Smith, L.T. 1999. Decolonizing Methodologies: Research and Indigenous Peoples. St. Martin's Press, Dunedin, New Zealand.Google Scholar
Spak, S. 2005. The Position of Indigenous Knowledge in Canadian Co-Management Organizations. Anthropologica 47(2):233–246.Google Scholar
Spellecacy, R. 2009. Water Resource Planning for the Agricultural Community in Washington State. Environmental Practice 11:95–104.Google Scholar
Takeda, L., and Ropke, I.. 2010. Power and Contestation in Collaborative Ecosystem-Based Management: The Case of Haida Gwaii. Ecological Economics 70:178–188.Google Scholar
Tan, P.L., Bowmer, K.H., and Baldwin, C.. 2012. Continued Challenges in the Policy and Legal Framework for Collaborative Water Planning. Journal of Hydrology 474:84–91.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Turner, D. 2006. This Is Not a Peace Pipe: Towards a Critical Indigenous Philosophy. University of Toronto Press, Toronto, Canada.Google Scholar
United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization. 2003. March. Indigenous Peoples Kyoto Water Declaration. Third World Water Forum, Kyoto, Japan.Google Scholar
United Nations General Assembly. 2007. United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples, United Nations.Google Scholar
von der Porten, S., and de Loë, R.C.. 2013. Collaborative Approaches to Governance for Water and Indigenous Peoples: A Case Study from British Columbia, Canada. Geoforum 50:149–160.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
von der Porten, S., and de Loë, R.C.. 2014a. How Collaborative Approaches to Environmental Problem Solving View Indigenous Peoples: A Systematic Review. Society and Natural Resources 27:1040–1056.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
von der Porten, S., and de Loë, R.C.. 2014b. Water Policy Reform and Indigenous Governance. Water Policy 16:222–243.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Xeni Gwet’in First Nation. 2002. Elegesi Qiyus Wild Horse Protocol Agreement, Xeni Gwet’in First Nations Government.Google Scholar
Youngblood Henderson, J.S. 2000. The Context of the State of Nature. In Reclaiming Indigenous Voice and Vision, M. Battiste, ed. UBC Press, Vancouver, Canada, 11–38.Google Scholar