Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-94fs2 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-17T15:19:24.118Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Commentary: Environmental Justice in the Big Easy? The Agriculture Street Landfill Tragedy

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  13 July 2009

Craig E. Colten
Craig E. Colten*
Affiliation:
Department of Geography and Anthropology, Louisiana State University, Baton Rouge, Louisiana
*
Associate Professor, Department of Geography and Anthropology, Louisiana State University, Baton Rouge, LA 70803; (e-mail) [email protected].
Get access

Extract

After 20 years, Superfund has evolved from a risk-based, technically oriented, litigation-driven site cleanup program to an effort that places greater emphasis on negotiated settlements, voluntary cleanups, and community involvement The USEPA's environmental justice initiative reflects this adjustment and sometimes presents unexpected difficulties for both agency personnel and affected community members. Superfund sites, such as the New Orleans Agriculture Street Landfill, assume qualities of what geographer Kenneth Foote refer to as “landscapes of tragedy.” Despite the merging of technical and community approaches to resolving Superfund problems, attachments to place sometimes defy agency efforts. The Agriculture Street situation suggests an additional assessment of community ties to the neighborhood could facilitate remediation and resolution.

Type
Features & Reviews
Information
Environmental Practice , Volume 3 , Issue 1 , March 2001 , pp. 19 - 26
Copyright
Copyright © National Association of Environmental Professionals 2001

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Notes

1. Mintz, J. A., 1995, Enforcement at the EPA: High Stakes and Hard Choices, University of Texas Press, Austin.Google Scholar

2. See Bullard, R. D., 1990, Dumping in Dixie: Race, Class, and Environmental Quality, Westview Press, Boulder.Google Scholar

3. Foote, K. E., 1997, Shadowed Ground: America's Landscapes of Violence and Tragedy, University of Texas Press, Austin, 8–27.Google Scholar Not all landscapes of tragedy are places of massive loss of life, and although Superfund sites seldom produce fatalities, neighbors view them in much the same manner. In addition, affected residents retain attachments to their homes or neighborhoods despite their proximity to sites of calamitous events. This point was first made by Sheehan, R. A., 1999, “Attachment to Place and Superfund Communities,” paper presented to the Southwest Association of American Geographers meeting, San Marcos, Texas, 10 22.Google Scholar

4. Hird, J. A., 1994, Superfund: The Political Economy of Environmental Risk, Johns Hopkins University Press, Baltimore, esp. chapter 5.Google Scholar

5. Greenberg, M. R. and Anderson, R. F., 1984, Hazardous Waste Sites: The Credibility Gap, Center for Urban Policy Research, New Brunswick, 123.Google Scholar

6. McGurty, E. M., 1997. “From NIMBY to Civil Rights: The Origins of the Environmental Justice Movement,” Environmental History 2 (07):301–323.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

7. Bullard, R. D., 1983, “Solid Wastes Sites and the Black Houston Community,” Sociological Inquiry 53:273–288CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed; and United Church of Christ, Commission for Racial Justice, 1987, Toxic Wastes and Race in the United States, New York, United Church of Christ, Commission for Racial Justice.Google Scholar

8. Browner, C. M., 1995, “The EPA's Environmental Justice Strategy,” http://www.epa.gov/docs/oejpubs/strategy/strategy.txt.html.Google Scholar

9. Wojtala, J. M., 1988, “Patterns of Refuse Disposal in New Orleans during the Middle to Late Nineteenth Century,” (Master's Thesis). Western Michigan University, Kalamazoo, Michigan, 72–86.Google Scholar

10. New Orleans Board of Health, 1903, Biennial Report, 1902–1903, Board of Health, New Orleans, 167.Google Scholar

11. New Orleans Division of Public Works, Monthly Reports, 1912–1921Google Scholar, KDW204, City Archives, New Orleans Public Library, New Orleans, Louisiana.

12. Schneider, C., 1949, “New Orleans Uses Sanitary Landfill in Marshy Areas Successfully,” American City 64 (12):110–111Google Scholar and Schneider, C., 1953, “Sanitary Fill Re-Used Safely,” American City 68 (10):83–84.Google Scholar

13. USEPA, 1999, Agriculture Street Landfill: Factsheet, Dallas, Region 6, 06 8.Google Scholar

14. For a general discussion of the diversion of wastes from water to land sinks, see Tarr, J. A., 1984, “The Search for the Ultimate Sink: Urban Air, Land, and Water Pollution in Historical Perspective,” Records of the Columbia Historical Society of Washington 41:1–29.Google Scholar

15. “Good Intentions Doom Press Park,” 1995Google Scholar, New Orleans Times-Picayune, 04 24, p. A1Google Scholar; USEPA, 1999, Agriculture Street Landfill: Fact-sheet, Dallas, Region 6, April 22; and USEPA, 1994, A Guide to Public Involvement in the Agriculture Street Landfill Remedial Removal Integrated Investigation, Dallas.

16. Louisiana Department of Health and Hospitals, 1997, Review of Health Outcome Data for the Agriculture Street Landfill, New Orleans, Louisiana, Baton Rouge, Louisiana Department of Health and Hospitals, 3.Google Scholar

17. “School Site Subject of Closed Session,” 1985Google Scholar, New Orleans Times Picayune, 02 12.Google Scholar

18. “Desire Residents want Moton School Despite Dump Site,” 1985Google Scholar, New Orleans Times Picayune, 02 27.Google Scholar

19. “Lead Tests for Kids Ordered,” 1996Google Scholar, New Orleans Times Picayune, 10 2.Google Scholar

20. “Lead Tests for Kids Ordered,” 1996, New Orleans Times Picayune, 10 2.Google Scholar

21. “Scientists Dispute Dangers of Pollution,” 1995Google Scholar, New Orleans Times Picayune, 04 23, p. A19.Google Scholar

22. “Federal Actions to Address Environmental Justice in Minority Populations and Low-Income Populations: Executive Order 128,” 1994 (02 11), http://www.epa.gov/swerosps/ej/html-doc/execordr.htm.Google Scholar

23. “Scientists Dispute Dangers of Pollution,” 1995Google Scholar, New Orleans Times Picayune, 04 23, p. A19.Google Scholar The rescoring process is relatively rare, with only four of over 700 sites in the USEPA's Region 6 undergoing a second evaluation.

24. USEPA, 1994, Community Relations Plan: A Guide to Public Involvement in the Agriculture Street Landfill SiteGoogle Scholar, Dallas. The agency went so far as to bring in residents from a Texarkana, Texas Superfund site that had been the center of an environmental-justice driven relocation effort to meet with people from the Agriculture Street neighborhood.

25. National Environmental Justice Advisory Council, 1996, The Model Plan for Public Participation, USEPA, Washington, 2.Google Scholar

26. USEPA, 1995, Remedial Removal Integrated Investigation: Agriculture Street LandfillGoogle Scholar, Dallas, Region 6.

27. USEPA, n.d., Record of Decision: Agriculture Street Landfill Superfund SiteGoogle Scholar, Dallas, Region 6.

28. “Scientists Dispute Dangers of Pollution,” 1995, New Orleans Times Picayune, 04 23, p. A19.Google Scholar Toxicologists attributed the reduction in number of children with high lead levels in their blood to a federal ban on leaded gasoline that would have reduced exposure from vehicles traveling on the major artery adjacent to the neighborhood.

29. Louisiana Office of Public Health, 1996, Public Health Assessment for Agriculture Street Landfill, Louisiana Office of Public Health, New Orleans, and Louisiana Department of Health and Hospitals, 1997, Review of Health Outcome Data for the Agriculture Street Landfill Site, Louisiana Department of Health and Hospitals, New Orleans.Google Scholar

30. “Superfund Site Residents Seek Government Buyout,” 1995Google Scholar, New Orleans Times Picayune, 09 28, p. B3.Google Scholar According to Elizabeth Blum, females typically express concern with environmental issues in maternal terms, and men employ financial rhetoric. See Blum, E., 2000, Pink and Green: A Comparative Study of Black and White Women's Urban Environmental Activism, (Dissertation). University of Houston, Houston, Texas.Google Scholar Both references emerged from the Agriculture Street area community.

31. Nationally, USEPA has relocated residents at only 14 sites, while it has undertaken emergency removal/response actions at over 2,000 sites and completed over 600 remediation efforts. USEPA, “Cleanup Responses at Hazardous Waste Sites,” http://www.epa.gov/superfund/accomp/ei/clean-up.htm, 12 1, 1998.Google Scholar

32. “EPA Might Scrape Away Tainted Soil in 9th Ward,” 1996Google Scholar, New Orleans Times Picayune, 04 9, p. A1Google Scholar and “EPA 9th Ward Cleanup Easier than Relocation,” 1996Google Scholar, New Orleans Times Picayune, 04 17, p. A1.Google Scholar

33. “Fix or Flee: Residents are at Odds,” 1997Google Scholar, New Orleans Times Picayune, 05 19, p. B1.Google Scholar

34. “End Agriculture Dump Deadlock,” 1997Google Scholar, New Orleans Times Picayune, 05 26, p. B6.Google Scholar

35. “Not All Oppose Life on Superfund Site,” 1997Google Scholar, New Orleans Times Picayune, 03 20, p. B1Google Scholar, and “9th Ward Superfund Cleanup Site Grows,” 1997.Google ScholarNew Orleans Times Picayune, 07 7, p. A1.Google Scholar

36. “Cleanup Proposal Called Too Little,” 1997Google Scholar, New Orleans Times Picayune, 09 3, p. A1.Google Scholar

37. “Morial Seeks Gore's Help in EPA Cleanup,” 1997Google Scholar, New Orleans Times Picayune, 09 27, p. B3.Google Scholar

38. “Council Want US to Pay Homeowners,” 1997, New Orleans Times Picayune, 10 4, p. B1.Google Scholar

39. “Delay Could Revive Buyout,” 1997Google Scholar, New Orleans Times Picayune, 11 2, p. B1.Google Scholar

40. “9th Ward Neighbors Sue to Stop EPA,” 1998Google Scholar, New Orleans Times Picayune, 01 16, p. B1.Google Scholar

41. “Soil Suit Thrown Out by Judge,” 1998, New Orleans Times Picayune, 03 12, B1.Google Scholar

42. “EPA Vows to Begin Landfill Cleanup,” 1999, New Orleans Times Picayune, 02 26, p. B1.Google Scholar

43. USEPA, 1999, “Administrative Order: In the Matter of City of New Orleans Regarding Agriculture Street Landfill,” USEPA Docket No. CERCLA 6–10–99 (02 2).Google Scholar

44. “Judge Stops Landfill Cleanup on City Land,” 1999Google Scholar, New Orleans Times Picayune, 05 9, p. B1.Google Scholar

45. “Judge OKs Landfill Cleanup in 9th Ward,” 1999Google Scholar, New Orleans Times Picayune, 04 2, p. B1.Google Scholar

46. “Louisiana Delegation to Testify about Discrimination,” 1999Google Scholar, New Orleans Times Picayune, 04 3, p. A14Google Scholar and “EPA May Help Landfill Residents Move,” 1999Google Scholar, New Orleans Times Picayune, 05 25, p. B1.Google Scholar

47. “Residents Protest Cleanup,” 1999Google Scholar, New Orleans Times Picayune, 06 24, p. B1.Google Scholar

48. “AG Street Residents Livid Over EPA Ruling,” 1999Google Scholar, New Orleans Times Picayune, 07 10, p. A1.Google Scholar

49. “Living a Nightmare,” 2000, New Orleans Times Picayune, 05 23.Google Scholar

50. “Landfill Suit OK'd as Class Action,” 1999Google Scholar, New Orleans Times Picayune, 09 21, p. A1.Google Scholar