Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-t5tsf Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-03T00:57:10.924Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEWS AND CASE STUDIES: Doing Credible Cultural Assessment: Applied Social Science1

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  26 July 2016

Patricia A. McCormack
Patricia A. McCormack*
Affiliation:
Native Studies, University of Alberta, Edmonton, Alberta, Canada.
*
Address correspondence to: Patricia A. McCormack, PhD, Professor Emerita, Faculty of Native Studies, Pembina Hall, University of Alberta, Edmonton, AB T6G 2H8, Canada; (phone) 780-992-9792; (e-mail) [email protected].
Get access

Abstract

This article is about socio-cultural expertise and knowledge in the context of environmental hearings in Alberta, Canada, to determine whether or not new oil sands projects should be approved. It identifies serious problems with cultural assessments about potential impacts on Aboriginal peoples done by consultants for oil sands hearings in Alberta and proposes that consultants doing cultural assessments should have qualifications equivalent to those of expert witnesses for the courts. It also raises the concern that the review panel members who preside over such hearings and their staffs may also lack expertise in socio-cultural matters concerning Aboriginal people. Both gaps impact directly on the recommendations made by review panels to the governments that make final decisions.

Environmental Practice 18: 148–165 (2016)

Type
Features
Information
Environmental Practice , Volume 18 , Issue 3 , September 2016 , pp. 148 - 165
Copyright
© National Association of Environmental Professionals 2016 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Footnotes

1

This article originated in a submission to an oil sands hearing in 2012 and then was prepared as a conference paper for “Who Has the Right to Define Cultural Values in Impact Assessment,” a session in Impact Assessment: The Next Generation, the 33rd Annual Conference of the International Association for Impact Assessment, 13-16 May 2013, Calgary, Alberta. It has greatly benefitted by editorial remarks provided by Dr. Jennifer S. H. Brown and three anonymous reviewers; I thank them all for their commentary and recommendations.

References

Academy of Experts, The. 2015. TAE Code of Practice for Experts: What Is an Expert Witness? Available at https://www.academyofexperts.org (accessed November 5, 2015).Google Scholar
Acuña, R.M. 2015. The Politics of Extractive Governance: Indigenous Peoples and Socio-Environmental Conflicts. The Extractive Industries and Society 2:85–92.Google Scholar
Alberta. 2005. The Government of Alberta’s First Nations Consultation Policy on Land Management and Resource Development. 16 May 2005. Available at indigenous.alberta.ca/documents/Policy_APPROVED-May16.pdf (accessed May 2013).Google Scholar
Alberta. 2011. Energy Resources Conservation Board Rules of Practice. Alberta Regulation 98/2011. Government Organization Act. Edmonton, AB: Alberta Queen’s Printer. Available at https:www.aer.ca/documents/actregs/AR_98_2011_erc_rules_of_practice.pdf (accessed June 8, 2016).Google Scholar
Alberta. 2012. Responsible Energy Development Act. Statutes of Alberta, 2012. Ch. R-17.3.Google Scholar
Alberta. 2013. The Government of Alberta’s Policy on Consultation with First Nations on Land and Natural Resource Management, 2013. Available at http://nationtalk.ca/story/aboriginal-consultation-policy (accessed August 20, 2013).Google Scholar
Alberta. 2014. The Government of Alberta’s guidelines on consultation with First Nations on land and natural resource management. 28 July 2014. Available at indigenous.alberta.ca/documents/First_Nations_Consultation_Guidelines_LNRD.pdf (accessed June 8, 2016).Google Scholar
Alberta. 2016. Indigenous consultation policies and guidelines. Available at www.indigenous.alberta.ca/policy-guidelines.cfm (accessed June 8, 2016).Google Scholar
Ali, S.H. 2009. Mining, the Environment, and Indigenous Development Conflicts. Tucson, AZ, University of Arizona Press, 254pp.Google Scholar
Allen, G.M., and Gould, E.M., Jr. 1986. Complexity, Wickedness, and Public Forests. Journal of Forestry 84(4):20–23.Google Scholar
Asch, M.I. 1979. The Ecological-Evolutionary Model and the Concept of Mode of Production. In Challenging Anthropology, David H. Turner and Gavin A. Smith, eds. Toronto: McGraw-Hill Ryerson, 881–899.Google Scholar
Asch, M.I., and Smith, S.. 1993. Some Facts and Myths about the Future of the Hunting and Trapping Economy in Alberta’s North. In The Uncovered Past: Roots of Northern Alberta Societies. Patricia A. McCormack and R. Geoffrey Ironside, eds. Circumpolar Research Series No. 3. Canadian Circumpolar Institute, University of Alberta, Edmonton, Aberta: 149–156.Google Scholar
Ballard, C., and Banks, G.. 2003. Resource Wars: The Anthropology of Mining. Annual Review of Anthropology 32:237–313.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bowness, E., and Hudson, M.. 2014. Sand in the Cogs? Power and Public Participation in the Alberta Tar Sands. Environmental Politics 23(1):59–76.Google Scholar
Briggs, L. n.d. Australian Public Service Commission Archive. Tackling Wicked Problems: A Public Policy Perspective. Available at www.apsc.gov.au/publications-and-media/archive/publications-archive/tacking-wicked-problems (accessed February 15, 2015).Google Scholar
Briggs, S., and Hudson, M.D.. 2013. Determination of Significance in Ecological Impact Assessment: Past Change, Current Practice and Future Improvements. Environmental Impact Assessment Review 38:16–25.Google Scholar
Burdge, R.J. 2002. Why Is Social Impact Assessment the Orphan of the Assessment Process? Impact Assessment and Project Appraisal 20(1):3–9.Google Scholar
Burdge, R.J., and Vanclay, F.. 1996. Social Impact Assessment: A Contribution to the State-of-the-Art Series. Impact Assessment 14:59–86.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Camillus, J.C. 2008. Strategy as a Wicked Problem. Harvard Business Review 86:98–101. Available at https://hbr.org/2008/05/strategy-as-a-wicked-problem (accessed February 15, 2015).Google Scholar
Canada. 2015a. Federal Court Rules (SOR/98-106). Justice Laws Website. Available at http://laws-lois.justice.gc.ca/eng/regulations/sor-98-106 (accessed November 5, 2015).Google Scholar
Canada. 2015b. Tax Court of Canada Rules (General Procedure) (SOR/90-688a). Justice Laws Website. Available at http://laws-lois.justice.gc.ca/eng/regulations/SOR-90-688A/index.html (accessed November 5, 2015).Google Scholar
Canadian Environmental Assessment Agency (CEAA). 2014. An Introduction To Environmental Assessment. Canadian Environmental Assessment Agency, Available at http://www.ceaa.gc.ca (accessed November 5, 2015).Google Scholar
Canadian Environmental Assessment Agency (CEAA). 2015. Frequently Asked Questions. Canadian Environmental Assessment Agency. Available at http://www.ceaa.gc.ca/ (accessed November 5, 2015).Google Scholar
Coglianese, C. 2015. Listening, Learning, Leading: A Framework for Regulatory Excellence. Penn Program on Regulation. Univerity of Pennsylvania Law School. Available at https://www.law.upenn.edu/institutes/regulation (accessed October 26, 2015).Google Scholar
Conklin, J. 2005. Wicked Problems and Social Complexity. In Dialogue Mapping: Building Shared Understanding of Wicked Problems. Hoboken, NJ: Wiley. Available at www.cognexus.org/wpf/wickedproblems.pdf (accessed February 15, 2015).Google Scholar
Davison, C.M., and Hawe, P.. 2012. All that Glitters: Diamond Mining and Tlicho youth in Behchoko, Northwest Territories. Arctic 65(2):214–228.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
de Vries, D. 2005. Choosing Your Baseline Carefully: Integrating Historical and Political Ecology in the Evaluation of Environmental Intervention Projects. Journal of Ecological Anthropology 9:35–50.Google Scholar
Doelle, M. 2012. CEAA 2012: The End of Federal EA as We Know It? Journal of Environmental Law and Practice 24(1):1–17. Available at http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2104336 (accessed June 8, 2016).Google Scholar
Ehrlich, A., and Ross, W.. 2015. The Significance Spectrum and EIA Significance Determination. Impact Assessment and Project Appraisal 33(2):87–97. Available at http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/14615517.2014.981023.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Energy Resources Conservation Board (ERCB). n.d. Regulations & Directives: Acts & Regulations. Available at http://www.ercb.ca/regulations-and-directives/acts-regulations (accessed May 28, 2013).Google Scholar
Ericsson, K.A., Prietula, M.J., and Cokely, E.T.. 2007. The Making of an Expert. Harvard Business Review. Available at https://hbr.org/2007/07/the-making-of-an-expert (accessed November 5, 2015).Google Scholar
Esteves, A.M., Franks, D., and Vanclay, F.. 2012. Social Impact Assessment: The State of the Art. Impact Assessment and Project Appraisal 30(1):34–42.Google Scholar
Feehan, K.P. 2012. Useful Expert Evidence—The Evolution of Rule and Practice. 2012 Canadian Bar Association Canadian Legal Conference & Marketplace. Available at docplayer.net/6540114-Useful-expert-evidence-the-evolution-of-rule-and-practice-canadian-bar-association-national-civil-litigation-section.html (accessed June 8, 2016).Google Scholar
Freudenburg, W. R. 1986. Social Impact Assessment. Annual Review of Sociology 12:451–478.Google Scholar
Gamu, J., Le Billon, P., and Spiegel, S.. 2015. Extractive Industries and Poverty: A Review of Recent Findings and Linkage Mechanisms. The Extractive Industries and Society 2:162–176. Available at http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.exis.2014.11.001.Google Scholar
Geisler, C.C., Usner, D., Green, R., and West, P., eds. 1982. Indian SIA: The Social Impact Assessment of Rapid Resource Development on Native Peoples. Natural Resources Sociology Research Lab, University of Michigan. Monograph #3, 448 pp.Google Scholar
Gibson, R.B. 2012. In Full Retreat: The Canadian Government’s New Environmental Assessment Law Undoes Decades of Progress. Impact Assessment Project Appraisal 30(3):179–188.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Golder Associates. 2012. Golder Associates Report: Jackpine Mine Expansion Project, Cultural Assessment, April 2012. Report No. 11-1346-0035.Google Scholar
Golder Associates. 2015. Environmental & social impact assessment services. Golder Associates. Available at http://www.golder.ca (accessed October 27, 2015).Google Scholar
Goulet, J.-G. 1998. Ways of Knowing: Experience, Knowledge, and Power among the Dene Tha. Vancouver: UBC Press, 334pp.Google Scholar
Greig, L.A., and Duinker, P.N.. 2011. A Proposal for Further Strengthening Science in Environmental Impact Assessment in Canada. Impact Assessment and Project Appraisal 29(2):159–165.Google Scholar
Haefele, M., and Cliffe-Phillips, K.. 2004. Environmental Impact Assessment Made in the North. Paper presented at the International Association for Impact Assessment annual conference, April 2004, Vancouver, BC. Available at www.reviewboard.ca/upload/ref_library/pa390%20Cliffe-Philips%20and%20Haefele%20EIA%20Made%20in%20the%20North_1183674172.pdf (accessed May 27, 2013).Google Scholar
Helm, J., ed. 1981. Subarctic. Vol. 6. Handbook of North American Indians. Washington, DC: Smithsonian Institution, 837pp.Google Scholar
IAIA. 2003. Social Impact Assessment International Principles. Special Publication Series No. 2. International Association for Impact Assessment.Google Scholar
IAIA. 2012. Special issue: The State of the Art of Impact Assessment in 2012 30(1).Google Scholar
International Council on Mining & Metals. 2015. Good Practice Guide. Indigenous Peoples and Mining. 2nd ed. (originally 2011) London, UK, International Council on Mining and Metals, 132pp. Available at www.icmm.com.Google Scholar
Jacobs, P. 1982. Cultural Impacts of Environmental Assessment. Environmental Impact Assessment Review 2(3):222–226.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Jarvenpa, R. 2004. Silot’ine: An Insurance Perspective on Northern Dene Kinship Networks in Recent History. Journal of Anthropological Research 60(2):153–178.Google Scholar
Joint Review Panel. 2013. Report of the Joint Review Panel. Shell Canada Energy, Jackpine Mine Expansion Project. Application to Amend Approval 9756, Fort McMurray area. 9 July 2013. 2013 ABAER 011. CEAA Reference No. 59540.Google Scholar
Jorgensen, J.G. 1971. Indians and the Metropolis. In The American Indian in Urban Society, Jack O. Waddell and O. Michael Watson, eds.,. Boston: Little Brown, 66–113.Google Scholar
Jorgensen, J.G. 1978. A Century of Political Economic Effects on American Indian Society, 1880-1980. Journal of Ethnic Studies 6(3):1–82.Google Scholar
Justus, R., and Simonetta, J.. 1982. Oil Sands, Indians and SIA in Northern Alberta. In Indian SIA: The Social Impact Assessment of Rapid Resource Development on Native Peoples. Charles C. Geisler et al., eds., Natural Resources Research Lab, University of Michigan. Monograph #3.238–257.Google Scholar
King, T.F. 1998. How the Archaeologists Stole Culture: A Gap in American Environmental Impact Assessment Practice and How to Fill It. Environmental Impact Assessment Review 18(2):117–133.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
King, T.F. 2000. What Should Be the “Cultural Resources” Element of an EIA? Environmental Impact Assessment Review 20(1):5–30.Google Scholar
King, T.F. 2003. Places That Count. Traditional Cultural Properties in Cultural Resource Management. Walnut Creek, CA: AltaMira.Google Scholar
Kirchhoff, D., and Tsuji, L.J.S.. 2014. Reading between the Lines of the ‘Responsible Resource Development’ Rhetoric: The Use of Omnibus Bills to ‘streamline’ Canadian Environmental Legislation. Impact Assessment and Project Appraisal 32(2):108–120.Google Scholar
Kruse, J. 2006. Indicators of Social, Economic, and Cultural Cumulative Effects Resulting from Petroleum Development in Alaska: A Review. Available at https://www.ceaa-acee.gc.ca/155701CE-docs/Jack_Kruse-eng.pdf (accessed June 15, 2013).Google Scholar
Kuttner, Thomas S. 2006. Administrative tribunals. The Canadian Encyclopedia. Available at http://www.thecanadianencyclopedia.ca/en/article/administrative-tribunals/ (accessed November 9, 2015).Google Scholar
Lambrecht, Kirk N. 2013. Aboriginal Consultation, Environmental Assessment, and Regulatory Review in Canada. Regina, SK: University of Regina Press, 208pp.Google Scholar
Levi, P. 2012. Expert Witness Rules, Rules and More Rules. Association of Certified Fraud Examiners. Available at www.acfe.com/uploadedFiles/ACFE_Website/Content/canadian/2012/presentations/cpp-9D-Philip-Levi.pdf (accessed November 4, 2015).Google Scholar
Lobo, P., and Henein, P.J.. 2011. Credibility under Scrutiny: A Research Study of the Weight Placed on Expert Valuation and Damages Evidence in Canadian Court Judgments. Prepared for the 2011 Ian R. Campbell Research Initiative of the Canadian Institute of Chartered Business Valuators. 31 Oct. 2011. PDF available by searching *Lobo and Henein, Credibility under scrutiny* (accessed June 8, 2016).Google Scholar
Mackenzie Valley Review Board. 2009. Status Report and Information Circular: Developing Cultural Impact Assessment Guidelines. A Mackenzie Valley Review Board Initiative. Mackenzie Valley Review Board, Yellowknife, NWT. May 2009.Google Scholar
MacNeish, J.H. 1956. Leadership among the Northeastern Athabascans. Anthropologica 2:131–163.Google Scholar
McCormack, P.A. 1984. How the (North) West Was Won: Development and Underdevelopment in the Fort Chipewyan Region. Ph.D. dissertation. Department of Anthropology, University of Alberta, 587 pp.Google Scholar
McCormack, P.A. 2010a. Fort Chipewyan and the Shaping of Canadian History 1788-1920s, In We Like to Be Free in This Country. Vancouver: UBC Press, 388pp.Google Scholar
McCormack, P.A. 2010b. Research report. An ethnohistory of the Mikisew Cree First Nation. Prepared for Janes Freedman Kyle LLC. 20 August 2010.Google Scholar
McCormack, P.A. 2010c. Research report in the Case of Moulton Contracting Ltd. v. Behn et al. Prepared for JFK Law Corporation. 5 May 2010.Google Scholar
McLachlin, B., The Right Honourable, Chief Justice of Canada. 2013. Administrative tribunals and the courts: An evolutionary relationship. Supreme Court of Canada. Available at http://www.scc-csc.gc.ca/court-cour/judges-juges/spe-dis/bm-2013-05-27-eng.aspx (accessed November 9, 2015).Google Scholar
Parker, J.M., and Tingley, K.W.. 1980. History of the Athabasca Oil Sands Region, 1890 to 1960s. Vol. 1, Socio-Economic Developments. Alberta Oil Sands Environmental Research Program, Project HS 10.2. APSERP Report No. 80.Google Scholar
Partidário, M., with input from L. den Broeder, P. Croal, R. Fuggle, and W. Ross. 2012. Impact Assessment. IAIA. Fastips. No. 1, April 2012.Google Scholar
Pénard, J.M. 1929. Land Ownership and Chieftaincy among the Chippewayan and Caribou Eaters. Primitive Man 2(1-2):20–24.Google Scholar
Preston, R.J. 2002. Cree Narrative: Expressing the Personal Meaning of Events. 2nd ed. Montreal: McGill-Queen’s University Press (Orig. 1975), 350pp.Google Scholar
Radcliffe-Brown, A.R. 1952. Structure and Function in Primitive Society. London: Cohen & West Limited, 219pp.Google Scholar
Ray, A.J. 2003. Native History on Trial: Confessions of an Expert Witness. Canadian Historical Review 84(2):253–273.Google Scholar
Ridington, R. 1982. Technology, World View, and Adaptive Strategy in a Northern Hunting Society. Canadian Review of Sociology and Anthropology 19(4):469–481.Google Scholar
Ridington, R. 1990. Little Bit Know Something. Iowa City: University of Iowa Press, 281pp.Google Scholar
Russell, D.R. 1991. Eighteenth-Century Western Cree and their Neighbours. Archaeological Survey of Canada, Mercury Series Paper 143. Ottawa: Canadian Museum of Civilization.Google Scholar
Sagnia, B.K. 2004. Framework for Cultural Impact Assessment. International Network for Cultural Diversity, Cultural Impact Assessment Project. June 2004. Available at www.dmeforpeace.org/sites/default/files/FRAMEWORKS520FOR%20IMPACTS%20ASSESSMENT%20(INCD)_2004.pdf (accessed June 8, 2016).Google Scholar
Sharp, H.S. 2001. Loon, Memory, Meaning, and Reality in a Northern Dene Community. Lincoln: University of Nebraska Press, 216pp.Google Scholar
Shell Canada. 2015. Shell Canada Withdraws Regulatory Application for Pierre River Mine. Shell Canada News Release. 23 Feb. 2015. Available at http://www.shell.ca/en/aboutshell/media-centre/news-and-media-releases/2015/pierre-river-022232015.html (accessed October 26, 2015).Google Scholar
Slobodin, R. 1966. Métis of the Mackenzie District. Ottawa: Canadian Research Centre for Anthropology, Saint-Paul University, 175pp.Google Scholar
Smith, D.M. 1982. Moose-Deer Island House People: A History of the Native People of Fort Resolution. Canadian Ethnology Service Paper No. 81, National Museum of Man Mercury Series. Ottawa: National Museums of Canada.Google Scholar
Smith, J.G.E. 1981a. Chipewyan. In Handbook of North American Indians. Subarctic. Vol. 6 of the Handbook of North American Indians. June Helm, ed. Washington, DC: Smithsonian Institution, 271–284.Google Scholar
Smith, J.G.E. 1981b. Western Woods Cree. In Handbook of North American Indians. Subarctic. Vol. 6 of the Handbook of North American Indians. June Helm, ed. Washington, DC: Smithsonian Institution, 256–270.Google Scholar
Steward, J. 1938. Basin-Plateau Aboriginal Sociopolitical Groups. Bureau of American Ethnology Bulletin 120. Washington, DC, 374 pp.Google Scholar
Steward, J. 1972. Theory of Culture Change. The Methodology of Multilinear Evolution. Urbana: University of Illinois Press (orig. 1955), 244pp.Google Scholar
Turnley, J.G. 2002. Social, Cultural, Economic Impact Assessments: A Literature Review. Prepared for the Office of Emergency and Remedial Response, U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. Galisteo Consulting Group Inc. 4 Oct. 2002. Available at www.epa.gov/superfund/policy/pdfs/SILitRevFinal.pdf (accessed May 27, 2013).Google Scholar
Vanclay, F. 2003. International Principles for Social Impact Assessment. Impact Assessment and Project Appraisal 21(1):5–11.Google Scholar
Vanclay, F., Esteves, with A.M., Aucamp, I., and Franks, D.M.. 2015. Social Impact Assessment: Guidance for Assessing and Managing the Social Impacts of Projects. Fargo, ND: International Association for Impact Assessment, Available at www.iaia.org/.Google Scholar
Westman, C.N. 2006. Assessing the Impacts of Oilsands Development on Indigenous Peoples in Alberta, Canada. Indigenous Affairs 2–3/06:30–39.Google Scholar
Westman, C.N. 2008. Understanding Cree Religious Discourse. Ph.D. thesis. Department of Anthropology, University of Alberta, Edmonton, 354 pp.Google Scholar
Westman, C.N. 2013a. Cautionary Tales: Making and Breaking Community in the Oil Sands Region. Canadian Journal of Sociology 38(2):211–231.Google Scholar
Westman, C.N. 2013b. On the Accreditation of an Oral History Expert. Native Studies Review 22(1 & 2):171–201.Google Scholar
Westman, C.N. 2013c. Social Impact Assessment and the Anthropology of the Future in Canada’s Tar Sands. Human Organization 72(2):111–120.Google Scholar
Weston, J. 2010. EIA theories—All Chinese Whispers and No Critical Theory. Journal of Environmental Assessment Policy and Management 12(4):357–374.Google Scholar
Wilson, R.P. 1998. The Role of Anthropologists as Short-Term Consultants. Human Organization 57(2):245–252.Google Scholar