Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-lj6df Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-09T20:33:52.233Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Études sur la rhétorique aristotélicienne et médiévale

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  05 May 2010

Georges Leroux
Affiliation:
Université du Québec à Montréal

Extract

Trois parutions récentes sur la rhétorique aristolélicienne et médiévale ont fourni le contenu de cette recension. Il s'agit des livres suivants:

Keith V. ERICKSON, Editor. Aristotle: The Classical Heritage of Rhetoric. Metuchen, New-Jersey, The Scarecrow Press, 1974; VIII-315pp. Joseph M. Miller, Michael H. PROSSER & Thomas W. Benson. Editors. Readings in Medieval Rhetoric. Bloomington, Indiana University Press, 1973; XX-299pp.

James J. MURPHY. Rhetoric in the Middle Ages. A History of Rhetorical Theory from saint Augustine to the Renaissance. Berkeley, University of California Press, 1974; XIV-395 pp.

Type
Critical Notices—Études Critiques
Copyright
Copyright © Canadian Philosophical Association 1976

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Cope, E. M.. The Rhetoric of Aristotle, with a Commentary. Revised and Edited by Sandys, John Edwin. Cambridge, University Press, 1877. 3 vols.Google Scholar Réédité par Brown Reprint. La situation nest pas meilleure en langue franfaise: c'est seulement en 1973 que la collection Bude a pu terminer l'édition de la Rhétorique, grâce au travail d'A. Wartelle qui a repris le manuscrit de M. Dufour.

2 Cf. Barnes, J., Schofield, M. & Sorabji, R. Eds. Key Articles on Aristotle. London, Duckworth, 1974.Google Scholar On trouvera dans ce livre une traduction anglaise de l'article important de KAPP sur la syllogistique, repris de Pauly-Wissowa. En allemand, voir Hager, F.P. Hrsg. Logik und Erkenntnislehre des Aristoteles. Darmstadt, Wissenschaftliche Buchgesellschaft, 1972 (Wege der Forschung, 226).Google Scholar A ma connaissance cependant, le recueil de Erickson est le premier consacré à la rhétorique.

3 À paraitre aux memes éditions.

4 La seule synthese disponible est celle de Baldwin, C.S.. Medieval Rhetoric and Poetic to 1400. Interpreted from representative works. New-York, Macmillan, 1928.Google Scholar Rééditée par Peter Smith, en 1959. On cite aussi Particle de Mckeon, R.. Rhetoric in the Middle Ages. Speculum 17 (1942) 132CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

5 Pour l'influence de Cicéron, voir la these non publiee de Ward, John O.. Artificiosa eloquentia in the Middle Ages. University of Toronto, 1972.Google Scholar Ce travail est cité par MURPHY, p. 116, note 88.

6 Voir. Throm, Hermann. Die Thesis. Ein Beitrag zu ihrer Entstehung und Geschichte. Paderborn, Schoningh, 1932 (Rhetorische Studien, 17)Google Scholar.

7 II pourra etre utile de citer ici les principales contributions de James J. Murphy à l'histoire de là rhetorique ancienne et medievale antérieurement à l'ouvrage que nous venons de recenser.

Murphy, James J.Saint Augustine and the Debate about a Christian Rhetoric, Quarterly Journal of Speech, 46 (1960) 400410CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

Murphy, James J.The Earliest Teaching of Rhetoric at Oxford, Speech Monographs, 27 (1960) 345347CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

Murphy, James J.The Arts of Discourse, 1050–1400, Medieval Studies, 23 (1961) 194205CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

Murphy, James J.Two Medieval Textbooks in Debate, Journal of the American Forensic Association, 1 (1964) 16Google Scholar.

Murphy, James J.A New Look at Chaucer and the Rhetoricians, Review of English Studies NS 15 (1964) 120CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

Murphy, James J.Modern Elements in Medieval Rhetoric, Western Speech 28 (1964) 206211Google Scholar.

Murphy, James J.Rhetoric in Fourteenth Century Oxford, Medievum Aevum, 34 (1965) 120Google Scholar.

Murphy, James J.A Fifteenth-Century Treatise on Prose Style, Newberry Library Bulletin, 6 (1966) 205210Google Scholar.

Murphy, James J.Aristotle's Rhetoric in the Middle Ages, Quarterly Journal of Speech, 52 (1966) 109115CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

Murphy, James J.Cicero's Rhetoric in the Middle Ages, Quarterly Journal of Speech, 53 (1967) 334341CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

Murphy, James J.Saint Augustin and Rabanus Maurus: the Genesis of Medieval Rhetoric, Western Speech, 31 (1967) 8896Google Scholar.

Murphy, James J.The Scholastic Condemnation of Rhetoric in the Commentary of Giles of Rome on the Rhetoric of Aristotle, in: Arts liberaux et Philosophie au Moyen-Age, Montreal et Paris, Librairie Vrin, 1969 (Actes du 4e congres international de philosophie medievale), pp. 832841Google Scholar.

Murphy, James J.The'Rhetorical Lore of the Boceras in Byhrferth's Manual, in: Philological Essays: Studies in Old and Middle English Language Literature in honour of Herbert Dean Meritt, ed. Rosier, James L., The Hague, 1970, pp. 111124Google Scholar.

Murphy, James J.Medieval Rhetoric. A Select Bibliography, Toronto, University Press, 1971 (Toronto, Medieval Bibliographies)Google Scholar.

Murphy, James J.Three Medieval Rhetorical Arts, Berkeley, University of California Press, 1971Google Scholar.

Murphy, James J.Alberic of Monte Cassino: Father of the Medieval «Ars dictaminis», American Benedictine Review, 22 (1971), pp. 129146Google Scholar.

Murphy, James J.The Metarhetorics of Plato, Augustine and McLuhan: A Pointing Essay, Philosophy and Rhetoric, 4 (1971), 201214Google Scholar.

Murphy, James J.A Synoptic History of Classical Rhetoric, New York, Random House, 1972Google ScholarMurphy, J.J., The Origins and Early Development of Rhetoric F.I. Hill, The Rhetoric of AristotleGoogle ScholarMurphy, J.J., The Age of Codification: Hermagoras and the Pseudo/Ciceronian Rhetorica ad HerenniumGoogle Scholar D.J. Ochs, Cicero's Rhetorical Theory; D.A. Meador, Quintilian and the Institutio Oratoria; J.J. Murphy, The End of the Ancient World: the Second Sophistic and Saint Augustine; Bibliographie, index.