Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-jkksz Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-23T16:36:11.296Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Unforgettable 1956? The PCI and the Crisis of Communism in Italy

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  02 April 2014

ALESSANDRO IANDOLO
ALESSANDRO IANDOLO*
Affiliation:
London School of Economics and Political Science: Department of International History, LSE, Houghton Street, London, WC2A 2AE; [email protected]
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

The Italian left has always perceived 1956 as an extraordinary year, because of the succession of international events that supposedly shocked many Italian militants and convinced them to abandon communism and the Italian Communist Party. On the contrary, this article claims that the real reasons for the crisis of communism in Italy had little to do with international events and must be found instead in the momentous economic and social changes that Italy was experiencing at the time. Unforgettable 1956 was therefore only a moment in a longer-term process that was destined to change communism in Italy. The article is based on previously unused documents now available at the Italian Communist Party Archive.

1956, année inoubliable? le pci et la crise du communisme en italie

Pour la gauche italienne, 1956 a toujours représenté une année extraordinaire à cause de la série d’événements internationaux qui auraient choqué de nombreux militants italiens, les persuadant d’abandonner le communisme et le parti communiste italien. Or selon cet article, les véritables causes de la crise du communisme en Italie n’ont rien à voir avec l’actualité internationale, mais résident dans les bouleversements économiques et sociaux qu’a connus le pays à cette époque. L’inoubliable année 1956 ne constituait donc qu’un épisode dans un processus de transformation à plus long terme du communisme en Italie. Cet article se fonde sur des documents non encore exploités, tirés des archives du parti communiste italien.

1956 – ein unvergessliches jahr? die pki und die krise des kommunismus in italien

Aufgrund der Abfolge internationaler Ereignisse, die vermeintlich viele italienische Aktivisten erschütterten und zur Abkehr vom Kommunismus und der Kommunistischen Partei Italiens (PKI) bewegten, hat die italienische Linke 1956 von jeher als außergewöhnliches Jahr empfunden. Dieser Beitrag vertritt die Hypothese, dass die wahren Gründe für die Krise des Kommunismus in Italien mit internationalen Ereignissen nur wenig zu tun hatten und stattdessen in den bedeutsamen wirtschaftlichen und gesellschaftlichen Umwälzungen zu suchen sind, die Italien damals erlebte. Das unvergessliche Jahr 1956 war daher lediglich ein kurzer Abschnitt in einem längerfristigen Prozess, der den Kommunismus in Italien dauerhaft ändern sollte. Der Beitrag stützt sich auf bisher unerschlossene Dokumente aus dem Archiv der Kommunistischen Partei Italiens, die nunmehr für die Forschung zugänglich sind.

Type
Articles
Information
Contemporary European History , Volume 23 , Issue 2 , May 2014 , pp. 259 - 282
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 2014 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Ingrao, Pietro, ‘L’Indimenticabile 1956’, Rinascita, 43 (29 Oct. 1966), 1–2Google Scholar.

2 Galli, Giorgio and Prandi, Alfonso, Patterns of Political Participation in Italy (New Haven: Yale University Press, 1970), 36Google Scholar.

3 Galasso, Giuseppe, Seguendo il PCI: Da Togliatti a D’Alema, 1955–1996 (Cosenza: Marco Editore, 1998), 30Google Scholar.

4 See, e.g. Indro Montanelli, ‘Un messaggio da Budapest agli studenti d’Italia’ in Corriere della Sera, 17 Nov. 1956; Corriere della Sera, 30 Oct. 1956, cited in Blackmer, Donald L. M., Unity in Diversity: Italian Communism and the Communist World (Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, 1968), 89Google Scholar; Galli, Giorgio, Storia del PCI: Il Partito Comunista Italiano: Livorno 1921, Rimini 1991 (Milan: Schwartz, 1958; Kaos, 1993), 219Google Scholar.

5 ‘L’indimenticabile ’56’, Micromega, 9 (2006). See also, Adam Michnik and Giorgio Napolitano, ‘Napolitano: Il mio cammino verso il Quirinale: “Mito dell’Urss fu anche una prigione per il Pci”’, la Repubblica, 9 June 2012.

6 Fegiz, Pierpaolo Luzzatto, Il volto sconosciuto dell’Italia: Seconda serie, 1956–1965 (Milan: Giuffrè, 1966)Google Scholar; Bonanni, Massimo, ed., La politica estera della Repubblica Italiana (Milan: IAI, 1967)Google Scholar; Cantril, Hadley, The Politics of Despair (New York: Collier Books, 1962), 185–6Google Scholar.

7 Foreign Relations of the United States (FRUS): 1955–1957, Western Europe and Canada, Vol. XXVII (Washington, DC: United States Government Printing Office, 1992), 401Google ScholarPubMed.

8 See, e.g., G. Bonacossi, Contini, ‘Gli operai comunisti e le svolte del 1956’ in Salvadori, Massimo L.et al., Ripensare il 1956, Annali Fondazione Giacomo Brodolini, 1 (1987)Google Scholar.

9 Mafai, Miriam, Botteghe Oscure addio: Com’eravamo comunisti (Milan: Mondadori, 1996), 106–7Google Scholar.

10 Borroni, Roberto, Renato Sandri, un italiano comunista: Un lungo viaggio tra rivoluzione e democrazia (Mantua: Tre Lune, 2010), 69Google Scholar.

11 Foa, Vittorio, ‘Il 1956 nel partito socialista e nel sindacato’, Ripensare il 1956, Annali Fondazione Giacomo Brodolini, 1 (1987)Google Scholar.

12 Spriano, Paolo, Le passioni di un decennio: 1946–1956 (Milano: Garzanti, 1986), 205Google Scholar.

13 Mammarella, Giuseppe, Il Partito Comunista Italiano, 1945–1975: Dalla Liberazione al Compromesso Storico (Florence: Vallecchi, 1976), 132–3Google Scholar.

14 Argentieri, Federigo, Ungheria 1956: La Rivoluzione calunniata (Venice: Marsilio, 2006), 67Google Scholar.

15 Sassoon, Donald, The Strategy of the Italian Communist Party: From the Resistance to the Historic Compromise (London: Frances Pinter, 1981), 197Google Scholar.

16 Gozzini, Giovanni and Martinelli, Renzo, Storia del Partito Comunista Italiano, Vol. VII: Dall’attentato a Togliatti all’VIII Congresso (Turin: Einaudi, 1998), 456–68Google Scholar.

17 Sassoon, Strategy of the ICP, 188.

18 Ibid. 93.

19 Gozzini and Martinelli, Storia del PCI, 608.

20 Ciocca, Pierluigi and Toniolo, Gianni, eds., Storia Economica d’Italia, Vol. 2: Annali (Rome and Bari: Laterza, 1999), 358–404Google Scholar.

21 Elaboration from Greene, Thomas H., ‘The Communist Parties of Italy and France: A Study in Comparative Communism’ in World Politics, 21, 1 (Oct. 1968), 1–38CrossRefGoogle Scholar, and Galli and Prandi, Patterns. In 1948, the PCI took part in the national elections together with the PSI, in the Fronte Democratico Popolare. They obtained 31% of the votes. Since it is not possible to separate votes for the PCI from votes for the PSI, the total percentage has been halved.

22 Maddison, Angus, Monitoring the World Economy 1820–1992 (Paris: OECD, 1995)Google Scholar, cited in Cotula, Franco, Stabilità e sviluppo negli anni cinquanta, Vol 2: Problemi strutturali e politiche economiche (Rome: Laterza, 2000), 664Google Scholar.

23 Mitchell, Brian R., European Historical Statistics 1750–975 (London: Macmillan, 1981)Google Scholar, cited in Cotula, Stabilità, 665.

24 See Ciocca and Toniolo, Storia Economica d’Italia, 374, about deflationary policies.

25 Cotula, Franco, ‘La riconquista della stabilita tra sviluppo e vincolo esterno (1946–1963)’ in Stabilità e sviluppo negli anni cinquanta, Vol. 1: L’Italia nel contesto internazionale, Collana Storica della Banca d’Italia (Roma and Bari: Laterza, 2001), 27Google Scholar.

26 Rossi, Elena Aga and Zaslavsky, Viktor, Togliatti e Stalin: Il PCI e la politica estera staliniana negli archivi di Mosca (Bologna: il Mulino, 1997), 185–7Google Scholar.

27 Shop-floor organisations, workers’ committees.

28 Negri, Sergio, ed., Fiat 1955: Giuseppe Di Vittorio e la sconfitta della CGIL alle elezioni delle Commissioni Interne (Rome: Ediesse, 2009)Google Scholar.

29 FRUS: Western Europe and Canada, Vol. XXVII, 321.

30 Pietro Ingrao, Il XX Congresso del PCUS e l’VIII Congresso del PCI in Spriano, Paolo et al., Problemi di Storia del Partito Comunista Italiano (Rome: Editori Riuniti, 1971), 132–3Google Scholar.

31 ‘Deplorato l’intervento delle truppe Sovietiche’, L’Avanti, 28 Oct. 1956.

32 Archivio PCI (henceforth, APC) Fondo Mosca (henceforth, FM), MF 127, Verbale 1956 Ott. 30.

33 FRUS: Western Europe and Canada, Vol. XXVII, 393–4.

34 Ibid. 391.

35 Sassoon, The Strategy of the ICP, 94.

36 Rome and Naples had to be left out for reasons of space, or owing to the temporary unavailability of sources. In the near future, I plan to extend the analysis to include these two cities as well.

37 Direzione PCI, Sezione d’Organizzazione, Note per i Congressi Federali 1956, APC, MF 0442, 3089.

38 APC, MF 0442, 3050, 14 June 1956.

39 APC, MF 0442, 3050, 14 June 1956.

40 Ibid.

41 APC, MF 0442, 3075–3076. A ‘cell’ was the smallest organisational unit in the PCI. A group of cells formed a party ‘section’, which was responsible for a larger territory. All the sections in a city or provincia formed a ‘federation’.

42 Ibid. 3077–3079.

43 APC, FM, MF 127, Verbale 1956 Oct. 30.

44 Ibid. 195.

45 APC, MF 0442, 3083–3085, 22 Nov. 1956.

46 Ibid.

47 APC, MF 0442, 3105–3494.

48 APC, MF 0442, 3105–3494.

49 Ibid. Several factory delegates reported on these rallies at the party congress.

50 APC, MF 0442, 3493–3494.

51 APC, MF 0443, 1761–1865, 9–10 June 1956.

52 Ibid.

53 Ibid.

54 APC, MF 0443, 1909–1914.

55 Ibid.

56 APC, MF 0443, 1915–1922.

57 ‘Problemi e lotte del popolo milanese’, Voce Comunista, Anno X no. 47, Thursday, 5 Dec 1956.

58 APC, MF 0443, 1697–2477.

59 Ibid.

60 Ibid. The translation is literal.

61 Ibid. 2285

62 APC, MF 0443, 1697–2477.

63 Ibid.

64 Ibid. 2365.

65 A leading Christian-Democratic thinker and politician, he was together with Amintore Fanfani and Giorgio La Pira, one of the most prominent members of the leftist and ‘social’ group inside the DC.

66 APC, MF 0444, 1776–1840, 1 June 1956.

67 Ibid.

68 ‘Riunione della Commissione Provinciale di Amministrazione della Federazione di Bologna – 26/6/1956’, APC, MF 0444, 1872.

69 Gozzini and Martinelli, Storia del PCI, 560–3.

70 APC, MF 0444, 2306–2374.

71 ‘Verbale Riunione di Comitato Federale tenuta il 27–8 Agosto 1956’, APC, MF 0444, 1996–2117.

72 APC, MF 0444, 2426–2450.

73 Ibid.

74 Ibid. 2472.

75 ‘La relazione del compagno Enrico Bonazzi’, La Lotta, Anno XIII, no. 48, Friday, 23 Nov. 1956 (Bologna), 4–5.

76 Ibid.

77 Edelman, Murray, ‘Causes of Fluctuations in Popular Support for the Italian Communist Party since 1946’, The Journal of Politics, 20, 3 (Aug. 1958), 535–52CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

78 ‘Unità di tutte le forze democratiche e socialiste nella lotta contro un ritorno alla guerra fredda’, La Lotta (Bologna), Anno XIII, no. 48, Friday, 23 Nov. 1956, 2–6.

79 APC, MF 0444, 2481–2527.

80 APC, MF 0445, 0706–0709.

81 Ibid. 0711–0712.

82 Ibid. 0735–0737.

83 Ibid.

84 APC, MF 0445, 0742–0871.

85 APC, MF 0445, 0742–0871.

86 Ibid.

87 Ibid. 0403–0409.

88 APC, MF 0445, 0403–0409.

89 Ibid.

90 Ibid. 0872–1201. Quotation from a militant.

91 Ibid. 1200.

92 APC, MF 0445, 0403–0409.

93 l’Unità, 13 July 1957.

94 Lomartire, Carlo Maria, O Comandante: Vita di Achille Lauro (Milan: Mondadori, 2009), 87–8Google Scholar, 106–7.

95 VIII Congresso del PCI: Atti e risoluzioni (Rome: Editori Riuniti, 1957).

96 Gozzini and Martinelli, Storia del PCI, 617.

97 Sebastiani, Chiara, Organi dirigenti nazionali: Composizione, meccanismi di formazione e di evoluzione, 1945–1979, in Accornero, Aris and Ilardi, Massimo, eds., Il Partito Comunista Italiano: Struttura e Storia dell’Organizzazione, 1921–1979 (Milan: Feltrinelli, 1982), 398Google Scholar, 429–30; Gozzini and Martinelli, Storia del PCI, 629.

98 Aga Rossi and Zaslavsky, Togliatti e Stalin, 262–6.