Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-8bhkd Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-06T08:30:08.478Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

A Profile of Thirteenth-Century Sainthood

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  03 June 2009

Michal Goodich
Michal Goodich
Affiliation:
The University of Haifa
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

Thus far, two quantitative studies of Catholic sainthood have been attempted. Altruistic Love by Pitirim Sorokin,1 which deals with the entire history of Christianity, established the patterns of saintly behavior over a two-thousand-year period. Although many of Sorokin's analytical categories are useful, his conclusions are rather broad and do not take sufficiently into account changing conditions in church history. His geographical subdivisions, for example, which are based upon the twentieth-century nation-state, are anachronistic when applied to a medieval context. No distinctions are made between the various genres of freeman, e.g., the old feudal aristocracy and the urban-dwelling nobility, although their interests were often in conflict. Nor does Sorokin consider the role of the papacy and the political crosscurrents-Guelph vs. Ghibelline, Englishman vs. Frenchman, heresy vs. orthodoxy-which determined the function of a saint's cult and the likelihood of his being venerated in any particular epoch. Frequently these saints became the objects of cults not so much because of their personal piety but rather as a result of their political activities, family connections, or membership in an aggressive religious order. Nor does Sorokin consider the many local saints, whose worship was restricted to one or several dioceses and who failed to gain international recognition. Such relatively obscure individuals, the sources of much local pride, were often the objects of more active and long-lasting cults than their well-known confreres.

Type
Sources of Religious Renewal
Information
Comparative Studies in Society and History , Volume 18 , Issue 4 , October 1976 , pp. 429 - 437
Copyright
Copyright © Society for the Comparative Study of Society and History 1976

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

I would like to thank Professor John H. Mundy of Columbia University for assisting me in the sometimes difficult task of defining and clarifying the terms of medieval social and professional classification. Without his considerable assistancethis paper would not have been possible.

1 Sorokin, Pitirim, Altruistic Love (Boston, 1950).Google Scholar

2 For a history of canonization, see Hertling, Ludwig, ′Materiali per la storia del processo di canonizzazione,′ Gregorianum, 16 (1935), 170–95;Google ScholarKuttner, Stephen, ′La reserve papale du droit de canonisation,′ Revue historique du droit français etéetrange, 4th ser., 17 (1938), 172–228;Google ScholarKemp, Eric Waldram, Canonization and Authority in the Western Church (London, 1948);Google ScholarDelahaye, Hippolyte, Sanctus(Brussels, 1927);Google ScholarBlaher, Damian Joseph, The Ordinary Processes in Causes of Beatification and Canonization, in The Catholic University of America Canon Law Studies, no. 268 (Washington, D.C., 1949);Google ScholarToynbee, Margaret R., S. Louis of Toulouse and the Process of Canonisation in the Fourteenth Century (Manchester, 1929).Google Scholar None of these works is completely thorough, considering the number of extant proceedings and Vitae. On present-day procedure, see Leclercq, C., inNaz, Raoul et al. , Traitée de droit canonique, 2nd rev. ed., 4 vols. (Paris, 1955), IV, 465–534.Google Scholar

3 His major source was Butler, Alban, The Lives of the Saints, ed. and rev.Thurston, Herbert and Attwater, Donald, 13 vols. (New York, 1938);Google Scholar also Attwater, Donald, The Lives of the Saints {Butler): First Supplementary Volume (London, 1949).Google Scholar

4 Delooz, Pierre, Sociologie et canonisations (Liége, 1969);Google Scholar cf. idem, ′Pour uneétude sociologique de la sainteté canonisée dans l'Éiglise catholique,′ Archives de sociologie des religions, 13 (1962), 17–43.Google Scholar For a discussion of his work, see Desroche, H., Vauchez, A., and Maîitre, J., ′Sociologie de saintetée canoniséee,′ Archivesde sociologie des religions, 30 (07–12, 1970), 109–15.Google Scholar Delooz relies largely upon Baudot, Jules, et al. , Les vies des saints et des bienheureux selon I'ordre du calendrier, 13 Vols. (Paris, 1935–1959).Google Scholar I have depended upon the monumental Socii Bollandiani, Ada sanctorum quotquot toto orbe coluntur…, new ed., 66 vols. to date (Paris, 1863–1940); this has been supplemented by source materials drawn from the Analecta Bollandiana (1881 to date) and the numerous other periodicals and primary works published under the auspices of the various Catholic religious orders. An excellent new biographical encyclopedia is Caraffa, Filippo, ed., Bibliotheca sanctorum, 12 vols. (Rome, 1961–1970).Google Scholar

5 Le Bras, Gabriel, Institutions éccléesiastiques de la Chrétienté mediévale, 2 pts.(Paris, 1959–1964) contains a thorough study of the structure and mores of the Church in this period.Google Scholar

6 See, e.g.,Moorman, John R. H., Church Life in England in the Thirteenth Century(Cambridge, 1955), 402 ff.Google Scholar

7 Friedberg, Emil and Richter, Lewis, eds., Corpus iuris canonici, 2 vols. (Leipzig, 1879), vol. II, X. III. 31. 7, 10, 18;Google ScholarJaffé, Philippe;, Regesta pontificum romanorum, 2 vols. (Leipzig, 1885–1888), 12447, 11866;Google ScholarPotthast, August, Regesta pontificum romanorum, 2 vols. (Berlin, 1874–1875), 2763 for canonical rules on this subject.Google Scholar

8 Allison, Joel, ′Religious Conversion: Regression and Progression in an Adolescent Experience,′ Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion, 8:1 (Spring 1969), 23–38;CrossRefGoogle ScholarStarbuck, Edwin D., The Psychology of Religion (London, 1899).Google Scholar

9 Cf. Gorlow, Leon and Schroeder, Harold E., ′Motives for Participation in the Religious Experience,′ Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion, 7:2 (1968),241–51.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

10 Sjöberg, Gideon, The Pre—Industrial City (Glencoe, 111., I960,, 109 ff.; J. Lestocquoy, Les villes de Flandre et d'ltalie sous le gouvernement des patriciens Xle–XJVe siècles) (Paris, 1952).Google Scholar

11 Guilhiermoz, P.,Essai sur l'origine.de la noblesse en France au moyen âge(Paris, 1902), 351 ff.Google Scholar

12 Ibid., 478.

13 Genicot, Léopold, L'Économie rurale namurois au Bas Moyen Âge (1199–1429), 2 vols. (Louvain, 1943–1960), I, 41.Google Scholar

14 Lestocquoy, op. cit., passim.

15 Guilhiermoz, , op. cit., 445.Google Scholar

16 Analecta Bollandiana, 27 (1908), 498–9;Google ScholarAda sanctorum, 13 04 II, 158–9; 16 June IV, 189–209.Google Scholar

17 A eta sanctorum, 19 04 II, 714 ff.Google Scholar

18 Lawrence, Clifford H., St. Edmund of Abingdon (Oxford, 1960), 108.Google Scholar

19 Luard, H. R., ′Robert Grosseteste,′ Dictionary of National Biography, VIII, 718–21.Google Scholar

20 The following is based largely on Cristiani, Emilio, Nobilità e popolo nel commune di Pisa (Naples, 1962);Google ScholarSayous, André—E., ′Les noblesses: aristocratie et noblesse à Gênes,′ Annales d'histoire economique et sociale, 9 (1937), 366–81;Google ScholarSalvemini, Gaetano, La dignità cavalleresca nel commune di Firenze (Florence, 1960).Google Scholar

21 Salvemini, passim, on the privileges of the Italian nobility.

22 For important thirteenth—century families, see Sayous, Andreé—E., ′Dans l'ltalieà l'interieure des terres: Sienne de 1221 à 1229,′ Annales d'histoire économique et sociale, 3 (1931), 189-206;CrossRefGoogle ScholarPetroni, Vittorio, Le antiche famiglie che ressero la repubblica e lo ′stato senese′ (Siena, 1949);Google ScholarSchneider, Fedor, ed., Regestum Senese(Rome, 1911);Google ScholarSpreti, Vittorio, et al. , Enciclopedia storico-nbbiliare italiano, 7 vols.(Milan, 1928–1935), passim.Google Scholar

23 Petroni, 10; Schneider, xciii.

24 Spreti, VI, 618–23;Google Scholar Petroni, 10; Lestocquoy, 49; Ada sanctorum, 27 04 IV, 464–87.Google Scholar

25 Schneider, , lxxxix;Google ScholarBigwood, Georges, Les livres des comptes des Gallerani, Grunzweig, Armand, ed. and rev., 2 vols. (Brussels, 1961–1962), I, 25 ff.;Google ScholarAda sanctorum, 19 03 III, 49 ff.Google Scholar

26 Spreti, , V, 325–38;Google Scholar Petroni, 10; Soulier, P. M., ′Vita ac legenda Ioachimi Senensisordinis servorum sanctae Mariae virginis,′ Analecta Bollandiana, 13 (1894),386–7;CrossRefGoogle ScholarAda sanctorum, 6 05 II, 121–2Google Scholar on two lesser-known Piccolomini saints.

27 Spreti, , V, 308–9;Google Scholar Petroni, 12; Ada sanctorum, 30 04 III, 841–5;Google ScholarAnalectaBollandiana, 14 (1895), 166–97.Google Scholar

28 Ada sanctorum, 26 04 III, 468–72;Google ScholarSchneider, xciii.Google Scholar

29 Petroni, 13; Saggi, L., ′Franco Lippi da Siena,′ Bibliotheca sanctorum, V, 1252–3.Google Scholar

30 Spreti, , V, 525–30.Google Scholar

31 Ada sanctorum, 20 04 II, 791 ff.; 22 April III, 302 ff.Google Scholar

32 Hallack, Cecily and Anson, Peter, These Made Peace (Paterson, N.J., 1957),2–9.Google Scholar

33 Ibid., 31–4.

34 Ada sanctorum, 12 03 II, 237.Google Scholar

35 Cristofani, F., ′Memorie del B. Pietro Pettignano,′ Miscellanea francescana,5 (1890), 34–52.Google Scholar

36 Naz, Raoul, ′Martyre,′ in Didionnaire de droit canonique, 7 vols. (Paris,1924–1965), VI, 837–71 for the canon law dealing with martyrdom.Google Scholar

37 Fortini, Arnaldo, Nova vita di San Francesco, 4 vols. (Assisi, 1950), II, 273 ff., 315 ff. for the early sainted followers of Francis and Clare.Google Scholar