Article contents
Minority Situation and Religious Acculturation: a Comparative Analysis of Jewish Communities
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 03 June 2009
Extract
The need for comparative studies of Jewish communities has occasionally been argued, but apart from largely typological comparisons of Jewish polities, there have been few, if any, attempts at a sociological comparative study of Jewish communities. Nearly all the sociological studies of Judaism have restricted their analysis to the Jewish community in the United States, and it is possible that their findings possess little generality beyond that society.
- Type
- Minority Acculturation Problems
- Information
- Copyright
- Copyright © Society for the Comparative Study of Society and History 1974
References
1 Elazer, Daniel J., ‘The Reconstruction of Jewish Communities in the Post-War Period’ Jewish Journal of Sociology, 11 (1969), 187–226.Google Scholar
2 Sklare, Marshall, Conservative Judaism, Glencoe, III, 1955;Google ScholarGlazer, Nathan, American Judaism, Chicago, 1957.Google Scholar
3 Lipset, S. M., ‘The Study of Jewish Communities in a Comparative Context’, Jewish Journal of Sociology, 5 (1963), 157–66.Google Scholar
4 Gordon, Milton M., Assimilation in American Life (New York, 1964), 79.Google Scholar
5 For a discussion of the distinction between acculturation and assimilation and of the assimilation variables see Gordon, ibid., chap. 3.
6 For a discussion of the comparative method see Smelser, Neil J., Essays in Sociological Explanation, Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey, 1968, chap. 3.Google ScholarEtzioni, Amitai and Dubow, Fredric L., Comparative Perspectives, Boston, 1970.Google ScholarMarsh, Robert M., Comparative Sociology, New York, 1967.Google Scholar
7 After the Temple of Solomon was destroyed and Judea captured by the Babylonians in 586 B.C, the major part of the population in Israel, was exiled to Babylonia while some fled to Egypt. From that period only a minority of the Jewish people continued to live in Israel.
8 Leslie, D. D., ‘The Kaifeng Jewish Community’, Jewish Journal of Sociology, 11 (1969), 175–85.Google Scholar Since writing this paper, the definitive book on Chinese Jews has appeared: Leslie, Donald Daniel, The Survival of the Chinese Jews; the Jewish Community of Kaifeng, Leiden, 1972.Google Scholar
9 Strizower, Schifra, Exotic Jewish Communities, London, 1962Google Scholar, chap. 3. Mandel-baum, David G., ‘The Jewish Way of Life in Cochin’, Jewish Social Studies, 1 (1939), 423–60.Google Scholar
10 Strizower, Schifra, The Children of Israel: the Bene Israel of Bombay, Oxford, 1971.Google Scholar The Bene Israel claim that they are descendants from the ten lost tribes of Israel and that they reached India about 175 B.C. The Cochin Jews claim that their ancestors came to India after the destruction of the Second Temple in A.D. 70. There is no independent evidence to support these claims. Although it is possible that there were Jewish communities in India as early as the fifth century A.D., the only certainty is that Jews had settled in India before the end of the first millennium after Christ.
11 Chouraqui, Andre N., Between East and West (Philadelphia, 1968), chap. 7.Google Scholar
12 Goitein, S. D., Jews and Arabs (New York, 1955), chap. 6.Google Scholar
13 Numerically Babylon was an important centre of Jewry from the destruction of the Temple of Solomon. Scholars have argued that the pure form of Jewish monotheism developed in the Babylonian exile.
14 Baron, S. W., A Social and Religious History of the Jews, New York, 1952–1969, vol. 2, chap. 13, vol. 5, chap. 23, vol. 6, chap. 27.Google Scholar
15 Ibid., vol. 6, chap. 27. Goitein, , op. clt., chaps. 1, 3, 7.Google Scholar
16 Baron, , op. cit., vol. 3, chap. 17.Google Scholar
17 Most Middle Eastern Jews spoke Aramaic before they adopted Arabic, but only in the mountains of Kurdistan and Armenia did Jews retain the Aramaic dialect, Goitein, , op. cit., chap. 7.Google Scholar
18 A number of Middle Eastern Jewish communities developed Judeo-Arabic vernaculars, but they contained far less Hebrew than Yiddish, the language of the Ashkenazi European Jews. Another difference was that Yiddish, a fusion of medieval German and Hebrew, was transplanted from Germany and preserved in an area, eastern Europe, entirely foreign to it.
19 Goitein, op. cit. Chouraqui, op. cit., chap. 6. Voinot, L., Pélérinages judeo-musulmans du Maroc, Paris, 1948.Google Scholar
20 Chouraqui, , op. cit.Google Scholar, Goitein, , op. cit.Google Scholar
21 Slouschz, Nahum, Travels in North Africa, Philadelphia, 1927.Google Scholar
22 Goitein, , op. cit.Google Scholar
23 Goitein, S. D., ‘Jewish Education in Yemen as an Archetype of Traditional Jewish Education’ in Frankenstein, (ed.), Between Past and Future, Jerusalem, 1953.Google Scholar
24 Feitelson, Dina, ‘Aspects of the Social Life of Kurdish Jews’, Jewish Journal of Sociology, 1 (1959), 201–16.Google Scholar
25 Briggs, L. C. & Guele, N. L., No More for Ever: A Saharan Jewish Town, Cambridge, Mass., 1964.Google Scholar
26 White, W. C., Chinese Jews: A Compilation of Matters Relating to the Jews of Kaifeng Fu, 3 vols. (Toronto, 1942Google Scholar). Leslie, , op. cit.Google Scholar
27 Mandelbaum, , op. cit.Google Scholar, Strizower, , Exotic Jewish Communities, op. cit.Google Scholar
28 Strizower, , The Children of Israel, op. cit.Google Scholar
29 Zimmels, H. J., Ashkenazim and Sephardim (London, 1958), pt. 2, chap. 7.Google Scholar
30 Katz, Jacob, Tradition and Crisis: Jewish Society at the End of the Middle Ages, New York, 1961.Google ScholarZborowski, Mark and Herzog, Elizabeth, Life is with People: the Culture of the Shtetl, New York, 1962.Google Scholar
31 Trachtenberg, Joshua, Jewish Magic and Superstition, Philadelphia, 1961.Google Scholar
32 Zimmels, , op. clt., pt. 2, chaps. 7, 10.Google Scholar
33 Coulborn, Rushton, ‘The State and Religion: Iran, India and China’, Comparative Studies in Society and History, 1 (1958–1959), 44–57.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
34 Weber, Max, The Religion of China (New York, 1964), 213–14.Google Scholar
35 Balazs, Etienne, Chinese Civilization and Bureaucracy, New Haven, 1964, 22.Google Scholar
36 White, , op. cit.Google ScholarLeslie, , op. cit.Google Scholar
37 Balazs, , op. cit., 41–2, 70–8.Google Scholar
38 Weber, Max, The Religion of India, New York, 1958, 9–29.Google Scholar
39 Srinivas, M. N., Religion and Society Among the Coorgs of South India (Oxford, 1952), 31–2.Google Scholar
40 Coulborn, , op. cit.Google Scholar
41 Bendix, Reinhard, Nation-Building and Citizenship (New York, 1969), 257–75.Google Scholar
42 Von-Grunebaun, Gustave E., Medieval Islam, Chicago, 1946.CrossRefGoogle ScholarWatt, W. Montgomery, Islam and the Integration of Society, London, 1961.CrossRefGoogle ScholarLevy, Reuben, The Social Structure of Islam, Cambridge, 1957.Google Scholar
43 Baron, , op. cit., vol. 3, chap. 18.Google Scholar
44 Goitein, , Jews and Arabs, op. cit., chap. 5.Google Scholar
45 Baron, , op. cit.Google ScholarChouraqui, , op. cit., chap. 5.Google Scholar
46 Goitein, , op. cit.Google Scholar Section on ‘Yemen’ in Encyclopaedia Judaica, Jerusalem, 1971.Google Scholar
47 Goitein, , op. cit., chap. 6.Google Scholar
48 Hirschberg, H. Z., ‘The Jewish Quarter in Muslim Cities and Berber Areas’, Judaism, 17 (1968), 405–21.Google Scholar
49 Cahnman, Werner J., ‘Religion and Nationality’, American Journal of Sociology, XLIX (1944), 524–29.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
50 Feitelson, , op. cit.Google Scholar
51 Briggs, and Guele, , op. cit.Google Scholar
52 Baron, , op. cit., vol. 4, chap. 20, vol. 9, chap. 37.Google Scholar
53 Ibid., vol. 4., chap. 21, vol. 10, chap. 49. Foliakov, Leon, The History of Anti-Semitism: From the Time of Christ to the Court Jews, London, 1965.Google ScholarTrachtenberg, Joshua, The Devil and the Jews, New York, 1961.Google Scholar
54 Baron, , op. cit., vol. 4, chap. 20, vol. 9, chaps. 37, 38, vol. 11, chap. 48.Google Scholar
55 Ibid., vol. 9, chaps, 40, 41, vol. 11, chap. 47.
56 Ibid., vol. 10, chap. 43, vol. 11, chap. 50.
57 Ibid., vol. 6, chap. 22, vol. 12, chaps. 51, 52, 53.
58 Ibid., vol. 10, chap. 24.
59 Zborowski, and Herzog, , op. cit.Google ScholarBaron, S. W., The Russian Jews Under the Tsars and the Soviets, New York, 1964.Google Scholar
60 Katz, , op. cit.Google Scholar, chap. 13.Dublow, S. M., History of the Jews in Russia and Poland, Phila delphia, 1920.Google Scholar
61 Baron, , Social and Religious History, op. cit., vol. 3, chap. 16, vol. 4, chap. 20, vol. 10, chap. 44, vol. 11, chap. 50, vol. 13, chaps. 55, 56.Google Scholar
62 Baer, Yitzhah, A History of the Jews in Christian Spain, Philadelphia, 1961.Google Scholar
63 Zimmels, , op. cit., pt. 2, chap. 8.Google Scholar
64 Ibid., pt. 2, chaps. 9, 10.
- 6
- Cited by