Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-r5fsc Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-26T07:05:21.509Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Free Market Metaphor: The Historical Dynamics of Stamp Collecting

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  03 June 2009

Steven M. Gelber
Steven M. Gelber
Affiliation:
Santa Clara University
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

Stamp collecting and industrial capitalism in the United States emerged simultaneously in the mid-nineteenth century. England issued the first government postage stamp in 1840, and other nations quickly adopted the idea. The United States printed its first official stamp in 1847, although it was preceded by the provisionals issued by local postmasters. Postage stamps were a product of the industrial revolution. The adoption of the prepaid penny post in England, while opposed by the General Post Office, was widely supported by large merchants who understood that a low-cost, single-rate system was vital to the communication demanded by an increasingly national market. The adhesive label was originally conceived by the English postal reformer, Rowland Hill, as a convenience for illiterates who would not be able to write addresses on the official envelopes that he preferred as proof of prepayment. Within a decade, almost every major nation in the world had borrowed this device, which became a symbol of the economic transformation of the nineteenth century. I would argue that the collecting of these tokens was a microcosmic performance of the system that created them. Stamp collectors took on many of the key roles of actors in the market economy and played out various conflicts embodied in the larger society in the philatelic arena.

Type
The Political Economy of Leisure
Information
Comparative Studies in Society and History , Volume 34 , Issue 4 , October 1992 , pp. 742 - 769
Copyright
Copyright © Society for the Comparative Study of Society and History 1992

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Hallgren, Mauritz, All About Stamps: Their History and the Art of Collecting Them (New York: Alfred A. Knopf, 1940), 55, 59.Google Scholar

2 For a discussion of the English and European beginnings of the postage stamp, see Briggs, Asa, Victorian Things (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1988), 327–48;Google Scholar Hallgren, All About Stamps, 54–59.

3 “Will It Last?,” The Stamp Collector's Guide, 1 (04 1871), 18;Google Scholar Hallgren estimates there were almost three hundred such papers started between 1870 and 1890 (Hallgren, All About Stamps, 188).

4 This distinction between preoccupation and leisure activity is not recognized by the Oxford English Dictionary but is quite clear in the historical record, see The Compact Edition of the Oxford English Dictionary, vol. 1 (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1971), 1314.Google Scholar

5 Phillips, Charles James, Stamp Collecting: The King of Hobbies and the Hobby of Kings (New York: H.L. Lindquist, 1936), 11–12;Google Scholar see also, Briggs, Victorian Things, 349.

6 McKibbin, Ross, “Work and Hobbies in Britain, 1880–1950,” in The Working Class in Modern British History: Essays in Honour of Henry Pelling, Winter, Jay, ed. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1983), 142–5.Google Scholar

7 For a summary of the state of the debate, see Banner, David K., “Towards a Theoretical Clarification of the ‘Spillover’ and ‘Compensatory’ Work/Leisure Hypotheses,” Omega: The International Journal of Management Science, 13:1 (1985), 13–18;CrossRefGoogle ScholarMannell, Roger C. and Iso-Ahola, Seppo E., “Work Constraints on Leisure: A Social Psychological Analysis,” in Constraints on Leisure, Wade, Michael G., ed. (Springfield, Ill.: Charles C. Thomas, 1985), 155–87.Google Scholar

8 Gelber, Steven M., “A Job You Can't Lose: Work and Hobbies in the Great Depression,” Journal of Social History, 24 (06 1991), 507–33.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

9 Geertz, Clifford, The Interpretation of Cultures (New York: Basic Books, 1973), 412–53.Google Scholar

10 McKibbin, “Work and Hobbies in Britain,” 127–46.

11 Mueller, Barbara R., Common Sense Philately (Princeton, N.J.: D. Van Nostrand, 1956), 4.Google Scholar

12 Harlow, Alvin F., Paper Chase: The Amenities of Stamp Collecting (New York: Henry Holt and Company, 1940), 15–16.Google Scholar

13 Phillips, Charles J., Fifty Years of Philately: The History of Stanley Gibbons, Ltd. (London: Stanley Gibbons, 1906), 194.Google Scholar

14 Harlow, Paper Chase, 18, 25.

15 For Germany, see Schenk, Gustav, The Romance of the Postage Stamp (Garden City, N.Y.: Doubleday and Company, 1959), 146–7.Google Scholar

16 Briggs, Victorian Things, 350–1; Christ, Edwin, “The Adult Stamp Collector” (Ph.D. disser., Department of Sociology, University of Missouri, 1957), 4–6.Google Scholar

17 “Will It Last?,” The Stamp Collector's Guide, 18.

18 Philo., “Philatelic Societies,” The Stamp, 1 (02 1887), 8;Google Scholar see also, Harlow, Paper Chase, 46–47.

19 Jay, Robert, The Trade Card in Nineteenth–Century America (Columbia, Mo.: University of Missouri Press, 1987).Google Scholar

20 Burk, Caroline Frear, “The Collecting Instinct,” Pedagogical Seminary, 1 (01 1900), 193–4.Google Scholar

21 Barth, Gunther, City People: The Rise of Modern City Culture in Nineteenth Century America (New York: Oxford University Press, 1980), 110–49.Google Scholar

22 Gruber Garvey, Ellen, “Commercial Fiction: Intersection Between Advertising and Fiction in American Magazines, 1893–1913” (Ph.D. disser, Department of English, University of Pennsylvania, draft), 5.Google Scholar

23 Ibid., 3.

24 Ibid., 13, 23, 28.

25 “Editorial: The Ladies' Number,” The Pennsylvania Philatelist, 6 (06 1894), 341.Google Scholar

26 Quackenbush, Lewis G., “The Ladies—A Philatelic Toast,” The Pennsylvania Philatelist, 6 (06 1894), 331.Google Scholar

27 Idem.; see also, Briggs, Victorian Things, 354.

28 Keene, Mame A., “A Plea for the Ladies—Second Paper,” The Pennsylvania Philatelist, 4 12 1893), 20.Google Scholar

29 Keene, Mame A., “The Silent Collector,” The Pennsylvania Philatelist, 6 (06 1894), 340.Google Scholar

30 Charlotte Bingham, Maud, “My Stamp Album,” The Pennsylvania Philatelist, 6 (06 1894), 334.Google Scholar

31 Keene, “The Silent Collector,” 339; see also, Harlow, Paper Chase, 44.

32 Kehr, Ernest A., The Romance of Stamp Collecting: Notes From the World of Stamps, Stamp Collecting and Stamp Collectors (New York: Thomas Y. Crowell, 1947), 282;Google Scholar Mueller, Common Sense Philately, 123.

33 Schlosser, Esther, “Women and Philately,” Hobbies, 36 (09 1931), 50;Google Scholar see also, Mueller, Common Sense Philately, 124.

34 Harlow, Paper Chase, 2–3.

35 See for example, Phillips, Fifty Years of Philately, 183.

36 Hallgren, All About Stamps, 8–9; see also, MacGuffin, R.D., Stamps As an Investment Narberth, Pa.: R.D. MacGuffin, 1926), 7.Google Scholar

37 Hallgren, All About Stamps, 10.

38 Murray, Lillie H., “Women and Philately,” The American Collector, 2 (03 1897), 70.Google Scholar

39 Quackenbush, Lewis G., “Philately as a Means of Education,” The Southern Philatelist, 3 (11 1891), 40–41.Google Scholar Cundinamarca is a province in central Colombia and Nowanugger was a principality in nineteenth–century India. See also Phillips, Stamp Collecting, 18.

40 Super, Donald E. and Carlson, Ralph L., “What Adolescent and Adult Stamp Collectors Learn From Their Avocation,” Journal of Genetic Psychology, 60 (1942), 99–108;Google Scholar for some examples of educational benefits claims, see Furse, G.A., “Philately in England,” The Sunday Journal [Providence, Rhode Island] (11 19, 1893), 10;Google Scholar“Everyday Movies” [cartoon], Scott's Monthly Journal, 1 (02 1921), 1;Google Scholar Phillips, Stamp Collecting, 14; “The Stamp Collectors” [editorial], reprinted from the Tacoma (Washington) Ledger, n.d., in Hobbies 39 (06 1934), 41;Google ScholarNew York Times (April 22, 1934), Section II; Frank Clark, W., “The Children of Today Are the Men and Women of Tomorrow,” Hobbies, 36 (06 1931), 51.Google Scholar

41 “Stamp Collecting,” The Stamp Collector's Guide, 1 (09 1871), 29;Google Scholar see also, “The Moral Factor in Philately,” The Southern Philatelist, 7 (02 1896), 19–20;Google ScholarFlint, Dick, “An Autobiography,” The Southern Philatelist, 2 (07 1891), 169–79;Google ScholarGreen, Guy W., “The Philatelic Kindergarten,” The Eastern Philatelist, 12 (10 1893), 21;Google Scholar Phillips, Fifty Years of Philately, 181.

42 Nose, Blue, “Philately's Benefits,” The Eastern Philatelist, 9 (04 1892), 36.Google Scholar

43 Thompson, R.L., “The Freemasonry of Philately,” The Eastern Philatelist, 14 (01 1895), 105;Google Scholar see also, Christ, “Adult Stamp Collector,” 226–7, 243–4.

44 Thompson, “Freemasonry,” 105.

45 For a discussion of the democracy of hobbies, see Gelber, “A Job You Can't Lose,” 513.

46 Lewis G. Quackenbush, “The Ladies—A Philatelic Toast,” 331; Mame A. Keene, “A Plea for the Ladies,” 20, 102.

47 Christ, “Adult Stamp Collector,” 90–96.

48 McDermott, D.J., “She Stoops to Conquer,” The Pennsylvania Philatelist, 6 (06 1894), 338;Google Scholar see also Mott, Luther W., “Phair Philatelists,” The Pennsylvania Philatelist, 6 (06 1894), 361–2;Google ScholarGreene, Roy F., “The Charms of Annabel,” The Pennsylvania Philatelist, 6 (07 1894), 330;Google ScholarBlake, William, “A Philatelic Romance,” The Collector's Journal, 10 (04 1920), 11–14.Google Scholar

49 See, for example, Green, Guy W., “How He Became a Collector,” The Southern Philatelist, 2 (08 1891), 188;Google ScholarGreen, Guy W., “A New Social Factor,” The Eastern Philatelist, 7 (06 1891), 53;Google ScholarKissinger, Clifford W., “The Fair Sex in Philately,” The Pennsylvania Philatelist, 5 01 1894), 173.Google Scholar

50 Mott, “Phair Philatelists,” 361.

51 Earl, Eva, “Give the Girls a Chance,” The Pennsylvania Philatelist, 4 (11 1893),126.Google Scholar

52 Charles Haviland Mekeel, ed., The Philatelic Journal of America, 8 (05 1892),Google Scholar cover; Ibid. (June 1892), cover; see also, Christ, “Adult Stamp Collector,” 193.

53 Mame A. Keene, “The Silent Collector,” 339.

54 Matson, Charlotte, “Minneapolis Women's Philatelic Society,” Hobbies, 44 (05 1939), 66–67.Google Scholar

55 “The Poetry of Philately,” The American Journal of Philately, 2 (09 20, 1869), 104.Google Scholar

56 Earl, Eva, “A Girl's Philatelic Reminiscence,” The Pennsylvania Philatelist, 5 (02 1894), 207;Google ScholarEarl, Eva, “A Female Philatelist,” The Southern Philatelist, 5 (01 1894), 10.Google Scholar

57 Iola, ., “The Postage Stamp Fiend,” The Pennsylvania Philatelist, 11 (03 1897), 158;Google Scholar see also Hallgren, All About Stamps, 7.

58 “A Plea for Philately and Philatelists,” The New Jersey Philatelist, 1 (03–04 1880), 1.Google Scholar

59 Philo., “Philatelic Societies,” 9.

60 Scott, Cleve, “My Experience With a Public Crank,” The Southern Philatelist, 4 (01 1893), 9;Google Scholar see also, Christ, “Adult Stamp Collector,” 119.

61 Furse, “Philately in England,” 10; Hallgren, All About Stamps, 181.

62 Williams, L.N. and Williams, M., The Postage Stamp: Its History and Recognition (Hamondsworth: Penguin Books, 1956), 66–67.Google Scholar

63 Philo., , “What is Philately?” The Stamp, 1 (06 1887), 47,Google Scholar emphasis added.

64 Philo., , “The Bluffton Stamp Collectors' Society,” The Stamp World, 6 (03 1886), 65;Google Scholar an English woman who wrote about scientific stamp collecting in the 1860s thought it prudent to use a male pseudonym (Williams, The Postage Stamp, 56).

65 See, for example “Editorial,” The Empire State Philatelist (12 5, 1886), 92.Google Scholar

66 “Are We Going Too Far?,” The Post Office, 1 (09 15, 1891), 53.Google Scholar

67 Earee, R.B., “Our Hobby,” The Stamp World, 3 (12 1882), 105.Google Scholar

68 Horan, Joseph C., “Philatelists Should Have a Hobby,” Recreation, 47 (09 1954), 407.Google Scholar

69 Earl, Eva, “A Lady's Experience,” The Pennsylvania Philatelist, 6 (06 1894), 337.Google Scholar

70 For a discussion of doctoring stamps, see Hallgren, All About Stamps, 314–20.

71 Christ, “Adult Stamp Collector,” 204, 239.

72 Phillips, Fifty Years of Philately, 191.

73 Phillips, Stamp Collecting, 16; see also, “Avocations: Timely News and Comments,” Avocations, 1 (10 1937), 9.Google Scholar

74 Witty, Paul A. and Lehman, Harvey C., “Further Studies of Children's Interest in Collecting,” Journal of Educational Psychology, 21 (1930), 112–5.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

75 “Stamp Collecting,” The Nation, 97 (11 6, 1913), 430.Google Scholar

76 Gelber, “A Job You Can't Lose.”

77 Emerson, Walter N., “Tendencies Toward Sanity,” Hobbies, 42 (03 1937), 33–34;Google Scholar Melville, Stamp Collecting, 19.

78 Harlow, Paper Chase, 24.

79 Williams, The Postage Stamp, 75.

80 Hallgren, All About Stamps, 191, 290–4.

81 Schenk, The Romance of the Postage Stamp, 152.

82 Christ calls economically motivated collectors “prospectors” and contrasts them with “homesteaders” who adopt stamp collecting as their social world and “exploiters” who are looking for some ulterior benefit (“Adult Stamp Collector,” 223–31).

83 Flint, “An Autobiography,” 165–7.

84 See, for examples, Cohen, I.B., “How I Became A Collector,” The Southern Philatelist, 1 (05 1890), 74–75;Google Scholar“A Schoolboy's Collection,” The American Journal of Philately, 1 (10 29, 1870), 69;Google ScholarLewis, Wilmarth S., Collector's Progress (New York: Alfred A. Knopf, 1951), 5.Google Scholar

85 Harlow, Paper Chase, 41–42.

86 Green, “Philatelic Kindergarten,” 21.

87 See, for example, Jullian, Philippe, The Collectors (Rutland, Vt.: Charles E. Tuttle, 1967), 31,Google Scholar 170; Hallgren, All About Stamps, 180.

88 Sydney J. Eisenberg, “A Strange ‘Change,” reprinted in “Poetry of Philately,” 105.

89 Philo., “Bluffton Stamp Collectors,” 65; see also Philo., “Philatelic Societies,” 9.

90 Phillips, Stamp Collecting, 19.

91 Longnecker, J.W., “Why I Collect Stamps,” Avocations, 1 (12 1937), 280–1;Google Scholar see also, Ellis, Henry M., How to Gain Pleasure and Profit From Stamp Collecting (New York: Funk and Wagnalls, 1947), 177;Google ScholarSutton, R.J., Stamps Are Money (London; Stanley Paul, 1959), 10;Google Scholar Phillips, Fifty Years of Philately, 191–2; “Moral Factor in Philately,” 20.

92 Belcher, H.B., “It Pays,” The Eastern Philatelist, 7 (01 1891), 55.Google Scholar

93 Iron, M., “The Philatelic Scarecrow,” The American Collector, 4 (07 1898), 84–5.Google Scholar

94 Hallgren, All About Stamps, 281.

95 Ibid., 296–9; Shawen, Lena, A President's Hobby (New York: H. L. Lindquist, 1949);Google Scholar see also Kehr, The Romance of Stamp Collecting, 58–74; Harlow, Paper Chase, 327; and for blatant market manipulation by governments, see Ibid., 182–93.

96 Cox, A.D., “Good As Wheat,” The American Collector, 4 (07 1898), 83.Google Scholar

97 Penne, Steele, “Philatelic Missionary Work,” The Eastern Philatelist, 14 (11 1894), 44.Google Scholar

98 Wright, James L., “Ten Cents Grows into $10,000,” The Nation's Business, reprinted in Hobbies, 36 (09 1931), 33.Google Scholar

99 Hallgren, All About Stamps, 25–55; Kehr, The Romance of Stamp Collecting, 193–5; Harlow, Paper Chase, 168–79; Williams, The Postage Stamp, 69–73.

100 See, for example, Blackman, M.J., “Big Moments,” Hobbies, 38 (06 1933), 44–45;Google Scholar for additional examples, see Townsend, A.C., “Call a Junk Man,” Hobbies, 40 (08 1935), 48–50;Google ScholarTownsend, A.C., “Consequences,” Hobbies, 41 (05 1936), 45–47;Google ScholarBurks, Paul Dore, Fireside Yarns—1001 Nights: Reminiscences of an Old Coin Man (Los Angeles; Privately printed, 1932), 14–25;Google ScholarTaussig, Charles W. and Meyer, Theodore A., The Book of Hobbies (New York; Minton, Balch and Co., 1924), 87;Google Scholar Harlow, Paper Chase, 162–6; but for stories of true treasure finds, see Robie, Lewis, Stamp Hunting (Chicago: Donohue Henneberry, 1898), 80–83.Google Scholar

101 “The Philatelic Liar,” The Perforator, 1 (03 1897), 1.Google Scholar

102 Ford, Margaret, “Philately,” The Southern Philatelist, 4 (05 1893), 77–82.Google Scholar

103 Clarence Nagley, Lester, “On Account of Jefferson D.,” The Stamp Herald, 2 (03 1918) 200.Google Scholar

104 For a story in which stamps were literally a buried treasure, see Stylus, , “The Hodgson Treasure,” The Collectors' Journal of Chicago, 6 (01 1916), 212–6.Google Scholar

015 Christ, “Adult Stamp Collector,” 238.

106 O'Donnell, Jack, “Hobby of Kids and Kings,” The Saturday Evening Post, 198 (11 14, 1925), 158.Google Scholar

107 Ibid.21ff.

108 “Moral Factor in Philately,” The Southern Philatelist, 7 (02 1896), 20;Google Scholar see also, Christ, “Adult Stamp Collector,” 220.

109 Hill, Edwin B., “A Mender of Stamps,” The Collectors' Journal of Chicago, 6 (12 1915), 77–178.Google Scholar

110 Croy, Homer, “Trinidad Triangle,” in The Boy Scouts Book of Indoor Hobby Trails, Mathiews, Franklin K., ed. (New York: D. Appleton-Century, 1939), 227–38.Google Scholar

111 Kehr, The Romance of Stamp Collecting, 40–41; Harlow, Paper Chase, 28; see also, Hallgren, All About Stamps, 183–4.

112 Ibid., 282–3.

113 Wilson, John M.H., “Fair Dealing,” [1928], reprinted in Ray, Leslie R. and Rogers-Tillstone, B., eds., Background to Philately: An Anthology of Papers Read at the Philatelic Congresses of Great Britain (London: Blandford Press, 1953), 76.Google Scholar

114 Cox, A.D., “A Committee of One,” The American Collector, 4 (03 1898), 19–20.Google Scholar

115 Townsend, A.C., “Diplomatic Entry,” Hobbies, 39 (12 1934), 30–31.Google Scholar

116 Hill, Edwin B., “In the Old ‘Oppen’,” The Collectors' Journal, 10 (08 1919), 6–7;Google Scholar see also Burkes, Fireside Yarns, 18–25; and two short stories by A. C. Townsend in which stamp collectors profit from knowledge and luck (Townsend, “Call a Junk Man,” 48–50; and Townsend, “Consequences,” 45–47).