The rate of dissolution of synthetic Al-goethites with 0–10 mole% Al in 6 m HCl at 24°C decreases markedly with increasing extent of Al substitution. Most of the dissolution-time curves are S-shaped, suggesting some increase in surface area during the initial stages of dissolution. Based on electron microscopic examination, the increase in surface area is explained by preferential dissolution of less ordered ‘interdomainic’ zones and the consequent production of isolated ‘domains’. Thin sections of crystals provided some support for defect zones oriented parallel to the crystallographic c-direction. Stepwise multiple correlation analysis employing various properties of the goethites was used to investigate the large variation in half-dissolution time (1–96 h). 94% of the variation could be explained by the variation of the mean crystallite dimension perpendicular to the planes (110) and (111) (MCD110, MCD111). Inclusion of Al-substitution increased R2 to only 97%. As shown in a separate experiment, increasing Al concentration in the system retarded crystal growth. It is therefore believed that Al affects the dissolution rate of goethites not directly, but indirectly, by influencing crystal growth rate which, in turn, affects crystal size and order as measured by MCD110 and MCD111.