Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-94fs2 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-19T08:36:15.321Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

How to avoid being a komodoumenos1

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  11 February 2009

Alan. H. Sommerstein
Alan. H. Sommerstein
Affiliation:
University of Nottingham
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

This paper is based on two separate, though partly overlapping, registers (Registers I and II) of male Athenian citizens known to have been in the public eye between theyears 432/1 and 405/4 B.C., inclusive. Register I comprises those who are known inthis period to have held important elective public office, or to have proposed andcarried resolutions in the Assembly; a total of 176 persons. These are singled out fromthe much wider range of ‘officials’, most of them chosen by lot, to be found in theprosopography of Develin 1989, because they are those who actively, and in somemeasure successfully, competed for the political favour of the Athenian public. Theimportant elective public offices I take to be those of general, proboulos (in 413–411), member of any embassy, and delegate for swearing to an international treaty. Register II comprises those who are known in this period to have been referred to asindividuals in Athenian comedies; a total of 224 persons. Both lists inevitably havesomewhat fuzzy edges, mainly over questions of identification and dating; doubtfulcases are briefly discussed in the notes to the Registers. Probably no other scholar willagree with every one of my decisions in these matters, but the general validity of thepicture here presented is unlikely to be affected. Within Register II can be identifiedtwo small but important subgroups: those who are referred to not, as is normal, fordisparagement but for praise; and those to whom is devoted an entire play or a largepart of one. I will be returning to these.

Type
Research Article
Information
The Classical Quarterly , Volume 46 , Issue 2 , December 1996 , pp. 327 - 356
Copyright
Copyright © The Classical Association 1996

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Borthwick, E. K., 1994: ‘New interpretations of Aristophanes, Frogs 1249–1328‘, Phoenix 48:21–41Google Scholar
Bowie, A. M., 1993: ritual and comedy (Cambridge)Google Scholar
Bremer, J. M., and Handley, E. W., (edd.), 1993: Aristophane (Vandoeuvres/Geneva: Fondation Hardt)Google Scholar
Carawan, E. M., 1990: ‘The five talents Cleon coughed up (schol. Ar. Ach. 6)’, CQ 40: 137–47CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Carey, C, 1994: ‘Comic ridicule and democracy’, in Osborne&Hornblower 1994: 69–83Google Scholar
Chambers, M. H., et al, 1990: ‘Athens' alliance with Egesta in the year of Antiphon’, ZPES 3: 38–63Google Scholar
Chambers, M. H., 1993:‘The archon’s name in the Athens–Egesta alliance (IGi311)‘, ZPES 9: 171–4Google Scholar
Christensen, K. A., 1988: ‘The Theseion: a slave refuge at Athens’, AJAH 9 [dated 1984]: 23–32Google Scholar
Corsini, E., (ed.) 1988: La polis e il suo teatro vol. 2 (Padova)Google Scholar
Daiches, D., and Thorlby, A. (edd.) 1972. The classical world (London)Google Scholar
Davidson, J., 1993: ‘Fish, sex and revolution in Athens’, CQ 43: 53–66CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Davies, J. K., 1971: Athenian propertied families 600–300 B.C. (Oxford)Google Scholar
Degani, E., 1988: ‘Giambo e commedia’, in Corsini 1988: 157–79Google Scholar
Degani, E., 1993: ‘Aristofane e la tradizione dell’invettiva personate in Grecia‘, in Bremer.Handley 1993: 1–49Google Scholar
DelCorno, D., 1985: Aristofane: Le Rane (Milan)Google Scholar
De Martino, F., and Sommerstein, A. H., (edd.) 1995. Lo spettacolo delle voci (Bari)Google Scholar
de Ste Croix, G. E. M., 1972: The origins of the Peloponnesian War (London)Google Scholar
Develin, R., 1989: Athenian officials 684–321 B.C. (Cambridge)CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Dilts, M. R., 1992: Scholia in Aeschinem (Stuttgart)Google Scholar
Dover, K. J., 1954: ‘Greek comedy’, in Platnauer 1954: 96–129 (reprinted with addenda in Dover 1987: 190–219)Google Scholar
Dover, K. J., 1972a. Aristophanic comedy (Berkeley)Google Scholar
Dover, K. J., 1972b. 'Greek comedy‘, in Daiches&Thorlby 1972:193–212Google Scholar
Dover, K. J., 1987: Greek and the Greeks. Collected papers, volume 1:language, poetry, drama (Oxford)Google Scholar
Dover, K. J., 1993:Aristophanes: Frogs.(Oxford)Google Scholar
Edmonds, J. M., 1957: The fragments of Attic comedy vol.1(Leiden)Google Scholar
Edwards, A. T., 1993: ‘Historicizing the popular grotesque: Bakhtin’s Rabelais and Attic Old Comedy‘, in Scodel 1993: 89–117Google Scholar
Etienne, R. et al., (edd.) 1989: Architecture et poesie dans le monde grec: hommages a George Roux. (Lyon)Google Scholar
Halliwell, S., 1980: ‘Aristophanes’ apprenticeship‘, CQ 30: 33–45CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Halliwell, S., 1984a. ‘Ancient interpretations of SvofMaarl KaifiaiSeiv in Aristophanes’,Google Scholar
CQ 34: 83–8Google Scholar
Halliwell, S., 1984b. ‘Aristophanic satire’, Yearbook of English Studies 14: 6–20CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Halliwell, S., 1991: ‘Comic satire and freedom of speech in classical Athens’, JHS 111: 48–70CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Halliwell, S., 1993: ‘Comedy and publicity in the society of the polis’, in Sommerstein et al. 1993:321–40Google Scholar
Handley, E.W., 1982: ‘Aristophanes' rivals’, Proceedings of the Classical Association 79: 23–5Google Scholar
Harding, P., 1994: Androlion and the Atthis (Oxford)Google Scholar
Henderson, J. J., 1987: Aristophanes: Lysistrata (Oxford)CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Henderson, J. J., 1991: The maculate muse: obscene language in Attic comedy 2nd ed. (New York and Oxford)CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Henderson, J. J., 1993: 'Problems in Greek literary history: the case of Aristophanes' Clouds', in Rosen&Farrell 1993: 591–601Google Scholar
Henry, A. S., 1992: 'Through a laser beam darkly: space–age technology and the Egesta decree' (I.G. i3 11). ZPE 91: 137–46Google Scholar
Henry, A. S., 1995: 'Pour encourager les autres: Athens and Egesta encore', CQ 45: 237–40CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kassel, R., and Austin, C.(edd.) 1983–: Poetae comici Graeci (Berlin)Google Scholar
Kovacs, D., 1990: 'De Cephisophonte verna, ut perhibent, Euripidis', ZPE 84: 15–18Google Scholar
Lang, M. L., 1990: The Athenian Agora: results of excavations conducted by the American School of Classical Studies at Athens. 25: Ostraka (Princeton)Google Scholar
Lanza, D., 1989: 'L'attor comico sulla scena', Dioniso 59: 297–312Google Scholar
Lefkowitz, M. R., 1981: The lives of the Greek poets (London)Google Scholar
Lewis, D. M., 1983: Review of Sommerstein 1981, CR 33: 175–7Google Scholar
Lopez, Ferez J. A., (ed.) forthcoming: La comedia griega: aspectos literarios, societies y educativos (Madrid)Google Scholar
MacDowell, D. M., 1961: 'Theagenes of Peiraieus', RhM 104: 229–36Google Scholar
MacDowell, D. M., 1962: Andokides: On the Mysteries (Oxford)Google Scholar
MacDowell, D. M., 1971: Aristophanes: Wasps (Oxford)Google Scholar
MacDowell, D. M., 1982: 'Aristophanes and Kallistratos', CQ 32: 21–6CrossRefGoogle Scholar
MacDowell, D. M., 1983: 'The nature of Aristophanes' Akharnians'. GR 30: 143–62Google Scholar
MacDowell, D. M., 1993: 'Foreign birth and Athenian citizenship in Aristophanes', in Sommerstein et al. 1993: 359–71Google Scholar
Mastromarco, G., 1994: Introduzione a Aristofane (Bari)Google Scholar
Mastromarco, G., forthcoming: 'La commedia attica antica fra tradizione ed innovazione', to appear in Lopez FerezGoogle Scholar
Mattingly, H. B., 1994: 'The practice of ostracism at Athens', Antichthon 25 [dated 1991]: 1–25.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Menu, M., and Thiercy, P., (eds.) forthcoming: Aristophane: la langue, la scene, la cite (Bari)Google Scholar
Osborne, M. J., and Byrne, S. G., 1994: A lexicon of Greek personal names. Vol. 2: Attica (Oxford)Google Scholar
Osborne, R. G., and Hornblower, S., (eds.) 1994: Ritual, finance, politics: Athenian democratic accounts presented to David Lewis (Oxford)Google Scholar
Platnauer, M., (ed.) 1954: Fifty years of classical scholarship (Oxford)Google Scholar
Raubitschek, A. E., 1942: 'Oulios (2)', RE 181: 1999–2000Google Scholar
Rhodes, P. J., 1990: Review of Develin 1989, CR 40: 347–8Google Scholar
Rhodes, P. J., 1994: ‘The ostracism of Hyperbolus’, in Osborne&Hornblower 1994: 85–98Google Scholar
Rosen, R. M., 1988: Old Comedy and the iambographic tradition (Atlanta)Google Scholar
Rosen, R. M., and Farrell, J.,(eds.)1993: Nomodeiktes: Greek studies in honor of Martin Ostwald (Ann Arbor)Google Scholar
Salviat, F., 1989: ‘La deuxieme reapresentation des Grenouilles: la faute d’Adeimantos, Cleophon et le deuil de l‘hirondelle’, in Etienne et al. 1989: 171–83Google Scholar
Scodel, R. S., (ed.) 1993: Theater and society in the classical world. (Ann Arbor)Google Scholar
Sommerstein, A. H., 1977a: ‘Aristophanes and the events of 411‘, JHS 97: 112–26CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Sommerstein, A. H., 1977b: ‘Notes on Aristophanes’ Wasps‘, CQ 27: 261–77CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Sommerstein, A. H., 1980a: The comedies of Aristophanes. Vol. 1: Acharnians (Warminster)Google Scholar
Sommerstein, A. H., 1980b: ‘Notes on Aristophanes’ Knights‘, CQ 30: 46–56CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Sommerstein, A. H., 1981:Google Scholar
The comedies of Aristophanes. Vol. 2: Knights (Warminster)Google Scholar
Sommerstein, A. H., 1982:Google Scholar
The comedies of Aristophanes. Vol. 3: Clouds (Warminster)Google Scholar
Sommerstein, A. H., 1983:Google Scholar
The comedies of Aristophanes. Vol. 4: Wasps (Warminster)Google Scholar
Sommerstein, A. H., 1984: ‘Aristophanes and the demon Poverty’, CQ 34: 314–33CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Sommerstein, A. H., 1985: The comedies of Aristophanes. Vol. 5: Peace (Warminster)Google Scholar
Sommerstein, A. H., 1986: ‘The decree of Syrakosios’, CQ 36: 101–8CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Sommerstein, A. H., 1987a: The comedies of Aristophanes. Vol. 6: Birds (Warminster)Google Scholar
Sommerstein, A. H., 1987b: ‘Phrynichos the dancer’, Phoenix 41: 189–90 Sommerstein, A. H., 1990: The comedies of Aristophanes. Vol. 7: Lysistrata (Warminster)CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Sommerstein, A. H., 1993: ‘Kleophon and the restaging of Frogs’, in Sommerstein et al. 1993: 461–76Google Scholar
Sommerstein, A. H., 1994: The comedies of Aristophanes. Vol. 8: Thesmophoriazusae (Warminster)Google Scholar
Sommerstein, A. H., forthcoming a: ‘The silence of Strepsiades and the agon of the first Clouds‘, to appear in Menu&ThiercyGoogle Scholar
Sommerstein, A. H., forthcoming b: ’The theatre audience and the demos’, to appear in Lopez FerezGoogle Scholar
Sommerstein, A. H., et al. 1993: Tragedy, comedy and the polls: papers from the Greek Drama Conference Nottingham, 18–20 July 1990 (Bari)Google Scholar
Spedding, J., et al. 1857–74: The works of Francis Bacon (London)Google Scholar
Stanford, W. B., 1963: Aristophanes: The Frogs 2nd ed. (London)Google Scholar
Storey, I.C, 1985: ‘The symposium at Wasps 1299ff’, Phoenix 39: 317–33CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Storey, I.C, 1990: ‘Dating and re–dating Eupolis’, Phoenix 44: 1–30CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Storey, I.C, 1993: ‘The dates of Aristophanes’ Clouds II and Eupolis‘ Baptai: a reply to E.C. Kopff’, AJP 114: 71–84Google Scholar
Storey, I.C, 1995: ‘Philoxenos... of doubtful gender', JHS 115: 182–4CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Vetta, M., 1995: 'La voce degli attori nel teatro attico', in De Martino&Sommerstein 1995:i 61–78Google Scholar
Zanetto, G., 1987: Aristofane: Gli Uccelli(con introduzione e traduzione di D. Del Corno) (Milan)Google Scholar