Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-v9fdk Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-19T01:44:22.340Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The Waldensian Recourse to Violence

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  28 July 2009

Susanna K. Treesh
Susanna K. Treesh
Affiliation:
Doctoral candidate in the history department, Rutgers University, New Brunswick, New Jersey.
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

From their origins in the twelfth century to their support for and involvement in the Reformation in the sixteenth, the Waldensian heretics professed nonviolence as one of their beliefs. Later Protestant and Catholic polemicists equated the profession of nonviolence with a policy and bestowed upon the sect a reputation as one of the precursors of religious pacifism. More recent scholars have noted that the heretics at least occasionally employed violence. I will argue that lay Waldensian believers, called credentes, reacted violently to persecution and learned to employ aggression in pursuit of political goals. In the later Middle Ages, at least, Waldensians resorted to violence on enough occasions and in enough different locations to justify dropping the idea that they were a nonviolent group. Their use of violence did become more sophisticated—that is, more closely connected to political goals—during the fifteenth century as access to representatives of the state increased.

Type
Research Article
Information
Church History , Volume 55 , Issue 3 , September 1986 , pp. 294 - 306
Copyright
Copyright © American Society of Church History 1986

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1. The Waldensian movement began with the evangelical activities of the merchant Waldes of Lyons. The year 1174 is celebrated as the year of origin; probably the movement took shape during the succeeding decade. It became the most widespread and long-lived of medieval heretical movements.

2. See the discussion of the intertwined political and aggressive reactions of the Dauphinois Waldensians to the crusade of Cattaneo, Albert in Cameron, Euan, The Reformation of the Heretics: The Waldenses of the Alps, 1480–1580 (Oxford, 1984), pp. 17–24.Google Scholar I disagree with Cameron's assertion that “Waldensian organization was, in short, very lay and very materialist; it was concerned with the defense of property, by litigation and by force.” If that were the case, there would have been no reason for Cattaneo's crusade. Rather, the Waldensians were willing at this point to use force to defend their beliefs. This had been the case in Germany and earlier in Piedmont and Dauphiné. I have tried to show the continuity and development of the Waldensians' willingness to employ violence.

3. Mullett, Michael, Radical Religious Movements in Early Modern Europe (London, 1980), p. 10.Google Scholar Although some authors (for example, Richard Kieckhefer, Repression of Heresy in Medieval Germany) recognize that the violence was not occasional or accidental, most have written on the assumption that the majority of Waldensians held to a principle of nonviolence. Howard Kaminsky states in A History of the Hussite Revolution that “At the same time there is much evidence to show that for at least a century before the Hussite revolt Central European Waldensians were occasionally capable of passing over to violent actions” (p. 177), but he assumes that in the normal course of events the Waldensian influence will be a pacifist one (pp. 320–321). Schneider, Martin, Europäische Waldensertum in 13 und 14 Jahrhundert (New York, 1981),CrossRefGoogle Scholar argues the opposite of what I propose in this paper: that the advocates of violent action were to be found chiefly among the inner religious leadership, with nonviolence as the layperson's belief (pp. 82–83). Merlo, Grado G., Eretici e inquisitori nella societá piemontese del Trecento (Turin, 1977),Google Scholar mentions “contrast between theory and practice in the [violent] Piedmontese episodes,” but attributes such actions to a chance convergence of causes, including errors in judgment by the Inquisition; pp. 151–152.

4. Gonnet, Jean and Molnar, Amedeo, Les Vaudois an Moyen Age (Turin, 1974), pp. 425–426.Google Scholar

5. The development of the Sylvestrine legend and the anti-legend is traced in Laehr, Gerhard, Die Konstantinische Shenkung in der abendländische Literatur des Mittelalters bis zum Mitte des 14 Jahrhunderts (Berlin, 1926).Google Scholar The first surviving mention of the voice comes from Gelraldus Cambrensis in 1197, who, however, attributed the voice to Lucifer rather than to an angel. For a Waldensian version see Schmidt, Karl, “Aktenstücke besonders zur Geschichte der Waldenser,” Zeitschrift für die historische Theologie 22 (1852): 240.Google Scholar

6. Döllinger, Ignaz von, Beitrage zur Sektengeschichte des Mittelalters, 2 vols. (New York, 1890), 2: 356.Google Scholar

7. “Le Quatre Semencz,” in Chaytor, H.J., Six Vaudois Poems (Cambridge, 1930): original, pp. 61–65;Google Scholar English translation, pp. 118–122.

8. Merlo, Grado G., Eretici e Inquistori nella societá piemontese del Trecento (Turin, 1977), p. 151 n.Google Scholar

9. Wattenbach, Wilhelm, “Über die Inquisition gegen die Waldenser in Pommern und der Mark Brandenburg,” Abhandlungen der Königlichen Akademie der Wissenschaften zu Berlin, Philosophische-Historische (III) Classe, Jg. 1886, p. 37.Google Scholar

10. Döllinger, von, Sektengeschichte, 2: 340.Google Scholar

11. Chevalier, Jules, Memoire historique sur les Heresies en Dauphiné (Valence, 1890), pp. 87–88.Google Scholar

12. Ochsenbein, Gotifried Friedrich, Aus dem schweizerischen Volksleben des XV Jahrhunderts (Bern, 1881), p. 321.Google Scholar

13. Brock, Peter, The Political and Social Doctrines of the Unity of Czech Brethren (The Hague, 1957), p. 192.Google Scholar

14. On Friedrich Reiser, see Vinay, Valdo “Friedrich Reiser und die Waldensische Diaspora deutscher sprache im XV. Jahrhundert,” in Waldenser, Geschzchte und Gegenwart, ed. Erk, Wolfgang (Frankfurt, 1971), pp. 25–47.Google Scholar Reiser's title was “Bishop by God's Grace of all the Faithful who resist the Donation of Constantine.”

15. The trial is discussed in Wattenbach, Wilhelm, “Über die Inquisition,” pp. 75–83.Google Scholar

16. Kurze, Dietrich, “Brief märkische Waldenser an die Böhm. Brüder, 1480,” Quellen zur Ketzergeschtchte Brandenburgs und Pommerns (New York, 1975): Czech text, pp. 313–317;Google Scholar German translation, pp. 317–319.

17. Ochsenbein, , Schweizerische Votksleben, p. 322.Google Scholar

18. Ibid., p. 321.

19. Chevalier, , Memoire historique, p. 52.Google Scholar A certain Daniel Griot was arrested on 1 September as he travelled from Val Pragalas to Val Freyssinieres to seek a barbe named Jeannet.

20. Vinay, Valdo, ed. Le Confessioni di Fede dei Valdesi, Riformati (Turin, 1975), pp. 44–45.Google Scholar

21. Döllinger, von, Sektengeschichte, 2: 311.Google Scholar

22. Friess, G. E., “Patarener, Begharden und Waldenser in Oesterreich während des Mittelalters,” Oesterreichische Vierteljahresschrift für Katholische Theologie 11 (1872): 262.Google Scholar

23. Wanenbach, , “Inquisition,” pp. 28–30.Google Scholar

24. Vinay, , Confessioni, p. 42.Google Scholar

25. Ibid.

26. Ibid.

27. Some who have considered Philip Regis to have been a sort of Cathar accepted him as a Waldensian even if some of his statements are not confirmed elsewhere; Weitzecker, Giacomo, “Processo di un Valdese nell' anno 1451,” La Rivista Cristiana 9 (1881): 363–367.Google Scholar

28. Chevalier, , Memoire historique, pp. 84–85.Google Scholar

29. Arnaud, Eugene, “Histoire des Persecutions Endurées par les Vaudois du Dauphiné aux XIIIe, XIVe, et XVe Siecles,” Bulletin de la société 12 (1895): 108–110.Google Scholar

30. Euan Cameron's Reformation of the Heretics was published only in 1984. His chapter, “The Rehabilitation of the Persecuted,” deals in detail with this drawn-out litigation.

31. Kurze, Dietrich, “Brief märkische Waldenser,” pp. 317–319.Google Scholar

32. Edited in Arnaud, Eugene, “Louis XI et les Vaudois du Dauphiné,” Bulletin historique et philologique du Comzté des travaux historique et scientifique (1895), pp. 513–518.Google Scholar

33. Vinay, , Confessioni, pp. 36–37.Google Scholar

34. Chevalier, , Memoire historique, p. 81.Google Scholar

35. Cameron, , Reformation, pp. 25–48;Google ScholarChevalier, , Memoire historique, pp. 87–89.Google Scholar See also Arnaud, , “Histoire des Persecutions,” pp. 87–97.Google Scholar

36. Arnaud, , “Louis XI,” pp. 513–518.Google Scholar Charles VIII died in 1498. The Waldensians were deceived in their hopes for Louis XII. He may have been more favorably disposed, but little tangible result came of it.

37. “Errores Valdensium in Paeana Commorantium,” in Arturo, Pascal, “Margherita di Foix ed i Valdesi di Paesana,” Athenaeum 4 (1916): 64–65.Google Scholar

38. Printed in full in Vinay, Confessioni, pp. 36–51.

39. Ibid., p. 44.

40. Ibid., p. 66.

41. Ibid., p. 108.