Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-t8hqh Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-25T09:02:47.508Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Servetus and the Genevan Libertines

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  28 July 2009

Roland H. Bainton
Roland H. Bainton
Affiliation:
Yale University
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

The defenders of John Calvin have sought to excuse his share in the execution of Servetus by resorting to the type of apologetic employed by Catholics in defense of the Inquisition. The victims, we are told, were politically and socially subversive and would have been suppressed in any age. In the case of Servetus this charge cannot be substantiated from his writings, since he did not reject the oath, nor the authority of the magistrate, neither did he counsel immorality. The only recourse for the apologists is to connect Servetus with Calvin's political opponents, the so-called Libertines. The argument has assumed slightly different forms in different hands, but three main contentions emerge: 1) that Servetus plotted with the Libertines for the overthrow of Calvin's régime; 2) that the Libertines endeavored to bring about the acquittal of Servetus; and 3) that they communicated with him to that end during the course of his trial.

Type
Articles
Information
Church History , Volume 5 , Issue 2 , June 1936 , pp. 141 - 149
Copyright
Copyright © American Society of Church History 1936

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Calvini Opera, XIV, 590 note.Google Scholar

2 Holl, Karl, Johannes Calvin, Tübingen, 1909, p. 53.Google Scholar

3 Émile Doumergue, Jean Calvin, 7 vols., Neuilly-sur-Seine, 1899–1927, VI, 309, note 5.Google Scholar

4 Calvini Opera, XX, 438.Google Scholar

5 Ibid., p. 437 and note.

6 Calvini Opera, VIII, 770Google Scholar, §28 “respond quil nestoit venu pour passer de la les montz et non point pour demorer icy, et sen aller au royaulme de naples la ou sont des Espagnolz, et vivre avec eulx de son art de medicine. Et que expressement pour ce fair il sestoit venu loger a la Rose, et quil en avoit ia parle a Ihoste et a Ihostesse pour trouver une barque pour aller tant hault par le lac quil pourroit pour trouver le chemin de Zurich. Et quil se tenoit cache en ceste ville tant quil pouvoit, affin sen pouvoir aller sans estre eogneu.”

Ibid., p. 749. “ledit Servetus … a respondu quil … se saulva et prit le chemin pour aller contre Espagne dempuys il sen est revenu a cause des gendarmes quil craignoit et sen vouloit passer par icy et par allemagne pour aller de la les mons pour exercer la medicine.”

Ibid., p. 782 §38. “respond quil avoit couche le iour dlevant a leluyset (?) et arriva a pied tout seul, et quil loua encor an cheval a Salenove. Et quil sen veult bien tenir a la dicte de Ihoste.”

7 “Mox,” Calvini Opera, XXI, 146.Google Scholar

8 “Statim,” Calvini Opera, XIV, 602.Google Scholar

9 “esté prins en ceste ville où il pensoit passer comme homme incognu.” Cited by Buisson, Ferdinand, Sébastien Castellion, Paris, 1892, II, 20, note 1.Google Scholar

10 “Hac transire forte cogitabat. Necdum enim scitur quo consilio venerit.” Calvini Opera, XIV, 589.Google Scholar

11 “Unde nescio quomodo elapsus, per Italiam erravit fere quatuor menses.” Calvini Opera, XIV, 614.Google Scholar

12 Calvini Opera, VIII, 782 §37.Google Scholar

13 Calvini Opera, XIV, 577.Google Scholar

14 Op. cit., VI, 310.

15 Calvini Opera, VIII, 731, 734 §38.Google Scholar

16 Ibid., p. 740, §38.

17 Ibid., pp. 768, §11, 780, §15, 781, §22–25.

18 Rilliet, Albert, Relation du procès criminel intenté à Genève, en 1553, contre Michel Servet, Geneva, 1844, p. 65Google Scholar. Doumergne, , Op. cit., p. 314.Google Scholar

19 Doumergue, , Op. cit., VI, 310Google Scholar. Gueroult was not released until Sept. 5. The last of these statements of Servetus was made on Aug. 28.

20 Calvini Opera VIII, 792.Google Scholar

21 Doumergue, , Op. cit., VI, 318–319 and 322.Google Scholar

22 Calvini Opera, VIII, 480Google Scholar. M. Doumergue cites from, the French version.

23 “violence convaincue.” Op. cit., VI, 205.Google Scholar

24 Calvini Opera, VIII, 751.Google Scholar

25 Calvini Opera, XIV, 606.Google Scholar

26 Cited by Doumergue, M., Op. cit., VI, 334Google Scholar, from Gautier who had access to a source now lost.

27 Doumergue, , Op. cit., VI, 332–34.Google Scholar

28 Calvini Opera, XIV, 628.Google Scholar

29 Calvini Opera, XIV, 624.Google Scholar

30 Rilliet, Albert, Op. cit., p. 54.Google Scholar

31 Calvini Opera, VIII, 827–29.Google Scholar

32 Calvini, Opera, VIII, 742–43.Google Scholar

33 Calvini Opera, XIV, 623–24.Google Scholar

34 Roset, Michel, Les chroniques ae Genève, ed. Fazy, Henri, Geneva, 1894, p. 355.Google Scholar

35 Calvini Opera, XIV, 657.Google Scholar

36 von Mosheim, Johann Lorenz, Anderweitiger Versuch einer vollständigen und unpartheyischen Ketzergeschichte, Helmstaedt, 1748, p. 449.Google Scholar

37 Calvini Opera, VIII, 825.Google Scholar

38 Contra Libellum Calvini, 1612, Dij.Google Scholar

39 Calvini Opera, XX, 438.Google Scholar

40 Roget, Amédée, Histoire du peuple de Genève depuis la réforme jusqu'à l'escalade, 7 vols, in 3, Geneva, 1870–1873, IV, appendix.Google Scholar

41 Ibid., IV, 167–68.

42 Ibid., IV, 291 note 1.

43 Bonivard, François, Advis et devis de l'ancienne et nouvelle police de Geneve, reprinted in Geneva, 1865, p. 108.Google Scholar

44 Op. cit., VI, 326–27.

45 Calvini Opera, XIV, 693.Google Scholar

46 Calvini Opera, XXI, 146.Google Scholar

47 Op. cit., p. 107. Cf. Rilliet, , Op. cit., p. 104Google Scholar, who suggests that Claude was suspect, because on October 23 Servetus was committed to other hands.

48 Calvini Opera, VIII, 789.Google Scholar

49 Ibid.

50 Rilliet, , Op. cit., pp. 69–70.Google Scholar

51 Calvini Opera, VIII, 746.Google Scholar

52 Op. cit., VI, 277. Calvini Opera, VIII, 732, 738, 789.Google Scholar

53 Calvini Opera, VIII, 746, §5, 749, 789.Google Scholar

54 Calvini Opera, VIII, 767, §4.Google Scholar

55 Even Roget was impressed by this consideration. Op. cit., IV, p. 76.

56 Doumergue, , Op. cit., VI, 363–64; cf. 336, 340.Google Scholar

57 Foster, Herbert Darling, “Geneva before Calvin,” in American Historical Review, VIII (1903), pp. 217–240, especially p. 231.Google Scholar