Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-gvvz8 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-27T13:49:48.509Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Fundamentalism and Femininity: Points of Encounter Between Religious Conservatives and Women, 1919–1935

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  28 July 2009

Margaret Lamberts Bendroth
Margaret Lamberts Bendroth
Affiliation:
Ms. Bendroth is presently an independent scholar funded by the Evangelical Scholarship Initiative.
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

“Women go to church for the same reason that farmers and convicts go to church,” H.L. Mencken once observed—strictly for the company. His book “in defense of women,” written at the close of World War I, systematically deflated the Victorian era's sentimental notions about the “fairer sex.” “They are growing less and less religious as year chases year,” he noted cheerfully. “The evangelical Protestant denominations will have a hard time holding them.” Others shared Mencken's conclusion, though less joyfully. “Women no longer accept Christianity as a matter of course because they happen to be women,” the Christian Century lamented in 1924. “They pause and question here as in all things else.”

Type
Research Article
Information
Church History , Volume 61 , Issue 2 , June 1992 , pp. 221 - 233
Copyright
Copyright © American Society of Church History 1992

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1. Mencken, H.L., In Defense of Women (New York, 1918; reprint 1977), pp. 175, 182, 184.Google Scholar

2. “What Shall Be Done With the Women?” Christian Century 1 (04 1920): 6.Google Scholar

3. DeBerg, Betty A., Ungodly Women: Gender and the First Wave of American Fundamentalism (Philadelphia, 1990).Google Scholar

4. See Marsden, George, Fundamentalism and American Culture: The Shaping of Twentieth-Century Evangelicalism (New York, 1980).Google Scholar

5. For a modern example see Fitzgerald, Frances, “Reflections: Jim and Tammy,” New Yorker (23 April 1990): 45–87.Google Scholar

6. Gilman, Charlotte Perkins, His Religion and Hers: A Study of the Faith of our Fathers, and the Work of Our Mothers (New York, 1923; reprint, Westport, Conn., 1976), pp. 225–226, 92–93.Google Scholar

7. See Bendroth, Margaret Lamberts, “Women and Missions: Conflict and Changing Roles in the Presbyterian Church in the United States of America, 1870–1935,” Journal of Presbyterian History 65 (1987): 49–59.Google Scholar

8. See Boyd, Lois A. and Brackenridge, Douglas J., Presbyterian Women in America: Two Centuries of a Quest for Status (Westport, Conn., 1983)Google Scholar; Verdesi, Elizabeth H., In But Still Out: Women in the Church (Philadelphia, 1973)Google Scholar; MacAfee, Clement, “Women and Official Church Life,” Presbyterian Banner 16 (01 1930): 32.Google Scholar

9. Warfield, B. B., “Paul on Women Speaking in Church,” Presbyterian (15 July 1920): 8Google Scholar; “Paul's Speaking About Women,” ibid., p. 4; William H. Bates, “Paul (And Others) on Women Speaking in the Church,” ibid., pp. 9–10; Wallace MacGowan, “A Word About Women Speaking in the Church,” ibid., pp. 11, 26; Hitchcock, F. L., “Shall Women Be Ordained as Elders and Deacons?” Presbyterian (2 September 1920): 7Google Scholar; Lamb, A. Mackenzie, “The Ecclesiastical Rank of Women,” Presbyterian (9 September 1920): 27.Google Scholar

10. Mathews, Mark A., “Why Women in the Pulpit?” Presbyterian (16 January 1930): 7Google Scholar; Jenkins, Finley, “The Self-Destruction of the Movement to License and Ordain Women,” Presbyterian (27 March 1930): 27Google Scholar; “Ordination of Women,” Presbyterian (3 April 1930): 27.Google Scholar

11. Macartney, , “Shall We Ordain Women as Ministers and Elders?” Presbyterian (7 November 1929): 7;Google ScholarPhilips, Euclid, “Woman's Place in the Church,” Presbyterian (16 September 1930): 10.Google Scholar

12. John Roach Straton, “Why I Am Cutting Loose from the Apostate Ecclesiastical Baptist Machine Though I Am a Better Baptist Than Ever Before,” sermon preached at Calvary Baptist Church, 29 October 1926, p. 10, Straton papers, American Baptist Historical Society (hereafter ABHS), Rochester, N.Y.; Straton, , “What Should We Do in the Present Denominational Situation?” Religious Searchlight, 15 May 1922Google Scholar; Tulga, Chester E., The Foreign Mission Controversy in the Northern Baptist Convention, 1919–1949 (Chicago, 1950).Google Scholar Tulga, “The Northern Baptist Convention and the New Testament,” unpublished ms. in ABHS. Years later Baptist fundamentalist Chester Tulga noted that women presided over the Northern Baptist Convention at both critical moments of defeat for conservatives, Montgomery in 1922 when the denomination adopted its “inclusive policy,” and Anna Canada Swain in 1946 when the Conservative Baptist Missionary Society failed to receive denominational acceptance.

13. Notes from Fundamentalist League Executive Committee Meeting, 30 August—3 September 1925, Massee papers, ABHS.

14. Massee, “Women Attend Special Meeting,” 30 January 1931, a reprinted excerpt from a standard sermon on “The Old Fashioned vs. the New Woman,” Massee papers, ABHS; Macartney, , The Way of a Man With a Maid (Nashville, 1931), p. 62.Google Scholar

15. Hassey, Janette, No Time for Silence: Evangelical Women in Public Ministry Around the Turn of the Century (Grand Rapids, 1986)Google Scholar; “Yes, God Uses Women Workers,” Moody Bible Institute Monthly (hereafter MBIM) 21 (1921): 344.Google Scholar See also Brereton, Virginia Lieson, Training God's Army: The American Bible School, 1880–1940 (Bloomington, 1990), pp. 129–132.Google Scholar

16. Riley, W. B., “Discontinuing This Magazine,” Christian Fundamentalist 6 (09—10 1932): 34Google Scholar; “Dr. Maclnniss Dismissed, Blames Book,” unidentified clipping, Riley collection, Billy Graham Center Archives (hereafter BGCA), Wheaton, Ill.; Baptist Bulletin (1930): 330.

17. “Taking the Bible ‘Literally’,” MBIM 23 (1923): 191–192Google Scholar; Gilmer, Graham, “Should Christian Women Speak or Lead in Prayer in Our Churches?” MBIM 27 (1928): 223–224Google Scholar; Stroh, Grant, “Practical and Perplexing Questions,” MBIM 21 (1920): 21.Google ScholarRiley, , “Women in the Ministry,” Christian Fundamentalist 1 (05 1928): 21.Google ScholarRiley's, views would become more conservative, however.Google Scholar See Trollinger, William Vance, God's Empire: William Bell Riley and Midwestern Fundamentalism (Madison, Wis., 1990), pp. 104–107.Google Scholar

18. Knauss, Elizabeth, The Conflict: A Narrative Based on the Fundamentalist Movement (Los Angeles, 1923).Google Scholar

19. Douglas, Ann C., The Feminization of American Culture (New York, 1977).Google ScholarOn the social context of “muscular Christianity” see Filene, Peter, Him/Her Self: Sex Roles in Modern America, 2d ed. (Baltimore, 1986)Google Scholar; Rotundo, Edward A., “Body and Soul: Changing Ideals of American Middle-Class Manhood, 1770–1920,” Journal of Social History 16 (1983): 23–35.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

20. See for example Coyle, Robert F., “The Present-Day Demand for Men in the Extension of the Kingdom,“ in Presbyterian Brotherhood: Report of the Second Convention Held in Cincinnati, Nov. 12th to 14th, 1907 (Philadelphia, 1908), pp. 54–56Google Scholar; “New Layman's Movement,” Watchman-Examiner (19 07 1923): 910.Google Scholar

21. Riley, “The Church and Men: Its Hold on Them Considered by Evangelist W. B. Riley in Revival Discourse Last Evening,” unidentified clipping, 3 March 1910; Riley papers, BGCA.

22. Fiske, George Walter, “Can Religion Come Back to the Home?” Christian Century (15 November 1927): 1486–1487Google Scholar; “The Modernist's Quest for God,” Atlantic Monthly 137 (09 1926): 228.Google Scholar

23. Quoted in Carter, Paul A., Another Part of the Twenties (New York, 1977), pp. 53–54.Google Scholar

24. “Dr. Straton No Eccentric, But Normal, Says Wife,” New York Evening Journal 31 May 1928Google Scholar; DeBlois, Austen K., “John Roach Straton: An Appreciation,” The Baptist (30 November 1929): 1484.Google Scholar

25. Lewis, A. William, “The Investment of Manhood,” Bible Champion 34 (1929): 384Google Scholar; Kennedy, , “Quit You Like Men, Be Strong,” Bible Champion 30 (1924): 134Google Scholar and “Notes and Comments,“ Bible Champion: 141.

26. “The Supernatural,” Watchman-Examiner (8 11 1923): 1432Google Scholar; “How to Interest Men in the Work of the Church,” MBIM 23 (09 1922): 33Google Scholar; Kennedy, , “Characteristics of the Destructive Rationalist,” Bible Champion 30 (07 1924): 355.Google Scholar

27. Straton, “Moral Decay Through Subservience to Foreign Fashions in Women's Dress,” unpublished sermon, Straton papers, ABHS.

28. “More Concerning Women's Dress,” MBIM 31 (1930): 64Google Scholar; Funderburk, A. R., “The Word of God on Women's Dress,” MBIM 22 (1922): 759.Google Scholar

29. “Concerning Women's Dress,” MBIM 30 (1930): 577.Google Scholar

30. “The Baptist Bible Union of America,” The Baptist (7 October 1922): 1110.Google Scholar

31. Bendroth, , “The Search for ‘Woman's Role’ in American Evangelicalism, 1930–1980,” in Evangelicalism and Modern America, ed. Marsden, George (Grand Rapids, 1984), pp. 122–134.Google Scholar

32. Scanzoni, Letha and Setta, Susan, “Women in Evangelical, Holiness, and Pentecostal Traditions,” in Women and Religion in America, 1900–1968, Ruether, Rosemary Radford and Keller, Rosemary Skinner, eds. (San Francisco, 1986), p. 228Google Scholar; Riley, , “World Christian Fundamentals Association,” King's Business 21 (1930): 346Google Scholar; Henry, James O., For Such a Time as This: A History of the Independent Fundamental Churches in America (Westchester, Ill., 1983), pp. 42, 126–129Google Scholar; “Important Meeting of the Independent Board of Presbyterian Foreign Missions,” Christianity Today 4 (10 1933): 11–12.Google Scholar

33. Riley, “Discontinuing This Magazine,” p. 34; Russell, C. Allyn, “Mark Allison Matthews: Seattle Fundamentalist and Civic Reformer,” Journal of Presbyterian History 57 (1979): 446–461Google Scholar; DeBlois, , “John Roach Straton: An Appreciation”Google Scholar; “Preachers You Hear on the Radio,” n.d., Massee papers, ABHS; Macartney, , The Way of a Man With a Maid, p. 137.Google Scholar

34. MrsMassee, J. C., “More Experiences of a Minister's Wife,” Watchman-Examiner (31 October 1929): 1394Google Scholar; Tarr, Leslie K., Shields of Canada (Grand Rapids, 1967), pp. 178–179Google Scholar; Riley, , “Mrs. W. B. Riley: In Memoriam,” Christian Fundamentalist 5 (1931): 99Google Scholar; Riley, , “Managing Church Troubles,” King's Business 26 (1935): 85Google Scholar; Sweet, Leonard I., The Ministers' Wife: Her Role in Nineteenth Century American Evangelicalism (Philadelphia, 1983).Google Scholar

35. Massee, “The Old-Fashioned Woman.”