1. Ribault, Jean-Yves, Un Chef d'Oeuvre Gothique: La Cathédrale de Bourges (Paris: Editions Anthese, 1995).Google Scholar

2. The Presentation of the Virgin Miniature by Jean Colombe (from the Trés-Riche Heures of the Duc de Berry) indicates that jamb statues decorated at least three doorways of the West facade. Colombe's depiction, however, is inaccurate in many respects and may be highly imaginative. See Bayard, Tanya, Bourges Cathedral: The West Portals (New York: Garland, 1976), plate XXXVI.Google Scholar

3. The original tympanum—probably depicting the legend of a local saint—was destroyed when the north tower of the cathedral fell in 1506; we are describing the one in place in 1562. (The same comments apply to the spandrel sculptures.)

4. Knecht, R. J., The Rise and Fall of Renaissance France (London: Fontana, 1996), 356 and 366–67.Google Scholar

5. Michalski, Sergiusz, The Reformation and the Visual Arts (New York: Routledge, 1993), 75.Google Scholar

6. Belting, Hans, Likeness and Presence, trans. Jephcott, Edmund (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1994), 459–60.Google Scholar

7. As in Strasbourg before 1529; see Michalski, 77.

8. Wandel, Lee Palmer, Voracious Idols and Violent Hands (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1995), 8.Google Scholar

9. Belting, 458.

10. Wandel, , 193Google Scholar, and Christensen, Carl C., “Patterns of Iconoclasm in the Early Reformation: Strasbourg and Basel” in The Image and the Word, ed Joseph, Gutmann (Missoula, Mont.: Scholars, 1977), 107.Google Scholar

11. Scavizzi, Guiseppe, The Controversy on Images from Calvin to Baronius (New York: Peter Lang, 1992), 5 and 20.Google Scholar

12. Hardy, Daniel W., “Calvinism and the Visual Arts: A Theological Introduction” in Seeing Beyond the Word: Visual Arts and the Calvinist Tradition, ed. Finney, Paul Corby (Grand Rapids, Mich.: Eerdmans, 1999), 15Google Scholar, and Crouzet, Denis, Les Guerriers de Dieu (Seyssel: Champs Vallon, 1990), 552.Google Scholar

13. Scavizzi, 50; n.b. 22: “Not accepting Calvin–s iconoclastic stance means not accepting Calvin himself.”

14. Calvin, wrote: “God has never given commandment, except to each one in his own house, and in public to those he arms with authority to cast down idols” in Letters of John Calvin, trans Gilchrist, Marcus Robert, ed. Bonnet, J. (New York: Burt Franklin, 1858, reprinted 1972), 4:206. See the entire letter, 205–7.Google Scholar

15. Beza's position develops out of the distinction between sign and res, explored in early chapters of his Confessio Christianae Fidei. In chapter vi (page 28 in the definitive edition of 1560), he says that true believers perceive both; “infideles vero, quoniam sola signa percipiunt, et ita quidem ut res ipsas quas Deus illis non minus vere quam signa offerebat, suo contemptu polluant quantum in se est & contumelia afficiant.” Quoted in Raitt, Jill, The Eucharistic Theology of Theodore Beza (Chambersburg, Penn.: American Academy of Religion, 1972), 27.Google Scholar Beza also claimed that the improper use of images caused his abandonment of the Church of Rome; see Nugent, Donald, Ecumenism in the Age of Reform: The Colloquy of Poissy (Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press, 1974), 193Google Scholar. See also Sutherland, N. M., The Huguenot Struggle for Recognition (New Haven, Conn.: Yale University Press, 1980), 124.Google Scholar

16. Christin, Olivier, Une révolution symbolique: l'iconodasme huguenot et la reconstruction catholique (Paris: Les Editions de Minuit, 1991), 171Google Scholar. A number of contemporary scholars, including Christin, discuss the extensive bibliography associated with image breaking in the sixteenth century; a useful survey of this phenomenon also emerges from the collection of essays edited by Scribner, R. W. and Warnke, N., entitled Bilder und Bildersturm im Spätmittelalter (Wiesbaden: Wolfenbütteler Forschungen 46, 1990)Google Scholar. Holt's, Mack P. “Putting Religion Back into the Wars of Religion,” French Historical Studies 18 (1993): 524–51 concentrates on the varying interpretations of what occurred in France.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

17. Jones, William R., “Art and Christian Piety: Iconoclasm in Medieval Europe” in Gutmann, 88Google Scholar, and O'Connell, Michael, The Idolatrous Eye (New York: Oxford University Press, 200), 50: “Seemingly disparate Reformation challenges to images … are themselves interconnected to their underlying target, the incarnational structure of latemedieval religion.”Google Scholar

18. Ibid., 172–73. The differing teleologies of medieval exempla are surveyed in Jennings, Margaret, “Lucan's Medieval Popularity: The Exemplum Tradition,” Revista di Cultura Classica e Mediovale 16 (1974): 215–18.Google Scholar

19. Jones, 89, and O'Connell, 47. A concise review of the changes in Eucharistic theology that precipitated Reformation iconoclasm appears in White's, Susan J. article, “Eucharist, History of, in the West,” in The New Dictionary of Sacramental Worship, ed. Fink, Peter E., S.J. (Collegeville, Minn.: Liturgical Press, 1990), 416–20.Google Scholar

20. Freedberg, David, Iconoclasts and Their Motives (Montclair, N.J.: Maarssen, Gary Schwartz, 1985), 37; the ubiquity of images is a point made by nearly every commentator on Reformation iconoclasm. For a succinct discussion of the function of images as expressed in the watershed Summa theologiae of Saint Thomas Aquinas, see Wandel, 46–47.Google Scholar

21. Christin, Olivier, “Iconographie de l'iconoclasme,” Actes de la recherche en sciences sociales 75 (1988): 53Google Scholar, and Christin, , Révolution, 174.Google Scholar

22. The clearest definition of practical theology is in Viladesau, Richard, Theological Aesthetics: God in Imagination, Beauty, and Art (New York: Oxford University Press, 1999), 37: “Practical theologies are directed to society at largeCrossRefGoogle Scholar. For their operative norm they take praxis (practical action informed by and informing theory). Responsible commitment to this norm and/or involvement in the situation of praxis is the supreme value. Such theologies emphasize ‘the good’ in its relation to the holy or to religious experience. They involve the disciplines of ethics and politics, as related to transforming faith/praxis. Their theological discourse involves the critique of ideology and (at times) the proposal of a future ideal.” See also Wandel, 23–24.

23. Wandel, 3.

24. Van Ackeren, G. F., “History of Theology,” in New Catholic Encyclopedia, (New York: McGraw-Hill, 1967), 14:47.Google Scholar

25. “Une volonté pédagogico-démonstrative et d'une aspiration à la restauration de la gloire de Dieu polluée par les abominations papistiques.” Crouzet, Denis, La Genèse de la Réfornte Française, 1520–1560 (Paris: Sedes, 1996), 381.Google Scholar

26. Wandel, 2 and 10.

27. Ibid., 11.

28. Ibid., 192–98.

29. Eire, Carlos N. M., War Against the Idols (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1986), 296CrossRefGoogle Scholar, and Holt, Mack P., The French Wars of Religion, 1562–1629 (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1995), 2.CrossRefGoogle Scholar “Pollution” as a cause of religious violence is treated extensively by Zemon Davis, Natalie, “The Rites of Violence,” in her Society and Culture in Early Modern France (Stanford, Calif.: Stanford University Press, 1975), 157ff. Eire, 308, discusses idolatry as “a social phenomenon, as something that needs to be wiped out from the body politic.”Google Scholar

30. O'Connell, 59–60, and Mentzer, Raymond A., “The Reformed Churches of France and the Visual Arts,” in Seeing Beyond the Word, ed. Finney, P., 207.Google Scholar

31. Réau, Louis, Histoire du Vandalisme (Paris: Laffont, 1994), 104.Google Scholar Note that Nicolas Catherinot's account was not published until 1684, more than a century after the event. Later narratives, especially Raynal's, LouisHistoire de Berry depuis les plus anciens jusqu'à on 1789, 4 vols. (Bourges: n.p., 1844–1846), are based on Catherinot.Google Scholar

32. Giles Chavet's Journal is currently unavailable and probably has been destroyed. An extract from it, describing events at Bourges, appears in the first edition of Glaumeau's Journal, with an introduction and notes by President Hiver (Bourges: n.p., 1867). A useful assessment of both texts and Catherinot's Le siège appears in New Smith, Ann, Twelfth Century Sculpture and the Cathedral of Bourges (Ph.D. diss., Boston University, 1974), 16, note 10.Google Scholar

33. Reau, 105.

34. Crouzet, , Guerriers, 540.Google Scholar

35. Boinet, Amadee, La Cathédrale de Bourges (Paris: Henri Laurens, n.d.), 19–20Google Scholar, vividly describes the sack of the cathedral; see also Christin, , Revolution, 167–69.Google Scholar

36. This hymn (quoted in Crouzet, 537) is adapted from Psalm 124; it opines, “If the heavenly power were not with us, if the Lord did not help his people, then there would have been no hope of change.” Psalm 124 was very popular with the Huguenots and was sung at Bourges to rally coreligionists; see Reid, W. Stanford, “The Battle Hymns of the Lord: Calvinist Psalmody of the Sixteenth Century,” Sixteenth Century Essays and Studies 2 (1971): 47.Google Scholar

37. Ibid., 538. So heedless of their own safety were some of the participants that they were killed by falling statuary; see Feld, Helmut, Der Ikonoklasmus des Westens (Leiden: Brill, 1990), 186.Google Scholar

38. Bayard, 118ff.

39. Ribault, 111. Cf. Gauchery, Paul, “Restes de l'ancien jubé de la cathédrale de Bourges,” Mémoires de la Société des Antiauaires du Centre 38 (1917–1918): 63–100Google Scholar, and Joubert, Fabienne, Le Jubé de Bourges (Paris: R. M. N. [Les Dossiers du Musée du Louvre], 1994).Google Scholar

40. Ribault, 112. The elements in Eucharistic theology that were despised by Calvinism are explained in Fink, Peter E., “Eucharist, Theology of” in Sacramental Worship, ed. Fink, , 435–37.Google Scholar

41. Schaff, Philip, The Creeds of Christendom, (New York: Harper, 1877), 1:462Google Scholar, and Milner, Benjamin C., Calvin's Doctrine of the Church (Leiden: Brill, 1970), 134.Google Scholar

42. Iserloh, Erwin and others, Reformation and Counter-Reformation in History of the Church, (New York: Seabury, 1980), 5:393.Google Scholar

43. Milner, 138.

44. Wandel, 137f. Cf. Alastair, Duke, Reformation and Revolt in the Low Countries (London: Hambledon, 1990), 41 and 43.Google Scholar

45. Restoration work on the figures representing souls rising from their tombs indicates that they also were damaged, but not when this occurred. Centuries of weathering as well as the French Revolution may share responsibility with sixteenth-century iconoclasm for their decayed state. See Bayard, 136, and plates XX and XXI.

46. Milner, 137.

47. Iserloh, 393.

48. Oberman, Heiko A., The Impact of the Reformation (Grand Rapids, Mich.: Eerdmans, 1994), 244.Google Scholar

49. Duke, 42.

50. New Smith, 18, note 12.

51. Réau, 53. Louis VII was crowned King of France in this edifice in 1137.

52. The correct translation is “A young woman shall conceive.” See Oberman, Heiko A., The Roots of Anti-Semitism, trans. Porter, James I. (Philadelphia, Penn.: Fortress, 1984), 83.Google Scholar

53. New Smith, 108.

54. Ibid., 17.

55. Ibid. We are not suggesting any negation of the importance of the Word in Huguenot belief and practice.

56. Diefendorf, Barbara, Beneath the Cross (New York: Oxford University Press. 1991), 178Google Scholar, and Benedict, Philip, Rouen During the Wars of Religion (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1981), 239.Google Scholar

57. Greengrass, Mark, The Longman Companion to the European Reformation, 1500–1610 (London: Longman, 1998), 15Google Scholar. See also Larreille, A. and others, Histoire du Catholicisme en France, (Paris: Editions Spes, 1960), 2:167–68.Google Scholar

58. Moreau, E. and others, La Crise religieuse du xvième Siècle in Histoire de l'Élise, (Paris: Bloud et Gay, 1950), 16:276.Google Scholar

59. Godineau, G., “Statuts synodaux inedites du Diocèse de Bourges,” Revue d'Histoire de l'Élise de France 72 (1986): 51; also Latreille, 172.Google Scholar

60. Moreau, 249–70.

61. Benedict, 236: Benedict describes Calvinism's growth (235–38) as a “mass movement”; see also Eire, 296.

62. Eire, 310: “Instead of being called upon to overturn statues and altars, Christians were now being called upon to overturn governments.”

63. In Knox, John, On Rebellion, ed. Mason, Roger A. (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1994), 95.Google Scholar See also The Political Writings of John Knox, ed. Breslow, Marvin A. (Washington, D.C.: Folger Books, 1985), 10.Google Scholar

64. Duffy, Eamon, The Stripping of the Altars (New Haven, Conn.: Yale University Press 1992), 565–69.Google Scholar

65. O'Connell, 60, and Duffy, 571.

66. Eire, 281.

67. Calvin's truncated reference to resistance has occasioned considerable scholarly controversy. McNeill's, John T. “The Democratic Element in Calvin's Thought,” Church History 18 (1949): 153–71CrossRefGoogle Scholar discusses the Institute's book IV, chapter 20, section 31 clearly, but with a proresistance bias. Brief but helpful are the comments of H.A. Lloyd, “Calvin and the Duty of Guardians to Resist,” and Stein, Peter, “Calvin and the Duty of Guardians to Resist: A Comment,” both published in the Journal of Ecclesiastical History 32 (1981): 65–67 and 69–70.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

68. Viret is unequivocal in L'Interim fait par dialogues, ed. Mermier, Guy R. (New York: Peter Lang, 1985), Dialogue Six, 249–50: “ne de rompre les autels et les images … sinon la où Dieu leur en à donné seigneurie.”Google Scholar

69. Bavaud, Georges, Le Réformateur Pierre Viret, Histoire et Société 10 (Geneva: Labor et Fides, 1986), 340, and Eire, 292–93.Google Scholar

70. Eire, 294, and Benedict, 237.

71. Benedict, 66.

72. Monter, William, Judging the French Revolution (Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press, 1999), 221–29.Google Scholar

73. Crew, Phyllis Mack, Calvinist Preaching and Iconoclasm in the Netherlands, 1544–1569 (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1978), 141.Google Scholar

74. Benedict, 67.

75. Holt, 3.

76. Ibid., 44. Alastair Duke terms the political agitation of the Huguenots “sedition,” in his “Perspectives on International Calvinism” in Calvinism in Europe, 1540–1620, ed. Andrew, Pettegree (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1994), 17.Google Scholar

77. Garrisson, Janine, A History of Sixteenth Century France: Renaissance, Reformation and Rebellion, 1483–1598, trans. Rex, Richard (New York: St. Martin's, 1995), 332–36.Google Scholar

78. Benedict, 239.

79. Holt, 46–48.

80. Greengrass, Mark, The French Reformation (Oxford: Blackwells, 1987), 67.Google Scholar

81. Garrisson, 270.

82. Greengrass, , Reformation, 67: “The aim of the civil war, however it was dressed up, was to seize power.” Cf., Garrison, 340–41.Google Scholar

83. Branner, Robert, The Cathedral of Bourges and Its Place in Gothic Architecture, ed. Branner, Shirley Praeger (Cambridge, Mass.: MIT Press, 1989), 8–9.Google Scholar

84. Devailly, Guy, Le Diocèse de Bourges (Paris: Letouzey et Ane, n.d.), 46.Google Scholar

85. The selective nature of the iconoclasm on the south portal has been discussed by Amadee Boinet (ibid.) and further amplified in Christin, , Révolution, 169–70Google Scholar, and in Christin, , “Iconographie,” 52–53.Google Scholar

86. Freedberg, 32.

87. Calvin, John, Institutes of the Christian Religion, ed. McNeill, John T. and trans. Battles, Ford Lewis (Philadelphia, Penn.: Westminster, 1960)Google Scholar, book I, chapter ii, sections 1–4 and 9–10, 99–105, and 109–10. Also, book II, chapter 8, sections 16–17, 381–84. See also, Christin, , “Iconographie,” 53.Google Scholar

88. Christin, ibid.; Christin's article (51) includes excellent illustrations from the spandrels, which he discusses on 52.

89. Crouzet, , Guerriers, 527, identifies iconoclasm with war against the tyranny of “princes étrangers.” Cf. Freedberg, 17.Google Scholar

90. Freedberg, 25.

91. Freedberg, David, “The Structure of Byzantine and European Iconoclasm” in Iconoclasm, ed. Anthony, Bryer and Judith, Herrin (Birmingham, England: University Press, Center for Byzantine Studies, 1977), 169.Google Scholar

92. Crew, 160.

93. Schreckenberg, Heinz, The Jews in Christian Art (New York: Continuum, 1996), 15.Google Scholar

94. Ibid., and 149 and 192.

95. Ribault, 94–99.

96. Brugger, Laurence, “Hebraii dicunt: le soubassement de la façade occidentale de la cathédrale de Bourges,” Cahiers archaèologique 41 (1993): 135–37Google Scholar; also Margaret, Jennings, “Prophecy in Glass and Stone: Jewish Influences on the Cathedral of Bourges,” in Insights and Interpretations, ed. Colum, Hourihane (Princeton, N.J.: Index of Christian Art/Princeton University Press, 2002), 182–210.Google Scholar

97. Schreckenberg, 163, 165, and 174.

98. Ribault, 91.

99. Baumgartner, Frederic J., France in the Sixteenth Century (New York: St. Martin's, 1995), 135.Google Scholar

100. Israel, Jonathan I., European Jewry in the Age of Mercantilism, 1550–1750 (Oxford: Clarendon, 1985), 36.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

101. Edwards, Mark U., “Against the Jews,” in Essential Papers on Judaism and Christianity in Conflict, ed. Jeremy, Cohen (New York: New York University Press, 1991), 357–58.Google Scholar

102. Edwards, John, The Jews in Christian Europe, 1400–1700 (London: Routledge, 1988), 62.Google Scholar

103. Benbassa, Esther, The Jews of France (Princeton, N.J.: Princeton University Press, 1999), 22–25.Google Scholar

104. Jordan, William C., The French Monarchy and the Jews (Philadelphia, Penn.: University of Pennsylvania Press, 1989), 256.CrossRefGoogle Scholar Cf. Chazan, Robert, Medieval Jewry in Northern France (Baltimore, Md.: Johns Hopkins University Press, 1973), 194,Google Scholar and Bourdrel, Philippe, Histoire des Juifs en France (Paris: Albin Michel, 1974), 67.Google Scholar

105. Blumenkranz, Bernhard, “Anti-Jewish Polemics and Legislation in the Middle Ages: Literary Fiction or Reality?” The Journal of Jewish Studies 15 (1964): 129.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

106. Rasmussen, Tarald, “Jacob Perez of Valencia's Tractatus contra Judeos (1484) in the Light of Medieval Anti-Jewish Traditions,” in Augustine, the Harvest, and Theology, ed. Kenneth, Hagen (Leiden: Brill, 1990), 42.Google Scholar

107. Oberman, , Impact, 139.Google Scholar

108. Schreckenberg, 14.

109. Ibid., 226; cf., 235.

110. Blumenkranz, Bernhard, Le Juif médiéval au mirroir de l'art Chrétien (Paris: Études Augustiniennes, 1966), 69.Google Scholar

111. Ibid., 84–115; in fact, scenes depicting Christ's Passion as well as those portraying the stoning of Stephen had been stridently and consistently anti-Jewish from the twelfth century onward; see Schreckenberg, 145 and 157–89.

112. Schreckenberg, 253–55.

113. Ibid., 257–76.

114. Blumenkranz, 44–46, and Schreckenberg, 241 and 244–45.

115. Schreckenberg, 182–83.

116. Ibid., 195 and 157.

117. Ibid., 155.

118. For a discussion of the Jewish ring and other distinguishing, external marks of Judaism in the Middle Ages, see Therese, and Metzger, Mendel, Jewish Life in the Middle Ages (New York: Alpine Fine Arts Collection, 1982); also see Schreckenberg, 118 and 140–41.Google Scholar

119. Schreckenberg, 110–11 and 120.

120. Ibid., 122–24.

121. Oberman, , Roots, 22.Google Scholar

122. Ibid., 81, 84–85, and 92.

123. Jordan, 254. For discussions of the multifaceted accusations of Jews by Christians see Mark Edwards, 373, and John Edwards, 11–12.

124. Stow, Kenneth R., Catholic Thought and Papal Jewry Policy, 1555–1593 (New York: Jewish Theological Society, 1977), 3.Google Scholar

125. Ibid., 13 and 63.

126. Israel, 67.

127. Nahon, Gerard, “La nation juive portugaise en France, xvi^ème–xviii^ème siècle: Espaces et Pourvoirs,” Revue des Études Juives, 153 (1994): 356–57CrossRefGoogle Scholar. Henri Hauser's emphasis on inflation as a destabilizer of social equilibrium is marginalized in Crouzet, , Genèse, 482.Google Scholar

128. Greengrass, Mark, “The Anatomy of a Religious Riot in Toulouse in May 1562,” Journal of Ecclesiastical History 34 (1983): 367–91.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

129. Szapiro, Elie, “Le Sud-Ouest,” in Histoire des juifs en France, ed. Bernhard, Blumenkranz (Toulouse: Privat, 1972), 222–23 and 229–30.Google Scholar