Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-t5tsf Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-13T00:46:48.549Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Archbishop Ebbo of Reims (816–835): A Study in the Carolingian Empire and Church

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  28 July 2009

Peter R. McKeon
Peter R. McKeon
Affiliation:
associate professor of history in the University of Illinois, Chicago Circle.
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

It is almost a commonplace that the ideology and circumstances of the Carolingian empire made possible assertion by the Frankish episcopacy of an increasingly active role in the government of ninth-century Frankish Europe. Restoration of the ecclesiastical hierarchy begun in the mid-eighth century by Pepin the Short and completed under his son, the emperor Charles, resulted in the establishment of a class of able men whose common interests were closely bound up with preservation and extension of the imperial structure; in the reign of Charles' successors this group came to be involved more and more prominently in the workings of the empire, as events in the forty years following Charles' death necessitated rapid reinterpretation of that entity. In that process no member of the hierarchy played a more ubiquitous part than did Ebbo, archbishop of Reims from 816 until his deposition nineteen years later. Loyal to the principles of imperial rule while at the same time betrayer of the friendship and fealty owed his monarch, Ebbo was scholar, builder, missionary, high public official, rebel and outcast during a career inextricably bound up with the course and transmutations of the empire. In the range of his activities and influence almost a paradigm of those opportunities and tasks open to the Carolingian episcopate, his history is in no small measure that of the empire itself and of the church with which in the ninth century that empire was conceived to be coextensive, even identical. It is those two histories and their interrelations that form the subject of the present paper.

Type
Research Article
Information
Church History , Volume 43 , Issue 4 , December 1974 , pp. 437 - 447
Copyright
Copyright © American Society of Church History 1974

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

BML: Böhmer, J.F. and Mühlbacher, M., Die Regesten des Kaiserrcichs unter den Karolingent, 751–918, 2d ed., revised by Lechner, J.(Innsbruck, 1908).Google Scholar

JE: Jaffé, P. et al. , Regesta pontificum Romanorum, 24 ed., vol. 1 (Leipzig, 1881).Google Scholar

MGH: Monurnenta Germaniae historica. ed. G. Pertz et al. (Hanover, 1826 ff.Google Scholar), with the series used as follows: Cap: Capitularia regum Francorum: Cone: Concilia; Epp: Epistolac; Form: Formulae; Poet. lat.: Poetae latina; SS: Scripiores; SS rer, Germ: Scriptores rerum Germanicarum in usum scholarum.

PL: Migne, J. P., ed., Patrologia latina (Paris, 1844 ff.)Google Scholar

1. Thegan, Vita Hludowici, a. 44, in Rau, R., ed., Quellen zur Karolingischen Reichsgeschichte 1 (Darmstadt, 1955): 240Google Scholar; Flodoard. Historia ecclesiae Remensis, 2, c. 19, in MGH SS, 13, 467; MGH Poet. lat., 2, 93. On Ebbo, see especially Rïckert, H., De Ebonis archiepiscopi Remensis vita (n. p., 1844); Nouvelle biographie générale 15 (Paris, 1856): 592–593Google Scholar; Histoire littéraire de la France 5 (Paris, 1866): 100–104Google Scholar; Biographic nationale … de Belgigue 5 (Brussels, 1876) 445–447Google Scholar; Biographic universelle 12 (Paris, nd.): 191–192;Google ScholarAllgemeine Deutsche Biographie 48 (Berlin, 1904): 242–248Google Scholar; Neue Deutsche Biographie 4 (Berlin, 1957): 268–269Google Scholar; Lexicon für Theologie und Kirche 3 (Freiburg-i-B., 1959): 621–622Google Scholar; Dictionnaire d'histaire et de geographie ecclésiastique 14 (Paris, 1960): 1270–1274Google Scholar; New Catholic Encyclopedia 5 (New York, 1967): 26Google Scholar; Dictionnaire de biographie francaise 12 (Paris, 1970): 1087–1089.Google Scholar

2. Annales regni Francorum, in Rau, 1:40.

3. Charles the Bald, Epistolae, ni. 5, in PL, 124, 871C.

4. On the coronation of 816, see Kleinclaucz, A., L'empire carolingien (Paris, 1903), pp. 284 ff.Google Scholar; Mohr, W., “Reichspolitik und Kaiserkrönung in den Jahren 813 und 816”, Die Welt als Geschichte 20 (1960)Google Scholar; Ullmann, W., The Growth of Papal Government in the Middle Ages, 2d ed. (London, 1962), pp. 143 ffGoogle Scholar. Stephen, Regarding and Ebbo, , MGH Poet. lat., 2, 93.Google Scholar

5. Duchesne, L., Fastes épiseopaux de l'ancienne Gaule, 2d ed. (Paris, 1907–1915), 3, 87.Google Scholar

6. Ibid.

7. Charles the Bald, Epistolae, no. 5, in PL, 124, 871C-872A.

8. Duchesne, 3, 81. For a reconstruction of the building, see Boussinesq, G. and Laurent, G., Histoire de Reims depuis les origines jusqu'd nos jours, 1: Reims ancien (Reims, 1933), p. 307.Google Scholar

9. Sickel, Th., Regesten der Urkunden der ersten Karolinger (751–340) (Vienna, 1867), pp. 150–151, 329–331Google Scholar; Flodoard, Hi.storia, 2, c. 19, pp. 468–469; 4, c. 8, pp. 573. See Vorcauteren, F., Etude sur les “civitates” de la Belgiquc Seconde (Brussels, 1934), pp. 63, 75Google Scholar; Diationnaire d'archéologie chrétien, et de liturgie, 142, 2243, 2253–2254.

10. A reconstruction in Boussinesq, and Laurent, , Histoire de Reims, 1: 307.Google Scholar

11. MGH Poet. lat., 2, 350–351.

12. MGH Epp., 5, 617, of ca. 830.

13. Boshoff, B., Agobard, Erzbischof von Lyon (Cologne, 1969), pp. 216 ff.Google Scholar

14. Agobard, Epistolae, no. 14, in MGH Epp., 5, 222–223.

15. Aubert, G., “Manuserit de l'abbaye d'Hautvillers dit Evangeliaire d'Ebon,” Mémoires de la Société des Antiquaires de France, 4th ser., t. 10 (t. 40 of the collection), (1879): 111–127Google Scholar; Dictionnaire d'archélogie chrétien et de liturgie, 142, 1697–1703. See the dedicatory verse, reproduced in MGH Poet. lat., 1, 623–624.

16. On Carolingian missionary activity, see Sullivan, B., “The Carolingian Missionary and the Pagan”, Speculum 28 (1953): 705–740.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

17. Ermoldus Nigellus, In honorem Hludowici, 4, 11. 1961 ff., in E. Faral, ed. (Paris, 1932); Annales regni Francorum, p. 136.

18. I, Paschal, Epistolo, in MGH Epp., 5, 69–70Google Scholar (JE, 2553); Epistolae variorum, no. 16, at MGH Epp., 6, 163.

19. Simson, B., Jahrbücher des fränkischen Reichs unter Ludwig dem Frommen (Leipzig, 1874–1876), 1, 208 f.Google Scholar; Annoics lantenses, in MGH SS rer. Germ., 12, 6.

20. Simson, 1, 210, 211.

21. Rimbert, Vita Anskarii, cs. 12.14, in MGH SS rer. Germ., 9, 34–36.

22. See in general Lesne, E., La hiérarchie épiscopale (Paris, 1905).Google Scholar

23. MGH Cap., 1, 360. Precisely what assembly is uncertain.

24. MGH Cone., 22, 597, 600, 605.

25. Ibid., pp. 684, 698.

26. Flodoard, , Historia, 2, e. 19, pp. 470–471.Google Scholar

27. MGH Cap., 1, no. 151, on p. 308; MGH Form., Formulae imperiales, no. 45, p. 321.

28. On the imperialist party in these years, see Ganshof, F. L., “Louis the Pious Reconsidered”, in The Carolingians and the Frankish Monarchy (Ithaca, 1971), pp. 261–272.Google Scholar

29. MGH Cap., 1, no. 172, pp. 353–355.

30. Ibid., no. 136, pp. 270–273. See Ganshof, F. L., “Some Observations on the Ordinatio imperii of 817”, in The Carolingians and the Frankish Monarchy, pp. 273–288.Google Scholar

31. Astronomer, , Vita Hludowici, e. 31,Google Scholar in Ran, 1:306.

32. Annales regni Francorum, p. 118.

33. See Halphen, L., Charlemagne et l'empire carolingien, 2d ed. (Paris, 1968), pp. 219 ff.Google Scholar

34. Annales Bertiniani, cd. Grat, F. et al. , Annales de Saint-Bertin (Paris, 1964), pp. 1–3Google Scholar; compare Annales Mettenses priores, in MGH SS rer. Germ., 10, 95 ff.

35. Nithard, Historiae librL iv, 1, c. 3, in Rau, 1: 388–392.

36. Auzias, L., L'Aquitaine carolingien (Toulouse-Paris, 1937), pp. 104 ff.Google Scholar; Nithard, Historiae, 1, c. 3. pp. 390–392.

37. See Chaume, M., Les origines du duche de Bouryogne (Dijon, 1925–1937), 1, 156–157.Google Scholar

38. Annales Bertiniani, p. 8; Annales Xantenses, p. 9.

39. Annales Bertiniani, pp. 9–10; Astronomer, , Vita Hludowici, c. 49, pp. 342–346.Google Scholar

40. Thus, for example, MGH Cap., 2, 4–6; Agobard, Epistolae, no. 15, p. 224.

41. See Arquillière, H.-X., L'Augusfinisme politique, 2d ed. (Paris, 1955), pp. 72 ff.Google Scholar

42. See for example, Ganshof, F. L., “The Church and the Royal Power in the Frankich Monarchy under Pippin III and Charlemagne”, in The Carolingians and the Frankish Monarchy, pp. 206–207.Google Scholar

43. Charles the Bald, Epistolae, no. 5, in PL, 124, 872A-B.

44. Compare n. 58, below.

45. MGH Cap., 2, no. 197, pp. 51–55. See especially Halpen, L.,“La penitence de Louis le Pieux à Saint-Médard de Soissons”, in A travers l'histoire du Moyen Age (Paris, 1950), pp. 58–66Google Scholar; Arquiflière, L'Augustinisme politique. pp. 122 ff.

46. See, for example, Ullmann, W., The Carolingian Renaissance and the Idea of Kingship (London, 1968), p. 68.Google Scholar

47. See n. 41, above.

48. MGH Cap., 2, 55.

49. Ibid., p. 53.

50. Thus, ibid., p. 54, and so forth.

51. Ibid., pp. 51–52.

52. Ibid. Compare this passage with MGH Cap., 1, no. 137, p. 274, of Louis the Pious.

53. Annales Xanfenses, ann. 827, p. 7.

54. Compare PL, 124, 872B-C with Mansi, J. D., ed., Sacrorum conciliorum nova et amplissma collectio (Venice, 1759 ff.), 15, 792C.Google Scholar The flight was the subject of a picture by David, reproduced by Boussinesq and Laurent, 1:177.

55. Epistolae Fuldensium fragmenta, MCH Epp., 5, 520–521.

56. For the assembly at Thionville, MGH Conc., 22, no. 55, pp.696–703.

57. Annales Bertiniani, pp. 16–17.

58. PL, 124, 873A-B.

59. MGH Cap., 2, no. 199, p. 55; MGH Cone., 22, 702–703. The bishops were Aiulfus of Bourges, Modoinus of Autun and Baradus of Paderborn.

60. Epistola synodica concilii Tricassini, in Mansi, , Sacrorum conciliorum nova et amplissima collectio, 15Google Scholar, 793B-C; MGH Cone., 22, 807.

61. BML, no. 1014c.

62. Lo', F. and Halphen, L., le règne de Charles le Chauve 1 (Paris, 1909): 13 ff.Google Scholar

63. BML, no. 995a.

64. Concilium Ingelhcimense, MGH Cone., 22, no. 61. pp. 791–814.

65. Apologelici Eboni forna prior, MGR Cone., 22, 797–798.

66. Annales Bertiniani, p. 66.

67. Lot and Halphen, 1:32–36: Pietzcker, F., “Die Schlaeht bei Fontenoy 841”, Zeitschrift für Rechtsgeschichte 81 (1964): 318–340.Google Scholar

68. Hinemar, of Reims, , Epistolae, no. 186,Google ScholarMGH Epp., 81, 192.

69. Nithard, , Historlae, 3, c. 5. pp. 438–442Google Scholar; compare 4, c. 3, pp. 450–452.

70. Annales Bertiniani, pp. 44–45.

71. On the “rule of fraternal concord” see, for example, Doizé, J., “Le gouvernement con- fraternal des fils de Louis le Pieux et l'unité de l'empire (843–855),” Le Moyen Age 2 (1898): 253–285.Google Scholar

72. Annales Bertiniani, pp. 45–46. On Drogo see Pfister, C., “L'archévéque de Metz, Drogon”, Mélanges Paul Fabre (Paris, 1902), pp. 101–140.Google Scholar

73. See Ulimaun, , The Growth of Papal Government, pp. 64 ff.Google Scholar

74. Ibid., pp. 102 ff.

75. BML, no. 1018a. See the discussion at Ullmann, , The Growth of Papal Government, pp. 150 ff.Google Scholar

76. BML, no. 1021. On the Constitutio Roanana compare Ullmann, W., “The Origins of the Ottonianum,” Cambridge Historical Journal 11 (1953–1955); 114–128CrossRefGoogle Scholar with the discussions of Bertolini, , “Osservazioni sulle ‘Constitutio Romana’ e sul ‘Sacramentum’”, Studi A. de Stefano (Palermo, 1956), pp. 43–78Google Scholar and Zimmerman, H., “Das Privilegium Ottonianum von 962 und seine Problemgesehichte”, Mitteilungen des instituts für österreichische Geschichtsforschung 20 (1962): 147–190.Google Scholar

77. Annalas regni. Francorum, pp. 173–174.

78. As appears in Astronomer, Vita Hludowici, c. 55, pp. 358–360.

79. Annales Bertiniani, pp. 45–46.

80. Thus, see Paeudo-Liutprandus, , Liber de pontificum Bomanorum vitis, in PL, 129, 1244C.Google Scholar

81. Annales Bertiniani, p. 46.

82. Liber pontificalis, ed. L. Duehesne, Le Liber Pontificalis (Paris, 1886), 2, 90.Google Scholar

83. Sergius II, Epistoiae, no. 1, in MGH Epp., 5, 583–584 (JE, 2586).

84. MGH Cap., 2, 112.

85. Ibid., no. 291, p. 385.

86. Ibid.

87. MGH Epp., 81, 1–2, 209. On Hinemar of Heims see especially Schrörs, H., Hinkmar, Erzbischof von Reims (Freiburg-i-B., 1884).Google Scholar

88. MGH Epp., 81, 181, 210. See on all Lesne, E.,“Hincmar et l'empereur Lothaire,” Revue des questions historiques 78 (1905): 5–58.Google Scholar

89. Flodoard, Historic, 2, c. 19, in MGH SS, 13, 475–476; MGH Epp., 81, 210. Compare Narratio clericorum Remensium, at MGH Cone., 22, 812.

90. Mansi, , Sacrorum conciliorum nova et amplissima collectio, 15, 794A.Google Scholar

91. Catalogue episcoporurm Hildesheirnensium, MGH SS, 13, 747: Concilium Moguntinum, MGH Cap., 2, 173; Rabanus Maurus, Epitolae, no. 56, MGH Epp., 5, 514. The dates and order of these events are unclear. Compare for example, Mansi, , Sacrorum conciliorum nova et amplissima collectio, 15, 794A–795A.Google Scholar It was later alleged that Ebbo had been restored to orders by Gerogry IV (see the letter ascribed to the pope, in MGH Epp., 5, 82–84 [JE, 2583, 2585], with which compare Narratio clericorum Remensium, in MGH Cone., 22, 810–811, where the circumstance is placed earlier), but this forged document was apparently seen only in 867 (thus Hincmar of Reims, Epistolae, no. 200, in MGH Epp., 81, 224).

92. MGH Epp., 81, 219.