Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-hc48f Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-27T13:34:23.463Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Gustavo Juan Franceschi and the Jews: The Overcoming of Prejudice by an Argentine Prelate

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  28 July 2009

Allan Metz
Allan Metz
Affiliation:
Assistant professor and reference librarian in Drury College, Springfield, Missouri.
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

This article seeks to demonstrate how Monsignor Gustavo Juan Franceschi (1871–1957) became a friend of the newly created state of Israel when only twenty years earlier he had maintained that Jews constituted Argentina's major political problem. This intellectual transformation will be traced through a consideration of Franceschi's writings about the Jews. As a prominent member of the Catholic church and a strong advocate of Argentine nationalism, his views also reflected the generally ambivalent and suspicious attitude which that powerful institution held regarding Jews. However, following the devastation of European Jewry during World War II and the creation of the state of Israel in 1948, Franceschi's opinion of Jews moderated, resulting in greater understanding. Before presenting Franceschi's views, a consideration of Argentine Catholic nationalism will be provided in order to place these opinions within a proper context.

Type
Research Article
Information
Church History , Volume 62 , Issue 2 , June 1993 , pp. 207 - 220
Copyright
Copyright © American Society of Church History 1993

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1. Burdick, M., “For God and the Fatherland: Religion and Politics in Argentina” (Ph.D. diss., Univ. of California, Santa Barbara, 1991), p. 44.Google Scholar

2. Rock, D., “Intellectual Precursors of Conservative Nationalism in Argentina, 1900–1927,” Hispanic American Historical Review 67:2 (1987): 299.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

3. For more detail on the tragic week, see Mirelman, V., “The Semana Tragica of 1919 and the Jews in Argentina,” Jewish Social Studies 37:1 (1975): 61–73;Google ScholarMetz, A., “Despues de la ‘Semana Trágica’: los intelectuales argentinos y la encuesta de opinión de ‘Vida Nuestra’ de 1919,” Coloquio 20 (1989): 65–109.Google Scholar

4. Rock, , “Intellectual Precursors,” p. 299.Google Scholar

5. Snow, P., Political Forces in Argentina (Westport, Conn., 1979), p. 106.Google Scholar

6. Ibid., p. 106–107.

7. Zurretti, J., Una nueva historia eclesiástica Argentina (Buenos Aires, 1972), p. 410.Google ScholarParaphrased in Burdick, “For God and the Fatherland,” p. 50.Google Scholar

8. Pico, C., Una carta a Jacques Maritain (Buenos Aires, 1935). Paraphrased in Burdick, “For God and the Fatherland,” p. 50.Google Scholar

9. Burdick, , “For God and the Fatherland,” pp. 44–51.Google ScholarThe Uriburu quotation is on page 51.Google Scholar

10. Ibid., pp. 68–69.

11. Meinvielle, J., El judío (Buenos Aires, 1936).Google Scholar

12. Gerarsi, M. Navarra, Los nacionalistas, trans. Ciria, A. (Buenos Aires, 1967), p. 117.Google Scholar

13. Franceschi, G. J., “Como se prepara una revolución,” Criterio 289 (14 09 1933): 30;Google ScholarSenkman, L., “El nacionalismo argentino y los judíos,” Nueva Presencia, 3 09 1977, p. 6.Google Scholar

14. Gerarsi, M. Navarra, Los nacionalistas, p. 117.Google Scholar

15. For more on the crisis of Argentine liberalism, see Senkman, L., La identidad judía en la literatura argentina (Buenos Aires, 1983), pp. 199–224.Google Scholar

16. Wast, H., Buenos Aires, futura Babilonia (Buenos Aires, 1935);Google ScholarWast, H., El Kahal/Oro (Santiago, Chile, 1935).Google Scholar

17. Franceschi, G. J., review of El Kahal/Oro, by Wast, H., in Criterio 382 (27 06 1935): 203–204.Google Scholar

18. Senkman, , “El nacionalismo,” p. 6.Google Scholar

19. New Catholic Encyclopedia, 18 vols., 1967, s.v. “Franceschi, Gustavo Juan,” vol. 6;Google ScholarSantillán, D. Abad de, Gran enciclopedia argentma, 8 vols. (Buenos Aires, 1956), 3: 387–388.Google Scholar

20. Israel vistopor ojos argentinos (Buenos Aires, 1960), p. 66.Google Scholar

21. Kennedy, J., Catholicism, Nationalism, and Democracy in Argentina (Notre Dame, Ind., 1938), p. 177.Google Scholar

22. Ibid., p. 180.

23. Cole, G. D. H. and Cole, M., A Guide to Modern Politics (New York, 1934), p. 63.Google Scholar

24. Franceschi, G. J., Totalitarismo, liberalismo, catolicismo (Buenos Aires, 1940), p. 82.Google ScholarCitations in notes 24–33 are quoted and/or paraphrased in Gerarsi, M. Navarra, “Argentine Nationalism of the Right: The History of an Ideological Development, 1930–1946” (Ph.D. diss., Columbia University, 1964), pp. 108–110.Google ScholarFranceschi, G. J., Totalitarismo, liberalismo, catolicismo, p. 34.Google Scholar

25. Ibid., p. 36.

26. Criterio 253 (5 Jan. 1933): 261.Google Scholar

27. Criterio 290 (21 Sept. 1933): 55.Google Scholar

28. Criterio 314 (8 Mar. 1934): 221.Google Scholar

29. Franceschi, G. J., Totalitansmo, liberalismo, catolicismo, p. 14.Google Scholar

30. Criterio 335 (2 Aug. 1934): 319.Google Scholar

31. Criterio 283 (14 Sept. 1933): 30.Google Scholar

32. Ibid.

33. Gerarsi, M. Navarro, “Argentine Nationalism of the Right,” pp. 110–111.Google Scholar

34. Farrel, G., Iglesia y pueblo en Argentina, 1860–1974 (Buenos Aires, 1976), p. 98.Google Scholar

35. Franceschi, G. J. in El Pueblo, 26 Jan. 1919;Google ScholarDeutsch, S. McGee, “The Argentine Right and the Jews, 1910–1933,” journal of Latin American Studies 18:1 (1986): 118.Google Scholar

36. Franceschi, G. J., “Como se prepara una revolución,” pp. 30–31;Google ScholarDeutsch, , “The Argentine Right and the Jews,” p. 128.Google Scholar

37. Franceschi's claim was not supported by the facts. According to The American Jewish Year Book, the Jewish population in Argentina was 215,000 in 1933 (or 1.81 percent of the total population) while the number of Jews in France was estimated at 225,000 and Italy, based on a census, at 47,435, both for 1931 (which were the nearest available figures to 1933). Thus the combined totals for Jews in France and Italy were 322,435 compared to Argentina's 215,000. See “Statistics of Jews: Jewish Population of the World,” American Jewish Year Book, ed., Schneiderman, H. (Philadelphia, 1935), pp. 359–360.Google Scholar

38. Gálvez, M., “Antisemitismo,” Criterio 239 (29 09 1932): 300–302.Google ScholarGálvez, outdid Franceschi, by greatly exaggerating the Jewish population in Argentina, citing a figure of 800,000.Google Scholar

39. Franceschi, G. J., “Antisemitismo,” Criterio 301 (7 12 1933): 317–321.Google Scholar

40. Franceschi, G. J., “Governar es poblar,” Criterio 376 (16 05 1935): 1.Google Scholar

41. “Dos pesas, dos medidas,” Criterio 560 (24 11 1938): 315–316.Google Scholar

42. Franceschi, G. J., “El problema judío, VI,” Criterio 593 (13 07 1939): 245–250.Google ScholarThe five other articles in this series under the same title were in the following issues of Criterio: 587 (1 June 1939): 101–105; 588 (9 June 1939): 125–130; 589 (15 June 1939): 149–154; 590 (22 June 1939): 173–178; 592 (6 July 1939): 221–226.Google Scholar

43. Franceschi's reference to “recent” anti-Semitism probably referred to incidents which took place during Juan Perón's presidential campaign in late November through mid-December 1945.Google Scholar

44. “La bestia enfurecida,” Criterio 559 (17 11 1938): 288;Google ScholarFranceschi, G. J., “Antisemitismo,” Criterio 925 (6 12 1945): 533–535.Google Scholar

45. Franceschi, G. J., “Impresiones de oriente (IV): Miradas sobre Israel,” Criterio 1167 (10 07 1952): 469–474.Google Scholar

46. New Catholic Encyclopedia, 1967, s.v. “Argentina.”Google ScholarFor more on Perón and the Catholic church, see Bianchi, Susana, La Iglesia Catolica y el estado peronista (Buenos Aires, 1988).Google Scholar

47. Franceschi, G. J., “Impresiones de oriente (V): Miradas sobre Israel (II),” Criterio 1168 (24 07 1952): 507–512.Google Scholar

47. Franceschi, expressed support for Israel on many occasions. See “Solidaridad argentinoisraeli,” Israel y América Latina 7:68 (01-02 1956): 8–9;Google ScholarFranceschi, G. J., “Odios de los seudo cristianos,” Criterio 1252 (26 01 1956): 43–45;Google ScholarFranceschi, G. J., “Amar a todos los humbres,” Israel y América Latina 7:71 (1956): 11–13;Google ScholarFranceschi, G. J., “Odios de los seudo cristianos,” p. 45;Google Scholar“Notas del continente,” Israel y América Latina 7:72 (1956): 14;Google ScholarFranceschi, G. J., “Fraternidad judeo cristiana,” Israel y América Latina 8:74 (1956): 8–11;Google Scholar“Notas del continente,” Israel y América Latina 8:73 (1956): 14;Google ScholarFranceschi, G. J., “Tierra llena de recuerdos,” Israel y América Latina 8:76 (1956): 6–7.Google Scholar

48. Tarnopolsky, S., Los prejuciados de honrada conciencia (Buenos Aires, 1971), p. 113.Google Scholar

49. Weisbrot, R., The Jews of Argentina, pp. 218–219;Google ScholarLa Luz 41: 1034 (16 07 1971): 8.Google Scholar

50. Mejia, J., “Monseñor Gustavo J. Franceschi,” Criterio 1288 (25 07 1957): 493;Google ScholarTarnopolsky, S., Los Prejudicios, p. 113.Google Scholar

51. Tarnopolsky, S., Los prejudicios, p. 113.Google Scholar