Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-jn8rn Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-31T14:42:05.451Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Woman Revolutionary: Xiang Jingyu

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  17 February 2009

Andrea McElderry
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

Xiang Jingyu was executed in 1928 at the age of 33 and has since been enshrined as a communist martyr in China. Historically her life is of interest both as the record of an individual woman and of a specific group within a particular generation who embraced Marxism-Leninism as the solution to warlord–imperialist power in China. As a result of her martyrdom, however, it is not easy to separate the actual record of her life from her posthumous persona. This consideration is especially significant with regard to her position in the early Chinese Communist Party, and since she was charged with responsibility for building a communist women's movement, it is equally important in understanding aspects of the woman question in relation to early Party history. Careful examination of Xiang's activities tends to support the conclusion that the women's movement was accorded a low priority and that Xiang's position in the Party reflected this in spite of her posthumous elevation to high status.

Type
Research Article
Information
The China Quarterly , Volume 105 , March 1986 , pp. 95 - 122
Copyright
Copyright © The China Quarterly 1986

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1. Hesen, Cai, “Xiang Jingyu tongzhi zhuan” (“A biography of Comrade Xiang Jingyu”), Jindai shi yenjiu (Studies in Modern History), Vol. 14, No. 4 (1982), p. 1Google Scholar.

2. Xugong, Dai, Xiang Jingyu zhuan (A Biography of Xiang Jingvu) (Beijing: Renmin chubanshe, 1981), p. 2Google Scholar.

3. Xugong, Dai, A Biography of Xiang, pp. 4–5Google Scholar; Jingyu, Xiang, Xiang Jingyu wenji (The Selected Works of Xiang Jingyu)(Changsha: Hunan renmin chubanshe, 1980), p. 37Google Scholar.

4. Wei Yu-hsiu wrote that of all the old legends that her mother told her, Mulan was her favourite. See Yu-hsiu, Wei (Madame Wei Tao-ming), My Revolutionary Years (New York: Charles Scribner's Sons, 1943), p. 1Google Scholar. Mulan is a central theme in Maxime Hong Kingston's autobiographical account of growing up as a Chinese-American. See Kingston, , Woman Warrior (New York: Knopf. 1976)Google Scholar. Roxane Witke discusses the “Mulan complex” in her study of attitudes towards women during the May Fourth period denning it as the “the unflagging popularity of the type of legendary heroine who rejects domestic feminity without protesting against it and adapts herself to a man's career without attempting to attract a movement of women in her wake.” See Witke, , “The transformation of attitudes toward women during the May Fourth era of modern China,” doctoral disseration (Berkeley: University of California1. 1970), pp. 45–46Google Scholar.

5. Ling, Ding, “Xiang Jingyu tongzhi liugei wo de yingxiang” (“Comrade Xiang Jingyu's lasting influence on me”), Shouhuo (Harvest), No. 1 (1980), p. 184Google Scholar.

6. Snow, Helen, Women in Modern China (The Hague and Paris: Mouton Press, 1967), p. 199Google Scholar.

7. Feifu, Song, Xinmin xuehui (The New People's Study Society) (Changsha: Hunan renmin chubanshe, 1980), p. 65Google Scholar.

8. Lieshi Xiang Jingyu (Martyr Xiang Jingyu)(Beijing: Zhongguo funu zazhishe, 1958), p. 28Google Scholar.

9. Jinian Xiang Jingyu tongzhi yinyong jiuyi wushi zhounian (Commemoration of Comrade Xiang Jingyu on the Fiftieth Anniversary of Her Heroic Death) (Beijing: Renmin chubanshe, 1978), p. 8Google Scholar.

10. Zhaozhi, Meng, Zhouyang, Ning and Guzhi, Ho, Cai Hesen zhuan (A Biography of Cai Hesen) (Changsha: Hunan renmin chubanshe, 1980), pp. 5–20Google Scholar.

11. Snow, , Women, pp. 233–36Google Scholar.

12. Xugong, Dai, A Biography of Xiang, p. 14Google Scholar; Zhaozhi, Meng, Zhouyang, Ning and Guzhi, Ho, A Biography of Cai, p. 22Google Scholar; Ch'en, Jerome, Mao and the Chinese Revolution (New York: Oxford University Press, 1965), pp. 48–49Google Scholar; Schram, Stuart, Mao Tse-tung (New York: Simon and Schuster, 1966), pp. 34–36Google Scholar.

13. Commemoration of Comrade Xiang, p. 8.

14. Siao-yu, (Xiao Zisheng), Mao Tse-tung and I Were Beggars (London: Hutchinson, 1961), p. 165Google Scholar.

15. Chinese Oral History Project, “Li Huang” (New York: Columbia University Rare Books and Manuscript Library), Vol. I, p. 123Google Scholar.

16. Xugong, Dai, A Biography of Xiang, p. 36Google Scholar.

17. Hesen, Cai, “A biography of Xiang,” p. 1Google Scholar.

18. Martyr Xiang, p. 28; Xugong, Dai, A Biography of Xiang, p. 12Google Scholar.

19. Jingyu, Xiang, Selected Works, pp. 15–24Google Scholar.

20. Xugong, Dai, A Biography of Xiang, pp. 7, 11Google Scholar.

21. Snow, , Women, p. 235Google Scholar.

22. Zhaozhi, Meng, Zhouyang, Ning and Guzhi, Ho, A Biography of Cai, p. 32Google Scholar.

23. Jingyu, Xiang, Selected Works, p. 46Google Scholar; Xugong, Dai, A Biography of Xiang, p. 26Google Scholar; Commemoration of Comrade Xiang, p. 38; Martyr Xiang, p. 29.

24. Commemoration of Comrade Xiang, p. 23; Feifu, Song, New People's, p. 66Google Scholar.

25. Commemoration of Comrade Xiang, pp. 37–38; Martyr Xiang, p. 29.

26. Feifu, Song, New People's, p. 66Google Scholar.

27. Xugong, Dai, A Biography of Xiang, p. 31Google Scholar; Hunan lishi ziliao (Historical Materials on Hunan)(Changsha, 1959), No. IV, p. 55Google Scholar.

28. Jingyu, Xiang, Selected Works, pp. 25–39Google Scholar.

29. Dai Xugong, pp. 29,31.

30. Feifu, Song, New People's, p. 11Google Scholar; Commemoration of Comrade Xiang, p. 7.

31. Cai, to Mao, , 30 June 1918, in Xinmin xuehui ziliao (Historical Materials on the New People's Study Society) (Beijing: Renmin chubanshe, introduction dated 1979), p. 43Google Scholar.

32. Cai to Mao, Chen Zhaoxiu, Xiao Zitong, Xiao Zisheng, 27 August 1918, in ibid. p. 51.

33. Cai to Mao, 24 July 1918, in ibid. pp. 52, 56.

34. Cai to Mao, 21 August 1918, in ibid. p. 58.

35. Huiyi Cai Hesen (Reminiscences of Cai Hesen) (Beijing: Renmin chubanshe, 1980), p. 99Google Scholar.

36. Xugong, Dai, A Biography of Xiang, p. 33Google Scholar.

37. Reminiscences of Cai, pp. 124–25.

38. Historical Materials on the New People's, p. 412; Feifu, Song, New People's, p. 63Google Scholar.

39. Xugong, Dai, A Biography of Xiang, p. 36Google Scholar; Zhaozhi, Meng, Zhouyang, Ning and Guzhi, Ho, A Biography of Cai, p. 57Google Scholar; Feifu, Song, New People's, p. 66Google Scholar.

40. Xugong, Dai, A Biography of Xiang, p. 34Google Scholar.

41. Historical Materials on the New People's, p. 448; Feifu, Song, New People's, p. 63Google Scholar.

42. Xugong, Dai, A Biography of Xiang, p. 41Google Scholar; Historical Materials on Hunan, pp. 3–6.

43. Xugong, Dai, A Biography of Xiang, p. 41Google Scholar.

44. Ibid. pp. 35–36.

45. Qinghua Daxue Zhonggongdang shi jiaoyan (Qinghua University Studies on the History of the Chinese Communist Party), Fufa qingong jianxue yundong shiliao (Materials on the Diligent Work-Frugal Study Movement in France), Vol. II, No. 1 (1980), pp. 115, 155Google Scholar.

46. Reminiscences of Cai, p. 79.

47. Xugong, Dai, A Biography of Xiang, p. 46Google Scholar; Zhaozhi, Meng, Zhouyang, Ning and Guzhi, Ho, A Biography of Cai, p. 59Google Scholar; Snow, , Women, p. 237Google Scholar.

48. Lisan, Li, ‘Dao Xiang Jingyu tongzhi” (“Lament for comrade Xiang Jingyu”), Hongqi piaopiao (The Red Flag Unfurls), No. 5, pp. 28–29Google Scholar.

49. Xugong, Dai, A Biography of Xiang, p. 41Google Scholar.

50. Hesen, Cai, “A Biography of Xiang,” p. 2Google Scholar.

51. Snow, , Women, p. 247Google Scholar.

52. Mao, to Zhangzai, Luo, 14 07 1920, in Historical Materials on the New People's, p. 121Google Scholar; Reminiscences of Cai, p. 137.

53. Ling, Ding, “Comrade Xiang,” p. 185Google Scholar; Commemoration of Comrade Xiang, p. 24.

54. Cai, to Mao, , 28 05 1920, in Historical Materials on the New People's, p. 127Google Scholar; Snow, , Women, p. 247Google Scholar.

55. Jingyu, Xiang, Selected Writing, p. 64Google Scholar.

56. Mao, to Zhangzai, Luo, 14 06 1920, in Historical Materials on the New People's, p. 121Google Scholar.

57. Chinese Oral History Project, “Li Huang,” Vol. I, p. 123Google Scholar.

58. Historical Materials on Hunan, p. 72.

59. Cai, to Mao, , 28 05 1920, in Historical Materials on the New People's, p. 124Google Scholar.

60. Xiao Zisheng to Mao, July–August, 1920, in ibid. p. 138.

61. Wohl, Robert, French Communism in the Making, 1914–1924 (Stanford: Stanford University Press, 1966), p. 152Google Scholar.

62. Ibid. pp. 116–18.

63. Ibid. pp. 165–66; 185.

64. Ibid. pp. 201, 218.

65. Cai, to Mao, , 16 09 1920, in Historical Materials on the New People's, pp. 156–62Google Scholar. For a summary of the correspondence between Mao and Cai during the latter's sojourn in France, see Scalapino, Robert A., “The evolution of a young revolutionary,” Journal of Asian Studies, Vol 42, No. 1, pp. 29–61CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

66. Cai, to Mao, , 13 08 1920, in Historical Materials on the New People's, pp. 129–31Google Scholar; Historical materials on Hunan, pp. 77–79.

67. Duxiu, Chen, Chen Duxiu wencun (Selected Writings of Chen Duxiu) (Shanghai: Yadong Bookstore, 1922), Vol. IV, pp. 291–98Google Scholar.

68. Zisheng, Xiao to Mao, , 07–08 1920 in Historical Materials on the New People's, p. 138Google Scholar.

69. Yunhou, Zhang, Xuyi, Yin and Junchen, Li, Liufa donggong jianxue yundong (The Diligent Work and Frugal Study Movement in France) (Shanghai: Renmin chubanshe, 1980), p. 38Google Scholar.

70. Jingyu, Xiang, Selected Writings, pp. 48–59Google Scholar.

71. Ibid. p. 52.

72. Commemoration of Comrade Xiang, p. 11.

73. Jingyu, Xiang, Selected Writings, pp. 61, 67–68Google Scholar; Daxue, Qinghua, Materials on the Work-Study Movement, Vol. VII, No. 1, pp. 24–25Google Scholar.

74. Jingyu, Xiang, Selected Writings, pp. 65–66Google Scholar; Historical Materials on Hunan, p. 72.

75. Reminiscences of Cai, pp. 102, 139.

76. Chinese Oral History Project, “Li Huang,” Vol. I, p. 123Google Scholar.

77. Zisheng, Xiao to Mao, , 07–08 1920, in Historical Materials on the New People's, p. 137Google Scholar.

78. Mao to members of the New People's Study Society, 1 December 1920, in ibid. p. 146.

79. Luo Zhangzai to Mao, 14 July 1920, in ibid. pp. 115–16; Historical Materials on Hunan, pp. 68–69.

80. Zhaozhi, Meng, Zhouyang, Ning and Guzhi, Ho, A Biography of Cai, pp. 67–68Google Scholar.

81. Yunhou, Zhang, Xuyi, Yin and Junchen, Li, The Work-Study Movement, p. 14Google Scholar.

82. Historical Materials on Hunan, pp. 66–67.

83. Cai, to Mao, , 28 05 1920, in Historical Materials on the New People's, p. 125Google Scholar; Historical Materials on Hunan, p. 68; Commemoration of Comrade Xiang, p. 8.

84. Yunhou, Zhang, Xuyi, Yin and Junchen, Li, The Work-Study Movement, pp. 14–19Google Scholar.

85. Société d'éducation franco-chinoise, Archives. (Paris: Centre de recherches et de documentation sur la Chine contemporaine de l'école des hautes études en sciences sociales), B/6 II 2[11], 21 July 1921, 26 July 1921.

86. Ibid. B/6 II 2[16], 29 July 1921, 1 September 1921; B/6 II 2[18a and 18b], 17 September 1921.

87. Ibid. B/6 II 2[19], 23 September 1921; B/6 II 2[20b], 27 September 1921.

88. Yunhou, Zhang, Xuyi, Yin and Junchen, Li, The Work-Study Movement, pp. 22–27Google Scholar.

89. Xugong, Dai, A Biography of Xiang, p. 70Google Scholar, gives 23 November 1921 as the date of Xiang's arrival in Shanghai. Yunhou, Zhang, Xuyi, Yin, and Junchen, Li, The Work-Study Movement, p. 31, give the date as 22 12 1921Google Scholar.

90. Xugong, Dai, A Biography of Xiang, p. 77Google Scholar; Commemoration of Comrade Xiang, p. 12; Martyr Xiang, p. 2.

91. Jingru, Zhang and Chaomei, Wang, Zhongguo gongchandang de chuangli (The Founding of the Chinese Communist Party) (Beijing: Renmin chubanshe, 1981) pp. 193–94Google Scholar; Zhongguo Shehui Kexue Yuan Xiandaishi Yanjiu Shi (Modern Historical Studies Bureau, Chinese Academy of Social Sciences) (ed.), Zhongguo gongchandang lici daibiao dahui (All Previous Delegates to the Party Congresses of the Chinese Communist Party) (Beijing: Zhonggong zhongyang dangxiao chubanshe, 1982), pp. 31, 35–36Google Scholar; Zhonggong Zhongyang Dangxiao Dangshi Jiaoyanshi Ziliao Zhu Bianxie (Research Bureau for Party History, Party School of the Central Committee of the Chinese Communist Party) (ed.), Zhongguo gongchandang lici zhongyao huiyi ji (A Collection on all Previous Meetings of the Chinese Communist Party) (Shanghai: Renmin chubanshe, 1982), Vol. I, p. 14Google Scholar; Huaibi, Feng, Jianmin, Zheng and Zhujun, Song, Zhongguo gongchandang lishi jiangyi (Materials on the History of the Chinese Communist Party) (Tianjin: Tianjin renmin chubanshe, 1983), pp. 20–21. 24–25Google Scholar.

92. In yuan, Zhonggong shehui kexue (ed.), All Previous Delegates to the Party Congresses, Xiang is listed as a delegate to the Third Party Congress (p. 57)Google Scholar and as being placed in charge of a women's department (bumeri) under the Central Executive Committee (p. 63). In an essay dated June 1925 on the resolutions of the Third Party Congress regarding women, in Xiang, , Selected Writings, p. 216Google Scholar, Xiang wrote, “For the purpose of bringing together our women party members to systematically lead the national women's movement, the Party should establish a women's committee (weiyuanhui).…,” Xing, Xiao, “Guanyu chuxi Zhonggong ‘sanda’ di daibiao wenti” (“The problem of the delegates attending the Third Congress of the Chinese Communist Party”), Dangshi yanjiu (Studies in Party History), No. 2 (1980), p. 51Google Scholar, concludes that Xiang was an alternate member. Huaibi, Feng, Jianmin, Zhao and Zhujun, Song. “Materials on the history of the Chinese Communist Party,” p. 24Google Scholar, list Xiang as attending.

93. Kuo-t'ao, Chang, The Rise of the Chinese Communist Party–1921–1927, Vol. I (Lawrence: University of Kansas Press, 1971), p. 404Google Scholar.

94. “Chen Duxiu zai Zhongguo gongchandang disanci chuanguo daibiao dahui di baogao” (”Chen Duxiu's report to the Third National Congress of the Chinese Communist Party”), Studies in Party History, No. 2 (1980), p. 42–43Google Scholar.

95. Shuzhi, Peng with Cadart, Claude and Yingxiang, Cheng, Memoires de Peng Shuzhi, L'envol du communisme en Chine (Paris: Gallimard, 1983), pp. 460–461, 470Google Scholar.

96. Jingyu, Xiang, Selected Writings, p. 216Google Scholar.

97. Ibid. pp. 136–37; Commemoration of Comrade Xiang, pp. 70–71; Martyr Xiang, pp. 38–39.

98. Jingyu, Xiang, Selected Writings, pp. 213–14Google Scholar.

99. Ibid. pp. 145–47.

100. Ibid. pp. 216–17.

101. Jingyu, Xiang, Selected Writings, p. 209Google Scholar; Commemoration of Comrade Xiang, p. 15.

102. Commemoration of Comrade Xiang, p. 12.

103. Witke, , “The transformation of attitudes toward women,” p. 287Google Scholar; Shuzhi, Peng, Memoires, p. 470Google Scholar.

104. Shuzhi, Peng, Memoires, p. 470Google Scholar.

105. See Martyr Xiang and Commemoration of Comrade Xiang.

106. Yingyu, Xiang, Selected Writings, p. 148Google Scholar; Commemoration of Comrade Xiang, p. 78; Martyr Xiang, p. 43.

107. Jingyu, Xiang, Selected Writings, p. 157Google Scholar.

108. Ibid. p. 136; Commemoration of Comrade Xiang, p. 72; Martyr Xiang, p. 59.

109. Zhaozhi, Meng, Zhouyang, Ning and Guzhi, Ho, A Biography of Cai, p. 109Google Scholar; Martyr Xiang, pp. 15–16.

110. Jingyu, Xiang, Selected Writings, pp. 142–144Google Scholar.

111. Ibid. pp. 159, 161–64.

112. Yi, Pi, Zhongguo funu yundong (The Chinese Women's Movement) (Taipei: Fu lianhua kanshe, 1973), p. 52Google Scholar; Martyr Xiang, p. 16.

113. Jingyu, Xiang, Selected Writings, pp. 204–206Google Scholar.

114. Commemoration of Comrade Xiang, p. 15; Snow, , Women, p. 247Google Scholar.

115. Jingyu, Xiang, Selected Writings, pp. 99–100, 114–16, 136–37Google Scholar.

116. Commemoration of Comrade Xiang, p. 56.

117. Ibid. p. 58; Yingyu, Xiang, Selected Writings, p. 117Google Scholar.

118. Commemoration of Comrade Xiang, pp. 14, 25; Martyr Xiang, p. 10.

119. Shuzhi, Peng, Memoires, p. 411Google Scholar.

120. Commemoration of Comrade Xiang, p. 14.

121. Kuo-t'ao, Chang, The Rise of the Chinese Communist Party, pp. 404, 420Google Scholar.

122. Ibid. p. 414.

123. Shuzhi, Peng, Memoires, p. 470Google Scholar.

124. Kuo-t'ao, Chang, The Rise of the Chinese Communist Party, p. 489Google Scholar.

125. Reminiscences of Cai, p. 61.

126. Shuzhi, Peng, Memoires, p. 324Google Scholar.

127. Jingyu, Xiang, Selected Writings, p. 212Google Scholar.

128. Remincences of Cai, p. 83; Commemoration of Comrade Xiang, p. 59.

129. Shuzhi, Peng, Memoires, pp. 386, 411Google Scholar.

130. Kuo-t'ao, Chang, The Rise of the Chinese Communist Party, p. 487Google Scholar; Shanfu, Xu, “Gongchandang fenlie shi” (“A history of splits in the Chinese Communist Party”), Tianhai shiliao (Tianhai Historical Materials), Vol. 2 (1935), p. 227Google Scholar.

131. Zilie, Yang, Zhang Guotaofuren huailu (Reminiscences of Madame Chang Kuot'ao) (Hong Kong: Zhongguo wenti yanjiu zhongxin, 1970), p. 196Google Scholar; Shuzhi, Peng, Memoires, pp. 386, 407Google Scholar; Kuo-t'ao, Chang, The Rise of the Chinese Communist Party, pp. 156–158Google Scholar; Shanfu, Xu, “A history of splits,” p. 227Google Scholar.

132. Jingyu, Xiang, Selected Writings, pp. 107–108Google Scholar; Martyr Xiang, p. 25.

133. Ling, Ding, “Xiang's lasting influence,” p. 186Google Scholar; Commemoration of Comrade Xiang, p. 26; Martyr Xiang, pp. 9, 15; Zilie, Yang, Reminiscences, p. 133Google Scholar.

134. Jingyu, Xiang, Selected Writings, p. 122Google Scholar; Martyr Xiang, p. 51.

135. Shanfu, Xu, “A history of splits,” p. 227Google Scholar.

136. Kuo-t'ao, Chang, The Rise of the Chinese Communist Party, pp. 487–88Google Scholar. See also Reminiscences of Cai, p. 61.

137. Shuzhi, Peng, Memoires, pp. 11, 124, 134, 163Google Scholar.

138. Zilie, Yang, Memoirs, pp. 146–47Google Scholar.

139. Kuo-t'ao, Chang, The Rise of the Chinese Communist Party, p. 488Google Scholar.

140. Ibid. p. 490; Feigon, Lee, Chen Duxiu. Founder of the Chinese Communist Party (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1983), p. 193Google Scholar.

141. Kuo-t'ao, Chang, The Rise of the Chinese Communist Party, pp. 490–91Google Scholar.

142. Zilie, Yang, Memoirs, p. 136Google Scholar.

143. Ibid. pp. 161.

144. Xugong, Dai, A Biography of Xiang, pp. 127–29Google Scholar.

145. Ibid. p. 133.

146. Lisan, Li, “Lament for Comrade Xiang,” p. 30Google Scholar.

147. Martyr Xiang, pp. 20–21.

148. Commemoration ofComrade Xiang, pp. 19–20.

149. Ibid. pp. 19, 21; Snow, , Women, pp. 242, 248Google Scholar.

150. Rankin, Mary Backus, “The Emergence of women at the end of the Ch'ing: the case of Ch'iu Chin,” in Wolf, Margery and Witke, Roxane, Women in Chinese Society (Stanford: Stanford University Press, 1975), pp. 59–62Google Scholar.

151. Commemoration of Comrade Xiang, p. 17.

152. Lisan, Li, “Lament of Comrade Xiang,” p. 30Google Scholar.

153. Reminiscences of Cai, p. 141.

154. Ibid.

155. Siao-yu, , Mao Tsu-tung and I, pp. 50, 63Google Scholar.