Article contents
Taxation without Representation: Peasants, the Central and the Local States in Reform China
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 12 February 2009
Extract
China's countryside has undergone tremendous changes in the last two decades, but the changes and the benefits that came with them were not distributed evenly. Rapid rural industrialization in the Eastern, coastal provinces under the aegis of the local developmental state dramatically improved the lives of villagers. In contrast, township and village enterprises (TVEs) and incomes grew much more slowly in the Central belt of provinces and still more slowly in the Western belt. Because agriculture was the major resource, rural governments had to rely on extraction of taxes and fees from the peasants in order to meet their expenses and to carry out developmental programmes. Here, predatory state agents imposed heavy financial burdens on the peasants. The result was a long festering crisis in the relations between peasants and the local state. Since the mid-1980s, the central authorities have been ordering their local agents to lighten the burdens of the peasants, yet the problem persists to the present. Why has it been so intractable?
- Type
- Research Article
- Information
- Copyright
- Copyright © The China Quarterly 2000
References
1. See, for example, Oi, Jean, Rural China Takes off (Berkeley: University of California Press, 1999)Google Scholar; Zweig, David, Freeing China's Farmers: Rural Restructuring in the Reform Era (Armonk, NY: M.E. Sharpe, 1997)Google Scholar; Walder, Andrew (ed.), Zouping in Transition: The Process of Reform in Rural North China (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 1998).Google Scholar
2. Qin, Li, “Dui woguo nongmin fudan zhuangkuang de fenxi” (“Analysis of peasant burdens”), Zhongguo nongcun jingji (ZNJ), No. 8 (1992), pp. 47–51.Google Scholar
3. For examples, see Fazhi ribao (FZRB), 21 05 1996.Google Scholar
4. Renmin ribao (RMRB), 1 04 1997.Google Scholar
5. Interviews, Wuhan, September 1998. All interviews cited in this article were done by Bernstein.
6. On this see L¨, Xiaobo, “The politics of peasant burden in reform China,” Journal of Peasant Studies, Vol. 24, No. 4 (10 1997), pp. 113–138.Google Scholar
7. See Hongjie, Han, “Nongmin fudan yu xiang (zhen) fuzhai” (“Peasant burdens and township (town) debts”), Nongcun jingji, No. 6 (1997)Google Scholar, for an analysis of the financial impact of pujiu on villages in Chengdu.
8. Wong, R. Bin, China Transformed: Historical Change and the Limits of European Experience (Ithaca: Cornell University Press 1997), pp. 236–37.Google Scholar
9. Yousheng, Luo and Zuohai, Sun (eds.), Zhonghua remin gongheguo nongye fa shiyi (Explanation of the PRC Agricultural Law) (Qinhuangdao: Zhongguo zhengfu daxue chubanshe), p. 56.Google Scholar
10. Yimin, Chen, “Nongmin fudan ji de jianqing,” (“It is urgently necessary to reduce peasant burdens”), Nongcun gongzuo tongxun, No. 8 (1983), pp. 19–20.Google Scholar
11. Nongmin ribao (NMRB), 20 01 1998.Google Scholar
12. Xinhua ribao, 30 10 1992Google Scholar, Joint Publications Research Service, 1992, No. 95, 22 12 1992, p. 32 (JPRS-92–95).Google Scholar
13. Ping, Tang in Zhongguo tongji xinxi, 10 09 1992Google Scholar, JPRS-92–86, pp. 32–34.
14. See Wedeman, Andrew, “Stealing from China's farmers: institutional corruption and the 1992 IOU crisis,” The China Quarterly, No. 152 (12 1997), pp. 805–931CrossRefGoogle Scholar, and “Jingti nongcun xubao fukua feng, (“Guard against false reports and exaggeration”), Banyuetan, No. 4, 25 02 1996, pp. 18–20.Google Scholar
15. Shanghai lingdian shichang diaocha youxian gongsi, “Miaodian: huangjie pinkun guocheng zhong de nonghu yanjiu” (“Research on the process of mitigating the poverty of peasant households”), Zhongguo qingnian yanjiu, No. 8 (1998), pp. 24–28.Google Scholar
16. See the directives published in RMRB, 1 04 1997Google Scholar and Xinhua, 8 12 1996Google Scholar, Summary of World Broadcasts — Far East/2797S1/3–4 (SWB-FE). For an earlier directive, see Zhonghua renmin gongheguo guowuyuan gongbao (GYCB), No. 18 (2 09 1993), p. 856.Google Scholar
17. Yinsu, Tang, “Jianjue renzhen de zhengdun ruanruo huansan de cunji zuzhi” (“Resolutely and earnestly rectify village organizations that are weak and lax”), Zhongguo minzheng, No. 9 (1991), pp. 18–19.Google Scholar For detailed descriptions of several such cases, see Daolong, Chen, “Xiangcun zai huhan” (“The cries of the countryside”), Yue hua, 1994 Supplement, pp. 2–22.Google Scholar
18. Beijing Review, 13–19 01 1992, pp. 37–38.Google Scholar
19. Xinhua neican xuanbian, No. 4 (1996), pp. 4–5.Google Scholar
20. Nanfang zhoumo, 11 09 1998.Google Scholar
21. Daolong, Chen, “The cries of the countryside,” p. 5.Google Scholar
22. Yanbin, Wang, “Nongmin fudan: anxia hulu qilai piao” (“Peasant burdens: solving one problem only to have another crop up”), Minzhu yu fazhi, No. 13 (6 07 1995), p. 12.Google Scholar
23. RMRB, 1 04 1997.Google Scholar
24. Qin, Li, “Analysis of peasant burdens.”Google Scholar
25. Meijun, Sun, “Nongmin fudan xiankuang ji qi guozhong de genyuan” (“Peasant burdens and the sources of their excess”), ZNJ, No. 4 (1998), p. 9.Google Scholar
26. Kang, Gu et al. , “Liudong guiwei – ‘feigaishui’ de jiben silu” (“Basic thoughts on the integration and distribution of funds by means of substituting taxes for fees”), Neibu canyue, No. 22 (6 06 1999), pp. 2–7.Google Scholar
27. Khan, Azizur Rahman and Riskin, Carl, “Income and inequality in China: composition, distribution and growth of household income, 1988 to 1995,” The China Quarterly, No. 154 (06 1998), p. 249.Google Scholar
28. Ibid. p. 240.
29. Yushao, Wang, “Yingdang zhengshi ‘nongmin fudan kongzhi guiding’ suo cunzai de biduan” (“Attention should be paid to malpractice that arise from the directives on peasant burden control”), Liaowang, No. 7 (1997), p. 30.Google Scholar
30. gongsi, Shanghai shichang, “Research on the process.”Google Scholar
31. See Oi, , Rural China Takes Off, pp. 79–80.Google Scholar
32. Wong, Christine (ed.), Financing Local Development in the People's Republic of China (Hong Kong: Oxford University Press, 1997), p. 199.Google Scholar
33. See GYGB, No. 11 (20 11 1985), pp. 1043–46.Google Scholar
34. FZRB, 21 05 1996.Google Scholar
35. Xueyi, Lu and Houyi, Zhang, “Some comments on current agricultural problems,” ZNJ, No. 3 (20 03 1993)Google Scholar, JPRS-93–35, 28 May 1993, p. 26.
36. GYGB, No. 18 (2 09 1993), pp. 850–57.Google Scholar
37. RMRB, 17 11 1985.Google Scholar
38. See Kang, Gu et al. , “Basic thoughts.”Google Scholar
39. See Shaoguang, Wang, “China's 1994 fiscal reform: an initial assessment,” Asian Survey, Vol. 37, No. 9 (1997), pp. 801–817Google Scholar, especially the table on p. 812 that shows three different sets of figures for central revenue.
40. See especially Lü, Xiaobo, “The politics of peasant burden,” pp. 127–130.Google Scholar
41. China News Agency wire, Beijing, 12 June 1993, Foreign Broadcast Information Service, Daily Report—China (FBIS), No 112, pp. 28–29.Google Scholar
42. See, for instance, the central government's decision on burdens, RMRB, 1 04 1997.Google Scholar
43. On IOUs, see Wedeman, , “Stealing from farmers,” pp. 805–831.Google Scholar Other issues that led to protest and sometimes violence against officials included uncompensated seizure of land, pollution by nearby or upstream factories, cultural conflicts such as resistance to regime suppression of popular religious movements, and especially conflicts over enforcement of birth quotas and cremation.
44. Liaowang, No. 8 (23 02 1987)Google Scholar and si, Zonghe jihua, “Guanyu nongmin fudan de diaocha” (“Investigation of peasant burdens”), Nongye jingji wenti. No. 2 (1990), p. 60.Google Scholar
45. Sheng, Jung, “Great impact of agricultural issue — tracking incident of peasant riots in Sichuan's Renshou county,” Xin bao, Hong Kong, 10 06 1993Google Scholar, FBIS, No. 111, pp. 10–15.Google Scholar
46. Yu-sha, Lu, “Wan Li delivers speech, expressing worry about peasant rebellion,” Dangdai, 15 04 1993Google Scholar, FBIS, No. 72, p. 43.Google Scholar
47. China News Agency wire, 6 06 1993Google Scholar, FBIS, No. 128, pp. 34–35.Google Scholar
48. RMRB, overseas ed., 7 05 1996Google Scholar; RMRB, 1 04 1997 and Xinhua, Beijing, 27 July 1998.Google Scholar
49. Nong, Lu, “Nongcun bu wending qingkuang ehua” (“The worsening of the unstable rural situation”), Zhengming, No. 8, (08 1994), pp. 28–29.Google Scholar Lu writes of a total of 1.67 million “cases” but did not define their meaning.
50. Jie, Guan, “Peasant riots in Shanxi, Henan, and Hunan,” Dongxiang, No. 124 (12 1995), pp. 18–19Google Scholar, trsl. in China Perspective, No. 2 (01–02 1996), pp. 6–9Google Scholar, and Zijing, Li, “Si sheng wushi wan nongmin kangzheng” (“Half a million peasants resist in four provinces”), Zhengming, No. 8 (1997), pp. 19–21Google Scholar, reproduced from Dongxiang, 04 1997.Google Scholar The title refers to the main story, which is quoted in Table 6.
51. South China Morning Post (SCMP), 3 11 1998.Google Scholar
52. Yanbin, Wang, “Peasant burdens.”Google Scholar
53. Ming bao, 8 11 1996Google Scholar, SWB-FE, No. 2765, pp. G/4–5 and SCMP, 11 11 1996Google Scholar, quoting Guangzhou yuegang xinxi ribao
54. Tarrow, Sidney, Power in Movement: Social Movements, Collective Action and Politics (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1994), pp. 17–18.Google Scholar
55. Ying, Zheng, “Dalu minzhong saodong ciqibuluo” (“People on the mainland stage more and more disturbances”), Jiushi niandai. No. 7 (1987), pp. 38–40.Google Scholar
56. Shanin, Theodore, “The peasantry as a political factor,” in Shanin, (ed.), Peasants and Peasant Societies (Baltimore, MD: Penguin Books, 1971), p. 258.Google Scholar
57. See Sidney Tarrow's Power in Movement for a superb analysis of social movements.
58. See Bernstein, Thomas, “In quest of voice: China's farmers and prospects for political liberalization,” paper presented to the University Seminar on Modern China, Columbia University, 02 1994, pp. 71–77Google Scholar, for a description of the Renshou riots. See Ming bao, 8 11 1996Google Scholar, in SWB-FE, No. 2765, pp. G/4–5 and New York Times, 1 02 1999.Google Scholar
59. Pingguo ribao, 25 11 1996Google Scholar, SWB-FE No. 2783, pp. G/4–5 and SCMP, 26 11 1996.Google Scholar
60. Li, Lianjiang and O'Brien, Kevin, “Villagers and popular resistance in contemporary China,” Modern China, Vol. 22, No. 1 (01 1996), pp. 28–61.Google Scholar See also O'Brien, and Li, , “The politics of lodging complaints in China,” The China Quarterly, No. 143 (09 1995), pp. 756–783.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
61. See Tilly, Charles, From Mobilization to Revolution (New York: Random House, 1975), p. 158.Google Scholar
62. Perry, Elizabeth J. in Perry, and Wong, Christine (eds.), The Political Economy of Post-Mao China (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 1985), p. 192.Google Scholar
63. Li, Tian and Cao, Fang, “‘Police's ineffectiveness in cracking down on crime is also discussed,” Renmin gong'an bao, 2 10 1993Google Scholar, JPRS-93–88, 14 December 1993, pp. 55–56.
64. NMRB, 9 05 1989.Google Scholar
65. Jie, Gan, “Peasant riots in Shanxi.”Google Scholar
66. New York Times, 1 02 1999.Google Scholar
67. Shijie ribao, 3 04 1999.Google Scholar
68. On this subject, see Weihua, Chen, “Cong xinfang gongzuo jiaodu duidang qian jianqin nongmin fudan wenti de zai sikao” (“Re-examination of the peasant burden problem from the perspective of the work of letters and visits”), Renmin xinfang. No. 9 (1998), pp. 28–31.Google Scholar
69. O'Brien, and Li, , “The politics of lodging complaints,” p. 758.Google Scholar
70. Jie, Guan, “Peasant riots in Shanxi.”Google Scholar
71. Zijing, Li, “Half a million peasants.”Google Scholar
72. See, for instance, Yong, Xu, Zhongguo nongcun cunmin zizhi (Villager Self-government in Rural China) (Wuhan: Huazhong shifan daxue chubanshe, 1997, p. 279.Google Scholar
73. NMRB, 26 09 1988.Google Scholar
74. Sheng, Jung, “Great impact.”Google Scholar
75. Jie, Gan, “Peasant riots in Shanxi.”Google Scholar
76. “Anhui nongmin kangshui shijian” (“Anhui incident of peasant resistance”), Zhengming, No. 9 (09 1993), p. 93.Google Scholar
77. Zijing, Li, “Half a million peasants.”Google Scholar
78. Interview, Beijing, 10 September 1998.
79. Perry, Elizabeth, “Casting a Chinese ‘democracy’ movement: the role of students, workers, and entrepreneurs,” in Wasserstrom, Jeffrey and Perry, Elizabeth (eds.), Popular Protest and Political Culture in China (Boulder: Westview Press, 2nd ed.), pp. 74–92.Google Scholar
80. See Solinger, Dorothy J., Contesting Citizenship in Urban China: Peasant Migrants, the State and the Logic of the Market (Berkeley: University of California Press, 1999), especially ch. 4.Google Scholar
81. FZRB, 5 11 1998.Google Scholar This was the revised version of a draft law which had been in effect since 1987.
82. For an analysis of township opposition, see Lianjiang, Li and O'Brien, Kevin J., “The struggle over village elections,” in Goldman, Merle and MacFarquhar, Roderick (eds.), The Paradox of Post-Mao Reforms (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 1999), pp. 129–144.Google Scholar
83. Yong, Xu, Villager Self-government, pp. 144–45.Google Scholar
84. For the trial law, see GYGB, No. 27 (5 12 1987)Google Scholar, and for the new one, FZRB, 5 11 1998.Google Scholar
85. Direct township elections have been proposed by officials in the Ministry of the Civil Affairs and by various academics. A direct township election in Sichuan, apparently experimental, was repudiated by the central leaders. See International Herald Tribune, 27 01 1999.Google Scholar
86. Xinhua, , Beijing, 11 07 1999Google Scholar, SWB-FE, No. 3585, p. G4, 13 07 1999Google Scholar and SCMP, 13 07 1999.Google Scholar
87. Gang, Bai, “Woguo cunmin zizhi buru guifanhua fazhan jieduan” (“China's villager self rule has entered the stage of regularization”), Neibu canyue, No. 13 (7 04 1999), pp. 2–9.Google Scholar
88. Xinhua, , 11 06 1999Google Scholar, SWB-FE, No. 3560, p. G/8, 14 07 1999.Google Scholar
89. See the two village comparison by Yong, Xu, in Villager Self-government, pp. 274–288.Google Scholar
90. Epstein, Amy, “Village elections in China: experimenting with democracy,” in U.S. Congress, Joint Economic Committee, China's Economic Future: Challenges to U.S. Policy (Washington, DC: GPO, 1996), p. 416.Google Scholar
91. Yong, Xu, Villager Self-government, pp. 274–288.Google Scholar
- 119
- Cited by