Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-l7hp2 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-28T14:21:40.197Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The Role of the Military in the Formation of Revolutionary Committees 1967–68

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  17 February 2009

Jürgen Domes
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

When, at a moment of high tide in the Cultural Revolution, the first Revolutionary Committee was established in the Manchurian province of Heilungkiang on 31 January 1967, a new type of leadership organ appeared on the Chinese scene, indicating drastic changes in the regional power structure. At the beginning, these Revolutionary Committees were supposed to act as “temporary supreme organs of power” (Lin-shih tsui-kao ch'üan-li chi-kou), in which capacity they combined the local and regional leadership of party, administration, economy and mass organizations. During the four weeks preceding the formation of the Heilungkiang Committee, violent activity by newly formed Maoist organizations in a number of Chinese provinces and cities had been answered by wide-spread popular resistance, which was in many cases instigated by the local and regional Party leadership. Facing this resistance, Mao Tse-tung, in a personal mandate to his First Deputy and presumptive successor, Lin Piao, on 17 or 18 January 1967 ordered the military to intervene in the power-struggle between Maoists and anti-Maoists. The immediate attitudinal response of the People's Liberation Army (PLA), however, was not wholly convincing. Nevertheless, this call for the military to support the faltering Maoist counterattack against “revisionist” oppositional forces marks the beginning of a definite rise in military influence on the political process in Communist China.

Type
Research Article
Information
The China Quarterly , Volume 44 , October 1970 , pp. 112 - 145
Copyright
Copyright © The China Quarterly 1970

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Peking Radio, 2 February 1967.Google Scholar

2 Tung-fang hung (The East is Red) (Peking), 28 01 1967.Google Scholar

3 See Volker, Gerth, Herrschaftssystem und Machtausübung in der Volksrepublik China unter dem Einfluβ der “Groβen Proletarischen Kulturrevolution,” in Berliner Zeitschrift für Politologie, Vol. 9, No. 3 (10 1968)Google Scholar, p. 49; China News Analysis (CNA) (Hong Kong), No. 653, pp. 1 ff., No. 658, p. 6, No. 659, pp. 3 f.Google Scholar

4 See below.Google Scholar

5 Wên-hui pao, Shanghai, 22 02 1967.Google Scholar

6 Jen-min jih-pao (People's Daily) (JMJP) (Peking), 28 02 1967.Google Scholar

7 Hung-ch'i, (Red Flag) (Peking) No. 5 (1967).Google Scholar

8 Shanghai Radio, 23 March 1967.Google Scholar

9 Central Radio, 20 April 1967.Google Scholar

10 NCNA, 13 August 1967.Google Scholar

11 NCNA, 1 November 1967.Google Scholar

12 JMJP, 7 12 1967.Google Scholar

13 Chieh-fang chün-pao (Liberation Army Daily) (CFCP) and NCNA, 25 01 1967.Google Scholar

14 NCNA, 28 January 1967.Google Scholar

15 Peking Central Radio, 2 February 1967.Google Scholar

16 According to Asahi Shimbun (Tokyo), 13 02 1967.Google Scholar

17 JMJP, 1 and 10 02 1967.Google Scholar

18 Hei-lung-kiang jih-pao, quoted in JMJP, 16 02 1967.Google Scholar

19 Kuang-ming jih-pao (KMJP), 26 and 31 01 1967; NCNA, 31 January 1967.Google Scholar

20 JMJP, 15 03 1967.Google Scholar

21 JMJP, 27 02, 20 03, 29 04, 7 and 12 06, 16 07 1967.Google Scholar

22 NCNA, 31 01 1967.Google Scholar

23 Shantung Radio, 4 02 1967.Google Scholar

24 Shantung Radio, 2 03 1967.Google Scholar

25 Peking Central Radio, 3 02 1967.Google Scholar

26 Shanghai Radio, 9 and 28 02 1967.Google Scholar

27 Peking Central Radio, 1 02 1967.Google Scholar

28 JMJP, 12 04 1967.Google Scholar

29 NCNA, 20 February 1967.Google Scholar

30 Peking Central Radio, 24 January 1967.Google Scholar

31 JMJP, 23 03 1967.Google Scholar

32 Shansi Radio, 28 January 1967; NCNA, 30 January 1967.Google Scholar

33 JMJP, 17 02 1967.Google Scholar

34 My italics. JMJP, 18 02 1967.Google Scholar

35 JMJP, 28 02 1967.Google Scholar

36 See above, p. 113.Google Scholar

37 JMJP, 21 04 1967.Google Scholar

38 See Domes, Jürgen, Kulturrevolution und Armee—die Rolle der Streitkräfte in der chinesischen “Kulturrevolution” (The Cultural Revolution and the Army: the Role of the Armed Forces in the Chinese Cultural Revolution) (Bonn, 1967), pp. 105–109.Google Scholar

39 CFCP, 25 02 1957.Google Scholar

40 For these developments see Union Research Service (URS), Vol. 48, No. 10 (4 08 1967), pp. 139–149Google Scholar; Wandzeitungen während der chinesischen Groβen Proletarischen Kulturrevolution (Wall Newspapers and Tabloids during the Cultural Revolution), a collection of photocopies of Red Guard Newspapers compiled by the Hong Kong Union Research Institute and bound at the Research Unit on Chinese and East-Asian Politics (Free University Berlin, 1967), Vol. II, pp. 58–73; URS, Vol. 48, No. 23 (19 09 1967), pp. 320–334Google Scholar; CNA, No. 671 (4 08 1967) and No. 674 (25 August 1967).Google Scholar

41 Asahi Shimbun and Yomiuri (both Toyko), 27 04 1967.Google Scholar

42 NCNA, 13 August 1967.Google Scholar

43 JMJP, 1 06 1967.Google Scholar

44 Huhehot Radio, 29 August 1967.Google Scholar

45 JMJP, 2 11 1967.Google Scholar

46 Chinese Communist Affairs: Facts and Features (FF) (Taipei), Vol. I, No. 7, pp. 17 f.Google Scholar

47 NCNA, 6 December 1967.Google Scholar

48 Nanchang Radio, 20, 22, 23 and 25 January 1967.Google Scholar

49 Nanchang Radio, 26 February 1967.Google Scholar

50 Nanchang Radio, 24 March 1967.Google Scholar

51 Nanchang Radio, 27 August 1967.Google Scholar

52 Nanchang Radio, 31 August 1967.Google Scholar

53 NCNA, 6 January 1968.Google Scholar

54 Peking wall-posters on 26 April 1967, quoted in Asahi Shimbun, 27 04 1967.Google Scholar

55 Lanchow Radio, 6 August 1967.Google Scholar

56 NCNA, 8 November 1967.Google Scholar

57 NCNA, 24 January 1968.Google Scholar

58 Honan Radio, 6 March 1967.Google Scholar

59 Current Scene (Hong Kong), Vol. 6, No. 9, p. 12.Google Scholar

60 Honan Radio, 25 and 26 May 1967; Ho-nan jih-pao, 24 05 1967Google Scholar, and Yomiuri (Tokyo), 28 05 and 3 06 1967Google ScholarPubMed; see Survey of the China Mainland Press (SCMP) (Hong Kong), No. 401, pp. 1–8.Google Scholar

61 Honan Radio, 8 August 1967.Google Scholar

62 Honan Radio, 4 and 5 January 1968.Google Scholar

63 Honan Radio, 12 January 1968.Google Scholar

64 NCNA, 27 January 1968.Google Scholar

65 Honan Radio, 26 March 1968.Google Scholar

66 JMMP, 11 03 1967; NCNA, 16 March 1967.Google Scholar

67 NCNA, 4 February 1968.Google Scholar

68 Hupeh Radio, 26 January and 3 February 1967.Google Scholar

69 Hupei Radio, 6 March 1967.Google Scholar

70 Hupei Radio, 11 March 1967.Google Scholar

71 See CNA, No. 555, p. 7.Google Scholar

72 See Wuhan Kang-erh-ssu, No. 38, 22 08 1967Google Scholar; URS, Vol. 48, No. 10, pp. 139–149Google Scholar; No. 23, pp. 320–334; Wandzeitungen, Vol. II, pp. 58–73Google Scholar; Wuhan Radio, 18 August 1967; SCMP, No. 3999, 11 08 1967, pp. 1–21.Google Scholar

73 Hupei Radio, 12 January 1968.Google Scholar

74 NCNA, 6 February 1968.Google Scholar

75 Ming-pao (Hongkong), 3 03 1967.Google Scholar

76 According to reports on Canton Radio, 26 September and 2 November 1967.Google Scholar

77 NCNA, 22 February 1968.Google Scholar

78 Kirin Radio, 28 December 1967.Google Scholar

79 NCNA, 9 March 1968.Google Scholar

80 Kiangsu Radio, 15 May 1967.Google Scholar

81 Peking wall-poster paper, quoted in: Yomiuri (Tokyo), 5 06 1967.Google Scholar

82 Ching-kang-shan chan-pao (Chingkangshan Battle News) (Peking), 11 08 1967.Google Scholar

83 Kiangsu Radio, 24 August 1967.Google Scholar

84 NCNA, 24 March 1968.Google Scholar

85 Chekiang Radio, 28 January 1967.Google Scholar

86 Chekiang Radio, 28 February 1967.Google Scholar

87 See Domes, , Kulturrevolution und Armee, p. 113.Google Scholar

88 Chekiang Radio, 2 March 1967.Google Scholar

89 R. L. and Powell, H. F., “Continuity and purge in the PLA,” in Marine Corps Gazette, Vol. 52, No. 2, p. 29.Google Scholar

90 FF, Vol. 1, No. 13, p. 96.Google Scholar

91 Chekiang Radio, 18, 20, 21 and 22 August 1967; Wenchou PBS, 2 September 1967.Google Scholar

92 Chekiang PBS, 14, 16 and 17 December 1967.Google Scholar

93 NCNA, 27 March 1968.Google Scholar

94 NCNA, 27 March 1968.Google Scholar

95 Hsü Shih-yu (Nanking), Han Hsien-ch'u (Fuchow), Huang Yung-sheng (Canton), Ch'en Hsi-lien (Shenyang), and Yang Te-chih, Tsinan.Google Scholar

96 Chu-ying tung-fang-hung (Pearl River East is Red) (Peking), in FF, Vol. 1, No. 17, p. 18.Google Scholar

97 From some remarks in Lin Piao's speech condemning Yang Ch'eng-wu, and also from the violent attack Chiang Ch'ing directed against Yang at the same rally in Peking, some observers have concluded that she also played an important part in the purge of the Acting Chief of General Staff. I would, however, argue that her role did not match that of the regional commanders, because in March 1968 the position of the Cultural Revolution Group—after the purges of Wan Li, Kuang Feng and Ch'i Pen-yü—had already been so weakened that this group and Chiang Ch'ing herself could only play an auxiliary role in the process of Yang's dismissal.Google Scholar

98 See Domes, , Kulturrevolution und Armee, p. 37.Google Scholar

99 NCNA, 8 April 1968.Google Scholar

100 NCNA, 11 April 1968.Google Scholar

101 Anhwei Radio, 6 February 1967.Google Scholar

102 Anhwei Radio, 2 March 1967.Google Scholar

103 Anhwei Radio, 4 March 1968.Google Scholar

104 NCNA, 19 April 1968.Google Scholar

105 See Watson, Andrew, “Revolution in Sian,” Far Eastern Economic Review (Hong Kong), Vol. 56, No. 4, pp. 231–233; No. 5, pp. 266–269; No. 7, pp. 403–406, and No. 8, pp. 449–452.Google Scholar

106 Shensi Radio, 25 July 1967.Google Scholar

107 JMJP, 17 and 27 02 and 1 03 1968.Google Scholar

108 NCNA, 2 May 1968.Google Scholar

109 NCNA, 11 May 1968.Google Scholar

110 Peking wall-posters, reported in Ming-pao (Hong Kong), 18 04 1967Google Scholar; and Asahi Shimbun, 7 05 1967.Google Scholar

111 Peking wall-posters, quoted in Asahi Shimbun, evening edition, 9 05 1967.Google Scholar

112 Szechwan PBS, 18 April 1968.Google Scholar

113 NCNA, 2 June 1967.Google Scholar

114 For a detailed account of the developments in Yunnan, see Falkenheim, Victor C., “The Cultural Revolution in Kwangsi, Yunnan and Fukien,” Asian Survey (Berkeley, Calif.), Vol. IX, No. 8 (08 1969), pp. 587–591.Google Scholar

115 Ibid. p. 588, quoting Kunming Radio, 23 April 1967.

116 FF, Vol. I, No. 24, p. 13.Google Scholar

117 NCNA, 14 August 1968.Google Scholar

118 See Falkenheim, , “The Cultural Revolution in Kwangsi,” Asian Survey, Vol. IX, No. 8, pp. 591–595.Google Scholar

119 See ibid. pp. 592 f, and Domes, , Kulturrevolution und Armee, pp. 105 f.Google Scholar

120 NCNA, 16 February 1967.Google Scholar

121 See Falkenheim, , “The Cultural Revolution in Kwangsi,” Asian Survey, Vol. IX, No. 8, p. 594.Google Scholar

122 NCNA, 20 August 1968.Google Scholar

123 See Falkenheim, , “The Cultural Revolution in Kwangsi,” Asian Survey, Vol. IX, No. 8, p. 582–587.Google Scholar

124 Kweilin Radio, 28 and 30 August 1968.Google Scholar

125 Falkenheim, , “The Cultural Revolution in Kwangsi,” Asian Survey, Vol. IX, No. 8, p. 585.Google Scholar

126 Cf. URS Vol. 53, No. 9, p. 101.Google Scholar

127 See URS, Vol. 53, No. 9, p. 101.Google ScholarPubMed

128 NCNA, 27 August 1968.Google Scholar

129 NCNA, 6 September 1968.Google Scholar

130 According to an evaluation of a list which appeared in Issues of Studies (Taipei), Vol. VI, No. 1 (10 1969), pp. 106–109.Google Scholar