Hostname: page-component-745bb68f8f-lrblm Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2025-01-09T14:12:12.886Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The Construction of Consent for High-altitude Resettlement in Tibet

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  03 March 2023

Yonten Nyima  and
Emily T. Yeh Open the ORCID record for Emily T. Yeh [Opens in a new window]
Yonten Nyima*
Affiliation:
Wagner Graduate School of Public Service, New York University; Independent Researcher, New York City, United States,
Emily T. Yeh
Affiliation:
Department of Geography, University of Colorado Boulder, United States
*
Corresponding author: Yonten Nyima, email: [email protected]
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

In 2018, the Tibet Autonomous Region began resettling pastoralists from high-altitude areas to newly built settlements in distant, lower-altitude farming locations under the “extremely high-altitude ecological resettlement” programme, with a stated dual purpose of environmental protection and improving pastoralist well-being. The programme is said to be based on a principle of “government guidance and voluntary participation.” However, despite its stated “voluntary” nature, the government reports a 100 per cent rate of agreement to participate. After examining the ecological rationales for resettlement and pastoralists’ reluctance to move owing to livelihood concerns and attachment to homeland, the article examines how consent is achieved. Based on official documents and reports as well as semi-structured interviews with officials and pastoralists in Nagchu Municipality, the core target area for the programme, the article identifies a three-step “thought-work” oriented process – beginning with an initial survey, followed by group incentives and warnings and then individual incentives and warnings – which is deployed until pastoralists sign a resettlement agreement. The process illustrates the dialectical relationship between coercion and consent.

摘要

摘要

自 2018 年起，以保护生态和改善民生为由，以“政府主导、群众自愿”为原则，西藏自治区实施 “极高海拔生态搬迁”项目，将生活在高海拔牧区的牧民远迁至在海拔相对较低的农区新建的安置点。政府宣称，牧民搬迁出于自愿，搬迁同意率达到百分之百。基于对项目核心区那曲市的牧民和官员的访谈，结合官方报道，在讨论完搬迁的生态保护理由以及事实上牧民因搬迁后的生计之忧和故土难离之情并不愿搬迁之后，本文探讨了政府是如何使牧民同意搬迁的。文章指出了一个以“思想工作”为核心的分三步的建构同意的过程。首先是对牧民进行搬迁意愿调查，紧接着是对牧民进行从集体 (第二步) 到个人 (第三步) 的思想引导，恩威并施，直到所有牧民签署搬迁同意书。这一过程显示了被强制与同意之间的辩证关系。

Keywords

Tibetpastoralismresettlementconsentthought work西藏畜牧业搬迁同意思想工作
Type
Research Article
Information
The China Quarterly , Volume 254 , June 2023 , pp. 429 - 447
Check for updates
Copyright
Copyright © The Author(s), 2023. Published by Cambridge University Press on behalf of SOAS University of London

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Barnett, Robert. 2021. “China is using Tibetans as agents of empire in the Himalayas.” Foreign Policy, 28 July, https://foreignpolicy.com/2021/07/28/china-tibet-bhutan-empire-borders-villages/?tpcc=recirc_trending06292.Google Scholar
Bauer, Ken. 2015. “New homes, new lives – the social and economic effects of resettlement on Tibetan nomads (Yushu prefecture, Qinghai province, PRC).” Nomadic Peoples 19(2), 209–220.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bum, Tsering. 2018. “Translating ecological migration policy: a conjunctural analysis of Tibetan pastoralist resettlement in China.” Critical Asian Studies 50(4), 518–536.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Cao, Bin, Cheng, Lu and Zhang, Jingpin. 2018. “Relocation changing lives on Tibetan Plateau.” China Daily, 22 June, https://www.chinadaily.com.cn/a/201806/22/WS5b2c58d6a3103349141ddb7d.html.Google Scholar
Cao, Jian, Zhang, Jingpin, Langjie, Gesang, Lü, Qiuping and Bianjiao, Gesang. 2022. “Tongwang xingfu de qianxi – quanguo haiba zuigao xian Xizang Shuanghu xian shengtai banqian ji” (The resettlement to happiness – an account of ecological resettlement of Tibet's Tsonyi county, the highest county in China). Xinhua baoye, 23 July, http://www.xhby.net/tuijian/202207/t20220723_7627356.shtml.Google Scholar
Chen, Hongbing, Zhang, Jingpin and Tian, Jinwen. 2021. “Qishang Shuanghu – Xinhuashe jizhe jianzheng woguo haiba zuigao xian zhibian” (Going up to Shuanghu for the seventh time – Xinhua reporters witnessed the change of the country's highest county). Xinhuanet, 17 February, http://www.xinhuanet.com/politics/2021-02/17/c_1127107688.htm.Google Scholar
Chu, Julie. 2014. “When infrastructures attack: the workings of disrepair in China.” American Ethnologist 41(2), 351–367.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ciji, . 2021. “Xizang 2.6 wan yu ming banqian qunzhong jinnian jiang ruzhu ‘xinjia’” (More than 26,000 resettled people in Tibet will move into “new homes” this year). Xizang shang bao, 3 March, https://mp.weixin.qq.com/s/uoM0W8QK7u--d3B5Giqx4Q.Google Scholar
Creemers, Rogier. 2017. “Cyber China: upgrading propaganda, public opinion work and social management for the twenty-first century.” Journal of Contemporary China 26(103), 85–100.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Du, Fachun. 2017. “Tibetan herders without livestock: an empirical analysis of ‘ecological resettlement’ in Madoi.” In Gruschke, Andreas and Breuer, Ingo (eds.), Tibetan Pastoralists and Development: Negotiating the Future of Grassland Givelihoods. Wiesbaden: Reichert Verlag, 95–108.Google Scholar
Farrington, John, and Tsering, Dawa. 2019. “Human–snow leopard conflict in the Chang Tang region of Tibet, China.” Biological Conservation 237, 504–513.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Foggin, Marc. 2011. “Rethinking ‘ecological migration’ and the value of cultural continuity: a response to Wang, Song, and Hu.” AMBIO: A Journal of the Human Environment 40, 100–01.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Foggin, Marc, and Torrance-Foggin, Marion. 2011. “How can social and environmental services be provided for mobile Tibetan herders? Collaborative examples from Qinghai province, China.” Pastoralism: Research, Policy and Practice 1, 21. https://doi.org/10.1186/2041-7136-1-21.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gebre, Ynitso. 2002. “Contextual determination of migration behaviours: the Ethiopian resettlement in light of conceptual constructs.” Journal of Refugee Studies 15(3), 265–282.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gegye County Government. 2019. “Gejizhen yantao gaohaiba fupin banqian” (Gegye town discusses poverty alleviation through high-altitude resettlement), 28 February, https://mp.weixin.qq.com/s/lUnghA0o84ej_kNgEdMn2Q.Google Scholar
Gong, Jinmei. 2020. “Jigaohaiba shengtai banqian: shixian renyuziran hexie gongsheng – shengtai baohu tong minsheng gaishan xiangjiehe de shengdong shijian” (High-altitude resettlement: achieving harmonious development between humans and nature – a vivid practice of combining ecological protection with improvement of people's livelihood). Tibetan Studies S1, 126–132.Google Scholar
Habich, Sabrina. 2015. “Strategies of soft coercion in Chinese dam resettlement.” Issues and Studies 51(1), 165–199.Google Scholar
Harris, Richard. 2010. “Rangeland degradation on the Qinghai-Tibetan Plateau: a review of the evidence of its magnitude and causes.” Journal of Arid Environments 74, 1–12.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hopping, Kelly, Knapp, Alan, Dorji, Tsechoe and Klein, Julia. 2018. “Warming and land use change concurrently erode ecosystem services in Tibet.” Global Change Biology 24(11), 5534–48.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Jiang, Cuilian, and Chen, Yuejun. 2020. “Wu Yingjie Qi Zhala zai Senburi jigao haiba diqu shengtai banqian anzhidian diaoyan” (Wu Yingjie and Chedralha conducted a field visit to the Sinpuri extremely high-altitude ecological resettlement site). Xizang ribao, 2 January, http://cpc.people.com.cn/n1/2020/0103/c117005-31533809.html.Google Scholar
Jiang, Yanpeng, Waley, Paul and Gonzalez, Sara. 2018. “‘Nice apartments, no jobs’: how former villagers experienced displacement and resettlement in the western suburbs of Shanghai.” Urban Studies 55(14), 3202–17.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lehnert, L.W., Wesche, K., Trachte, K., Reudenbach, C. and Bendix, J.. 2016. “Climate variability rather than overstocking causes recent large cover changes of Tibetan pastures.” Scientific Reports 6, 24367.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Liu, Nicole, Lo, Carlos, Zhan, Xueyong and Wang, Wei. 2015. “Campaign-style enforcement and regulatory compliance.” Public Administration Review 75(1), 85–95.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lo, Kevin, and Wang, Mark. 2017. “How voluntary is poverty alleviation resettlement in China?” Habitat International 73, 34–42.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Municipal Statistics Bureau of Nagchu. 2021. “Naqu shi diqici quanguo renkou pucha zhuyao shuju gongbao” (The seventh national census of Nagqu municipality: the main data bulletin), 9 July 2021, https://mp.weixin.qq.com/s/b7CsgU7TaJTsmxM_93D7lg.Google Scholar
Nagchu Municipal Government. 2022. “Naqu shi zhengfu gongzuo baogao” (Nagchu municipality government work report). Zhongguo jingji wang, 31 March, http://district.ce.cn/newarea/roll/202203/31/t20220331_37452088.shtml.Google Scholar
National Bureau of Statistics of China. 2022. “Zhonghua renmin gongheguo 2021 nian guomin jingji he shehui fazhan tongji gongbao” (Statistical communiqué of the PRC on the 2021 national economic and social development), 28 February, http://www.stats.gov.cn/tjsj/zxfb/202202/t20220227_1827960.html.Google Scholar
NCG (Nyima County Government). 2018a. “Nima xian zhashi kaizhan gaohaiba shengtai banqian diaoyan gongzuo” (Nyima county solidly carries out field research on high-altitude ecological resettlement), 6 April, https://mp.weixin.qq.com/s/dyA78OwkVytDPj0p8EDTEA.Google Scholar
NCG. 2018b. “Nima xian yi ‘liuxiangcuoshi’ wei zhuashou, zhashi kaizhan gaohaiba shengtai banqian gongzuo” (Grasping “six measures,” Nyima county solidly carries out high-altitude ecological resettlement work), 25 June, https://mp.weixin.qq.com/s/fQLrsuburUmHt3P9TZnOzQ.Google Scholar
NCG. 2020a. “Nima xian Laiduo xiang dangwei shuji xiangzhang Gusang shenru cun (ju) kaizhan jigao haiba shengtai banqian qunzhong sixiang jiaoyu gongzuo” (Kusang, deputy secretary of the Latod township Party committee and head of the township, went deep into villages (residences) to carry out work on thought education among masses about extremely high-altitude ecological resettlement), 10 July, https://mp.weixin.qq.com/s/Fun64MbSsdmFRMi3ZUd0ag.Google Scholar
NCG. 2020b. “Nima xian Zhongcan xiang zuzhi kaizhan jigao haiba duqi shengtai banqian xunhui xuanchuan jiaoyu huodong” (Drongtsang township, Nyima county, organizes and conducts publicity and educational tours for extremely high-altitude ecological resettlement), 5 June, https://mp.weixin.qq.com/s/Jh8MqAjKsKJWOSW7ppgisw.Google Scholar
NCG. 2022. “Shi gaohaiba shengtai banqian anzhi lingdao xiaozu chengyuan Caiwang Renzeng yixing diaoyan Nima xian jigao haiba banqian qianqi gongzuo kaizhan qingkuang” (Tsewang Renzin, a member of the municipal leading group for high-altitude ecological resettlement, and his team investigated the preliminary work of high-altitude resettlement in Nyima county), 13 April, https://mp.weixin.qq.com/s/OYkC4Zg0dKrJaIyGfgtLVw.Google Scholar
NCPC (Nyima County Party Committee). 2022. “Shixian Rongma xiang gaohaiba shengtai banqian qunzhong wendezhu youjiuye zhubu nengzhifu” (Realizing [the goal] of settling down, finding employment and gradually getting rich among masses resettled under the extremely high-altitude ecological resettlement [programme] in Rongma Township), 10 April, https://mp.weixin.qq.com/s/Cc4IOE6GLIBhIaiZCrCKSw.Google Scholar
Nyima, Yonten. 2019. “Political-economic factors in official reports on rangeland degradation: a critical case study from the Tibet Autonomous Region.” Area 51(1), 104–112.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Nyima, Yonten. 2021. “The implementation of China's rangeland protection program: the case of Nagchu in the Tibet Autonomous Region.” Journal of Contemporary China 132, 977–992.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Nyima, Yonten, and Yeh, Emily T.. 2016. “Environmental issues and conflict in Tibet.” In Hillman, Ben and Tuttle, Gray (eds.), Ethnic Conflict and Protest in Tibet and Xinjiang. New York: Columbia University Press, 151–178.Google Scholar
OPADAC (Office of Poverty Alleviation and Development of Amdo County). 2018. “Anduo xian shunli wancheng Sewu xiang 2, 3, 4 cun mumin qunzhong gaohaiba shengtai banqian yiyuan zhengqiu gongzuo” (Amdo county has smoothly completed the work of soliciting the willingness of pastoralists in villages 2, 3 and 4 of Seu township for high-altitude ecological resettlement), 25 May, https://mp.weixin.qq.com/s/07SKq2h9ANANfU_qaBoXgQ.Google Scholar
OPADNP (Office of Poverty Alleviation and Development of Nagchu Prefecture). 2017. “Naqu diqu shengtai banqian gongzuo kaizhan qingkuang” (On the development of ecological resettlement work in Nagchu prefecture), 6 June, https://mp.weixin.qq.com/s/cSnC9GLQZe9VvbMGvM_hpw.Google Scholar
Organization Department of Ngamring County. 2020. “Qiere xiang zhashi tuijin jigao haiba shengtai banqian zhengce xuanchuan gongzuo” (Gad'rag township solidly advances publicity work on the policy of extremely high-altitude ecological resettlement), 13 October, https://mp.weixin.qq.com/s/huuECkIAt3wj2M8sdH21hQGoogle Scholar
PDNC (Propaganda Department of Nangkarze County). 2020. “Langkazi xian zhaokai gaohaiba shengtai banqian zuotanhui” (Nangkarze county convenes a forum on high-altitude ecological resettlement), 23 October, https://mp.weixin.qq.com/s/eFY-PQYKfkvTfLrbyE8Gwg.Google Scholar
PDSCPC (Propaganda Department of Saga County Party Committee). 2019. “Dunzhu shenru woxian Gaoqiong cun xuanjiang gaohaiba shengtai banqian zhengce” (Dondrub went to Karchung village in our county to publicize high-altitude ecological resettlement policies), 11 November, https://mp.weixin.qq.com/s/Kv0CaQp2acYRHAfbBtKw0w.Google Scholar
PSBTC (Public Security Bureau of Tsonyi County). 2021. “Shuanghu xian gong'anju zhu Senburi jingwuzhan chenggong tiaojie yiqi jubu zhifu laodong baochou jiufen” (Sinpuri police station successfully mediated a dispute over refusal to pay labour compensation), 4 June, https://mp.weixin.qq.com/s/IrZDv-lBJIVglhFaDurubA.Google Scholar
Ptáčková, Jarmila. 2020. Exile from the Grasslands: Tibetan Herders and Chinese Development Projects. Seattle, WA: University of Washington Press.Google Scholar
Regional Bureau of Statistics of Tibet. 2022. “2021 nian Xizang zizhiqu guomin jingji he shehui fazhan tongji gongbao” (Statistical communiqué of the TAR on the 2021 national economic and social development), 26 April, https://www.xizang.gov.cn/zwgk/zfsj/ndtjgb/202204/t20220426_295819.html.Google Scholar
Rogers, Sarah, Li, Jie, Lo, Kevin, Guo, Hua and Li, Cong. 2020. “China's rapidly evolving practice of poverty resettlement: moving millions to eliminate poverty.” Development Policy Review 38(5), 541–554.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Rogers, Sarah, and Wang, Mark. 2006. “Environmental resettlement and social dis/re-articulation in Inner Mongolia, China.” Population and Environment 28(1), 41–68.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Sun, Xin. 2020. “Campaign-style implementation and affordable housing provision in China.” The China Journal 84, 76–101.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Tang, Zhaoming. 2022. “Liuzai xin zhong de ge: yifen kaifa Shuanghu wurenqu de zhengui baogao” (Songs that remain in one's heart: a precious report on the development of the no-man's land in Tsonyi). Tibet.cn, 26 November, http://m.tibet.cn/cn/zt2019/zbgs/wz/202211/t20221126_7314941.html.Google Scholar
TARDEE (Tibet Autonomous Regional Department of Ecological Environment). 2019. “Naqu shi gaohaiba shengtai banqian gongzuo youxu tuijin” (The work of high-altitude ecological resettlement in Nagchu municipality advances in an orderly manner), 28 October, http://www.xizang.gov.cn/xwzx_406/dsdt/201911/t20191114_122504.html.Google Scholar
TARFD (TAR Forestry Department). 2018. “Yundan tongzhi dao Gurong xiang gaohaiba diqu shengtai banqian anzhiqu xietiao banqian anzhi gongzuo shiyi” (Comrade Yonten went to the high-altitude ecological resettlement site in Gurum township to coordinate resettlement and placement work), 17 June, https://mp.weixin.qq.com/s/qB2bS4pANNJaTpeiqKWaOg.Google Scholar
TARG (TAR Government). 2017. “Xizang zizhiqu shengtai banqian shidian fang'an” (The TAR's pilot plan for ecological resettlement). TAR Government.Google Scholar
TARG. 2018. “Xizang zizhiqu jigao haiba diqu shengtai banqian guihua (2018–2025)” (The TAR's plan for extremely high-altitude ecological resettlement (2018–2025)). TAR Government.Google Scholar
TCG (Tsonyi County Government). 2017a. “Shuanghu xian jizhong kaizhan Yangbajing yidi banqian zhengce xuanchuan gongzuo” (Tsonyi county mobilizes launch of propaganda work on resettlement policy to Yangpachen), 12 June, https://mp.weixin.qq.com/s/QbtJofWhdZvC_TgjVc2lQA.Google Scholar
TCG. 2017b. “Shuanghu xian shenru kaizhan gaohaiba shengtai banqian minyi diaocha” (Tsonyi county conducts in-depth public opinion surveys on high-altitude ecological resettlement), 14 November, https://mp.weixin.qq.com/s/6dUU2FenCVtaHvutU_HKMw.Google Scholar
TCG. 2018. “Shuanghu xian guanyu Xizang zizhiqu 2018 nian gaohaiba diqu shengtai banqian shidian shishi fang'an fankui yijian taolun huiyi” (Tsonyi county's discussion meeting on the TAR's pilot implementation plan for high-altitude ecological resettlement for 2018), 15 June, https://mp.weixin.qq.com/s/IutBQaH2QFbRpq_DXclXpQ.Google Scholar
Vandergeest, Peter, Idahosa, Pablo and Bose, Pablo (eds.). 2007. Development's Displacements Economies, Ecologies, and Cultures at Risk. Chicago: The University of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
Wang, Mark, and Lo, Kevin. 2015. “Displacement and resettlement with Chinese characteristics: an editorial introduction.” Geography Research Forum 35, 1–9.Google Scholar
Wang, Min, and Han, Hailan. 2020. “Naqu shi Senburi banqian anzhidian 286 ming qunzhong jiang shixian jiuye” (286 people from Nagchu municipality resettled at Sinpuri will be employed). Renmin wang, 3 April, http://xz.people.com.cn/n2/2020/0403/c138901-33925346.html.Google Scholar
Wilmsen, Brooke, and Wang, Mark. 2015. “Voluntary and involuntary resettlement in China: a false dichotomy?” Development in Practice 25, 612–627.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Wilmsen, Brooke, Webber, Michael and Duan, Yuefang. 2011. “Development for whom? Rural to urban resettlement at the Three Gorges Dam, China.” Asian Studies Review 35(1), 21–42.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bank, World. 2004. Involuntary Resettlement Sourcebook: Planning and Implication in Development Projects. Washington, DC: World Bank.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Xue, Longyi, Wang, Mark and Xue, Tao. 2013. “‘Voluntary’ poverty alleviation resettlement in China.” Development and Change 44, 1159–80.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Yeh, Emily T. 2013. Taming Tibet: Landscape Transformation and the Gift of Chinese Development. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Zhang, Jingpin, and Jueguo. 2018. “Xizang shoupi banli gaohaiba diqu mumin shuxie qianxi chuanqi” (The first group of pastoralists moving out of high-altitude areas writes migration legends). Tibet.cn, 20 September, http://www.tibet.cn/cn/cloud/xszqkk/zgxz/2018/05/201809/t20180920_6275045.html.Google Scholar
Zhang, Mingyu. 2010. “Tibet's no-man land: today's new pastoral area.” Xinhuanet, 13 January, https://www.mfa.gov.cn/ce/cein//eng/focus/t652530.htm.Google Scholar
Zhou, Jianwei, Zhang, Jingpin and Tian, Jinwen. 2020. “Kuayue bange shiji de shengming qianxi: Xizang jigao haiba shengtai banqian pojie renyuziran gongsheng nanti” (Life migration spanning half a century – Tibet's extremely high-altitude ecological resettlement solves the problem of symbiosis between man and nature). Xinhuanet, 17 March, http://www.xinhuanet.com/politics/2020-03/17/c_1125726595.htm.Google Scholar
Zou, Wenxue, and Tang, Lu. 2021. “What do we believe in? Rumors and processing strategies during the COVID-19 outbreak in China.” Public Understanding of Science 30(2), 153–168.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed