Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-g7gxr Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-03T02:46:12.358Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

“War Trauma” and the Politics of PTSD during and after the Wars of Yugoslav Succession

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  13 June 2022

Ana Antić Open the ORCID record for Ana Antić [Opens in a new window]
Ana Antić*
Affiliation:
University of Copenhagen, Kobenhavn, Denmark
*
Email: [email protected]
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

This article explores how the concept of post-traumatic stress disorder was developed and debated during the wars of Yugoslav succession 1991–1995. It focuses on the rich, wide-ranging, and complex psychiatric and psychotherapeutic discussions of war trauma in the post-Yugoslav space, arguing that arguments about PTSD became a site for expressing political tensions, controversies, and anxieties that could not otherwise be addressed or identified.

This research explores how Yugoslav psychiatrists tailored the language of PTSD to their own particular clinical and political needs, infusing it with local assumptions and experiences, often radically changing its original meaning and intentions in the process. Moreover, the article engages with discourses of psychological trauma in Eastern Europe and the socialist world, which remains a neglected topic. It examines how the post-WWII and socialist-era psychiatric discourse and silences were reinterpreted and worked into the psychiatric-political attempts to make sense of the wars of Yugoslav succession.

Keywords

history of psychiatryPTSDWars of Yugoslav succession
Type
Article
Information
Central European History , Volume 55 , Issue 2 , June 2022 , pp. 242 - 266
Copyright
Copyright © The Author(s), 2022. Published by Cambridge University Press on behalf of Central European History Society of the American Historical Association

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Lerner, Paul and Micale, Mark, Traumatic Pasts: History, Psychiatry, and Trauma in the Modern Age, 1870–1930 (Cambridge and New York: Cambridge University Press, 2009)Google Scholar. On the political and intellectual history of PTSD, see Young, Allan, The Harmony of Illusions: Inventing Post-traumatic Stress Disorder (Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 1995)Google Scholar; Shephard, Ben, A War of Nerves (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 2000)Google Scholar; Horwitz, Allan V., PTSD: A Short History (Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press, 2018)Google Scholar.

2 Derek Summerfield, “A Critique of Seven Assumptions Behind Psychological Trauma Programmes in War-Affected Areas,” Social Science and Medicine 48 (1999): 1449–62; Patrick Bracken, Trauma: Cultural Meaning and Philosophy (London: Whurr Publishers, 2002); Paul Stubbs and Baljit Soroya, “War Trauma, Psycho-Social Projects and Social Development in Croatia,” Medicine and War 12 (1996): 303–14; R. Yehuda and A. C. McFarlane, “Conflict between Current Knowledge about Posttraumatic Stress disorder and Its Original Conceptual Basis,” American Journal of Psychiatry 152 (1995): 1705–13.

3 For notable exceptions, see Catherine Merridale, “The Collective Mind: Trauma and Shell-Shock in Twentieth-Century Russia,” Journal of Contemporary History 35, no. 1 (2000): 39–55; Lisa Kirschenbaum, “The Meaning of Resilience: Soviet Children in WWII,” Journal of Interdisciplinary History 47, no. 4 (2017): 521–35.

4 Janko Kostnapfel, “Rat i mir sa stanovista psihijatrije,” Zbornik III lekara Jugoslavije (Ljubljana: Savez lekarskih društava Jugoslavije, 1971), 281–82.

5 Jozo Tomasevich, War and Revolution in Yugoslavia, 1941–1945: Occupation and Collaboration (Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press, 2001), 744. Although figures remain contested, total human losses are taken to exceed 1.5 million in the entire country; see Bogoljub Kocovic, Zrtve Drugog svetskog rata u Jugoslaviji (London: Nase Delo London, 1985), 172–80). The Yugoslav Reparations Commission estimated material losses at more than $9 billion, which included more than 20 percent of residential housing destroyed or heavily damaged, approximately 60 percent of livestock killed or plundered, and more than 19 million tons of grain and other crops taken out of the country between 1941 and 1945; see Tomasevich, War and Revolution in Yugoslavia, 1941–1945, 715.

6 Bosko Niketic, ”Otvaranje konferencije,” Narodno Zdravlje 2, no. 3 (1946): 4–5.

7 Hugo Klajn, Ratna neuroza Jugoslovena (Belgrade: Tersit, 1995 [1955]).

8 Ruth Betlheim and Gordana Lerotic, Stjepan Betlheim: Radovi, pisma, dokumenti, 1898–1970 (Zagreb: Antibarbarus, 2006), 12. For more on war neurosis in Yugoslavia, including “partisan hysteria,” see Ana Antic, Therapeutic Fascism: Experiencing the Violence of the Nazi New Order (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2017); Heike Karge, “Making Sense of War Neurosis in Yugoslavia,” in Psychological Trauma and the legacies of the First World War, ed. Jason Crouthamel and Peter Leese (London: Palgrave Macmillan, 2017).

9 Eduard Klain, “Uspomene Prof. Dr Huga Klajna na njegovie prve kontakte sa psihoanalizom,” Psihoterapija 29 (1999): 217–21.

10 Stjepan Betlheim et al., “Adaptacija ratnih neurotika,” VSP 9 (1957): 508–09.

11 Kostnapfel, “Rat i mir sa stanovista psihijatrije,” 283–84.

12 Nikola Nikolić, “Drugovima neuropsihijatrima!, Narodno zdravlje: Organ Komiteta za zaštitu narodnog zdravlja F.N.R.J. 3, no. 1 (1946).

13 For more information, see Catherine Baker, The Yugoslav Wars of the 1990s (Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan, 2015).

14 Lara Nettelfield and Sarah Wagner, Srebrenica in the Aftermath of Genocide (Cambridge and New York: Cambridge University Press, 2014).

15 Jovan Bukelic, “Institut za mentalno zdravlje, 1963–1993,” in Stresovi Rata, ed. Predrag Kalicanin et al. (Belgrade: Institute za mentalno zdravlje, 1994), 13–20.

16 Bukelic, “Institut za mentalno zdravlje, 1963–1993,” 19.

17 Interviews with Nevenka Tadic, Svetomir Bojanin, Dusan Popovic and Ksenija Kondic, January–February 2014, Belgrade, Serbia.

18 Vladimir Jovic, “Posttraumatski poremecaj u socijalnom I politickom kontekstu devedesetih,” in Ratna psihotrauma srpskih veterana, ed. Zeljko Spiric (Belgrade: Udruženje boraca rata Republike Srbije od 1990. godine opštine Zvezdara, 2008), 381

19 Jovic, “Posttraumatski poremecaj u socijalnom I politickom kontekstu devedesetih,” 384.

20 Jovan Bukelic, “Prof. Dr Hugo Klajn: Ratna neuroza Jugoslovena,” in Stresovi Rata.

21 Eduard Klain, “Sjecanja na Huga Klajna,” Psihoterapija (1999): 29, 209–15.

22 Klain, “Sjecanja na Huga Klajna,” 213

23 Vlado Jukic and Vasko Muacevic, “Posttraumatski stresni poremecaj,” in Ratna psihologija I psihijatrija, ed. Eduard Klain (Zagreb: Glavno Sanitetski Stozer, 1992), 33.

24 Jukic and Muacevic, “Posttraumatski stresni poremecaj,” 33–34.

25 Vladan Starcevic, “DSM-IV: Nov product iz radionice za proizvodnju psihijatrijskih klasifikacija,” Psihijatrija Danas 26, no. 2–3 (1994): 211–18.

26 Vlado Jukic, “Klinicka slika posttraumatskog stresnog poremecaja,” Socijalna Psihijatrija 20 (1992): 187–97.

27 Marko Munjiza, “Dijagnosticki kriterijumi u psihijatriji,” Psihijatrija Danas 24, no. 3–4 (1992): 257–66.

28 Goran Dokic, “Psychosocial Transition in a Postsocialist Context: PTSD in Croatian Psychiatry” (master's diss., University of Victoria, 2005).

29 Paul Stubbs, “Transforming Local and Global Discourses: Reassessing the PTSD movement in Bosnia and Croatia,” in Forced Migration and Mental Health: Rethinking the Care of Refugees and Displaced Persons, ed. David Ingleby (New York: Springer, 2006).

30 K. Allden et al., Harvard Trauma Manual: Croatian Veterans Version (Cambridge: Harvard Program in Refugee Trauma, 1998).

31 Goran Dokic, “States of Victimhood and Irreparable Losses: Serbian Veterans of the Post-Yugoslav Wars,” Glasnik Etnografskog Instituta SANU 1 (2017): 104–05.

32 Mladen Pupavac and Vanessa Pupavac, “Trauma Advocacy, Veteran Politics and the Croatian Therapeutic State,” Alternatives: Global, Local, Political 37, no. 3 (2012): 199–213.

33 Pupavac and Pupavac, “Trauma Advocacy, Veteran Politics and the Croatian Therapeutic State,” 201–02.

34 Zoran Komar and Herman Vukusic, “Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder in Croatian War Veterans; Incidence and Psychosocial Features” (Zagreb: Ministry of Defence of the Republic of Croatia, 2000).

35 Dokic, “States of Victimhood and Irreparable Losses,” 105; Pupavac and Pupavac, “Trauma Advocacy, Veteran Politics and the Croatian Therapeutic State,” 202.

36 Pupavac and Pupavac, “Trauma Advocacy, Veteran Politics and the Croatian Therapeutic State,” 207–08.

37 Goran Dokic, “Psychosocial transition in a postsocialist context,” 75–80.

38 Ljiljana Moro et al., Potpora radne sredine I obitelji kod posttraumatskog stresnog poreemcaja,” Socijalna Psihijatrija 20 (1992): 233–40.

39 Vlado Jukic, “Posttraumatski stresni sindrom I paranoidnost,” Socijalna Psihijatrija 21 (1993): 52.

40 Jukic, “Klinicka slika posttraumatskog stresnog poremecaja,” 195–96.

41 Jukic, “Klinicka slika posttraumatskog stresnog poremecaja,” 195.

42 Vlado Jukic and Eduard Klain, “Psihicke poteskoce ranjenika I zrtava rata, sa posebnim osvrtom na PTSP,” Klinicka Medicina 1, no. 1 (1992): 79–86.

43 Josip Dojč, “Inozemstvo-Mania, nova zarazna bolest!,” Arhiv Sanitetske sluzbe Ministarstva odbrane, R-202.

44 Vlasta Stalekar and Leonida Akrap, “Otpori proradi ratne trauma I gubitaka,” Socijalna Psihijatrija, 28 (2000): 113–16.

45 Jukic and Klain, “Psihicke poteskoce ranjenika I zrtava rata, sa posebnim osvrtom na PTSP,” 81.

46 James Gow, The Serbian Project and its Adversaries: A Strategy of War Crimes (London: Hurst Publishers, 2003), 236–40.

47 Klajn, Ratna neuroza Jugoslovena, 78–82.

48 Aleksandar Maletic, ”Psihoterapija psihickih ratnih traumi,” Socijalna psihijatrija (1992): 20, 213–14.

49 Jukic and Klain, “Psihicke poteskoce ranjenika I zrtava rata, sa posebnim osvrtom na PTSP,” 81–82.

50 Archive of Serbia, G-222, F-120, files 20888, 20890.

51 Muradif Kulenovic, “Balintove grupe u poslijeratnom razdoblju Hrvatske,” Psihoterapija, 28, no. 1–2 (1998): 77.

52 Kulenovic, “Balintove grupe u poslijeratnom razdoblju Hrvatske,” 76–77.

53 Vedran Bilic, “Oboljeli ucesnik rata u obitelji,” Psihoterapija 28, no. 1–2 (1998): 23–31.

54 Zeljko Spiric, “Foreword,” in Ratna psihotrauma srpskih veterana, ed. Zeljko Spiric (Belgrade, 2008), 12–15.

55 Ljiljana Mitrinovic, NIN, January 16, 2003 (2716).

56 Vladan Beara, Predrag Miljanovic, Boris Popov, “Zasto uopste pomagati ratnim veteranima,” Temida: Casopis o viktimizaciji, ljudskim pravima I rodu 7, no. (2004): 47–49.

57 Jovic, “Posttraumatski poremecaj u socijalnom i politickom kontekstu devedesetih,” 369–386.

58 Dokic, “States of Victimhood and Irreparable Losses,” 97–110.

59 Dokic, “States of Victimhood and Irreparable Losses,” 105–06.

60 Jovic, “Posttraumatski poremecaj u socijalnom I politickom kontekstu devedesetih,” 384.

61 Spiric, “Foreword,” 13.

62 Milanko Cabarkapa, “Psiholoske i socijalne posledice neizlecene ratne traume,” in Ratna psihotrauma srpskih veterana, 308.

63 Spiric, “Posleratna adaptacija ratnih vojnih veterana,” in Ratna psihotrauma srpskih veterana, 323–63.

64 Milanko Cabarkapa, “Psiholoski faktori stresa u borbenim aktivnostima” (PhD diss., University of Belgrade, 1996).

65 Cabarkapa, “Psiholoske i socijalne posledice neizlecene ratne traume,” 30.

66 Cabarkapa, “Psiholoske i socijalne posledice neizlecene ratne traume,” 32–33.

67 Cabarkapa, “Psiholoski faktori stresa u ratu na prostorima bivse Jugoslavije,” in Ratna psihotrauma srpskih veterana.

68 Cabarkapa, “Psiholoski faktori stresa u ratu na prostorima bivse Jugoslavije,” 47–48.

69 Branislav Petrovic et al., “Zlostavljanje uhapsenih I zarobljenih lica,” in Stresovi Rata, 158.

70 Spiric, “Posleratna adaptacija ratnih vojnih veterana,” 326–37.

71 Spiric, “Posleratna adaptacija ratnih vojnih veterana,” 327.

72 Predrag Kalicanin and Irina Petkovic, “Reaktivni psihicki poremecaji prema ICD-X klasifikaciji,” Psihijatrija Danas 24, no. 3–4 (1992): 285–90.

73 Spiric, “Posleratna adaptacija ratnih vojnih veterana,” 349–53.

74 Spiric, “Posleratna adaptacija ratnih vojnih veterana,” 354–60.

75 Jovic, “Posttraumatski poremecaj u socijalnom I politickom kontekstu devedesetih,” 369–86.

76 Jovic, “Posttraumatski poremecaj u socijalnom I politickom kontekstu devedesetih,” 384.

77 Jovic, “Posttraumatski poremecaj u socijalnom I politickom kontekstu devedesetih,” 376–77.

78 Jovic, “Posttraumatski poremecaj u socijalnom I politickom kontekstu devedesetih,” 377–78.

79 Allan Young, “The Self-Traumatized Perpetrator as a ‘Transient Mental Illness,’” L'Evolution Psychiatrique 67 (2002): 1–21.

80 Vida Rakic et al., “Psihosocijalne reakcije I poremecaji dece I mladih u izbeglistvu,” in Stresovi Rata, 70–71.

81 Rakic et al., “Psihosocijalne reakcije I poremecaji dece I mladih u izbeglistvu,” 72.

82 Veronika Ispanovic-Radojkovic et al., “Zastita mentalnog zdravlja dece I mladih,” in Stresovi Rata, 62–63.

83 Slobodan Jakulic and Miomir Krstic, “Silovanje kao psihotrauma u ratnim uslovima,” in Stresovi Rata, 161–68.

84 Predrag Kalicanin, “Nasilje nad zdravljem,” in Stresovi Rata, 5–12.

85 Kalicanin, “Nasilje nad zdravljem,” 5–12.

86 Marko Marusic, “The Belgrade Letter,” Croatian Medical Journal 33, no. 2–3 (1992).

87 Predrag Kalicanin, Josif Vesel, Dusica Lecic-Tosevski, “Zloupotreba medicine I psihijatrije u satanizaciji srpskog naroda,” in Stresovi Rata, 219.

88 Marusic, “The Belgrade Letter.”

89 Miro Jakovljevic, “Psychiatric Perspectives of the War against Croatia,” Croatian Medical Journal, War Supplement 2 (1992): 10–17.

90 Vladimir Gruden, “Psychologic Sources of the Serbian Aggression against Croats,” Croatian Medical Journal, War Supplement 2 (1992): 6–9.

91 Eduard Klain, “Yugoslavia as a Group,” Croatian Medical Journal, War Supplement 1 (1992): 3–13.

92 Klain, “Yugoslavia as a Group,” 5.

93 Jakovljevic, “Psychiatric Perspectives of the War against Croatia,” 14–15.

94 Gruden, “Psychologic Sources of the Serbian Aggression against Croats,” 9.

95 Gruden most likely referred to Jovan Raskovic, who emerged as the political representative of Croatian Serbs in 1990, and Radovan Karadzic, the wartime political leader of the Bosnian Serb community, both of whom were trained as psychiatrists. But Croatian psychiatrists and psychoanalysts were by no means alone in engaging in such acts of collective diagnosing and pathologization. In 1996, for instance, Milanko Cabarkapa diagnosed Croats with a “complex of historical inferiority and running away from their south Slavic origins,” Serbs with a complex of “unrequited love and narcissism,” while other, smaller Yugoslav nations were deemed to be suffering from a complex of “unclear identity” that led to secessionism. See Cabarkapa, “Psiholoski faktori stresa u borbenim aktivnostima,” 54.

96 Antic, Ana, “Raising a True Socialist Individual: Yugoslav Psychoanalysis and the Creation of Democratic Marxist Citizens,” Social History 44, no. 1 (2019) 86–115CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Antic, Ana, “Pedagogy of Workers’ Self-Management: Terror, Therapy and Reform Communism after the Tito-Stalin Split,” Journal of Social History 50, no. 1 (Fall 2016)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Antic, Ana, “Imagining Africa in Eastern Europe: Transcultural Psychiatry and Psychoanalysis in Cold War Yugoslavia,” Contemporary European History 28, no. 2 (2019)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

97 Klain, “Yugoslavia as a Group,” 13.

98 Radomir Samardzic, “Ratno zarobljenistvo I tortura,” in Ratna psihotrauma srpskih veterana.

99 Freud, Sigmund, “Zasto rat?,” Psihoterapija 23, no. 1–2 (1993)Google Scholar.