Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-8bhkd Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-08T17:35:29.327Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Arguing Abortion: The New Anti-Abortion Discourse in Canada

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  17 June 2013

Paul Saurette  and
Kelly Gordon
Paul Saurette*
Affiliation:
University of Ottawa
Kelly Gordon*
Affiliation:
University of Ottawa
*
Paul Saurette, University of Ottawa, School of Political Studies, Room 7005, Social Sciences Building, 120 University, Ottawa ON K1N 6N5. Email: [email protected]
Kelly Gordon, University of Ottawa, School of Political Studies, Room 7005, Social Sciences Building, 120 University, Ottawa ON K1N 6N5. Email: [email protected]
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Abstract. This article analyzes the nature of contemporary anti-abortion discourse in Canada. Based on a rigorous qualitative and quantitative analysis of the public discourse of a wide variety of influential actors, this study shows that contemporary anti-abortion discourse in Canada is quite different than the portrait offered by traditional accounts. Specifically, our analysis demonstrates that the new anti-abortion discourse aims at changing cultural values more than legislation; is explicitly framed as ‘pro-woman’; largely avoids appealing to religious grounds; and relies on a new ‘abortion-harms-women’ argument that has supplanted and transformed traditional fetal personhood arguments. The article argues that these findings are important as they provide a more accurate account of the political discourse surrounding one of the most contentious issues in politics today and because they illustrate broader ideological patterns that are increasingly characteristic of Canadian political discourse.

Résumé. Cet article propose d'analyser la nature du discours contemporain sur l'anti-avortement au Canada. Fondée sur une analyse qualitative et quantitative rigoureuse du discours public d'une grande variété d'acteurs influents, cette étude démontre que le discours contemporain sur l'anti-avortement au Canada se distingue de manière caractéristique du portrait qu'il en a traditionnellement été donné. Notre analyse révèle en particulier que le nouveau discours sur l'anti-avortement vise plutôt à transformer les valeurs culturelles que la législation; qu'il est explicitement formulé comme étant « pro-femme »; qu'il évite de faire appel à des motifs religieux; et qu'il déploie un nouvel argument, « l'avortement-nuit-aux-femmes », qui évince et transforme les arguments traditionnels qui cherchaient à accorder le statut de personne au fétus. Cet article argumente alors que ces constats sont importants non seulement parce qu'ils permettent de brosser un tableau plus complet du discours politique qui touche à l'une des questions les plus controversée de la politique contemporaine, mais également parce qu'ils mettent en évidence des tendances idéologiques de plus en plus caractéristiques du discours politique au Canada.

Type
Research Article
Information
Canadian Journal of Political Science/Revue canadienne de science politique , Volume 46 , Issue 1 , March 2013 , pp. 157 - 185
Copyright
Copyright © Canadian Political Science Association 2013 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Ackerman, Bruce. 1991. We the People. vol. 1. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.Google Scholar
AFLO. 2010a. “The Trauma of Abortion.” at http://www.allianceforlife.org/abortion9.htmlGoogle Scholar
AFLO. 2010b. “Teens and Abortion.” at http://www.allianceforlife.org/teenabortion.htmlGoogle Scholar
Althusser, L. 2001. “Ideology and Ideological State Apparatuses.” In Lenin and Philosophy and other Essays. New York: Monthly Review Press.Google Scholar
Arendt, Hannah. 1958. The Human Condition. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
Aristotle. 1992. The Art of Rhetoric. New York: Penguin Classics.Google Scholar
Austin, J.L. 1975. Illocutionary Acts and Sentence Meaning. Ithaca: Cornell University Press.Google Scholar
Bacchi, Carol. 2005. Women, Policy and Politics. London: Sage.Google Scholar
Bernays, Edward and Ewen, Stuart. 2011. Crystallizing Public Opinion. New York: Ig Publishing.Google Scholar
Blanchard, Dallas. 1994. The Anti-Abortion Movement and the Rise of the Religious Right. New York: Twayne Publishers.Google Scholar
Boucher, Joanne. 2004. “The Politics of Abortion and the Commodification of the Fetus,” Studies in Political Economy 73 (Spring/Summer): 69–88.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bowen, Kurt. 2004. Christians in a Secular World: The Canadian Experience. Montreal: McGill University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Brodie, Janine, Gavigan, Shelley and Jenson, Jane. 1992. The Politics of Abortion. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.Google Scholar
Canada. 2008. House of Commons Debate. February 27, 2008. Line 1520.Google Scholar
Canada. 2012. House of Commons Debate. Apr 26, 2012. Number 111. Line 1715.Google Scholar
Cassidy, Keith. 1996. “The Right to Life Movement.” In The Politics of Abortion and Birth Control, ed. Critchlow, Donald. University Park PA: Pennsylvania State University Press.Google Scholar
CBC News. January 19, 2011a. “Death Penalty Not on Agenda.” http://www.cbc.ca/politics/story/2011/01/18/harper-mansbridge-interview-tues.html#ixzz1Bu5SbDCu.Google Scholar
CBC News. April 21, 2011b. “Harper says he won't reopen the abortion debate.” http://www.cbc.ca/news/politics/canadavotes2011/story/2011/04/21/cv-election-parenthood-042111.html.Google Scholar
CBC News. May 10, 2012. “Anti-Abortion protesters demand Tories revisit issue”, http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/ottawa/story/2012/05/10/pol-anti-abortion-demonstration.html (May 15, 2012).Google Scholar
Chandler, Marthe, Cook, Elizabeth Adell, Jelen, Ted G. and Wilcox, Clyde. 1994. “Abortion in the United States and Canada: A Comparative Study of Public Opinion.” In Abortion Politics in the US and Canada, ed. Jelen, Ted and Chandler, Marthe. Westport: Praeger.Google Scholar
Cicero, M.T. 2001. “Cicero on the Ideal Orator”. In De Oratore, ed. May, J.M. and Wisse, trans. J.. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Connolly, William. 2002. Neuropolitics: Thinking, Culture, Speed. Minneapolis: University of Minnessota Press.Google Scholar
Connolly, William. 2008. Capitalism and Christianity. Raleigh: Duke University Press.Google Scholar
Cuneo, Michael. 1985. Catholics Against the Church: Anti-Abortion Protest in Toronto. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.Google Scholar
deVeber Institute for Bioethics and Social Research. 2004. “Women's Health After Abortion: The Medical and Psychological Evidence.” http://www.deveber.org/text/whealth.html (January 27, 2004).Google Scholar
Dworkin, Andrea. 1983. Right-Wing Women. New York: Perigee Books.Google Scholar
Dworkin, Ronald. 1986. Law's Empire. Cambridge: HUP.Google Scholar
Dworkin, Ronald. 1996. Freedom's Law. Cambridge: HUPGoogle Scholar
Erdman, J. 2006. “In the Back Alleys of Health Care: Abortion, Equality and Community in Canada.” Emory Law Journal 56 (4): 1093–1156.Google Scholar
Ewen, Stuart. 1996. PR! A Social History of Spin. New York: Basic Books.Google Scholar
Ewen, Stuart and Ewen, Elizabeth. 1992. Channels of Desire. Minneapolis MI: University of Minnesota Press.Google Scholar
Fairclough, Norman. 2001. Language and Power. New York: Longman.Google Scholar
Faludi, Susan. 1991. Backlash: The Undeclared War Against Women. New York: Anchor Books.Google Scholar
Ferguson, Michaele. 2010. “Choice Feminism and the Fear of Politics.” Perspectives on Politics 8 (1): 247–53.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Flanagan, Tom. 2012. “Landing the Big One: Political Science in the Pursuit of Power.” Paper presented at the WSSR graduate student workshop. Concordia University, May.Google Scholar
Gramsci, A. 1971. Selections from the Prison Notebooks, ed. Smith, G. and Hoard, trans. Q.. New York: International Publishers.Google Scholar
Halfmann, Drew. 2011. Doctors and Demonstrators: How Political Institutions Shape Abortion Law in the United States, Britain, and Canada. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Haussman, Melissa. 2002. “Of Rights and Power: Canadian Federal Abortion Policy 1969–1991.” In Women's Movements and the Democratic State, ed. Stetson, D.. New York: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Haussman, Melissa. 2005. Abortion Politics in North America. Bolder: Lynne Reinner.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Herring, Mark. 2003. The Pro-Life/Choice Debate. Westport: Greenwood Press.Google Scholar
Hirschmann, Nancy. 2010. “Choosing Betrayal.” Perspectives on Politics 8 (1): 271–78.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hoggan, James and Littlemore, Richard. 2009. Climate Cover-Up. Vancouver: Greystone Books.Google Scholar
Jelen, Ted and Chandler, Marthe, eds. 1994. Abortion Politics in the US and Canada. Westport: Praeger.Google Scholar
Kaposy, Chris. 2009. “Improving Abortion Access in Canada.” Health Care Analysis 18 (1): 17–34.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kirkpatrick, Jennet. 2010. “Introduction: Selling Out? Solidarity and Choice in the American Feminist Movement.” Perspectives on Politics 8 (1): 241–45.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lakoff, George. 2002. Moral Politics: How Liberals and Conservatives Think. 2nd ed. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lakoff, George. 2009. The Political Mind. New York: Penguin Books.Google Scholar
Life Canada. 2010, “Our Mission.” at http://www.lifecanada.org/html/organization/mission.html (May 2010).Google Scholar
Luna, Zakiya T. 2009. “From Rights to Justice: Women of Color Changing the Face of US Reproductive Rights Organizing.” Societies without Borders 4 (3): 343–65.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Luna, Zakiya T. 2010. “Marching toward Reproductive Justice: Coalitional (Re) Framing of the March for Women's Lives.” Sociological Inquiry 80 (4): 554–78.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Luna, Zakiya T. 2011. “‘The Phrase of the Day’: Examining Contexts and Co-optation of Reproductive Justice Activism in the Women's Movement.” Research in Social Movements: Conflict and Change 32: 219–246.Google Scholar
Luntz, Frank. 2008. Words that Work: It's Not What You Say, It's What People Hear. New York: Hyperion.Google Scholar
Major, Brenda, Appelbaum, M., Beckman, L., Dutton, M., Russo, N. and West, C.. 2009. “Abortion and Mental Health: Evaluating the Evidence.” American Psychologist 64 (9): 863–90.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Marso, Lori. 2010. “Feminism's Quest for Common Desires.” Perspectives on Politics 8 (1): 263–69.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Mathie, William. 1986. “Reason, Revelation and Liberal Justice.” CJPS 19 (3): 443–66.Google ScholarPubMed
Maurice Vellacott Official Website. 2008. “Niece of Martin Luther King Jr. says abortion is civil rights issue of the 21st century.” May. http://www.mauricevellacott.ca/2003%20MV%20Speaks/May%207,%202008%20-%20PPLC%20press%20conf%20press%20release.pdf.Google Scholar
McDonald, Marci. 2010. The Armageddon Factor. Toronto: Random House Canada.Google Scholar
McLaren, Angus and McLaren, Arlene. 1997. The Bedroom and the State. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Mendelsohn, Matthew and Nadeau, Richard. 1997. “The Religious Cleavage and the Media in Canada.” CJPS 30 (1):129–46.Google Scholar
Morton, F. 1992. Morgentaler vs. Borowski. Toronto: McClelland & Stewart.Google Scholar
Morton, F.L. and Allen, Avril. 2001. “Feminists and the Courts.” CJPS 34 (1): 55–84.Google Scholar
Muldoon, Maureen. 1991. The Abortion Debate in the United States and Canada. New York: Garland.Google Scholar
New York Times. 2011a. “Across Country, Lawmakers Push Abortion Curbs.” Jan 21, A1.Google Scholar
New York Times. 2011b. “Where Abortion Rights are Disappearing.” September 24. http://www.nytimes.com/2011/09/25/opinion/sunday/where-abortion-rights-are-disappearing.html (Sept. 24, 2011).Google Scholar
Perrault, Martine and Cardinal, Linda. 1996. “Le droit au choix et le choix du Droit.” CJPS 29 (2): 244–67.Google Scholar
PWPL. 2007. “The Story.”Google Scholar
PWPL. Feb 4, 2008. “Why I'm prowomanprolife.”Google Scholar
PWPL. Feb 23, 2008. “The Ultimate Goal.”Google Scholar
PWPL. May 13, 2008. “What fits in mother Russia.”Google Scholar
PWPL. May 14, 2008. “A pro-life movement for the new millenium.”Google Scholar
PWPL. July 17, 2008. “Yeah good question.”Google Scholar
PWPL. March 27, 2009. “PWPL in the Citizen.”Google Scholar
PWPL. Apr 18, 2009. “New study: abortion cause relationship problems.”Google Scholar
PWPL. May 21, 2009. “A Pro-life movement for the New Millennium.”Google Scholar
PWPL. Aug 5, 2009. “Abortion and Domestic violence.”Google Scholar
Rue, Vincent. 1981. “Abortion and Family Relations.” Testimony before the Subcommittee on the Constitution of the US Senate Judiciary Committee, US Senate, 97th Congress, Washington DC.Google Scholar
Sethna, Christabelle and Doull, Marion. 2009. “Journey's of Choice? Abortion, Travel and Women's Autonomy.” In Critical Interventions in the Ethics of Healthcare, ed. Murray, Stuart and Holmes, Dave. London: Ashgate.Google Scholar
Signal Hill. 2010. “What to Expect.” http://www.prolifebc.ca/abortion_expect.html.Google Scholar
Signal Hill. 2011. “Campaigns.” http://www.thesignalhill.com/campaigns.Google Scholar
Smith, Andrea. 2005. “Beyond Pro-Choice Versus Pro-Life: Women of Color and Reproductive Justice.” NWSA Journal 17 (1): 119–40.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Snyder-Hall, R. Claire. 2010. “Third-Wave Feminism and the Defence of ‘Choice.’” Perspectives on Politics 8 (1): 255–61.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Steiner, Mark. 2006. The Rhetoric of Operation Rescue. New York: T T and Clark.Google Scholar
Strauss, Leo. 2002. Introduction to Political Philosophy. New York: Scholarly Book Services.Google Scholar
Sunstein, Cass. 1993. Democracy and the Problem of Free Speech. New York: The Free Press.Google Scholar
Tatalovich, Raymond. 1997. The Politics of Abortion in the US and Canada. New York: M.W. Sharpe.Google Scholar
Toronto Star, February 26, 2013. “Rob Ford invited to prayer lobby gainst zoning bylaw.” http://www.thestar.com/news/city_hall/2013/02/26/mayor_rob_ford_invited_to_prayer_rally_against_zoning_bylaw.html.Google Scholar
TRTL. 2010a. “A List of Major Psychological Sequelae of Abortion.” http://www.righttolife.to/wp-content/uploads/2010/02/psychological-effects-of-abortion.pdfGoogle Scholar
TRTL. 2010b. “Abortion Statistics.” http://www.righttolife.to/key-life-issues/abortion/statisticsGoogle Scholar
Tully, James, ed. 1988. Meaning and Context: Quentin Skinner and His Critics. Princeton: Princeton University Press.Google Scholar
Vignetta, Charles, Polis, C.B., Sridhara, S.K. and Blum, R.W.. 2008. “Abortion and long-term mental health outcomes” Contraception 78 (6): 436–50.Google Scholar
Westen, Drew. 1985. Self and Soceity. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Westen, Drew. 2007. The Political Brain. New York: Public Affairs.Google Scholar
Wodak, Ruth and Meyer, Michael. 2009. Methods of Critical Discourse Analysis. 2nd ed. London: Sage.Google Scholar
Wu, Fanda and Arthur, Joyce. 2010. A Survey of Anti-Choice Protesting Activity at Canadian Abortion Clinics. Vancouver: Abortion Rights Coalition of Canada.Google Scholar
www.weneedalaw.ca (May 15, 2012).Google Scholar