Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-mlc7c Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-09T14:08:03.407Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Scandinavian Neuroscience during the Nazi Era

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  23 September 2014

Daniel Kondziella ,
Klaus Hansen  and
Lawrence A. Zeidman
Daniel Kondziella*
Affiliation:
Department of Neurology, Rigshospitalet, Copenhagen University Hospital, Denmark
Klaus Hansen
Affiliation:
Department of Neurology, Rigshospitalet, Copenhagen University Hospital, Denmark
Lawrence A. Zeidman
Affiliation:
Department of Neurology and Rehabilitation, Neuropsychiatric Institute, University of Illinois at Chicago, Chicago, Illinois, USA
*
Department of Neurology, Rigshospitalet, Copenhagen University Hospital, Blegdamsvej 9; DK-2100 Copenhagen. Email: [email protected]
Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Core share and HTML view are not available for this content. However, as you have access to this content, a full PDF is available via the ‘Save PDF’ action button.

Although Scandinavian neuroscience has a proud history, its status during the Nazi era has been overlooked. In fact, prominent neuroscientists in German-occupied Denmark and Norway, as well as in neutral Sweden, were directly affected. Mogens Fog, Poul Thygesen (Denmark) and Haakon Sæthre (Norway) were resistance fighters, tortured by the Gestapo: Thygesen was imprisoned in concentration camps and Sæthre executed. Jan Jansen (Norway), another neuroscientist resistor, escaped to Sweden, returning under disguise to continue fighting. Fritz Buchthal (Denmark) was one of almost 8000 Jews escaping deportation by fleeing from Copenhagen to Sweden. In contrast, Carl Værnet (Denmark) became a collaborator, conducting inhuman experiments in Buchenwald concentration camp, and Herman Lundborg (Sweden) and Thorleif Østrem (Norway) advanced racial hygiene in order to maintain the “superior genetic pool of the Nordic race.” Compared to other Nazi-occupied countries, there was a high ratio of resistance fighters to collaborators and victims among the neuroscientists in Scandinavia.

Résumé:

Résumé:

Bien que l'histoire éminente des neurosciences en Scandinavie soit reconnue à juste titre, son statut pendant la période nazie a été passé sous silence. En fait, des neuroscientifiques éminents au Danemark et en Norvège, deux pays occupés par les nazis, ainsi qu'en Suède, un pays neutre, ont été directement touchés. Mogens Fog, Poul Thygesen (Danemark) et Haakon Saethre (Norvège) étaient des combattants de la résistance qui ont été torturés par la Gestapo, Thygesen a été emprisonné dans des camps de concentration et Saethre a été exécuté. Jan Jansen (Norvège), un autre neuroscientifique résistant, a fui en Suède et il est retourné dans son pays sous déguisement pour continuer de combattre. Fritz Buchthal (Danemark) était parmi environ 8000 Juifs qui ont échappé à la déportation en fuyant Copenhague pour se réfugier en Suède. Par contre, Carl Vaernet (Danemark) est devenu collaborateur et il a réalisé des expériences inhumaines au camp de concentration de Buchenwald, et Herman Lundborg (Suède) et Thorleif Østrem (Norvège) ont fait la promotion de l'hygiène raciale pour maintenir le « pool génétique supérieur de la race nordique ». Si l'on compare la Scandinavie aux autres pays occupés par les nazis, il y a eu un taux élevé de combattants de la résistance par rapport aux collaborateurs et les victimes chez les neuroscientifiques.

Type
Review Article
Information
Canadian Journal of Neurological Sciences , Volume 40 , Issue 4 , July 2013 , pp. 493 - 503
Copyright
Copyright © The Canadian Journal of Neurological 2013

References

1. Bak, SL. From rescue to escape in 1943: De-victimizing the Danish Jews. Paper presented at the congress ‘Towards an integrated perspective on Nazi Policies of Mass Murder;’ Oslo, Norway; June 20-21, 2009.Google Scholar
2. Christensen, CB, Lund, J, Olesen, NW, Sørensen, J. Danmark besat. Krig og hverdag 1940-45. 4th ed. Copenhagen: Informations Forlag; 2009.Google Scholar
3. Dahl, HF, Kirchhoff, H, Lund, J, Vaale, LE, editors. Danske tilstande norske tilstande 1940-45. 1st ed. Copenhagen: Gyldendal; 2010.Google Scholar
4. Aarli, JA, Stien, R. The history of neurology in Scandinavia. Handb Clin Neurol. 2010;95:657–66.Google Scholar
5. Fog, M. Efterskrift 1904-45. 1st ed. Copenhagen: Gyldendal; 1976.Google Scholar
6. Fog, M. Første illegale brevet. Dokumentationsarkivet, Frihedsmuseet, Copenhagen; 1942.Google Scholar
7. Møller, M. Mogens, Fog. Fra Modstandshelt til landsforræder. En biografi. 1st ed. Copenhagen: Gyldendal; 2009.Google Scholar
8. Thygesen, P. Læge i tyske koncentrationslejre. 1st ed. Copenhagen: Thanning og Appel; 1945.Google Scholar
9. Anonymous. Kommentar zu Poul Thygesen - Arzt im Konzentrationslager. Nordfriesland. 1982;16:63–4.Google Scholar
10. Thygesen, P. The concentration camp syndrome. Dan Med Bull. 1980;27:224–8.Google Scholar
11. Zeidman, LA. Dr. Haakon Sæthre: A Norwegian Neuroscientist and his Resistance against Nazi Germany. J Hist Neurosci. 2013;22:160–73.Google Scholar
12. Sæthre, H. Über den Turmschädel, seine Erblichkeit, Pathogenes und neuropsychiatrischen Symptome. Acta Psych Neurol Scand. 1931;6:405–7.Google Scholar
13. Sæthre, H. Ein Beitrag zum Turmschädelproblem (Pathogenese, Erblichkeit und Symptomatologie). Deutsch Zeitschr Nervenheilk. 1931;117:533–5.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
14. Chotzen, F. Eine eigenartige familiäre Entwicklungsstörung. (Akrocephalosyndaktylie, Dysostosis craniofacialis and Hypertelorismus). Monatsschr Kinderheilk. 1932;55:97–102.Google Scholar
15. Gogstad, AC. Helse og hagekors. Helsetjeneste og helse under okkupasjonsstyret i Norge 1940-1945. 1st ed. Bergen: Alma Mater Forlag AS; 1991.Google Scholar
16. Stien, R, Aarli, JA. Hjernens leger - historien om de første norske neurologer. 1st ed. Oslo: Den norske nevrolitterære klubb; 2012.Google Scholar
17. Cohen, MM, Vidaver, D. Asbjørn Følling. In: Ashwal, S, ed. The Founders of Child Neurology. 1st ed. San Francisco: Norman Publishing; 1990.Google Scholar
18. Cohen, MM, Vidaver, D. The man behind the syndrome: Sigvald Refsum. J Hist Neurosci. 1992;1:277–84.Google Scholar
19. Cohen, MM, Vidaver, D. Two Norwegian neurological giants: Georg H Monrad-Krohn and Sigvald Refsum. J Med Biograph. 1989; 6:194–9.Google Scholar
20. McIntosh, J. Transcript of an Oral History Interview with Henrik A. Hartmann, Norwegian, Engineer, Swedish Army, World War II. Conducted via the Wisconsin Veterans Museum Research Center, Madison, WI; 2000.Google Scholar
21. modstand.natmus.dk/Person.aspx?15965 [homepage on the Internet] Copenhagen:Frihedsmuseet [cited December 28, 2012]. Available from http://www.modstand.natmus.dk. Google Scholar
22. Pinelli, P. A tribute to Fritz Buchthal. Neurol Sci. 2004;25:38.Google Scholar
23. Horowitz, SH, Krarup, C. Obituary. Fritz Buchthal, MD. Muscle Nerve. 2004;30:1–2.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
24. Davidsen-Nielsen, H, Høiby, N, Danielsen, NB, Rubin, J. Værnet. Den danske SS-læge i Buchenwald. 1st ed Viby: JP Bøger; 2002.Google Scholar
25. Lundborg, H. Die progressive Myoklonus-Epilepsie (Unverricht’s Myoklonie). 1st ed: Uppsala: Almqvist & Wiksell; 1903.Google Scholar
26. Unverricht, H. Die Myoclonie. 1st ed Wien: F. Deuticke; 1891.Google Scholar
27. Lundborg, H. The danger of degeneracy. Eugenic Rev.1922;13:531–9.Google Scholar
28. Lundborg, H. The danger of degeneracy, II. Eugenic Rev. 1922;14:41–3.Google ScholarPubMed
29. Lundborg, H, Linders, FJ (eds.) The Racial Character of the Swedish Nation. Uppsala: Anthropologia Suecica MCMXXVI. Swedish State Institute for Race Biology; 1926.Google Scholar
30. Lundborg, H. Race biological aspects of some problems of population. Eugenic Rev. 1928;19:290–3.Google Scholar
31. Lundborg, H. Västerlandet i fara: befolkningsfrågor i biologisk och rashygienisk belysning. Göteborg: Ernst V. Hansson; 1934.Google Scholar
32. Rodenwaldt, E. Letter to Schneider C, December 11, 1935; UAH, B-1523-5, cited in Remney, S. P. The Heidelberg Myth: The Nazification and Denazification of a German University. 1st ed. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press; 2003.Google Scholar
33. Hansson, MG, Nilsson, PM. Läkarmedlemmar i Riksföreningen Sverige-Tyskland 1937-1945: vilka och varför? Svensk Medicinhist Tidskr. 2007;11:151–64.Google Scholar
34. Haave, P. Sterilisering av tatere 1934-1977. Norges forskningsrad; 2000.Google Scholar
35. Østrem, T. Fra negativ til positiv befolkningspolitikk. In: Østbye HN, editors. Det nye Norge. Oslo: Blix; 1941.Google Scholar
36. Zeidman, LA. Neuroscience in Nazi Europe Part I: Eugenics, Human Experimentation, and Mass Murder. Can J Neurol Sci. 2011;38:696–703.Google Scholar
37. Berg, O. Spesialisering og profesjonalisering. En beretning om den sivile norske helseforvaltnings utvikling fra 1809 til 2009. Helsetilsynet; 2009 Google Scholar
38. Lund, S. Lægerne og Jødeflugten. In: Svendstorp, A, editor. Den hvide brigade. Danske lægers modstand. Copenhagen: Carl Allers Bogforlag; 1946. p. 175–202.Google Scholar
39. Kondziella, D. Thirty neurological eponyms associated with the Nazi era. Eur Neurol. 2009;62:56–64.Google Scholar
40. Roll-Hansen, N. Eugenic sterilization: A preliminary comparison of the Scandinavian experience to that of Germany. Genome 1989;31:890–5.Google Scholar
41. Björkman, M, Widman, S. Selling eugenics: The case of Sweden. Notes Rec R Soc Lond. 2010;64:379–400.Google Scholar
42. Shevell, M. Neurosciences in the Third Reich: from ivory tower to death camps. Can J Neurol Sci. 1999;26:132–8.Google Scholar
43. Zeidman, LA. Neuroscience in Nazi Europe Part II: Resistance against the Third Reich. Can J Neurol Sci. 2011;38:826–38.Google Scholar
44. Zeidman, LA, Kondziella, D. Neuroscience in Nazi Europe Part III: Victims of the Third Reich. Can J Neurol Sci. 2012; 39: 729–46.Google Scholar