Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-g8jcs Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-22T20:34:05.413Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Lost Lives at Westray: Official Discourse, Public Truth and Controversial Death

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  18 July 2014

John McMullan
John McMullan
Affiliation:
Department of Sociology and Criminology, Saint Mary's UniversityHalifax (N.S.) B3H [email protected]
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

This paper examines the role of official inquiry in the context of controversial deaths at a mine explosion in Canada. It documents how medical science and law contributed to the social production of official knowledge about lost lives in the Westray disaster and analyzes the significance of this public truth-telling on the registration of other truth accounts. The paper concludes by considering the counter-memories to official accounts and the role that a formal public inquiry into the disaster played in further transforming the fields of enunciation about the truth of death at Westray.

Résumé

Cet article examine le rôle de l'enquête officielle sur des décès controversés lors de l'explosion dans une mine au Canada. Il documente comment la science médicale et le droit ont contribué à la production sociale des connaissances officielles sur les vies perdues lors de la catastrophe de Westray et analyse la signification de ce conte public de vérité sur l'enregistrement d'autres comptes-rendus de vérités. L'auteur tient aussi compte des contre-mémoires des comptes-rendus officiels et du rôle qu'une enquête publique formelle sur la catastrophe a joué dans la transformation ultérieure des champs d'énonciation atour de la vérité sur les décès à Westray.

Type
Research Article
Information
Canadian Journal of Law and Society / La Revue Canadienne Droit et Société , Volume 22 , Issue 1 , April 2007 , pp. 21 - 42
Copyright
Copyright © Canadian Law and Society Association 2007

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Province of Nova Scotia. The Westray Story: A Predictable Path to Disaster, Report of the Westray Mine Public Inquiry (Halifax: Government Printer, 1997)Google Scholar Justice K. Peter Richard, Commissioner [The Westray Story].

2 McCormick, C., “The Westray Mine Explosion: Covering a Disaster and a Failed Inquiry” in McCormick, C., ed., Constructing Danger: The Mis/Representation of Crime in the News (Halifax: Fernwood Publishing, 1995) 1 at 197Google Scholar [“Westray Mine Explosion”]; McMullan, J. & Hinze, S., “The Press, Ideology, and Corporate Crime” in McCormick, C., ed., The Westray Chronicles: A Case Study in Corporate Crime (Halifax, Fernwood Publishing, 1999) 183Google Scholar [Westray Chronicles]; T. Richards, “Public Relations and the Westray Mine Explosion” in Westray Chronicles, ibid. 136.

3 Jobb, D., Calculated Risk: Greed, Politics and the Westray Tragedy (Halifax: Fernwood Publishing, 1994)Google Scholar.

4 Ibid.; D. Jobb, “Legal Disaster: Westray and the Justice System” in Westray Chronicles, supra note 2, 163.

5 Beveridge, D. R. & Duncan, P.I., Review of the Nova Scotia Public Prosecution Service (Halifax: Nova Scotia Department of Justice, 2000)Google Scholar.

6 The Westray Story, supra note 1 at VII.

7 Gilligan, G., “Official Inquiry, Truth and Criminal Justice” in Gilligan, G. & Pratt, J., eds., Crime, Truth and Justice: Official Inquiry, Discourse, Knowledge (Cullompton: Willan, 2004) 21Google Scholar [Crime, Truth and Justice].

8 Foucault, M., “Politics and the Study of Discourse” in Burchell, G., Gordon, C. & Miller, P., eds., The Foucault Effect: Studies in Governmentality (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1991a) 53Google Scholar; M. Foucault, “Questions of Method” in Burchell, Gordon & Miller, Ibid. 73.

9 Arendt, H., Between Past and Future: Eight Exercises in Political Thought (New York: Viking Press, 1971)Google Scholar [Eight Exercises]; Arendt, H., The Crises of the Republic (New York: Harcourt, Brace Jovanovich, 1972)Google Scholar [Crises of the Republic]; Williams, B., Truth and Truthfulness: An Essay in Genealogy (Princeton, N.J.: Princeton University Press, 2002)Google Scholar.

10 G. Gilligan & J. Pratt, “Introduction: Crime, Truth and Justice – Official Inquiry and the Production of Knowledge” in Crime, Truth and Justice, supra note 7, 1; Rothberg, R.I. & Thompson, D., eds., Truth vs Justice: The Morality of Truth Commissions (New Jersey: Princeton University Press, 2000)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

11 Burton, F. & Carlen, P., Official Discourse: On Discourse Analysis, Government Publications, Ideology and The State (London: Routledge and Kegan Paul, 1997) at 48Google Scholar.

12 Scratton, P., Hillsborough: The Truth (Edinburgh, Mainstream Publishing, 1999) at 83Google Scholar.

13 Scraton, P., “Lost Lives, Hidden Voices: ‘Truth’ and Controversial Deaths” (2002) 1 Race and Class 107Google Scholar.

14 Foucault, M., “The Eye of Power” in Gordon, C., ed., Power/Knowledge: Selected Interviews and Other Writings (1972-1977) (New York: Pantheon Books, 1980d) 93 [Power/Knowledge]Google Scholar.

15 M. Foucault, “Politics and the Study of Discourse” in G. Burchell, Gordon & Miller, supra note 8, 53.; M. Foucault, “Questions of Method”, Ibid. 73.

16 Findlay, D., “The Good, the Normal and the Healthy: The Social Construction of Medical Knowledge about Women” (1993) 18:2Canadian Journal of Sociology 115CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

17 M. Foucault, “Power and Strategies” in Power/Knowledge, supra note 14, 134.; Foucault, M., Fearless Speech (Los Angeles: Semiotexte, 2001)Google Scholar.

18 Prior, L., The Social Organization of Death: Social Practices and Medical Discourse in Belfast (Basingstoke: MacMillan, 1989)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

19 Latour, B., Science in Action: How to follow Scientists and Engineers through Society (Cambridge, Mass: Harvard University Press, 1987)Google Scholar.

20 Supra note 18 at 325.

21 Atkinson, J.M., Discovering Suicide: Studies in the Social Organization of Death (London: MacMillan, 1978)Google Scholar; Douglas, J.D., The Social Meaning of Suicide (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1967)Google Scholar.

22 Leadbetter, A., “Confessions of Ignorance of Causation in Coroners' Necropsies” (1996) 49:6Journal of Clinical Pathology 439 at 442Google Scholar.

23 Figlo, K., “What is an Accident?” in Weindling, P., ed., The Social History of Occupational Health (London: Croom-Helm, 1985)Google Scholar; Smith, R., “Forensic Pathology, Scientific Expertise, and the Criminal law” in Smith, R. & Wynne, B., eds., Expert Evidence: Interpreting Science in the Law (London: Routledge, 1989) 56.Google Scholar; Tombs, S., “Workplace Injury and Death: Social Harm and the Illusions of Law” in Hillyard, P., Pantazis, C., Tombs, S. & Gordon, D., eds., Beyond Criminology, Taking Harm Seriously (London: Pluto Press, 1984) 156Google Scholar.

24 Slapper, G., Blood in the Bank: Social and Legal Aspects of Death at Work (Aldershot: Ashgate, 1999) at 134Google Scholar.

25 Supra note 19 at 100.

26 Bakan, J., The Corporation, The Pathological Pursuit of Profit and Power (Toronto: Penquin Books, 2004)Google Scholar; Glasbeek, H., Wealth By Stealth: Corporate Crime, Corporate Law and the Perversion of Democracy (Toronto: Between the Lines, 2002)Google Scholar.

27 Becker, H., “Whose Side We On?” (1967) Social Problems 1 at 243Google Scholar.

28 Supra note 9, Eight Exercises and Crises of the Republic; Cohen, S., States of Denial: Knowing About Human Atrocities and Suffering (Cambridge: Polity Press, 2001)Google Scholar.

29 Cohen, Ibid. at 105-106.

30 G. Gilligan & J. Pratt, “Introduction: Crime, Truth and Justice – Official Inquiry and the Production of Knowledge” in Crime, Truth and Justice, supra note 7, 1; Rothberg, R.I., & Thompson, D., eds., Truth vs. Justice: The Morality of Truth Commissions (New Jersey: Princeton University Press, 2000)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Tucker, E. “The Westray Disaster and Its Aftermath: The Politics of Causation” (1995) 10:1C.J.L.S. 92CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

31 P. Scraton. “From Deceit to Disclosure: the Politics of Official Inquiries in the United Kingdom” in G. Gilligan & J. Pratt, supra note 7 [“From Deceit to Disclosure”]; Scraton, P., “Lost Lives, Hidden Voices: ‘Truth’ and Controversial Deaths” (2002) 44:1Race and Class 107Google Scholar; Scraton, P., Hillsborough: The Truth (Edinburgh: Mainstream Publishing, 1999)Google Scholar.

32 G. Gilligan, “Official Inquiry, Truth and Criminal Justice” in G. Gilligan & J. Pratt, supra note 7, 1.

33 P. Stenning, & C. LaPrairie, “‘Politics by Other Means’: the Role of Commissions of Inquiry in establishing the ‘Truth’ about Aboriginal Justice in Canada” in G. Gilligan & J. Pratt, eds., supra note 7.

34 Foucault, M., Fearless Speech (Los Angeles: Semiotexte, 2001)Google Scholar; Miller, J., The Passion of Michel Foucault (New York: Simon and Schuster, 1993) at 270–274Google Scholar; Prado, C. G., Searle and Foucault on Truth (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press) at 93–96Google Scholar; P. Carlen, “Official discourse, comic relief and the play of governance” in G. Gilligan & J. Pratt, supra note 7, 271.

35 Supra note 1 at 552.

36 Trial Transcripts of R. v. Curragh Inc., [1995] N.S.R. (2d) at Feb 14, 1995 (paginated by day of trial only) [Trial Transcripts].

37 Lundsgaarde, H., Crime in Space City: A Cultural Analysis of Houston Homicide Patterns (New York: Oxford University Press, 1977) at 36Google Scholar.

38 “From Deceit to Disclosure”, supra note 31.

39 Trial Transcripts, supra note 36.

40 Ibid.

41 Ibid. at Feb 23, 1995.

42 Perry, R.A., Death Certificates of Explosion Victims (Halifax: Office of Chief Medical Examiner, 1992a)Google Scholar; Perry, R.A., Report of the Chief Medical Examiner: Westray Mine Explosion (Halifax: Office of the Chief Medical Examiner, 1992b)Google Scholar.

43 Trial Transcripts, supra note 36 at Feb 23, 1995.

44 Ibid.

45 Atkinson, J.M., Discovering Suicide: Studies in the Social Organization of Death (London: MacMillan, 1978) at 172–181Google Scholar.

46 Supra note 24 at 138.

47 Cameron, S. & Mitrovica, A., “Burying Westray” Saturday Night (May 1994) 54 at 56Google Scholar.

48 F. Burton & P. Carlen, supra note 11 at 51.

49 Trial Transcripts, supra note 36, at February 2, 1995.

50 Trial Transcripts, supra note 36 at April 10, 1995.

51 Ibid.

52 Ibid.

53 Ibid.

54 Cohen, supra note 28.

55 Gilligan & Pratt, supra note 30 at 132.

56 Supra note 24.

57 Supra note 24 at 93.

58 Bourdieu, P., Outline of a Theory of Practice (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1977) at 169CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

59 F. Burton & P. Carlen, supra note 11 at 51.

60 H. Glasbeek & E. Tucker, “Death by Consensus at Westray?” in Westray Chronicles, supra note 2, 71; T. Hynes & P. Prasad, “The Normal Violation of Safety Rules”, Ibid., 117; Tucker, E., “The Westray Disaster and Its Aftermath: The Politics of Causation” (1995) 10:1C.J.L.S. 92CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

61 Comish, S., The Westray Tragedy: A Miner's Story (Halifax: Fernwood Publishingm, 1993) at 53Google Scholar.

62 D. Jobb “Legal Disaster: Westray and the Justice System” in Westray Chronicles, supra note 2, 163.

63 S. Dodd, “Unsettled Accounts after Westray” in Westray Chronicles, ibid., 232.

64 Ibid. at 230.

65 Davis, C.G., “Picking up the Pieces: The Personal Legacies of Westray” (Paper presented at the Congress of the Humanities and Social Sciences, June 1, 2003, Halifax, Nova Scotia, Canada)Google Scholar [unpublished] [“Picking up the Pieces”]; C.G. Davis, M.J.A. Wolh & N. Verberg “Profiles of Posttraumatic Growth Following an Unjust Loss” Death Studies [forthcoming in 2007].

66 Davis, Wolh & Verberg, Ibid.

67 Krieger, N. & G, Davey Smith, “Bodies Count, and Body Counts: Social Epidemiology and Embodying Inequality” (2004) 26:1Epidemologic Review 94Google ScholarPubMed; Prior, supra note 18 at 63.

68 Dodd, “Unsettled Accounts after Westray” in Westray Chronicles, supra note 2 230 at 238-239.

69 “Picking up the Pieces”, supra, note 65 at 6.

70 Westray Public Inquiry Transcripts (Halifax: Westray Mine Public Inquiry, 1995–1997) Jan. 18, 1996 at 3998Google Scholar.

71 Ibid. at 3965.

72 Ibid. Jan. 22/1996 at 3941.

73 Ibid. at 4344.

74 Ibid. Jan. 18, 1996 at 4149.

75 Ibid, Jan. 25, 1996 at 5150.

76 Ibid. Jan. 18, 1996 at 4151.

77 Ibid. Jan. 22, 1996 at 4333.

78 Ibid. Jan. 18, 1996 at 4136.

79 Ibid. Jan. 18, 1996 at 4115.

80 Ibid. Jan. 22, 1996 at 4404.

81 Ibid. at 4386.

82 Davis, Wohl & Verberg, supra note 65 at 19.

83 Supra note 1 at 1X.

84 Dodd, S., “Where the Slaughter is Wholesale: Fatality Reports from Nova Scotia's Coal Miners” (2005) [unpublished, archived at Halifax: King's College, Nova Scotia, Canada] at 26Google Scholar.

85 Supra note 1 at 3, 14.

86 Supra note 7 at 22.

87 Supra note 1, at VIII.

88 Supra note 11 at 51.