Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-dh8gc Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-08T21:35:59.856Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

III Jean de Gaucourt v. Sir John Handford

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  21 December 2009

Extract

This suit, really three in one, concerned primarily the attempt by Jean de Gaucourt, archdeacon of Joinville at Châlons, to obtain seisin (‘dominium rei’) of the lordship of Maisons-sur-Seine which straddled the river a few miles below Paris, and which had been granted to the Cheshire knight, John Handford, probably (but not certainly, for the point was disputed) by Henry V who had confiscated it from Raoul de Gaucourt. The secondary suits were those brought by a religious community of Senlis first against Jean de Gaucourt, then against Handford, and by the chapter of the Sainte Chapelle in Paris against Handford, to secure the payment of rent-charges with which the lordship was burdened.

Type
Texts
Copyright
Copyright © Royal Historical Society 1982

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 The background of this suit was discussed by Bossuat, A., ‘Le Parlcment de Paris pendant l'occupation anglaise’, Revue Historique 229 (1963), 1940Google Scholar, and particularly 27 seq.

2 For Sir John Handford, sec appendix II.

3 Maisons-Laffitte, Yvelines, arr. Saint-Germain-en-Laye.

4 Raoul de Gaucourt had played an important part in trying to resist the English. He was bailli of Rouen, where he was assassinated on 23 July 1417.

5 For Nicole Pitement, M.A., M.Th., of the diocese of Rouen, see Denifle, H. S. and Chatelain, E., Chartularium Universitatis Parisiensis, iv (1394–1452) (Paris, 1897)Google Scholar, nos 763, 1786 etc. Curiously, a man of this name was appointed to a prebend in a church at Mantes by Henry V in February 1421 (D.K.R., xlii, 396).Google Scholar

6 Rouen, Seine-Maritime.

7 Chartres, Eure-et-Loir.

8 Meaux, Seine-et-Marne.

9 Poissy, Yvelines, arr. Saint-Germain-en-Laye.

10 The value of land was frequently estimated by the value of the year 1410.

page 46 note a MS Hongreford

page 46 note b MS Hongreford

page 46 note c MS Hongreford

11 Jean de Rinel, an anglophile who served as the leading royal secretary for many years.

12 Jean was the brother of the late Raoul de Gaucourt; he died in 1435. 13 Joinville, Haute-Marne, arr. Saint-Dizier.

14 Châlons-sur-Marne, Marne.

15 The community of St. Maurice de Senlis (Oise).

16 Louis IX, king of France 1226–70.

page 47 note a Followed by Honnef, struck out

17 Saint-Germain-en-Laye, Yvelines, of which Handford was captain.

page 48 note a In the margin

page 48 note b In the margin

page 48 note c MS qu'il

18 Philippe de Morvilliers was first président of the Parlement 1418–33.

19 Henry V.

20 That Handford had a grant earlier than that of 26 September 1424 (the one printed at the beginning of this record and referred to in the re-grant of 31 October 1429 (below, pp. 71–2) is likely. On 23 March 1423, the lieutenant of the bailli of Rouen ordered the vicomtes of that bailliage to allow Sir John Handford all the profits of the crossing at Maisons-sur-Seine to the value of 500 livres parisis, half the value allowed in the grant of 26 September 1424 (Arch. Seine-Mme, Fonds Danquin, doss. ‘Capitaines’, H).

21 Handford was doubtless basing his demand upon an ordinance of Henry V, probably the one copied into a fifteenth-century Norman coutumier: ‘Item, en consel a Rouen le chancellier de Normendie presidera et fera court souveraine, et congnoistra de tous les dons fais ou a faire par le roy tant en regalles que heritages et autres dons, et en sera defendue la cognoissance a tous baillis et aultres quelxconques, et seront leurs proces nulz se il[s] les font’ (B.N., MS fr. 5964, fos. 207v–208r: B.L., Add. MS 21411, fo. 9v. See above, p. 22, n. 8).

page 49 note a followed by null, struck out

page 49 note b Followed by prevo, struck out

page 49 note c y interlined

page 49 note d et singuliers interlined

22 See the treaty of Troyes (Cosneau, , Grands traités, pp. 105, 106Google Scholar), articles 7 and 10.

23 Ibid., p. 105 (articles).

24 Ibid., pp. 108–9 (articles 15, 16 and particularly 19).

page 50 note a soubz le ressort de la court interlined

page 50 note b Followed by do, struck out

page 50 note c son conseil written in another hand over an erasure

page 50 note d dit written in another hand over an erasure

25 Cosneau, Grands traités, pp. 105–6, 108–9 (articles 9 and 17).

26 For the fifteenth-century application of the much older maxim ‘Rex est imperator regni sui’, see Bossuat, A., ‘La formule “Le roi est empereur en son royaume”Revue historique de droit français et étranger, 4e sér., 39 (1961), 371–81.Google Scholar

27 A number of references to commissioners for confiscations are to be found in these texts, e.g., Rose v. R. Handford (X1a 4795, fo. 237r); Sens v. Suffolk (X1a 4794, fo. 35r). In 1423 Pierre Baille was appointed ‘receveur des confiscations dans la prévôté de Paris’ (Gallia Regia, iv, 372).

page 51 note a court written over an erasure

page 51 note b drois written over an erasure

28 Pontoise, Val d'Oise.

29 Mantes-la-Jolie, Yvelines.

30 Gisors, Eure, arr. Les Andelys.

31 See the treaty of Troyes (Cosneau, , Grands traités, p. 105Google Scholar (article 8)).

32 A similar argument was used in Dring v. Dynadam; see below, pp. 183–4.

page 52 note a In the margin

page 52 note b In the margin

page 52 note c In the margin

page 52 note d In the margin

33 Jean Aguenin was second président of the Parlement.

34 16 April 1425.

35 Louis de Luxembourg, bishop of Thérouanne, appointed chancellor ot France for Henry VI on 7 February 1425.

36 Pierre Cauchon, bishop of Beauvais since August 1420.

page 53 note a disoient interlined

page 53 note b Followed by ad, struck out

page 53 note c Followed by a leur, struck out

37 Philippe de Ruilly (or Rueil), conseiller clerc at the Parlement.

38 Pierre de Marigny, avocat du roi in 1418, prévôt of Paris, royal councillor and master of requests in 1421 (See Delachenal, R., Histoire des avocats au Parlement de Paris, 1300–1600 (Paris, 1885), pp. 364–5).Google Scholar

39 Jean, sire de Courcelles, member of the court of requests, had been present at the duke of Bedford's marriage at Troyes in May 1423.

40 Quentin Massue, conseiller in the Parlement in 1410, master of requests in 1422.

41 Hugues Rapiout, formerly lieutenant to the prévôt of Paris; avocat du roi at the Châtelet in 1421; commissioner for confiscations and forfeitures; master of requests (See Bourgeois, p. 284Google Scholar, n. 1).

42 Bois de Vincennes, Val-de-Marne, arr. Nogent-sur-Marne. It was here that Henry V had died on 31 August 1422.

43 A wavy line in the margin draws attention to the importance of this text, which is printed in Fauquembergue, ii, 178–80.Google Scholar

page 54 note a pour tous delais interlined

44 An ordinance of Henry V stated that all grants made by him were ‘chargees’ by debts, unless otherwise stated. They were, however, quit of ‘debtes mobiliaires’ (B.L., Add. MS 21411, fo. 9r; B.N., MS fr. 5964, fo. 207r. See Ferret v. Russell (no I), n. 8).

page 55 note a chastellerie written over an erasure

45 This is likely to be the earliest grant referred to in n. 20, above.

page 56 note a Followed by enf, struck out

page 56 note b MS pour

46 A reference to the siege of Senlis by Charles VI in February 1418.

47 The siege of Rouen by Henry V began at the end of July 1418 and ended on 13 January 1419.

48 See above, pp. 25–7.

page 57 note a In the margin

page 57 note b MS le

49 This text is printed in Fauquembergue, ii, 193–4.Google Scholar

50 ‘Actore nihil probante … reus tamen absolvitur’ (Libri Feudorum, lib. II, tit. xxxiii). Also cited no XVIII, n. 20.

51 Probably John Grey of Heton, count of Tancarville, killed at Baugé in March 1421.

51a He was dead by 19 August 1427 (A.N., X1a 8302, fo. 195v). See appendix I.

page 58 note a Followed by le struck out

page 58 note b Followed by a word erased

page 58 note c Followed by 1, struck out

page 58 note d In the margin

52 Jean de Paris was one of the leading procureurs to serve in the Parlement in these years. He also represented Sir John Fastolf against Denis Sauvage.

page 59 note a In the margin

page 59 note b de laquele interlined over desqueles, struck out

53 This was ihe formal manner of publication of a summons.

54 Marly-le-Roi, Yvelines, arr. Saint-Germain-en-Laye.

55 Mid-Lent.

page 60 note a MS possessions

page 60 note b et tiltres interlined

page 60 note c …c The text de leur … lesdis is in the margin, in place of another, struck out. About four lines long, it shows signs of having been drawn up as a draft of terms acceptable to both parties

56 Eight days after Christmas.

page 62 note a In the margin

page 62 note b MS quem

page 63 note a MS inquestamque

page 63 note b veoir interlined

page 63 note c In the margin

page 63 note d saisine interlined

page 64 note a MS que

page 64 note b sur l'intendit par lui baillé interlined

57 The Sainte Chapelle, or Chapel Royal, in Paris.

page 65 note a Followed by que ledit defendeur, comme seigneur, proprietaire et detenteur d'iceulx peage, travers et seigneurie, struck out

page 65 note b affectéz interlined over et faiz, struck out

58 Sartrouville, Yvelines, arr. Saint-Germain-en-Laye. It is opposite Maisons, on the right bank of the Seine.

page 66 note a que ledit defendeur written over qu'il, struck out

page 66 note b icelui written over ledit, struck out

page 66 note c Passage sans … demander interlined

page 66 note d demourront written over sont declairés, struck out

page 66 note e sauf interlined

page 66 note f Followed by sauf, struck out

page 66 note g desdites seignouries interlined

page 66 note h maistre interlined

page 66 note i Followed by de juillet, struck out

59 1 October 1427.

page 67 note a Followed by quate, struck out

page 67 note b Followed by co. struck out

page 67 note c Followed by demand, struck out

page 67 note d Written on a fold

page 68 note a trespas du interlined

60 The siege of Orléans was begun in October 1428.

page 69 note a Blank space in the MS

page 69 note b In the margin

page 69 note c Followed by fe, struck out

page 69 note d en interlined

61 Charles VI died on 21 October 1422.

page 70 note a MS le

page 70 note b Followed by y, struck out

page 70 note c Followed by ca, struck out

62 A reference to the Charte aux Normands of 1315 which limited appeals outside the duchy of Normandy. The procureur du roi was emphasizing that the lands in question were outside the duchy.

page 71 note a In the margin

page 71 note b par interlined

63 This text is printed in Fauquembergue, ii, 314–15.Google Scholar

64 On this collection, see Allmand, C. T., ‘The Collection of Dom Lenoir and the English Occupation of Normandy in the Fifteenth Century’, Archives, vi (19631964), 202–10.Google Scholar

65 See Gallia Regia, v, 108–10Google Scholar; iii, 366–7.

66 See Gallia Regia, v. 125–7.Google Scholar

67 He held this office from 1427 to 1442 (Gallia Regia, v, 187–8Google Scholar). This letter constitutes an exercise of the crown's prerogative power. See also p. 196, n. 53.

page 73 note a MS et trente ung

page 73 note b Passage a la … defendeur interlined

page 73 note c en interlined

page 74 note a MS et trente ung