Hostname: page-component-669899f699-g7b4s Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2025-04-25T20:12:36.375Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Welfare, Abortion, and Organ Donation: A Reply to the Restrictivist

A Response to William Simkulet, “Restrictivism, Abortion, and Organ Donation” (CQ 31(3))

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  14 April 2023

Emily Carroll  and
Parker Crutchfield
Emily Carroll
Affiliation:
Western Michigan University Homer Stryker M.D. School of Medicine, Kalamazoo, MI, USA
Parker Crutchfield*
Affiliation:
Department of Medical Ethics, Humanities, and Law, Western Michigan University Homer Stryker M.D. School of Medicine, Kalamazoo, MI, USA
*
*Corresponding author. Email: [email protected]
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

We argued in a recent issue of this journal that if abortion is restricted,1 then there are parallel obligations for parents to donate body parts to their children. The strength of this obligation to donate is proportional to the strength of the abortion restrictions. If abortion is never permissible, then a parent must always donate any organ if they are a match. If abortion is sometimes permissible and sometimes not, then organ donation is sometimes obligatory and sometimes not. Our argument was based on the following ideas: (a) that a fetus has full moral status, (b) that parents have special obligations to their offspring, fetus or not, and (c) that this special obligation is to protect them. The result is the conclusion that abortion restrictivists cannot also consistently deny that organ donation should be compulsory.

Type
Responses and Dialogue
Information
Cambridge Quarterly of Healthcare Ethics , Volume 33 , Issue 2 , April 2024 , pp. 290 - 295
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2023. Published by Cambridge University Press

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Article purchase

Temporarily unavailable

References

Notes

1. Carroll, E, Crutchfield, P. The duty to protect, abortion, and organ donation. Cambridge Quarterly of Healthcare Ethics 2022;31(3):333–43. doi:10.1017/S096318012100102X CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed.

2. Simkulet, W. Restrictivism, abortion, and organ donation. Cambridge Quarterly of Healthcare Ethics 2022;31(3):348–54. doi:10.1017/S0963180121001043 CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed.

3. Goodin, R. Protecting the vulnerable: A Re-analysis of our social responsibilities. 1986. Chicago University Press.Google Scholar

4. RAINN. The Criminal Justice System: Statistics; available at https://www.rainn.org/statistics/criminal-justice-system (last accessed 8 Mar 2023).

5. Jaffe DJ. Involuntary Commitment (Assisted Treatment) Standards (50 states)—Treatment Advocacy Center Report. Mental Illness Policy Org; available at https://mentalillnesspolicy.org/national-studies/state-standards-involuntary-treatment.html (last accessed 8 Mar 2023).

6. Center for Reproductive Rights [Internet]. After Roe Fell:Abortion Laws by State; c1992–2022 [cited 2023 Mar 8]; available at https://reproductiverights.org/maps/abortion-laws-by-state/ (last accessed 8 Mar 2023).

7. Child Welfare Information Gateway. Infant Safe Haven Laws; available at https://www.childwelfare.gov/topics/systemwide/laws-policies/statutes/safehaven/ (last accessed 8 Mar 2023).

8. Arey, W, Lerma, K, Beasley, A, Harper, L, Moayedi, G, White, K. A preview of the dangerous future of abortion Bans—Texas Senate Bill 8. New England Journal of Medicine 2022;387(5):388–90. doi: 10.1056/NEJMp2207423 CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed .

9. DePanfilis D, Newman J, Taylor LR, Shuman M, Strohl J, Denniston J, et al. Child Neglect: A Guide for Prevention, Assessment, and Intervention: (624592007-001) [Data set]. American Psychological Association; 2006. doi:10.1037/e624592007-001.

10. National Safe Haven Alliance. Find a Safe Haven Location; available at https://www.nationalsafehavenalliance.org/safe-haven-locations (last accessed 8 Mar 2023).

11. Child Welfare Information Gateway. Infant Safe Haven Laws: Summary of State Laws; available at https://pdba.georgetown.edu/Security/citizensecurity/eeuu/documents/safehavenall.pdf (last accessed 8 Mar 2023).

12. Child Welfare Information Gateway. Definitions of Child Abuse and Neglect; 2022; available at https://www.childwelfare.gov/topics/systemwide/laws-policies/statutes/define/ (last accessed 8 Mar 2023).