Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-xbtfd Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-09T14:22:35.242Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Wagner's Nuremberg

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  27 August 2008

Extract

As far as we know, Wagner paid eight visits to Nuremberg, although I shall be concerned here only with the first four of them. The first was the longest – a week-long stay with his sister Clara and her husband Heinrich Wolfram in January 1834, when he was twenty. According to the much later account in Mein Leben, Wagner's only memory of this visit was ‘the sociable house’ of his brother-in-law and the gemütlich goings-on in Nuremberg's taverns. In July 1835, when talent-spotting for Heinrich Bethmann's near-insolvent opera company, he passed through Nuremberg towards the end of the month. It was on this occasion that he witnessed that ‘extraordinary nocturnal adventure’ which, according to Mein Leben, was to leave its mark on the final scene of Act II of Die Meistersinger. (What, to my own mind, is even more ‘extraordinary’ about this account is that it is confirmed neither by Die rothe Brieftasche – the aide-mémoire that Wagner began in August 1835 – nor by any of Wagner's letters of the time. It is difficult to avoid the suspicion that this is a case of life imitating art, a suspicion increased when we recall that the passage in Mein Leben was dictated between March and May 1866, just before Wagner embarked on the first complete draft of Act II of Die Meistersinger.)

Type
Research Article
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 1992

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Wagner's, other visits took place on 13 11 1862Google Scholar, 16/17 April 1871, 22/3 July 1877 and 1 May 1882.

2 Wagner, Richard, Mein Leben, ed. Gregor-Dellin, Martin (Munich, 1976), 87Google Scholar; trans. Gray, Andrew (Cambridge, 1983), 78.Google Scholar

3 In his letter to his mother of 25 July 1835, Wagner writes that he will be visiting Nuremberg ‘tomorrow or the day after’, Wagner, Richard, Sämtliche Briefe, ed. Strobel, Gertrud and Wolf, Werner, I (Leipzig, 1967), 212.Google Scholar There is no other evidence to date this visit more accurately.

4 Wagner, , Mein Leben (see n. 2), 113–16Google Scholar; trans., 104–7.

5 Wagner, , Mein Leben, 674Google Scholar; trans., 657–8.

6 Richard Wagners Briefwechsel mit B. Schott's Söhne, ed. Altmann, Wilhelm (Mainz, 1911), 24Google Scholar; trans. from Selected Letters of Richard Wagner, trans. and ed. Spencer, Stewart and Millington, Barry (London, 1987), 527Google Scholar (letter of 30 October 1861).

7 I am grateful to Egon Voss of the Richard Wagner-Gesamtausgabe for this information. Emile Ollivier's diary ( Journal 1846–1869, 2 vols. [Paris, 1961]Google Scholar) is equally unforthcoming on the subject, entertaining though it is on other aspects of Wagner's personality at this time.

8 Wagner, , Mein Leben (see n. 2), 684Google Scholar; trans., 667.

9 Briefwechsel mit B. Schott's Söhne (see n. 6), 23Google Scholar; trans. from Selected Letters of Richard Wagner (see n. 6), 527.Google Scholar

10 Briefwechsel mit B. Schott's Söhne, 26.Google Scholar

11 One of the National Socialists' first actions on coming to power was to return the regalia to Nuremberg.

12 Nürnberg und Lübeck im 19. Jahrhundert: Denkmalpflege, Stadtbildpflege, Stadtumbau (Munich, 1981), 16.Google Scholar

13 Quoted in Brix, , 21.Google Scholar

14 Über dramatische Kunst und Litteratur: Vorlesungen von August Wilhelm Schlegel (Heidelberg, 18091811), I, 24.Google Scholar

15 Wackenroder, Wilhelm Heinrich, Werke and Briefe (Heidelberg, 1967), 57.Google Scholar

16 Quoted in Brix, (see n. 12), 25.Google Scholar

17 Johanek, Peter, ‘“Du treue, fleiβige Stadt”: Nurnberg, das Städtewesen des Mittelalters und Richard Wagners Meistersinger’, Programmhefte der Bayreuther Festspiele 1986: VIIGoogle ScholarDie Meistersinger von Nürnberg’, 1034Google Scholar; trans., 41–60. See also Cannon-Geary, Irene S., The Bourgeoisie Looks at Itself The Sixteenth Century in German Literary Histories of the Ninteenth Century (Göppingen, 1980).Google Scholar

18 See, for example, Baberadt, Carl Friedrich, Hans Sachs im Andenken der Nachwelt: Em Beitrag zur Hans.Sachs-Literatur (Halle, 1906)Google Scholar; and Bauer, Oswald Georg, ‘Rezeption und Geschichtsbewuβtsein: Materialien zur Hans Sachs-Rezeption des 19. Jahrhunderts’, Programmhefte der Bayreuther Festspiele 1975: III – ‘Die Meistersinger von Nürnberg’, 113Google Scholar; trans., 19–24. For a more general introduction to Nuremberg festivals, see Grimm, Reinhold and Hermand, Jost, eds., Deutsche Feiern (Wiesbaden, 1977)Google Scholar, and Grote, Ludwig, Die rornantische Entdeckung Nürnbergs (Munich, 1967).Google Scholar

19 Brix, (see n. 12), 106.Google Scholar The Sängerfest, held between 20 and 22 07 1861Google Scholar, is reported in detail in Gartenlaube, Die, 35 and 37 [1861], 571–4 and 587–92.Google Scholar The festival was not a competition in the Wagnerian sense but a gathering of 260 male-voice choirs which met to perform a number of choral works by Vinzenz and Franz Lachner, Franz Abt, Ferdinand Hiller, Duke Ernst von Saxe-Coburg and others. Their titles – All-Deutschland, An das Vaterland, An die deutsche Tricolore, An die Deutschen, Frühlingsgruβ an des Vaterland, Der deutsche Landsturm and Ermanne Dich, Deutschland! – give a flavour of the occasion. It was not originally intended to award any prizes, but a silver goblet sent from Bern was presented to Franz Lachner for his Sturmesmythe. Dieter Borchmeyer ( Das Theater Richard Wagners [Stuttgart, 1982], 32–3Google Scholar; trans. Spencer, Stewart as Richard Wagner: Theory and Theatre [1991], 19Google Scholar) suggests that the influence behind the Festwiese scene may be the Zurich Sechseläuten, a spring festival celebrated on the third Monday in April and including a traditional procession of local guilds.

20 Quoted in Die Meistersinger und Richard Wagner: Die Rezeptionsgeschichte einer Oper von 1868 bis heute, ed. Grosse, Helmut and Götz, Norbert. Catalogue published on the occasion of an exhibition at the Germanisches Nationalmuseum, Nuremberg, 10 July–11 October 1981 (Nuremberg, 1981), 129.Google Scholar

21 Quoted in Die Gartenlaube (see n. 19), 37 ‘07/08 1861’, 592.Google Scholar

22 McFarland, Timothy, ‘Wagner's Nuremberg’, The Mastersingers of Nuremberg: ENO/R OH Opera Guide 19, ed. John, Nicholas (London, 1983), 2734, esp. 33.Google Scholar

23 Johanek, (see n. 17), 18Google Scholar; trans., 45.

24 McFarland, (see n. 22), 33.Google Scholar

25 Wagner, Richard, Gesammelte Schriften and Dichtungen, 4th edn (Leipzig, 1907), IV, 284–5.Google Scholar

26 Wagner, , Gesammelte Schriften und Dichtungen, IV, 64.Google Scholar

27 Wagner, , Gesammelte Schriften und Dichtungen, III, 25–6.Google Scholar

28 Wagner, Cosima, Die Tagebücher, ed. Gregor-Dellin, Martin and Mack, Dietrich, 2 vols. (Munich and Zurich, 19761977), II, 503Google Scholar; trans. by Skelton, Geoffrey as Cosima Wagner's Diaries, vols. (London and New York, 19781980), II, 450Google Scholar (entry of 14 March 1880).

29 Wagner, Cosima, Die Tagebücher, II, 561Google Scholar; trans., II, 503 (entry of 2 July 1880).

30 Wagner, Cosima, Die Tagebücher, II, 915Google Scholar; trans., II, 830 (entry of 25 March 1882).

31 Wagner, Cosima, Die Tagebucher, II, 1017Google Scholar; trans., II, 924 (entry of 7 October 1882).

32 König Ludwig II. und Richard Wagner: Briefwechsel [ = Königsbriefe], ed. Strobel, Otto, 5 vols. (Karlsruhe, 19361939), II, 78Google Scholar; trans. from Selected Letters ofRichard Wagner (see n. 6), 701.Google Scholar

33 These diary entries were published in abridged form in vol. X of Wagner's Gesammelte Schriften (see n. 25) under the title ‘Was ist deutsch?’ The complete text was published for the first time in 1936 in Königsbriefe, IV, 534.Google Scholar

34 Königsbriefe, IV, 78.Google Scholar

35 Königsbriefe, IV, 16.Google Scholar

36 ‘Nuremberg Trial: Is there Anti-semitism in Die Meistersinger?’, this journal, 3 (1991), 247–60.Google Scholar

37 Königsbriefe, IV, 21.Google Scholar

38 Gesamnelte Schr und Dichtungen (see n. 25), VII, 178.Google Scholar

39 Königsbriefe, IV, 29.Google Scholar

40 Königsbriefe, IV, 33.Google Scholar

41 Wagner, , Gesarnmelte Schrijien and Dichtungen (see n. 25), VII, 270.Google Scholar

42 Königsbriefe, II, 103Google Scholar; trans. from Selected Letters ofRichard Wagner (see n. 6), 708.Google Scholar

43 In the opera, of course, musical constraints require monosyllabic alternatives such as ‘mad’ or ‘crazed’. The best articles on the subject of Wahn are Turner's, Richard“Die Meistersinger von Nürnberg”: The Conceptual Growth of an Opera’, Wagner, 3 (1982), 216Google Scholar; and Gillespie's, IrisThe Theory and Practice of “Wahn”’, Wagner, 5 (1984), 7985.Google Scholar

44 Königsbriefe, II, 79Google Scholar; trans. in Selected Letters ofRichard Wagner, 702.Google Scholar

45 Gesammelte Schriften und Dichtungen (see n. 25), X, 119–20.Google Scholar The French friends mentioned by Wagner include Jules Etienne Pasdeloup, Léon Leroy and Paul Chandon (see Wagner, Richard, Das braune Buch: Tagebuchaufzeichnungen 1865 bis 1882, ed. Bergfeld, Joachim [Zurich, 1975], 199; trans. by George Bird [London, 1980], 167)Google Scholar; it has not been possible to identify the Nuremberg opera director. Die Meistersinger von Nürnberg received its first performance in the town on 24 March 1874; the Hans Sachs Monument was unveiled on 24 June 1874.