Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-fbnjt Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-19T15:19:58.318Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Ghazis, roads and trade in north-west Anatolia 1179–1291

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  22 January 2016

Ian Booth
Ian Booth*
Affiliation:
Sussex
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

This article shows that parts of the late antique road system in north-west Anatolia were sometimes closed between 1179 and 1291, due to unsettled conditions, and that alternatives were in use. The alternative road from Herakleia Pontica to Kastamonu went via Çaycuma and Daday and that to Ankara via Eskişehir. Both Christian and Muslim border raiders existed in the area and may have caused these closures. They sometimes acted together but their importance is unclear since conditions were also both politically and militarily unstable. The article concludes that the Muslim raiders were not ghazis, as has been thought.

Type
Articles
Information
Byzantine and Modern Greek Studies , Volume 31 , Issue 2 , 2007 , pp. 127 - 145
Copyright
Copyright © The Centre for Byzantine, Ottoman and Modern Greek Studies, University of Birmingham 2007

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Ducellier, A., Chrétiens d’Orient et Islam au Moyen Age, Vlle-XVe siècles (Paris 1996) 273 Google Scholar.

2 See Table 1.

3 For a full discussion of what this expression means in this context, see Ahrweiler, H., ‘La frontière et les frontières de Byzance en Orient’, in Ahrweiler, , Byzance: les pays et les territoires (Aldershot 1976)Google Scholar; Holmes, C., ‘How the east was won’, Eastern Approaches to Byzantium, ed. Eastmond, A. (Aldershot 1999) 41–72 Google Scholar; Medieval Frontier Societies, ed. Bartlett, R. and Mackay, A. (Oxford 1989)Google Scholar; Shifting Frontiers in Late Antiquity, ed. Mathisen, R. and Sivan, H. (Aldershot 1996) 1–214 Google Scholar; Medieval Frontiers: Concepts and Practices, ed. Abulafia, D. and Berend, N. (Aldershot 2002) 1–142 Google Scholar; The Frontiers in Question: The Eurasian Borderlands, ed. Power, D. and Standen, N. (London 1998)Google Scholar.

4 Ankara and Eskişehir are not shown on the maps because they are not in the area under discussion.

5 Reinaud, J., Géographie d’Aboulféda (Paris 1848, 1883, repr. 1985) II, 2, 133-9Google Scholar.

6 Hereafter called Herakleia.

7 Cahen, C., ‘Ibn Sa’id sur l’Asie Mineure seljuquide’, in Cahen, , Turkobyzantina et Oriens Christianus (London 1974), study VII, 6 Google Scholar (hereafter Ibn Sa’id). Extracts from Ibn Sa’id to which I refer in this article are cited in translation in the Appendix to this article.

8 Comfort, A and Ergeç, R., ‘Following the Euphrates in Antiquity: north-south routes around Zeugma’, Anatolian Studies 51 (2001) 32, 38CrossRefGoogle Scholar. This is a long way east but much the same.

9 The Travels of Ibn Battutab, ed. Mackintosh-Smith, T. (London 2002) 118 Google Scholar.

10 Akropolites makes reference to the good quality of the soldiers from Paphlagonia: Georgii Acropolitae Opera, ed. Heisenberg, A., I (Leipzig 1903) 147-8Google Scholar.

11 Ibn Sa’id, 48.

12 Ibid., 43.

13 Ibid., 48.

14 French, D., Roman Roads and Milestones in Asia Minor, 2 vols (London 1981)Google Scholar. There are references throughout this work.

15 All distances are from the Turkey Tourist Map, Ministry of Tourism, 1994, and are rounded down.

16 For this see Odo of Deuil, De profectione Ludovici VII in orientem, ed. Berry, V. G. (New York 1948) 91-7Google Scholar. My experience of the area also reinforces the point.

17 The Travels of Ibn Battutah, ed. Mackintosh-Smith, 43-8.

18 This diversion is a loop off the road and not an out-and-back diversion.

19 All diversions are shown as a there-and-back distance.

20 Fuat, Y., Araç (Izmir 1990) 23, 337Google Scholar. The language used implies a degree of uncertainty.

21 The present building is about twenty years younger, the original having burnt down.

22 Kara, I., Kastamonu (Istanbul 1997) 102, 220-1Google Scholar; Öztuna, T. Y., Türkiye Tarihi 2 (Istanbul 1964) 206 Google Scholar; Yazıcıoğlu, H. and Al, M., Safranbolu (Karabük 1982) 20-1Google Scholar.

23 Langdon, J. S., Byzantium’s Last Imperial Offensive in Asia Minor (New York 1992) 13 Google Scholar.

24 Kara, , Kastamonu, 165, 217-21Google Scholar; Öztuna, , Türkiye Tarihi 2, 206-7Google Scholar; Uzunçarsılı, I., Osmanli Devieti Teşkilâtina Medhal (Ankara 1988) 138 n. 139Google Scholar.

25 Ibn Sa’id, 50.

26 Pachymeres, George, Relations historiques, ed. Fauler, A., I (Paris 1984) 43 Google Scholar.

27 Choniates, Niketas, Historia, ed. van Dieten, J.-L. (Berlin 1975) 197-8Google Scholar.

28 Pachymeres, ed. Fauler, II, 634.

29 It was certainly cut when Manuel I was there in 1179 and probably during the rebellions of the 1180s.

30 The Travels of Ibn Battutah, ed. Mackintosh-Smith, 113-17.

31 Nicol, D. M., The Last Centuries of Byzantium (London 1993) 82 Google Scholar.

32 Pachymeres, ed. Failler, I, 291-3.

33 Pachymeres, ed. Failler, II, 598-9; see also Failler, A., ‘Chronologie et composition dans l’Histoire de Georges Pachymère’, REB 39 (1981) 242-8CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

34 Pachymeres, ed. Failler, II, 633-7.

35 This is pure guesswork, but likely.

36 Ibn Sa’id, 48 (footnote).

37 Bartusis, M., The Late Byzantine Army (Philadelphia 1991) 263-5Google Scholar.

38 Pliny, (the Younger), Letters and Panegyrics, tr. Pardine, B. (Cambridge, MA 1969) 293 Google Scholar.

39 Choniates, ed. van Dieten, 18; Kinnamos, John, Epitome, ed. Meineke, A. (Bonn 1836) 14 Google Scholar.

40 Choniates, ed. van Dieten, 34.

41 Calder, W. and George, E., A Classical Map of Asia Minor (London 1958)Google Scholar. This map shows a coast road. This is a serious error.

42 Yazıcıoğlu and Al, Safranbolu, 13.

43 Choniates, ed. van Dieten, 197-8.

44 Choniates makes reference in this passage to Bithynia as it was in 1179.

45 Choniates, ed. van Dieten, 243.

46 French, Roman Roads and Milestones in Asia Minor, passim.

47 Kara, Kastamonu, 45, 297.

48 Abulfeda makes no mention of Kastamonu.

49 Amitai-Preiss, R., Mongols and Mamluks, the Mamluk-llkhanid War 1260-1281 (Cambridge 1995), ch. 1CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

50 Lemerle, P., ‘Philadelphie et l’Émirat d’Aydin’, in Lemerle, , Philadelphie et autres études (Paris 1984) 55–67 CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

51 Ibn Sa’id, 44.

52 ‘Persai’, the normal name for Turks in Byzantine literature, does not distinguish between different tribes or between Turks settled in the empire and those from the sultanate.

53 I lived in the region from 1964 to 1967.

54 See, for example, Rogan, E., The Frontiers of the State in the Late Ottoman Empire: Transjordan, 1850-1921 (Cambridge 1999)Google Scholar. Several instances are given but the rebellion of 1905 is the most spectacular.

55 Langdon, Byzantium’s Last Imperial Offensive, 22-3.

56 Kafadar, C., Between Two Worlds: the Construction of the Ottoman State (Berkeley 1995) passim Google Scholar; Köprülü, F., The Origins of the Ottoman Empire, tr. Leiser, G. (New York 1992) 1–14, 27-8Google Scholar; Lindner, R., Nomads and Ottomans in Medieval Anatolia (Bloomington, IN 1983) 1–50 Google Scholar.

57 Langdon, Byzantium’s Last Imperial Offensive, 22-3.

58 Pachymeres, ed. Failler, I, 42-9.

59 This conclusion is strictly limited to the Paphlagonian frontier.

60 The Travels of Ibn Battutah, ed. Mackintosh-Smith, 117.

61 Booth, I., ‘The Sangarios frontier: the history and strategic role of Paphlagonia in Byzantine defence in the thirteenth century’, BF 28 (2004) 45–86 Google Scholar.

62 Bouras, C., ‘Aspects of the Byzantine city, eighth-fifteenth centuries’, in Laiou, A. (ed.), The Economic History of Byzantium from the Seventh through the Fifteenth Century, II (Washington, DC 2002) 523 Google Scholar.

63 French, Roman Roads and Milestones in Asia Minor, passim.

64 Choniates, ed. van Dieten, 420-1, 461-2. The pseudo-Alexios rebelled with Turkish help in 1193, and another Alexios did the same near Malagina in 1195, also with Turkish assistance. These two instances appear not to have been cases of raids but of semi-formal assistance.