Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-t5tsf Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-20T00:44:37.232Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Managing Door-to-Door Sales of Vacuum Cleaners in Interwar Britain

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  13 December 2011

Peter Scott
Peter Scott
Affiliation:
PETER SCOTT is professor of international business history at theHenley Business School, University of Reading.
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Door-to-door selling was a key factor behind the particularly rapid interwar diffusion of vacuum cleaners among British households, relative to other “high-ticket” labor-saving appliances. Yet the door-to-door system incurred both high distribution costs and considerable controversy—owing to widespread sharp practice. Employers enticed salesmen through grossly inflated claims regarding earnings, which were in fact insufficient for most salesmen to make an acceptable living. This led many salesmen to engage in their own sharp practices—which eventually brought this form of marketing into disrepute.

Type
Articles
Information
Business History Review , Volume 82 , Issue 4: A Special Issue on Salesmanship , Winter 2008 , pp. 761 - 788
Copyright
Copyright © The President and Fellows of Harvard College 2008

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 While door-to-door selling was much more strongly developed in the United States than in Britain by the First World War, its widespread use for selling branded durable goods also dates from the 1920s. See Friedman, Walter A., Birth of a Salesman: The Transformation of Selling in America (Cambridge, Mass., 2004), 193.Google Scholar

2 Church, Roy, “Salesmen and the Transformation of Selling in Britain and the U.S. in the Nineteenth and Twentieth Centuries,” Economic History Review 61, no. 3 (2008): 695–725CrossRefGoogle Scholar; French, Michael, “Commercials, Careers, and Culture: Travelling Salesmen in Britain, 1900s-1930s,” Economic History Review 58, no. 2 (2005): 352–77CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Hopsgood, C. P., “The ‘Knights of The Road’: Commercial Travellers and the Culture of the Commercial Room in Late-Victorian and Edwardian England,” Victorian Studies, 37, no. 4 (1994): 519–48.Google Scholar

3 Johnson, Paul, Saving and Spending: The Working-Class Economy in Britain, 1870–1939 (Oxford, 1985), 11–47.Google Scholar

4 Finn, Margot, “Scotch Drapers and the Politics of Modernity: Gender, Class and National Identity in the Victorian Tally Trade,” in The Politics of Consumption: Citizenship and Material Culture in Europe and America, ed. Hilton, Matthew and Daunton, Martin (Oxford, 2001).Google Scholar

5 Hire purchase is a form of installment selling in which the good is technically hired until the final installment is paid. See Davies, Robert Bruce, Peacefully Working to Conquer the World: Singer Sewing Machines in Foreign Markets, 1854–1920 (New York, 1976), 63–66.Google Scholar Singer also tempered potential opportunism by salesmen through paying salary as well as commission and by withholding part of their commission as a safeguard against dishonesty.

6 Sources: Political and Economic Planning, The Market for Household Appliances (London, 1945), 211–12.Google Scholar Sue Bowden gives a significantly higher diffusion rate for vacuum cleaners in England and Wales in 1939, at 38 percent of wired households. See Bowden, Sue, “The Market for Domestic Electric Cookers in the 1930s: A Regional Analysis” (unpublished Ph.D. thesis, London School of Economics, 1985), 45–54Google Scholar; and Bowden, Sue and Offer, Avner, “Household Appliances and the Use of Time: The United States and Britain since the 1920s,” Economic History Review 47, no. 4 (1994): 745.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

7 Jefferys, J. B., The Distribution of Consumer Goods: A Factual Study of Methods and Costs in the United Kingdom in 1938 (Cambridge, 1950), 292–300.Google Scholar

8 For example, see Scott, Peter, “The Twilight World of Interwar Hire Purchase,” Past & Present 177 (2002): 195–225.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

9 Furnival, Jane, Suck, Don't Blow (London), 1998, 10–11.Google Scholar

10 Ibid., 15.

11 Hoover, Frank G., Fabulous Dustpan: The Story of the Hoover (Cleveland, 1955), 133–34, 198.Google Scholar

12 Bowden, Sue, “Colston, Sir Charles,” 755–59 in Dictionary of Business Biography: A Biographical Dictionary of Business Leaders Active in Britain in the Period 1860–1980, ed., Jeremy, David J. (1984), vol. 1, p. 756Google Scholar; “Hoover Production Facts and Figures, 1938–1950,” report, 1950, 0108 NAEST 146/1/1, Sir Walter Charles Puckey papers, National Archive for Electrical Science and Technology, London, U.K. [hereafter Puckey papers, NAEST]. The 1938 sales-value figure also includes accessories.

13 “New Hoover Factory,” Times, 20 Jan. 1932, 10, col. C; Hitchmough, Wendy, Hoover Factory: Wallis, Gilbert and Partners (London, 1992), 3.Google Scholar

14 “Hoover Production Facts and Figures, 1938–1950,” report, 1950, Puckey papers, NAEST; Hitchmough, Hoover Factory, 20.

15 Jackson, Alan A., The Middle Classes, 1900–1950 (Nairn, 1991), 121.Google Scholar

16 Furnival, Suck, Don't Blow, 16.

17 Electrolux Ltd., The Cleaner Cleaner (undated leaflet), Geffrye Museum Library, London.

18 Hoover, Fabulous Dustpan, 111–12, 128; Hoover Ltd., On Judging a Vacuum Cleaner (leaflet, n.d., C.1936).

19 Jefferys, Distribution of Consumer Goods, 297.

20 Electrical Trading (Mar. 1933): 68–69, and (Mar. 1938): 73–74.

21 The Hoover “Success Family” Magazine (Apr. 1922): 3, 82.85/4, Gunnersbury Park Museum, London, notes a price of £19 15s for a Hoover (having been reduced by £5 5s); a cleaner guide in Electrical Trading (Mar. 1933): 68–69 lists the Hoover 750 at £19 19s and the Hoover 900 at £26 5s; while a 1938 guide in the same journal (Mar. 1938): 73–74 listed the Hoover 875 at £19 19s and the 160 at £23 3s.

22 Hoover advertisement, Times, Feb. 1935, 11, col. E.

23 The Market for Household Appliances, 211.

24 For example, Daily Express Publications, The Home of Today:Its Choice, Planning, Equipment, and Organisation (London, 1934), 177–78Google Scholar; Bateman, R. A., How to Own and Equip a House (London, 1925), 295.Google Scholar

25 “Reactions to Advertising,” Dec. 1938, File Report A10, Mass Observation Archive, University of Sussex [hereafter MOA]. This report appears to have formed part of the general research of Mass Observation, rather than representing work for a particular commercial client.

26 It appears that respondents wrote in their top priorities, rather than being presented with a range of options. Electric equipment ranked thirteenth.

27 Bowden, Sue, “Credit Facilities and the Growth of Consumer Demand for Electrical Appliances in the 1930s,” Business History 32, no.1 (1990): 63–64.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

28 Prices taken from John Noble Ltd., John Noble's Ideal Club Catalogue (Manchester, 1935), 360Google Scholar; Manchester Mutual Trading Association Ltd., Mutual Clubs Catalogue A.38 (Manchester, n.d., c. 1938), 271.Google Scholar

29 “Reactions to Advertising,” Dec. 1938, File Report A10, MOA.

30 Cited in Political and Economic Planning, Market for Household Appliances, 26–27.

31 Hoover Ltd., On Judging a Vacuum Cleaner (leaflet, n.d., c.1936).

32 Craig, Elizabeth, Keeping House with Elizabeth Craig (London, 1936), 203.Google Scholar

33 A major 1938–39 national survey of households with annual incomes of £250 to £700 (£250 being considered the lower boundary for the middle class) indicated an average weekly expenditure on domestic help of 43s.5d. See Massey, Philip, “The Expenditure of 1,360 British Middle-Class Households in 1938–39,” Journal of the Royal Statistical Society 105, no. 3 (1942): 159–96.CrossRefGoogle Scholar For the decline in indoor servants, see Davidson, Caroline, A Woman's Work is Never Done: A History of Housework in the British Isles, 1650–1950 (London, 1982), 176.Google Scholar

34 Hoover recommended servicing every six months, at three shillings per visit. Hoover Ltd., vacuum cleaner guarantee, 19 Jan. 1939, held privately by the author.

35 Buell, Victor P., “Door-to-Door Selling,” Harvard Business Review 32 (May/June 1954): 21.Google Scholar

36 Nelson, Phillip, “Information and Consumer Behaviour,” Journal of Political Economy 78, no. 2 (1970): 311–29.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

37 Ibid., 317.

38 Wood, William W., Selling to the Home Market: A Guide to its Management (London, 1954). 46.Google Scholar

39 Memorandum on electrically operated vacuum cleaners for the Chief Industrial Advisor's office by W. Hall, 2 Jan. 1931, BT56/43, National Archives, London [hereafter NA].

40 Hoover, Fabulous Dustpan, 109–21.

41 Bowden, “Colston, Sir Charles,” 757.

42 Hitchmough, Hoouer Factory, 3.

43 Harrods advertisement, Times, 18 Nov. 1920, 9, col. E, stating that the store hosted daily demonstrations of the Hoover cleaner.

44 Memorandum on electrically operated vacuum cleaners.

45 “Hoover Statistics at 30 July 1938,” 29 Sept. 1938, HF9/3/7, Harrods Company Archive, London.

46 Harrods Ltd., notes on accounts for half year ended 31 July 1936, p. 2×4, on Kendal Milne & Co. and its Hoover trade, 10 Aug. 1936, HF9/3/6, Harrods Company Archive.

47 Electrolux advertisement, Times, 17 Mar. 1924, 19, col. A.

48 Memorandum on electrically operated vacuum cleaners.

49 Interview with Sam Tobin, material collected for Weightman, Gavin and Humphries, Steve, The Making of Modern London, 1914–1939 (London, 1984), Museum of London Archive, London.Google Scholar

50 MacLaren-Ross, Julian, Of Love and Hunger (London, 1947), 104.Google Scholar For example, few women were employed as commercial travelers; French, “Commercials, Careers, and Culture,” 368–69.

51 Memorandum on electrically operated vacuum cleaners.

52 GEC Board minutes, Apr. 1919-Sept. 1939, and GEC Magnetstaff magazine, 1932–39, Marconi papers, Bodleian Library, Oxford. GEC stands for General Electric Co., though the company was better-known by its initials.

53 “Vac-Trie Vacuum Cleaners” (display advertisement), Times, 27 Nov. 1934, 20, col. E.

54 Carr, Gerald, “Selling Vacuum Cleaners with a Difference,” Electrical Trading (Mar. 1937): 71Google Scholar.

55 Bognor Regis Post, 19 Feb. 1938, 12.

56 Jefferys, Distribution of Consumer Goods, 298.

57 “Have You Invited Manufacturers' Help for Your Hire-Purchase?” Electrical Trading (Oct. 1930): 48–50.

58 Smith, Everett R., “The Economic Future of House-to-House Selling,” Harvard Business Review 4 (Apr. 1926): 326Google Scholar; Buell, “Door-to-Door Selling,” 118.

59 Smallpeice, Basil, Of Comets and Queens (Shrewsbury, 1981), 13.Google Scholar

60 Political and Economic Planning, Market for Household Appliances, 211.

61 Jefferys, Distribution of Consumer Goods, 297–98. A 25 percent mark-up was applied in approximately two-thirds of cases and 33 percent in the remaining third.

62 Smallpeice, Of Comets and Queens, 13.

63 For estimates for the United States, see Friedman, Birth of a Salesman, 183; Buell, “Door-to-Door Selling,” 117.

64 Smallpeice, Of Comets and Queens, 14. Contemporary sources indicate that it was common for salesmen laid off by one company to find employment later with another, though companies did not usually rehire salesmen whom they had previously dismissed.

65 Chief Industrial Advisor's file regarding Hoover's proposal to set up U.K. production, note, signed C.L.W., 8 Feb. 1932, and “Confidential Report” from Hoover, 27 May 1932, both BT56/49, NA. It is not clear whether the value given for sales included accessories and replacement parts as well as cleaners.

66 Smallpeice, Of Comets and Queens, 14.

67 Smith, “Economic Future of House-to-House Selling,” 327; Buell, “Door-to-Door Selling,” 118.

68 Groff, Charles R., Observations of Management: Confidential Report for Electrolux Executives 1, no. 1 (1932): 7.Google Scholar Copy available in the British Library.

69 A.B.C. [pseud.], “Sales Representative,” New Statesman and Nation, 21 May 1938, 863; MacLaren-Ross, Julian, Collected Memoirs (London, 2004), 186.Google Scholar

70 Times, 17 Jan. 1935, 3, col. A.

71 Interview with Harold Marshall, C900/19547/C1, Millenium Memory Bank, National Sound Archive, British Library, London.

72 Friedman, Birth of a Salesman, 42; Buell, “Door-to-Door Selling,” 117–21.

73 Buell, “Door-to-Door Selling,” 117.

74 Smallpeice, Of Comets and Queens, 14.

75 A.B.C. [pseud.], “Sales Representative,”863–64.

76 MacLaren-Ross, Of Love and Hunger, 123–24.

77 French, “Commercials, Careers, and Culture,” 354–56.

78 Day survey 379, 12 July 1937, MOA.

79 MacLaren-Ross, Collected Memoirs, 186. This sales pitch was paralleled in Hoover's promotional literature, e.g., Hoover Ltd., “Dirt—and How to Get Rid of It,” leaflet, n.d., c. 1930s, copy privately held by the author.

80 Interview with Sam Tobin.

81 Hoover Co., Steps to the Hoover Sale (North Canton, Oh., 1936).Google Scholar

82 A.B.C, [pseud.], “Sales Representative,”864.

83 Ibid.; interview with Sam Tobin.

84 Interview with Sam Tobin.

85 Ibid.

86 Ibid.

87 MacLaren-Ross, Of Love and Hunger, 7.

88 Friedman, Birth of a Salesman, 42.

89 Ibid., 194. This was one of the “seven laws” of sales management set down by Richard H. Grant and based on the teachings of John H. Patterson at NCR.

90 Day survey 379, 12 May 1937, MOA; interview with Sam Tobin; A.B.C, [pseud.], “Sales Representative,” 864.

91 Interview with Howard Stone, conducted by Ted Haley, 7 Sept. 1983, SA 20/1/48/1, Essex Sound and Video Archive, Essex Record Office.

92 Naughton, Bill, A Roof Over Your Head (London, 1945), 19–20.Google Scholar

93 Interview with Howard Stone.

94 Interview with Sam Tobin.

95 Buell, “Door-to-Door Selling,” 119.

96 Groff, Observations of Management..

97 Hoover “Family Success” Magazine, Apr. 1922, 2, 82.85/4, Gunnersbury Park Museum.

98 Friedman, Birth of a Salesman, 36.

99 A.B.C, [pseud.], “Sales Representative,” 864; MacLaren-Ross, Of Love and Hunger, 114.

100 Collection of Hoover awards made to W. H. Newsome, held privately by the author.

101 Interview with Cyril K. Jaegar, conducted by the author on 21 Aug. 2006.

102 Day survey 425, 12 June 1937, MOA.

103 Day survey 379, 12 July 1937, MOA.

104 Friedman, Birth of a Salesman, 50.

105 Hoover, Fabulous Dustpan, 142–43; Furnival, Suck, Don't Blow, 17.

106 Interview with Sam Tobin. See also MacLaren-Ross, Of Love and Hunger, 36.

107 A.B.C. [pseud.], “Sales Representative,” 864.

108 “Intensive Door-to-Door Salesmanship,” Hire Traders Record (June 1936): 3.

109 Interview with Cyril K. Jaeger, conducted by the author on 21 Aug. 2006.

110 Interview with Sam Tobin.

111 MacLaren-Ross, Of Love and Hunger, 4.

112 Day survey 425, 12 June 1937, MOA.

113 A.B.C, [pseud.], “Sales Representative,” 864.

114 Interview with Sam Tobin. An identical scam was practiced by salesmen of Unilever's U.S. subsidiary; Groff, Observations of Management, 4–5.

115 MacLaren-Ross, Collected Memoirs, 109.

116 “Vacuum Cleaner Fraud,” Hire Traders Record (1 Oct. 1936): 8.

117 For example, “Penny a Month in H.P. Claims,” Hire Purchase Journal (May 1938): 8.

118 “Just 120 Years to Pay Instalments!” Hire Traders Record (Mar. 1937): 5.

119 Groff, Observations of Management, 6.

120 “Commission on Bogus Orders,” Hire Traders Record (l Feb. 1936): 4–5.

121 “Intensive Door-to-Door Salesmanship,” Hire Traders Record (June 1936): 3.

122 See Scott, Peter, “The Twilight World of Interwar British Hire Purchase,” Past & Present 177 (2002): 195–225.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

123 “Hoover Limited,” Times, 16 Mar. 1939, 25, col. G.

124 “The Replacement Market,” Electrical Trading (Mar. 1938): 69.

125 Political and Economic Planning, Market for Household Appliances, 211–12, 355.