Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-mlc7c Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-05T08:59:02.108Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Personal Styles, Cultural Values and Management: The Sincere and Wing on Companies in Shanghai and Hong Kong, 1900–1941

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  13 December 2011

Wellington K. K. Chan
Wellington K. K. Chan
Affiliation:
WELLINGTON K. K. CHAN is professor of history and acting chair of the Department of History at Occidental College.
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

While retailing a great variety of goods under one roof and single management already existed in China by the late nineteenth century, modern style department stores on the China coast began only in 1900. Organized by Chinese entrepreneurs who had started their careers in Australia, they consciously borrowed managerial techniques from abroad. Sincere and Wing On, the two premier Chinese department stores, expanded rapidly during diese years and, in the process, developed new forms of organization and strategy based on western models as well as on traditional Chinese business practices and cultural values. When political and economic turmoil during the 1920s and 1930s slowed the growth of these companies, Wing On emerged more successfully tban Sincere. Wing On's path diverged from that of its competitor because its stronger management team was better at blending individual personality, western organization and Chinese cultural values.

Type
Articles
Information
Business History Review , Volume 70 , Issue 2 , Summer 1996 , pp. 141 - 166
Copyright
Copyright © The President and Fellows of Harvard College 1996

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Barth, Gunther, City People: The Rise of the Modern City Culture in Nineteenth-Century America (New York, 1980)Google Scholar, provides a colorful account of the rise of modern department stores in Europe and America.

2 Clifford, Nicholas R., Spoilt Children of Empire: Westerners in Shanghai and the Chinese Revolution of the 1920s (Hanover, Vt., 1991), 62.Google Scholar

3 Shanghai jindai baihuo shangye shi (The history of modern department stores in Shanghai) (Shanghai, 1988), 9–25.

4 Ibid; Bohua, Lo and Guangbiao, Deng, “Cong Su-Hang duo baihuo” (From Suzhou and Hangzhou style shops to department stores), in Guangzhou wenshi ziliao (Historical Materials on Guangzhou) 20 (1969): 228–250.Google Scholar

5 The Sincere Company, Xianshi gongsi ershiwu zhounian jinian ce (The Sincere Company: Twenty-Fifth Anniversary Commemorative Issue)(Hong Kong, 1925)Google Scholar, “Records,” 1; Guo Luo, Hui'yi lu (Memoires) (n.p., dedication dated 1949), 1–2.

6 The Sincere Company, Xianshi gongsi ershiwu zhounian, “Records,” 1–2; Ma Wenfei, son of Ma Yingbiao, interview by author, Hong Kong, 7 and 9 July 1980.

7 Barth, City People, 128–30, 137–38.

8 The Sincere Company, The Sincere Company, Limited, Hong Kong: Diamond jubilee 1900–1975 (Hong Kong, n.d.), 12–14, 26–27Google Scholar; The Sincere Company, Xianshi gongsi ershiwu zhounian, “Records,” 1–3, 11–13.

9 Cf. Wu Xin, Yao Wendan, et al., comps., Minguo Shanghai xian zhi (Gazetteer of the Shanghai county of the republican era) (Shanghai, preface dated 1936), chuan 5: 1a–b, 16b, 20b, 24b, 31a.

10 The Sincere Company, Xianshi gonsi ershiwu zhounian, “Records,” 10–16; The Sincere Company, Sincere Company: Diamond Jubilee, 13–18.

11 Ma Wenfei, interview by author, 9 July 1980.

12 Guo Jing, retired employee of Wing On, interview by author, Shanghai, 26 Feb. 1979.

13 Guo Chuan, Yong'an jingshen zhi faren ji qi changcheng shilue (A brief history of the origin and development of the spirit of Wing On)(n.p., preface 1960), 10–11, 14–17. The names “Yong'an” and “Wing On” share the same Chinese characters; the different romanizations come from their different pronunciations in Mandarin and Cantonese respectively.

14 The Sincere Company, Xianshi gongsi ershiwu zhounian, “Records,” 9; The Wing On Company, Xianggang Yong'an youxian gongsi ershitou zhounian jinianlu (The Wing On Company Limited of Hong Kong: In Commemoration of the Twenty-Fifth Anniversary, 1907–1932) (Hong Kong, preface 1932)Google Scholar, section on “History.”

15 The Sincere Company, Hong Kong: Diamond Jubilee, 14–15.

16 Shanghai Yong'an gongsi di shansheng fazhan wo gaizao (The Birth, Development, and Reconstruction of the Shanghai Wing On Company) (Shanghai, 1981), 71–74; see Table 1 on p. 11 for the Guo brothers' 5.6 percent ownership of the Shanghai company.

17 Wei, Betty P. T., Shanghai: Crucible of Modern China (London, 1987), 212.Google Scholar

18 Sincere Company, Xianshi gongsi ershiwu zhounian, “Records,” 11; The Sincere Company, Hong Kong: Diamond Jubilee, 20; Shanghai Yong'an gongsi, 109–119; on the Ch. $500,000 (or 500,000 Ch. yuan) contribution, see Coble, Parks M. Jr, The Shanghai Capitalists and the Nationalist Government, 1927–1937 (Cambridge, Mass., 1980), 34.CrossRefGoogle Scholar Throughout this period until the mid-1930s, the Hong Kong dollar and the Chinese dollar (yuan) were worth about the same.

19 Shanghai Yong'an gongsi, 125–28.

20 Fanbo, Xiao, “Guangzhou Xianshi gongsi ershidou nian di sheng'ai,” (The rise and fall of Guangzhou's Sincere Company during its twenty-odd years) Guangzhou wenshi ziliao 23 (1972): 126–43, esp. 137–38.Google Scholar

21 Shanghai Yong'an gongsi, 147–149. Wing On's response to the British Consulate's rebuff was to change their British registration to American registration. It provided some company stock to two senior managers of the American firm in Shanghai, Andersen, Meyer & Company, and then invited them to sit on the Wing On board. The Wing On Textile Company, whose mills sat on Chinese territory, was also deeded to the American firm as collateral, so as to prevent Japanese seizure. The American registration, too, lost its efficacy after Pearl Harbor and American declaration of war against Japan.

22 Ibid., 149–159.

23 Cf. Redding, S. G., “Culture and Entrepreneurial Behavior among the Overseas Chinese,” in Berger, Brigitte, ed., The Culture of Entrepreneurship (San Francisco, 1991), 137–156.Google Scholar

24 Chan, Wellington K. K., “The Origins and Early Years of the Wing On Company Group in Australia, Fiji, Hong Kong and Shanghai: Organisation and Strategy of a New Enterprise,” in Chinese Business Enterprise in Asia, ed. Brown, Rajeswary Ampalavanar (London, 1995), 80–95.Google Scholar

25 Guo Chuan, Yong'an jingshen, 24–30.

26 The Wing On Company, Xianggang Yong'an youxian gongsi, “History,” 4–6; Shanghai Yong'an gongsi, 8, 85; The Sincere Company, Xianshi gongsi ershiwu zhounian, “Records,” 8–9, 12–13.

27 Shanghai Yong'an gongst, 87.

28 Guo Yihuo, interview by author, Guangzhou, 28 May 1981.

29 Charles Mar Fan, Ma Xiaocong, Daniel P. K. Au, and Pan Chengrong, with Sincere, interview by author, Hong Kong's Sincere Company head office, 25 June 1980. Ma Yubao, Liang Caokui, Ji Gaozhi, Xie Xianglin and Sheng Jiang, with Wing On, interview by author, Shanghai, 27, 28 February and 2 March 1980. Guo Dihuo, interview by author, Guangzhou, 28 May 1981.

30 Quoted in Wing On, The Wing On Life Assurance Company Limited: Golden Jubilee Book 1925–1975 (Hong Kong, n.d.), 18.

31 Ding Ruchu, “Shanghai huazi daying baohuo gongsi di chuangjian wo jingying” (The establishment and operation of Chinese-owned large department stores in Shanghai) (paper presented at Cornell's Luce Seminar on Shanghai, 14–15 Aug. 1992) 8.

32 Pan Chengrong, íormer employee of Sincere, interview by author, Hong Kong, 25 June 1980. Xie Xianglin, retired Wing On employee, interview by author, Shanghai, 28 Feb. 1980.

33 Ma Xiaocong, the youngest son of Ma Yingbiao, interview by author, Sincere Company office, Hong Kong, 25 June 1980.

34 Shanghai Yong'an gongsi, 46; Guo Dihuo, interview by author, Guangzhou, 28 May 1981.

35 Schumpeter, Joseph, “The Creative Response in Economic History,” Journal of Economic History 8 (Nov. 1947): 151.Google Scholar

36 Berger, ed., The Culture of Entrepreneurship, passim.