Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-m6dg7 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-08T04:45:06.564Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Five Yurok Songs: A Musical and Textual Analysis

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  24 December 2009

Extract

Certain parallels between musical structure and linguistic structure have been insisted on by Professor J. R. Firth in several publications. This is an attempt to illustrate a parallel musical and linguistic analysis within a strictly limited field, and in a ‘restricted language’, and thereby to exhibit in this field a congruence of musical and linguistic structuring. It is hoped that the material employed will be of interest as being the first published, examples of songs from the Yurok community.

Type
Articles
Copyright
Copyright © School of Oriental and African Studies 1956

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

page 592 note 1See Firth, ‘Sounds and prosodies’, TPS, 1948, 131 and 137; id., ‘Modes of meaning’, Essays and Studies, 1951, 120 and 122; id., note to Thornley, G.C., ‘The accents and points of MS Junius 11’, TPS, 1954, 201–3.Google Scholar

page 592 note 2For the Yurok see Kroeber, A.L., ‘Handbook of the Indians of California’, BAEB, 78, 1925, 197Google Scholar. The distinctiveness of Yurok music was pointed out by Kroeber (ibid., 95–6).

page 592 note 3For the term ‘collocation’ see Firth, ‘Modes of meaning’, esp. p. 126.

page 592 note 4One's informants were, of course, clear about a difference between singing and talking; but they did not consider singing as a complex activity of two parts. They could ‘say’ the text of what had been sung, from the tape recording, but this was an effort and even a discovery for them.

page 593 note 1At the time of writing a grammar of Yurok was in process of publication in the University of California Publications in Linguistics series.

page 593 note 2For this term see Robins, Formal divisions in Sundanese’, TPS, 1953, 122.Google Scholar

page 593 note 3The phonological diphthong ey is frequently realized phonetically as [e;] or [ε:].

page 594 note 1That is to say, the syllable is assignable to the pitch level of the note indicated, but the manner of production involves a less even series of sound waves for the fundamental and dependent overtones, giving an impression of a spoken rather than a sung syllable; cf. Hockett, C.F., A manual of phonology (Indiana University Publications in Anthropology and Linguistics, Memoir 11), 1955, 183.Google Scholar

page 594 note 2In the light of what was said above, Song will be taken as Text and Music.

page 594 note 3Textual phrases will be symbolized by lower case roman letters, musical phrases by corresponding Greek letters.

page 595 note 1The grammatical terms employed are treated in detail in the Yurok grammar referred to in note 1, p. 593.

page 595 note 2TPS, 1935, 36–72. For levels of analysis in linguistics see this article and id., Personality and language in society’, Sociol. Rev., XLII, 1950, 3752.Google Scholar

page 596 note 1‘Handbook’, 61–2.

page 596 note 2See McBeth, Frances Turner, Lower Klamath country, 1950, 3847.Google Scholar

page 597 note 1See Firth, ‘Sounds and prosodies’, 129–30.

page 597 note 2‘Handbook’, 63–6. SUmi:g in the text is identified as Patrick's Point on the Pacific coast in the Yurok country; see Waterman, T.T., ‘Yurok geography’, UCPAAE, xvi, 5, 1920Google Scholar, map 32 and p. 267, where the importance of Sumi:g in Yurok mythology is emphasized.

page 598 note 1Such syntactically parallel pairs of inflected verbs and shorter (non-inflected) verbs are quite common in Yurok.

page 598 note 2cf. what was said of the relation of α and γ in Song 2 (p. 597 above).

page 599 note 1rek'wOy in the text occupies the same place as the present village of Requa, which takes its name from an anglicization of the Yurok word. The village is situated at the mouth of the Klamath river, on the right bank. See Waterman, op. cit., map 5 and p. 231.

It is interesting to note the presence of similar syllable groups at the end of songs of the ‘Bird’ song-series among the Yuman and Mohave. One may point out that musicologically these songseries fall within the limits of the Yuman musical style, which, as Herzog has noted, is different from the rest of Western Hemisphere music stylistically. See Herzog, G., ‘The Yuman musical style’, Journal of American Folk-lore, XLI, 1928, 185.Google Scholar Whether Yurok music has other affinities with the Yuman style remains a question for future research. This feature may have travelled independently of music in shaman formulas. Kroeber quotes a formula for release from corpse contamination among the Yurok which begins with these syllable groups (‘Handbook’, 71).

page 600 note 1On the schematization of context of situation see Firth, ‘Personality and language in society’, 43; for this approach to language analysis see also id., ‘The technique of semantics’.

page 600 note 2See Plate 3, facing p. 288 in Waterman, op. cit.

page 601 note 1ef. the relation between α and γ (α1) Song 1, above (p. 595).

page 601 note 2cf. the relation between α and y (α1) in Song 2, above (p. 597).

page 603 note 1Waterman, op. cit., map 5 (28).

page 604 note 1It might not be unreasonable to compare this with the linguistic conception of different systems operating at different places in structures (see Allen, W.S., BSOA8, xvi, 3, 1954, p. 556, n. 2).CrossRefGoogle Scholar

page 605 note 1cf. Firth, ‘Modes of meaning’, 134. The whole of this most suggestive article points the way to such an extension of the operations of linguistic analysis.

page 608 note 1Literally, ‘Because of what’.