Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-dsjbd Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-30T01:11:32.174Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

A Periplus of Magan and Meluḫḫa

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  24 December 2009

Extract

Perhaps no question of historical-geographical interest relating to the ancient Middle East has been so frequently a subject of inquiry or brought a greater difference of opinion than has that of the location of the countries of Magan and Meluḫḫa. The problems of identification are particularly confused because widely separate areas appear to be indicated at different periods. Old Babylonian and Sumerian references seem to place these regions at the lower end of the Persian Gulf and along the coast of the Indian Ocean beyond, while texts of the late Assyrian period indicate Egypt and Nubia/Ethiopia

Type
Articles
Copyright
Copyright © School of Oriental and African Studies 1973

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 For abbreviations, see p. 584.

2 Landsberger, B., ZA, xxxv, 3, 1924, 217Google Scholar.

3 ibid., p. 217, n. 2.

4 Herzfeld, E., The Persian Empire, Wiesbaden, 1968, 63Google Scholar.

5 Note by Eilers, W. in Leemans, W., JESHO, III, 1, 1960, 29Google Scholar.

6 Herzfeld, , op. oit., 63–4Google Scholar.

7 Gelb, I. J., RA, LXIV, 1, 1970, 5Google Scholar.

8 Leemans, W. F., Foreign trade in the Old Babẏlonian period, Leiden, 1966, 162, 164Google Scholar.

9 Weidner, E. F., Af.O, XVI, 1, 1962, 22Google Scholar.

10 Leemans, , Foreign trade, 159Google Scholar.

11 Kramer, S. N., An., XXXVII, 146, 1963, p. 114, n. 11Google Scholar.

12 The case for identifying Telmun or Dilmun with Bahrain is set out in Cornwall, B., BASOR, 103, 1946, 3f.Google Scholar, and in Cornwall, B., JCS, VI, 4, 1952, 137 fGoogle Scholar.

13 Barton, G. A., The royal inscriptions of Sumer and Akkad, New Haven, (1929, 108Google Scholar.

14 ibid., 128–30.

15 ibid., 142.

16 ibid., 180, 184, 220.

17 Leemans, , Foreign trade, Magan copper, 19 (UET, III, 1689)Google Scholar; Magan onions, 21 (UET, III, 751); Magan reed, 26 (UET, V, 678).

18 Leemans, , Foreign trade, Meluḫḫa copper, 161 (UET, III, 368)Google Scholar; A.AB.BA wood, 161 (UET, in, 430, 660, 703, 752); mesu wood, 161 (UET, in, 818, 1498, 1241); ivory birds, 161 (UET, in, 757, 761, 764, 768, 770).

19 Leemans, , Foreign trade, 125Google Scholar, quoting OIP, XLIII, p. 194, no. 121.

20 ibid., 24–6 (UET, v, 526, 678).

21 ibid., 27 (UET, v, 292).

22 ibid., 36 (UET, v, 367).

23 ibid., 138 (ABM, v, 14).

24 Landsberger, B., MSL, vGoogle Scholar. For Magan and Meluḫḫa chairs, 158; Magan and Meluḫḫa tables, 168; MES wood of Magan and Meluḫḫa, 109; date-palm of Magan and Meluḫḫa, 117; A.AB.BA wood of Meluḫḫa, 105. For Magan and Meluḫḫa copper see Matouš, , LTBA, iGoogle Scholar, tablet 33, col. 5, 11. 32–6. See Scheil, , RA, xv, 1918, 115Google Scholar, for na4 GUG Meluḫḫa.

25 On these toponyms see Herzfeld, , The Persian Empire, 63Google Scholar.

26 Benedict, W. C. and von Voigtlander, E., JCS, x, 1, 1956, 3Google Scholar.

27 Kent, R. G., Old Persian grammar, New Haven, 1953, 117, 136, 141, 151Google Scholar.

28 ibid., 36, ‘Maka is ethnic Maciya with the palatalization because the suffix began with the palatal sound’.

29 Herodotus, III, xciii.

30 See Herzfeld, , op. cit., 300Google Scholar.

31 See Marquart, J. (ed.), A catalogue of the provincial capitals of Ērānshahr, Rome, 1931, 77Google Scholar.

32 Marquart, J. (ed.), Ērānšahr, Berlin, 1901, 16Google Scholar; Maricq, A., Syria, XXXV, 3–4, 1958, 336Google Scholar.

33 Herzfeld, , op. cit., 63Google Scholar; Leemans, , JESHO, III, 1, 1960, 29Google Scholar; Salonen, A., Die Türen des alten Mesopotamien, Helsinki, 1961, p. 99, n. 1Google Scholar.

34 See p. 555.

35 The identification of na4ESI as diorite is deduced from the finding that nearly all the covered statues of Gudea are of this stone.

36 Forbes, R. J., Metallurgy in antiquity, Leiden, 1950, 187Google Scholar.

37 CAH, third ed., i, pt. n, 440.

38 Forbes, R. J., Studies in ancient technology, VIII; Leiden, 1964, 212Google Scholar.

39 Caldwell, J., Investigations at Tal-i Iblis, Springfield, III., 1967, 347–8Google Scholar.

40 CHI, I, 85.

41 Caldwell, , op. cit., 13, 375Google Scholar; see also CHI, I, 503.

42 Gershevitch, I., BSOAS, XIX, 2, 1957, 317–20CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

43 Watt, G., A dictionary of the economic products of India, III, Calcutta, 1890, 1314Google Scholar.

44 Legrain, L., UET, III, 859, 233Google Scholar.

45 ibid., 219, 493; 214, 363.

46 ibid., 260, 14.

47 On this point see Leemans, , Foreign trade, 159Google Scholar.

48 Although KÚB can be read as ‘mountain’ or ‘hill’, it may also indicate a land. In the case of KÚB MELUTḪḪA, Gudea caused ušu wood and gold dust to be brought down (IM.TA.É) from there (Barton, , The royal inscriptions, 184)Google Scholar. In the case of KÚR MAGANk1, a more specifio word for mountain, ḪÚR.SAG MAGANk1, is also attested (Barton, , op. cit., 190)Google Scholar.

49 KB, III, 1, 37; Thureau-Dangin, F. (ed.), Vne relation de la huitième campagne de Sargon, Paris, 1912, p. 53, n. 6Google Scholar.

50 Arrian, , Anabasis, vi, xxii, 67Google Scholar.

51 Watt, , A dictionary of the economic products of India, II, Calcutta, 1889, 261Google Scholar. For mangroves on the coast of Las Bela which geographically forms a part of eastern Magan, see Stein, M. A., GJ, CII, 5–6, 1943, 196Google Scholar.

52 Watt, , op. oit., II, 261Google Scholar.

53 RGSP, I, 1, 1948, 10Google Scholar, and plate 1; VII, 2, 1955, 58. See also Forbes, R. J., Studies in ancient technology, VII, Leiden, 1964, 12Google Scholar.

54 C. H. Desch, ‘Sumerian copper. Seventh interim report of committee appointed to report on the probable sources of the supply of copper used by the Sumerians’ [Report, British Association for the Advancement of Science, annual meeting, Blackpool, 1936, Section H, 3 pp.; a copy is in the Library of the Institute of Archaeology, University of London].

55 Peake, H., An., II, 8, 1928, 454Google Scholar.

56 ibid., 456.

57 SirMarshall, John (ed.), Mohenjo-daro, II, London, 1931, 484Google Scholar.

58 Lambert, W. G. (ed. and tr.), Babylonian wisdom literature, Oxford, 1960, 272Google Scholar.

59 Dales, G., An., XXXVI, 142, 1962, 90–2Google Scholar; Raikes, R. L., AA, LXVI, 2, 1964, 290Google Scholar.

60 Dales, , art. oit., 90–1Google Scholar.

61 ibid., 92.

62 Lamberg-Karlovsky, C. C., Iran, X, 1972, 93Google Scholar.

63 Tosi, M., EW, NS, XX, 1–2, 1970, 13Google Scholar.

64 Cardi, B. De, APAMNH, LI, 3, 1970, 268Google Scholar.

65 ibid., 257.

66 SirWheeler, Mortimer, The Indus civilization, third ed., Cambridge, 1968, 1618Google Scholar.

67 On the Kulli sequence see Wheeler, op. cit.

68 Fairservis, W. A. Jr, The roots of ancient India, London, 1971, 227Google Scholar.

69 Lamberg-Karlovsky, , art. oit., 93Google Scholar.

70 Personal communication from Dr. M. Tosi.

71 Cardi, De, art. cit., 243Google Scholar.

72 Wheeler, , op. oit., 132–3Google Scholar.

73 For the Sanskrit sources see below Bailey, pp. 584–6, § A.

74 Śatapathabrāhmaṇa (tr. Eggeling, J.), SBE, xxvi, 32Google Scholar.

75 Leemans, , Foreign trade, 164Google Scholar.

76 Luckenbill, D. D., The annals of Sennacherib, Chicago, 1924, 106, 110Google Scholar.

77 Herzfeld, , The Persian Empire, 70Google Scholar.

78 Luckenbill, , op. cit., 106Google Scholar.

79 Thompson, R. C., A dictionary of Assyrian botany, London, 1949, 342–3Google Scholar.

80 ibid., loc. cit. For the habitat of this plant see Watt, , A dictionary of the economic products of India, III, 334Google Scholar.

81 Thompson, , op. cit., 238–9Google Scholar(šamA.AB.BA and šamKA.A.AB.BA). For kušabku see CAD, VIII (K), 597.

82 Watt, , A dictionary of the economic products of India, II, 261Google Scholar.

83 Kent, , Old Persian grammar, 136, 141Google Scholar.

84 Arrian, , Anabasis, VI, xxii, 1Google Scholar.

85 There are structural similarities of Gadrosii and Gadrā, the name of a servile tribe who inhabit the Las Bela region west of Sind (Bray, D., The tribes of Baluchistan, Calcutta, 1915, 101Google Scholar). The language of these Gadrā is ‘local Sindhi vernacular’ classed together with Sindhi, Jaṭki (Census of India, 1931, IV, 1, 143Google Scholar). It is not possible on the available evidence to consider a linguistic connexion of the two names.

86 Herzfeld, , The Persian Empire, 335Google Scholar.

87 Stephanus Byzantinus, s.v. Alexandria Makarene.

88 Arrian, , Anabasis, vi, xxiv, 1Google Scholar.

89 Strabo, XV, ii, 9 and 14.

90 Strabo, XV, ii, 9.

91 See makan, Burrow, T. and Emeneau, M. B., A Dravidian etymological dictionary, Oxford, 1961, 304Google Scholar.

92 Maroian, , Periplus of the outer sea (trans. Sohoff, W.), Philadelphia, 1927, 23–4Google Scholar; Arrian, , Anabasis, VI, xvii, 2Google Scholar.

93 Al-Ṭabarī, I, 820.

94 Maricq, A., Syria, XXXV, 3–4, 1958, 306, 336Google Scholar.

95 Marquart, , Ērānšahr, 16Google Scholar.

96 Al-Muqaddasi, 478.

97 Firdausī, , Shāhnāma (tr. Warner, ), VII, London, 1915, 216–17Google Scholar.

98 Nöldeke, T., Geschichte der Perser und Araber zur Zeit der Sasaniden, Leyden, 1879 p.157, n.3Google Scholar.

99 Al-Mnqaddasī, 488–9.

100 El, first ed., s.v. ‘Balōčistān’, 628.

101 For a concise account of the Islamic history of Baluchistan and a list of the relevant sources, see ibid., 634–9.

102 Spooner, B., ‘Notes on the toponymy of the Persian Makran’, in Bosworth, C. E. (ed.), Iran and Islam, Edinburgh, [1971], 520Google Scholar.

103 Arrian, , Anabasis, VI, xxiv, 1Google Scholar; VI, xxvii, 1.

104 See Appendix II for a note on Alexander in Carmania.

105 Holdich, T. H., GJ, VII, 4, 1896, 409Google Scholar; Tarn, W. W., Alexander the Great, II, Cambridge, 1948, mapGoogle Scholar.

106 Stein, M. A., Archaeological reconnaissances, London, 1937, 105–6Google Scholar.

107 ibid., 110.

108 On the ruins of Tiz, see Stein, , op. cit., 87–8Google Scholar.

109 Al-Muqaddasi, 478.

110 Al-Idrīsī, Nuzhat al-mushtāq, translated into English by Ahmad, S. M. as India and the neighbouring territories, Leiden, 1960, 46Google Scholar.

111 See p. 556.

112 On the end of the Indus civilization see Wheeler, , The Indus civilization, 132–3Google Scholar.

113 Mercer, S. A. (ed.), Tell el-Amarna tablets, Toronto, 1939, i, 266, 366, 374, 382, 390, 440Google Scholar.

114 ibid., I, 422, 436.

115 ibid., I, 222.

116 ibid., I, 712.

117 Posener, G., Kush, vi, 1958, 45–7Google Scholar.

118 For discussion and sources on Kush see CAH, third ed., II, pt. I, 346–9.

119 JCS, VI, 4, 1952, 143 fGoogle Scholar.

120 Mercer, , Tell el-Amarna tablets, I, 22, 70, 80–8, 128–44Google Scholar.

121 KUB, II, no. 51, 1. 20, and no. 52, 1. 6 f.

122 Weidner, E. F., A f. O, Beiheft 12, 1959, 30Google Scholar; ABA, I, 59.

123 Weidner, 21.

124 CAH, II third ed., pt. II, fasc. 49, 14.

125 Winckler, H., Die Keilschrifttexte Sargons, I, Leipzig, 1889, 114, 116Google Scholar; ABA, II, 32.

126 Luckenbill, , The annals of Sennacherib, 31–2Google Scholar.

127 Borger, R., Die Inschriften Asarhaddons, Graz, 1956, 86Google Scholar.

128 ibid., 112.

129 ibid., 36.

130 ibid., 80.

131 Piepkorn, A., Historical prism inscriptions of Ashurbanipal, Chicago, 1933Google Scholar, text B.30 and text D.31, no. 12; ABA, n, 292.

132 Piepkorn, 30–8; ABA, II, 292–3.

133 Piepkorn, 38; ABA, II, 295.

134 See above, p. 555, n. 11.

135 Weidner, , A f. 0, XVI, 1, 1952, 1Google Scholar.

136 ibid., 19.

137 Luckenbill, , The annals of Sennacherib, 74Google Scholar; ABA, I, 146.

138 See ARM, XV, 1954, 129Google Scholar, for text references to this Mari.

139 Barton, , The royal inscriptions, 105–6 and 112Google Scholar.

140 The bēru has been reckoned as equalling about 10 69 kilometres. SeeRA, XVIII, 1921, 133Google Scholar.

141 Mercer, Tell el-Amarna tablets. For gold see 1, 10, 16, 24, 32, 44–6; for ivory, I, 16, 41, 54–6.

142 ibid., I, 36.

143 Winekler, , Die Keilschrifttexte Sargons, I, 116Google Scholar; ASA, II, 32.

144 See Leemans, , Foreign trade, 144, 21Google Scholar.

145 Watt, , A dictionary of the economic products of India, III, 333–4Google Scholar.

146 Thompson, , A dictionary of Assyrian botany, 353–9 (šamAŠ)Google Scholar.

147 Watt, , op. cit., 330Google Scholar.

148 Lamberg-Karlovsky, C. C., Excauations at Tepe Yahya 1967–1969, Cambridge, Mass., 1970, 5Google Scholar.

149 J. Marquart, A catalogue of the provincial capitals of Ērānshahr. Marquart arrives at this location by equating Old Persian Yutiya with Middle Persian Krmān Yut, the Yut of Kirman, and these with the Jut of south Kirmān.

150 Poebel, A. M., University of Pennsylvania. University Museum. Publications of the Babylonian Section, IV, 1914, 234Google Scholar.

151 Barton, , The royal inscriptions, 128, 130Google Scholar.

152 Herzfeld, , The Persian Empire, 178–9Google Scholar; Hansman, , Iran, X, 1972, 105Google Scholar.