Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-2brh9 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-28T19:59:09.294Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The British Whigs on America: 1820–1860

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  17 February 2011

D. P. Crook
Get access

Extract

There has been a tendency among historians of the Anglo-American connection to suggest that there was a fairly rigid dichotomy in English opinion about America in the first half of the nineteenth century. On the one hand, it is suggested, there were the Radicals, who, by tradition and in principle, favoured the United States and its institutions. This group - the Left of that period - comprised the excluded classes of society, the dissenters, the artisans and labourers, the Chartists and democrats, the utilitarians. Confronting them was the Establishment, opposed to innovation, and especially democratic innovation, embittered by memories of 1776 and 1812, and therefore thoroughly anti-American.

Type
Research Article
Information
Bulletin of the British Association for American Studies , Volume 3 , December 1961 , pp. 4 - 17
Copyright
Copyright © British Association for American Studies 1961

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

REFERENCES

1.See, e.g., Lillibridge, G.D., Beacon of Freedom: The Impact of American Democracy upon Great Britain 1830–1870 (Pennsylvania, 1954); Henry Pelling, America and the British Left (London, 1956), pp. 1–4; Frank Thistlethwaite, The Anglo-American Connection in the Early Nineteenth Century (Philadelphia, 1959), ch. 2, and his “America and Two Nations of Englishmen”, Virginia Quarterly Review, XXXI (Autumn, 1955), pp. 505 – 525.Google Scholar
2.See, e.g., Walsh, Robert, Appeal from the Judgments of Great Britain respecting the U.S.A. etc. (Philadelphia, 1819), pp. 211–305; Henry Cabot Lodge, One Hundred Years Peace (New York, 1913). pp. 43–63; E. D. Adams, “The Point of View of the British Traveller in America”,Political Science Quarterly, XXIX (1914), pp. 244–264.Google Scholar
3.Edinburgh Review (hereafter ER), no. 110, July 1832, p. 521 (America and her Detractors), by Empson. I should like to acknowledge the assistance given to me, in locating the authorship of the articles mentioned in this paper, by Mrs. Esther Rhoads Houghton of the Wellesley Index to Victorian Periodicals, Wellesley College, Massachusetts.Google Scholar
4.E.g., ER, no. 112, January 1833, p. 461 (Stuart on America), by McCulloch.Google Scholar
5.ER, no. 188, October 1850, p. 371 (Lyell's Second Visit to the United States).Google Scholar
6.ER, no. 66, May 1820, pp. 400, 401, 405.Google Scholar
7.Before 1832 he had complained to his brother and to his American friend, Charles Wilkes, about party violence and vulgarity in the Union; and after 1832 he opposed further extensions of the suffrage in Britain. See Cockburn, Lord, The Life and Correspondence of Francis Jeffrey (London, 1852), II, 49, 147, 183–185; and Selections from the Correspondence of Macvey Napier, ed. by his son (London, 1877), letter from Jeffrey to Napier, 27. 12. 1837.Google Scholar
8.Westminster Review, no. 2, April 1824, p. 513.Google Scholar
9.See Empson's articles of June 1829 (Art. 9 on Hall's Travels in North America); of July 1830 (Art. 9 on Jefferson's Memoirs and Correspondence); and of July 1832 (Art. 8 on Mrs. Trollope's Domestic Manners of the Americans, and other works.Google Scholar
10.ER, no. 131, October 1837, p. 167 (Tucker's Life of Jefferson).Google Scholar
11.ER, no. 151, April 1842, p. 11 (France America and Britain).Google Scholar
12.ER, no. 167, January 1846, p. 141 (Lyall's Travels in North America). Merivale, who was Professor of political economy at Oxford from 1837 to 1842, was a classicist who was also closely interested in the emigration movement to North America.Google Scholar
13.ER, no. 188, October 1850, p. 367. Spedding, known for his editing of Bacon's works, was a secretary on the Ashburton mission to the United States in 1842. He was a staunch liberal who moved freely in literary and intellectual Whig circles.Google Scholar
14.ER, October 1829, p. 132 (American Literature - Dr. Channing).Google Scholar
15.ER, no. 66, May 1820, p. 430.Google Scholar
16.ER, no. 194, April 1852, p. 517.Google Scholar
17.ER, no. 112, January 1833, p. 481 (Stuart on America).Google Scholar
18.ER, no 124, July 1835, p. 385 (Mrs. Butler's Journal), possibly by Bulwer-Lytton.Google Scholar
19.ER, no. 122, July 1837, Art. 9 (Causes and Consequences of the Crisis in American Trade).Google Scholar
20.E.g., ER, no. 135. April 1838, pp. 189–190 (Martineau's Retrospect of Western Travel). This article is possibly by Bulwer -Lytton.Google Scholar
21.ER, no. 163, January 1845, p. 29 (Brougham's Political Philosophy). 22. ER, no. 163, January 1845, p. 30.Google Scholar
22.ER, no. 163, January 1845, p. 30.Google Scholar
23.E.g., ER, no. 167, January 1846, pp. 194–195 (European and American State Confederacies).Google Scholar
24.ER, no. 163, January 1845, p. 35.Google Scholar
25.See the following: ER, no 206, April 1855, Art. 1 (Slavery in the United States) by Senior, assisted by John Chandler Bancroft Davis, Secretary of the American Legation to Britain 1849–52 and American correspondent of the Times 1854–61; ER, no. 212, October 1856, Art. 10 (The Political Crisis in the United States) by William Henry Hurlbert, a New York journalist; ER, no. 220, October 1858, p. 572 (The Slave Trade in 1858). Both Davis and Hurlbert were from New York, and they imparted a strong Northern and abolitionist flavour to their articles, which were well received in liberal quarters.Google Scholar
26.E.g., ER, no. 196, October 1852, Art. 7 (Representative Reform); no. 200, October 1853, Art. 9 (Parliamentary Purification); no. 215, July 1857, Art. 4 (Representative Reform)–all by W.R. Greg.Google Scholar
27.ER, no. 196, October 1852, pp. 455 ff.Google Scholar
28.ER, no. 188, October 1850, p. 367.Google Scholar
29.ER, no. 215, July 1857, Art 9 (Representative Reform).Google Scholar
30.ER, no. 215, July 1857, Art 9 (Representative Reform)., pp. 263–4 (The preceding quotation is from p. 267 of the same article).Google Scholar
31.ER, no. 61, December 1818, pp 199–201 (Universal Suffrage).Google Scholar
32.ER, no. 102 July 1830, p. 517 (Jefferson's Memoirs and Correspondence).Google Scholar
33.See, e.g., Spedding's commendation of the voluntary system and the Massachusetts system of schools in ER, no. 188, October 1850, pp. 355–360. George Combe, who wanted the creation in Britain of a national scheme of education based on that of Massachusetts, also propagated his ideas in the Edinburgh Review, e.g., no. 148, July 1841, Art. 6 (State of Massachusetts).Google Scholar
34.ER, no. 188, October 1850, p. 510 (Difficulties of Republican France), by Greg.Google Scholar