It is rather a pity that modem criticism is couched so exclusively in terms of black and white. If a writer these days is not a great creative artist, he is liable to be wiped off the slate altogether. Therefore, those who would preserve a reputation seek to establish it in the strongest possible terms. Terms, perhaps, which it cannot possibly support. This often draws a rebuttal from critics who are impressed less favourably. And, indeed, they may be quite within the bounds of reason if what is in question is the inflating of a minor talent. Yet, to confute an over-estimation is not to condemn a talent which may be genuine. Good writing is rare enough in any period, and we must take it as we find it.