Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-rdxmf Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-22T20:40:31.718Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Tea consumption and mortality of all cancers, CVD and all causes: a meta-analysis of eighteen prospective cohort studies

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  23 July 2015

Jun Tang ,
Ju-Sheng Zheng ,
Ling Fang ,
Yongxin Jin ,
Wenwen Cai  and
Duo Li
Jun Tang
Affiliation:
Department of Food Science and Nutrition, Zhejiang University, Hangzhou 310058, People’s Republic of China
Ju-Sheng Zheng
Affiliation:
Department of Food Science and Nutrition, Zhejiang University, Hangzhou 310058, People’s Republic of China
Ling Fang
Affiliation:
Second Provincial People’s Hospital of Gansu, Lanzhou 730000, People’s Republic of China
Yongxin Jin
Affiliation:
Second Provincial People’s Hospital of Gansu, Lanzhou 730000, People’s Republic of China
Wenwen Cai
Affiliation:
Department of Food Science and Nutrition, Zhejiang University, Hangzhou 310058, People’s Republic of China
Duo Li*
Affiliation:
Department of Food Science and Nutrition, Zhejiang University, Hangzhou 310058, People’s Republic of China
*
*Corresponding author: Professor D. Li, fax +86 571 8898 2024, email [email protected]
Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Epidemiological studies have demonstrated inconsistent associations between tea consumption and mortality of all cancers, CVD and all causes. To obtain quantitative overall estimates, we conducted a dose–response meta-analysis of prospective cohort studies. A literature search in PubMed and Embase up to April 2015 was conducted for all relevant papers published. Random-effects models were used to calculate pooled relative risks (RR) with 95 % CI. In eighteen prospective studies, there were 12 221, 11 306 and 55 528 deaths from all cancers, CVD and all causes, respectively. For all cancer mortality, the summary RR for the highest v. lowest category of green tea and black tea consumption were 1·06 (95 % CI 0·98, 1·15) and 0·79 (95 % CI 0·65, 0·97), respectively. For CVD mortality, the summary RR for the highest v. lowest category of green tea and black tea consumption were 0·67 (95 % CI 0·46, 0·96) and 0·88 (95 % CI 0·77, 1·01), respectively. For all-cause mortality, the summary RR for the highest v. lowest category of green tea and black tea consumption were 0·80 (95 % CI 0·68, 0·93) and 0·90 (95 % CI 0·83, 0·98), respectively. The dose–response analysis indicated that one cup per d increment of green tea consumption was associated with 5 % lower risk of CVD mortality and with 4 % lower risk of all-cause mortality. Green tea consumption was significantly inversely associated with CVD and all-cause mortality, whereas black tea consumption was significantly inversely associated with all cancer and all-cause mortality.

Keywords

TeaMortalityCancersCVDAll-cause mortalityMeta-analyses
Type
Systematic Reviews
Information
British Journal of Nutrition , Volume 114 , Issue 5 , 14 September 2015 , pp. 673 - 683
Check for updates
Copyright
Copyright © The Authors 2015 

Cancer and CVD are two of the most common leading causes of mortality worldwide. According to the World Health Organization( 1 ), cancer and CVD accounted for 8·2 and 17·5 million deaths worldwide in 2012, representing 15 and 31 % of all global deaths, respectively. Over the past few decades, dietary factors were postulated to play an important role in the prevention of various degenerative diseases. Tea, the second most popular beverage around the world, was reported to be protective against cancer and CVD( Reference Chen, Milacic and Chen 2 , Reference Tangney and Rasmussen 3 ).

It is generally believed that the anti-cancer effects of tea are attributed to its abundant polyphenols. The main anti-cancer mechanisms of tea polyphenols include promotion of antioxidant activity, inhibition of NF-κB and AP-1, regulation of the cell cycle, inhibition of receptor tyrosine kinase pathways, control of epigenetic modifications and modulation of the immune system( Reference Shirakami, Shimizu and Moriwaki 4 ). It has been proved that an increased level of plasma cholesterol is a major risk factor for CVD. Tea and its polyphenols could lower plasma cholesterol levels by increasing the expression of LDL and reducing the oxidisation of LDL( Reference Brown and Goldstein 5 , Reference Kuhn, Burns and Kazi 6 ). It has also been suggested that tea can inhibit the process of atherosclerosis by removing reactive oxygen species, inducing hypolipaemia and decreasing antifibrinolysis( Reference Vinson, Teufel and Wu 7 ). In general, tea and its polyphenols could be effective dietary factors for the prevention of cancer and CVD.

However, results from observational studies have been inconsistent. To date, we identified eighteen cohort studies investigating the associations between tea consumption and mortality of all cancers, CVD and all causes( Reference Klatsky, Armstrong and Friedman 8 – Reference Saito, Inoue and Sawada 25 ). Among them, one study( Reference Gardener, Rundek and Wright 23 ) suggested an inverse association between tea consumption and mortality of all cancers, whereas another seven studies suggested a null association( Reference Hertog, Sweetnam and Fehily 9 , Reference Iwai, Ohshiro and Kurozawa 11 , Reference Khan, Goto and Kobayashi 13 , Reference Kuriyama, Shimazu and Ohmori 14 , Reference Suzuki, Yorifuji and Takao 18 , Reference Odegaard, Koh and Yuan 24 , Reference Saito, Inoue and Sawada 25 ). Similarly, conclusions from the studies that investigated the association between tea consumption and mortality from CVD and all causes were inconsistent.

Although a significant number of meta-analyses have been carried out to investigate the relationship between tea consumption and cancer and CVD in recent years, they mainly focused on individual cancers or specific types of CVD. The outcome of the studies, included in these meta-analyses, was primarily risk of incidence, but not mortality. Several questions are still unanswered – for example, whether the associations remain consistent when it comes to mortality of all cancers, all CVD and all causes, compared with morbidity of individual cancers or specific types of CVD. Therefore, it is necessary to conduct a meta-analysis with cohort studies using mortality as the outcome. The objective of the present study was to investigate the association between tea consumption and mortality of all cancers, CVD and all causes. In addition, a dose–response analysis was carried out to determine trend estimation, and sub-group analyses were carried out to examine sources of heterogeneity.

Methods

Selection of studies

Our report followed the Meta-analysis Of Observational Studies in Epidemiology Guidelines( Reference Stroup, Berlin and Morton 26 ). PubMed and Embase were searched for all relevant papers published in English from 1 January 1966 to 10 April 2015 and from 1 January 1974 to 10 April 2015, respectively. The search terms included ‘tea’ (or ‘coffee’ or ‘beverage’ or ‘beverages’ or ‘dietary habits’ or ‘flavonols’ or ‘flavonoids’ or ‘caffeine’ or ‘catechin’); ‘all cancers’ (or ‘cancer’ or ‘carcinoma’ or ‘carcinomas’ or ‘neoplasm’ or ‘neoplasms’ or ‘oral cancer’ or ‘breast cancer’ or ‘liver cancer’ or ‘pancreatic cancer’ or ‘stomach cancer’ or ‘gastric cancer’ or ‘colon cancer’ or ‘rectal cancer’ or ‘colorectal cancer’ or ‘prostate cancer’); ‘cardiovascular disease’ (or ‘CVD’ or ‘all cardiovascular diseases’ or ‘all CVDs’ or ‘vascular disease’ or ‘vascular event’ or ‘coronary heart disease’ or ‘CHD’ or ‘angina’ or ‘ischemic heart disease’ or ‘IHD’ or ‘myocardial ischemia’ or ‘myocardial infarction’ or ‘MI’ or ‘coronary artery disease’ or ‘atherosclerosis’); ‘all-cause’ (or ‘all causes’ or ‘overall’ or ‘total’); ‘prospective’ (or ‘cohort’ or ‘nest case control’ or ‘nest case-control studies’); and ‘mortality’ (or ‘risk’ or ‘incedence’ or ‘morbidity’). The complete details of the search strategy are shown in the online Supplementary Methods. The search was restricted to human studies. Furthermore, references from the retrieved articles were reviewed to identify potential bibliographies.

The search was conducted by two of the authors (J. T. and J. Z.) independently, and discrepancies were resolved through group discussion. Included studies were required to meet the following criteria: (a) studies used a prospective observational design (prospective cohort or nested case–control study); (b) risk estimates (hazard ratio (HR) or RR) with their corresponding 95 % CI of mortality rate for each category of tea consumption were available; and (c) the most recent and complete study was included if cohorts were duplicated. The exclusion criteria were as follows: (a) case–control or intervention studies; (b) the outcome was risk of incidence, not mortality; (c) the detailed risk estimates were not reported; (d) studies only investigated individual cancers, but did not report mortality of all cancers; and (e) studies only investigated specific types of CVD such as CHD and stroke, but did not report overall CVD mortality.

Data extraction

We collected the following data from the included studies: first author’s name, year of publication, study region, age of subjects, duration of follow-up, sex, sample size, type of tea consumed, number of events for each tea consumption category, adjusted covariates, methods of dietary assessment and HR or RR with their 95 % CI for mortality of all cancers, CVD and all causes.

Quality assessment was conducted according to the Newcastle–Ottawa criteria for non-randomised studies( Reference Wells, Wells and O’Connell 27 ). A maximum of 9 points was assigned to each study: 4 for selection, 2 for comparability and 3 for assessment of outcomes for cohort study. Comparability was assessed based on the adjustment of age and BMI; 10 years or above was considered to be the adequate length of follow-up, and 80 % response rate was considered to be adequate. We regarded scores of 0–3, 4–6 and 7–9 as low, moderate and high quality, respectively.

Statistical analysis

RR was considered as the common risk estimate for the associations between tea consumption and mortality. HR was treated as RR directly. RR from each study was transformed to its natural logarithm, and the 95 % CI was used to calculate the corresponding standard error. As different studies might report different exposure categories, we used the study-specific RR for the highest v. lowest category of tea consumption in this meta-analysis. Dersimonian and Laird random-effects model, which takes variation both within and between studies into consideration, was used to combine the RR and they were weighted by the inverse of their variance.

Dose–response analysis was carried out according to Greenland and Longnecker( Reference Greenland and Longnecker 28 ) and Orsini et al.( Reference Orsini, Bellocco and Greenland 29 ), which estimates study-specific slope and 95 % CI from the natural logs of the RR estimates and CI across categories of tea consumption. According to this method, amount of tea consumption, RR, 95 % CI and distribution of cases and person-years/non-cases in each included study should be extracted for the trend estimation using generalised least squares regression. For studies that did not provide the number of cases or person-years/non-cases, slopes were estimated using variance-weighted least squares regression. For studies conducted in Western countries that did not describe the type of tea, black tea was considered as the tea consumed, based on the fact that people living in these counties primarily consume black tea in daily life( Reference Mukhtar and Ahmad 30 ). Midpoint of the upper and lower boundaries was considered as the dose of each category when the study reported only the range of tea consumption. If the highest category was open-ended, we regarded it as of the same amplitude as the preceding one. The lowest boundary was set to 0 if the lowest category was open. We regarded 150 g tea beverages equivalent to one cup of tea. To estimate a potential non-linear association, we used a two-step random-effects model: tea consumption was modelled using restricted cubic splines with three knots at 10, 50 and 90 % of the distribution of tea consumption( Reference Harrell 31 ); a P value was then obtained by testing the null hypothesis that the regression coefficient of the second spline was equal to 0( Reference Orsini, Li and Wolk 32 ). Study-specific coefficient estimates were calculated using generalised least squares regression, and subsequently the regression coefficients of each study were pooled using the multivariate random-effects meta-regression model proposed by Jackson et al.( Reference Jackson, White and Thompson 33 ).

We assessed statistical heterogeneity with Q and I 2 statistics. I 2 values of 25, 50 and 75 % corresponded to cut-off points for low, moderate and high degrees of heterogeneity, respectively. Sub-group analysis was carried out to examine sources of study heterogeneity and the influence of potential confounding factors such as region, sex, duration of follow-up years, smoking status and study quality. Sensitivity analysis was carried out by excluding one study at a time and evaluating the effect of an individual study on the overall risk estimate. Begg’s funnel plot and Egger’s regression test (significant at P<0·05) were used to evaluate publication bias. All the analyses were carried out using STATA version 12.0 (StataCorp LP).

Results

Literature search and study characteristics

Fig. 1 represents the detailed selection process. Through full test examination of sixty-two potential publications, we identified eighteen eligible publications. Among them, six cohorts( Reference Klatsky, Armstrong and Friedman 8 , Reference Mukamal, Maclure and Muller 12 , Reference Andersen, Jacobs and Carlsen 16 , Reference Paganini-Hill, Kawas and Corrada 17 , Reference Zhang, Lopez-Garcia and Li 19 , Reference Gardener, Rundek and Wright 23 ) were from the USA, four cohorts( Reference Hertog, Sweetnam and Fehily 9 , Reference Bidel, Hu and Qiao 15 , Reference de Koning Gans, Uiterwaal and van der Schouw 20 , Reference Harris, Bergkvist and Wolk 22 ) were from Europe and eight cohorts( Reference Nakachi, Matsuyama and Miyake 10 , Reference Iwai, Ohshiro and Kurozawa 11 , Reference Khan, Goto and Kobayashi 13 , Reference Kuriyama, Shimazu and Ohmori 14 , Reference Suzuki, Yorifuji and Takao 18 , Reference Mineharu, Koizumi and Wada 21 , Reference Odegaard, Koh and Yuan 24 , Reference Saito, Inoue and Sawada 25 ) were from Asian countries. Eight cohorts( Reference Hertog, Sweetnam and Fehily 9 , Reference Iwai, Ohshiro and Kurozawa 11 , Reference Khan, Goto and Kobayashi 13 , Reference Kuriyama, Shimazu and Ohmori 14 , Reference Suzuki, Yorifuji and Takao 18 , Reference Gardener, Rundek and Wright 23 , Reference Odegaard, Koh and Yuan 24 , Reference Saito, Inoue and Sawada 25 ) involving 12 221 cases among 163 854 individuals described the association between tea consumption and all cancer mortality; ten cohorts( Reference Nakachi, Matsuyama and Miyake 10 , Reference Mukamal, Maclure and Muller 12 , Reference Kuriyama, Shimazu and Ohmori 14 – Reference Andersen, Jacobs and Carlsen 16 , Reference Suzuki, Yorifuji and Takao 18 , Reference Zhang, Lopez-Garcia and Li 19 , Reference Mineharu, Koizumi and Wada 21 , Reference Gardener, Rundek and Wright 23 , Reference Odegaard, Koh and Yuan 24 ) involving 11 306 cases among 240 637 individuals described the association between tea consumption and CVD mortality; fifteen cohorts( Reference Klatsky, Armstrong and Friedman 8 , Reference Hertog, Sweetnam and Fehily 9 , Reference Iwai, Ohshiro and Kurozawa 11 , Reference Mukamal, Maclure and Muller 12 , Reference Kuriyama, Shimazu and Ohmori 14 – Reference de Koning Gans, Uiterwaal and van der Schouw 20 , Reference Harris, Bergkvist and Wolk 22 , Reference Gardener, Rundek and Wright 23 – Reference Saito, Inoue and Sawada 25 ) involving 55 528 cases among 440 297 individuals reported the association between tea consumption and all-cause mortality.

Fig. 1. Flow diagram for the selection of studies in the meta-analysis.

The main characteristics of the studies included in the meta-analysis are summarised in online Supplementary Table S1. The duration of follow-up ranged from 3 to 28 years. The average score for quality assessment of the included studies was 6·1, and all the studies scored 4 or above (online Supplementary Table S2).

Tea consumption and all cancer mortality

Among the eight studies investigating associations between tea consumption and all cancer mortality, two studies( Reference Khan, Goto and Kobayashi 13 , Reference Odegaard, Koh and Yuan 24 ) reported the RR for green tea and black tea consumption; thus, six sets of data for green tea consumption and four sets of data for black tea consumption were used. For the highest v. lowest categories of green tea and black tea consumption, the pooled RR of all cancer mortality were 1·06 (95 % CI 0·98, 1·15; I 2=0·0 %, P=0·827) and 0·79 (95 % CI 0·65, 0·97; I 2=14·3 %, P=0·321), respectively (Fig. 2).

Fig. 2. Relative risk (RR) of all cancer mortality for highest v. lowest category of (a) green tea consumption and (b) black tea consumption. Random-effects model was used to obtain the overall RR. The grey square stands for study-specific RR with the square size reflecting the corresponding weight and horizontal bars reflecting 95 % CI.

In the dose–response analysis for the association between tea consumption and all cancer mortality, one article( Reference Khan, Goto and Kobayashi 13 ) was excluded because it did not report the detailed dose for each category of tea consumption. The pooled RR for one cup per d increment of green tea and black tea consumption were 1·01 (95 % CI 0·99, 1·02) and 0·98 (95 % 0·86, 1·10), respectively (online Supplementary Fig. S1). No significant dose–response association was observed for either green tea or black tea consumption with all cancer mortality.

Tea consumption and CVD mortality

Among the ten studies investigating associations between tea consumption and CVD mortality, two studies( Reference Mineharu, Koizumi and Wada 21 , Reference Odegaard, Koh and Yuan 24 ) reported the RR for green tea and black tea consumption; thus, five sets of data for green tea consumption and seven sets of data for black tea consumption were used. For the highest v. lowest categories of green tea and black tea consumption, the pooled RR of CVD mortality were 0·67 (95 % CI 0·46, 0·97; I 2=85·3 %, P<0·001) and 0·88 (95 % CI 0·77, 1·01; I 2=43·6, P=0·101), respectively (Fig. 3).

Fig. 3. Relative risk (RR) of CVD mortality for highest v. lowest category of (a) green tea consumption and (b) black tea consumption. Random-effects model was used to obtain the overall RR. The grey square stands for study-specific RR with the square size reflecting the corresponding weight and horizontal bars reflecting 95 % CI.

The dose–response analysis indicated that one cup per d increment of green tea consumption was associated with 5 % lower risk of CVD mortality (RR=0·95; 95 % CI 0·90, 0·99), and one cup per d increment of black tea consumption was associated with 8 % lower risk of CVD mortality (RR=0·92; 95 % CI 0·85, 0·99) (online Supplementary Fig. S2).

Tea consumption and all-cause mortality

Among the fifteen studies investigating associations between tea consumption and all-cause mortality, two studies( Reference Kuriyama, Shimazu and Ohmori 14 , Reference Odegaard, Koh and Yuan 24 ) reported the RR for green tea and black tea consumption; thus, five sets of data for green tea consumption and twelve sets of data for black tea consumption were used separately. For the highest v. lowest categories of green tea and black tea consumption, the pooled RR of all-cause mortality were 0·80 (95 % CI 0·68, 0·93; I 2=88·7 %, P<0·001) and 0·90 (95 % CI 0·83, 0·98; I 2=63·7 %, P=0·001), respectively (Fig. 4).

Fig. 4. Relative risk (RR) of all-cause mortality for highest v. lowest category of (a) green tea consumption and (b) black tea consumption. Random-effects model was used to obtain the overall relative risk. The grey square stands for study-specific relative risk with the square size reflecting the corresponding weight and horizontal bars reflecting 95 % CI.

The dose–response analysis indicated that one cup per d increment of green tea consumption was associated with 4 % lower risk of all-cause mortality (RR=0·96; 95 % CI 0·94, 0·98), and one cup per d increment of black tea consumption was associated with 3 % lower risk of all-cause mortality (RR=0·97; 95 % CI 0·94, 0·99) (online Supplementary Fig. S3).

Non-linear associations

No significant non-linear associations were observed for tea consumption with mortality of all cancers and CVD (online Supplementary Fig. S4). However, green tea and black tea consumption both demonstrated a significant non-linear association with all-cause mortality (P=0·009 and P<0·001, respectively) (Fig. 5). The slope of the relationship between black tea consumption and all-cause mortality was roughly U-shaped.

Fig. 5. Dose–response analysis for non-linear associations between tea consumption and all-cause mortality: (a) green tea consumption; (b) black tea consumption.

Assessment of publication bias

Begg’s funnel plot with 95 % CI limits was presented for visual inspection (online Supplementary Fig. S5). Publication bias was found only in the meta-analysis of associations between green tea consumption and all-cause mortality; however, after the trim and fill method was adopted, the pooled RR and corresponding 95 % CI remained stable.

Sub-group analysis

Table 1 represents the detailed results of the sub-group analyses.

Table 1 Sub-group analyses of green tea and black tea consumption with mortality of all cancers, CVD and all causes (highest v. lowest category)Footnote *(Number of cohorts, relative risk and 95 % confidence intervals)

* A random-effects model was used to obtain the overall relative risk of each sub-group.

For all cancer mortality, sub-group analyses did not show any substantial change in the summary RR for green tea consumption. Black tea consumption, however, was inversely associated with all cancer mortality only in studies with covariate adjustment for smoking. In addition, the inverse association between black tea consumption and all cancer mortality was only found in studies with a higher quality (≥7).

For CVD mortality, the sub-group analyses indicated that for green tea consumption the inverse association was observed only in studies with adjustment for smoking, and the inverse association was more evident in women compared with men. For the association between black tea consumption and CVD mortality, the sub-group analysis indicated that the inverse association was observed only in studies conducted in Asian countries.

The inverse association between green tea consumption and all-cause mortality was observed only in studies with adjustment for smoking. Black tea consumption was inversely associated with all-cause mortality only in studies conducted in Western countries.

Discussion

To the best of our knowledge, the present meta-analysis was the first quantitative systematic analysis that investigated the relationship between tea (black and green) consumption and mortality of all cancers, CVD and all causes. Green tea consumption was inversely associated with mortality of CVD and all causes, whereas black tea consumption was inversely associated with mortality of all cancers and all causes.

Tea consumption and all cancer mortality

Polyphenols are believed to be the main functional components in tea. Catechins including epigallocatechin-3-gallate (EGCG), epicatechin-3-gallate, epigallocatechin and epicatechin are the most abundant polyphenolic components of green tea( Reference Graham 34 ). Catechins in black tea are not as abundant as in green tea, but black tea contains more dimeric flavanols and polymeric polyphenols known as theaflavins (TF) and thearubigins (TR)( Reference Halder, Pramanick and Mukhopadhyay 35 ). According to previous studies, catechins, especially EGCG, can inhibit DNA damage and tumour promotion through their antioxidant activity in in vitro cell cultures( Reference Anderson, Fisher and Hara 36 ). Animal studies have also confirmed similar results( Reference Lu, Liao and Yang 37 , Reference Srivastava, Singh and Roy 38 ). Black tea and black tea constituents, although less well studied, have also been proven to have inhibitory effects against cancer( Reference Yang, Liu and Seril 39 – Reference Patel and Maru 41 ).

However, the present study suggested that black tea consumption was inversely associated with all cancer mortality, whereas green tea consumption was not. The different effects of green tea and black tea consumption on all cancer mortality may be attributed to other confounding factors such as area and dietary habits, rather than the different components in tea. In this meta-analysis, for green tea consumption with all cancer mortality, all the studies were conducted in Asia, especially in Japan, and studies for black tea consumption with all cancer mortality were conducted in both Western countries and Asian countries. The sub-group analysis indicated that in Asia green tea and black tea consumption both had no association with all cancer mortality. One possible explanation for this phenomenon could be attributed to the dietary habits in Asian countries. Several studies have confirmed that drinking hot tea may increase the risk or mortality of cancer( Reference Kinjo, Cui and Akiba 42 – Reference Tang, Xu and Zhang 44 ), and in Asian countries, especially in China, mortality due to oesophageal cancer were far higher compared with other countries, and drinking hot tea was believed to be one of the risk factors( Reference Yuwei 45 ). To some extent, drinking hot tea may balance out the benefits of the functional components in tea. Moreover, in these areas, people tend to drink high concentrations of green tea and they are often heavy smokers or alcohol drinkers. The smoking and drinking habit may offset the protective effect of drinking tea on cancer( Reference Mao, Jia and Zhou 43 ). The sub-group analysis also proved the discrepancy between studies with and without covariate adjustment for smoking.

The number of studies regarding the association between black tea consumption and all cancer mortality was limited; therefore, more prospective studies are warranted, especially studies of black tea consumption in Asian countries and of green tea consumption in Western countries.

Tea consumption and CVD mortality

As described above, the protective effects of tea against CVD could be attributed to antioxidant components such as catechins. Evidence has shown that the oxidisation of LDL can cause atherosclerosis, which could eventually increase the risk or mortality of CVD. Tea and its antioxidant compounds could effectively reduce the oxidisation of LDL( Reference Tardy, Benghuzzi and Tucci 46 ); therefore, it is reasonable to conclude that tea consumption, especially green tea consumption, could decrease the risk of CVD.

However, in this meta-analysis, we found that unlike green tea black tea consumption had no significant association with CVD mortality. One possible explanation was that, as described previously, black tea contains less catechins than green tea. The main components of black tea are TF and TR; thus, the antioxidant activity of black tea is not as significant as that of green tea( Reference Pękal, Dróżdż and Biesaga 47 ), which could explain the different protective effects of green tea and black tea consumption against CVD. In addition, studies on black tea consumption and CVD mortality were mainly conducted in Western countries, and studies on green tea consumption and CVD mortality were all conducted in Asian countries; therefore, race, genetic factors and lifestyle could be potential factors that contributed to the different results

The sub-group analysis indicated that the inverse association of tea consumption with CVD mortality was more evident in women than in men. One single study( Reference Nakamura, Nagata and Wada 48 ) also found the same phenomenon; they postulated that men tend to smoke more compared with women, and thus it might mask the beneficial association of green tea consumption. Cheng( Reference Cheng 49 ) summarised that the functional components of green tea that have cardioprotective actions were not only flavonoids but also oestrogens and phyto-oestrogens. Oestrogen-related mechanisms could be another explanation for the stronger inverse association between tea drinking and cardiovascular mortality in women compared with men.

Heterogeneity substantially reduced among studies with longer follow-up duration (≥10 years); thus, years of follow-up could be one factor that could cause heterogeneity between studies. Furthermore, the number of studies regarding the association between tea consumption and CVD mortality was limited; therefore, more studies are warranted for further analysis.

Tea consumption and all-cause mortality

For all-cause mortality, high degree and moderate degree of heterogeneity were observed between studies for green tea and black tea consumption, respectively. For green tea consumption, sensitivity analysis indicated that the heterogeneity vanished among studies with a high quality (≥7). For black tea consumption, heterogeneity substantially reduced in sub-groups for men or women, but still remained moderate in sub-groups for both sexes. Therefore, study quality and sex could be two confounding factors leading to heterogeneity between studies. However, sources of heterogeneity between these studies were still not clear and warrant further investigation.

The dose–response analysis for non-linear association suggested that the maximum reduction in all-cause mortality was observed at two to three cups of tea per d, whereas under a high degree of tea consumption (more than five cups per d), the reason why associations became null or positive is still not very clear. Based on the current evidence, we can still conclude that two cups of tea, whether green or black tea, have a beneficial effect on health.

Strengths and limitations

The present meta-analysis has several strengths. First, the large sample size makes it reliable to assess the association between tea consumption and mortality of all cancers, CVD and all causes, and the results of the present study appear to be more powerful than any individual study. Second, the prospective nature of the included studies avoided the influence of recall and selection bias. Third, we systematically reviewed and assessed the summarised association between mortality due to different causes and different types of tea, including green tea and black tea. These data provide the most comprehensive view of the association between tea consumption and mortality of all cancers, CVD and all causes, based on the current evidence.

This meta-analysis also has several limitations. First, available data from studies for black tea consumption in Asian countries and studies for green tea consumption conducted in Western countries are rather limited. Therefore, more prospective studies are needed for further detailed analysis. Second, we did not differentiate between the different types of CVD and cancer, because the number of included cohorts was limited. Third, the observational nature of the included studies makes it subject to the influence of residual confounders. In addition, all the studies included in this meta-analysis were in English, thus possible language bias could occur.

Conclusions

The present systematic review and meta-analysis indicated that green tea consumption was inversely associated with CVD and all-cause mortality, but not associated with all cancer mortality. On the other hand, black tea consumption was found to be inversely associated with all cancer and all-cause mortality, but not associated with CVD mortality. The inverse association between green tea consumption and CVD mortality was more evident in women than in men; however, the reason is unknown and requires further research. Finally, more studies on different types of tea consumption within Asian and Western countries are warranted.

Acknowledgements

We thank Dr Andrew J. Sinclair at the School of Medicine, Deakin University, Victoria, Australia for helping to revise this manuscript.

This study was funded by National Natural Science Foundation of China (NSFC No. 81273054); by the PhD Programs Foundation of Ministry of Education of China (20120101110107); and by the National Basic Research Program of China (973 Program: 2011CB504002). The funder had no role in the study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish or preparation of the manuscript.

J. T. and J. Z. were responsible for the study concept and design; J. T. and J. Z. acquired the data; J. T., J. Z., L. F., Y. J. and W. C. analysed and interpreted the data; all the authors contributed to the manuscript drafting. J. T., J. Z. and D. L. were responsible for the critical revision of the manuscript for important intellectual content; J. T., J. Z. and W. C. carried out the statistical analysis; and D. L. obtained the funding and was responsible for the study supervision.

There are no conflicts of interest.

Supplementary Material

To view supplementary material for this article, please visit http://dx.doi.org/10.1017/S0007114515002329

Footnotes

†

These authors contributed equally to the present work.

References

1. World Health Organization (2014) Global Status Report on Noncommunicable Diseases 2014. Geneva: WHO.Google Scholar
2. Chen, D, Milacic, V, Chen, MS, et al. (2008) Tea polyphenols, their biological effects and potential molecular targets. Histol Histopathol 23, 487–496.Google Scholar
3. Tangney, CC & Rasmussen, HE (2013) Polyphenols, inflammation, and cardiovascular disease. Curr Atheroscler Rep 15, 324.Google Scholar
4. Shirakami, Y, Shimizu, M & Moriwaki, H (2012) Cancer chemoprevention with green tea catechins: from bench to bed. Curr Drug Targets 13, 1842–1857.Google Scholar
5. Brown, MS & Goldstein, JL (1998) Sterol regulatory element binding proteins (SREBPs): controllers of lipid synthesis and cellular uptake. Nutr Rev 56, S54–S75.Google ScholarPubMed
6. Kuhn, DJ, Burns, AC, Kazi, A, et al. (2004) Direct inhibition of the ubiquitin-proteasome pathway by ester bond-containing green tea polyphenols is associated with increased expression of sterol regulatory element-binding protein 2 and LDL receptor. Biochim Biophys Acta 1682, 1–10.Google Scholar
7. Vinson, J, Teufel, K & Wu, N (2004) Green and black teas inhibit atherosclerosis by lipid, antioxidant, and fibrinolytic mechanisms. J Agric Food Chem 52, 3661–3665.Google Scholar
8. Klatsky, AL, Armstrong, MA & Friedman, GD (1993) Coffee, tea, and mortality. Ann Epidemiol 3, 375–381.Google Scholar
9. Hertog, MG, Sweetnam, PM, Fehily, AM, et al. (1997) Antioxidant flavonols and ischemic heart disease in a Welsh population of men: the Caerphilly Study. Am J Clin Nutr 65, 1489–1494.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
10. Nakachi, K, Matsuyama, S, Miyake, S, et al. (2000) Preventive effects of drinking green tea on cancer and cardiovascular disease: epidemiological evidence for multiple targeting prevention. Biofactors 13, 49–54.Google Scholar
11. Iwai, N, Ohshiro, H, Kurozawa, Y, et al. (2002) Relationship between coffee and green tea consumption and all-cause mortality in a cohort of a rural Japanese population. J Epidemiol 12, 191–198.Google Scholar
12. Mukamal, KJ, Maclure, M, Muller, JE, et al. (2002) Tea consumption and mortality after acute myocardial infarction. Circulation 105, 2476–2481.Google Scholar
13. Khan, MM, Goto, R, Kobayashi, K, et al. (2004) Dietary habits and cancer mortality among middle aged and older Japanese living in Hokkaido, Japan by cancer site and sex. Asian Pac J Cancer Prev 5, 58–65.Google Scholar
14. Kuriyama, S, Shimazu, T, Ohmori, K, et al. (2006) Green tea consumption and mortality due to cardiovascular disease, cancer, and all causes in Japan: the Ohsaki study. J Am Med Assoc 296, 1255–1265.Google Scholar
15. Bidel, S, Hu, G, Qiao, Q, et al. (2006) Coffee consumption and risk of total and cardiovascular mortality among patients with type 2 diabetes. Diabetologia 49, 2618–2626.Google Scholar
16. Andersen, LF, Jacobs, DR Jr, Carlsen, MH, et al. (2006) Consumption of coffee is associated with reduced risk of death attributed to inflammatory and cardiovascular diseases in the Iowa Women’s Health Study. Am J Clin Nutr 83, 1039–1046.Google Scholar
17. Paganini-Hill, A, Kawas, CH & Corrada, MM (2007) Non-alcoholic beverage and caffeine consumption and mortality: the Leisure World Cohort Study. Prev Med 44, 305–310.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
18. Suzuki, E, Yorifuji, T, Takao, S, et al. (2009) Green tea consumption and mortality among Japanese elderly people: the prospective Shizuoka elderly cohort. Ann Epidemiol 19, 732–739.Google Scholar
19. Zhang, WL, Lopez-Garcia, E, Li, TY, et al. (2009) Coffee consumption and risk of cardiovascular events and all-cause mortality among women with type 2 diabetes. Diabetologia 52, 810–817.Google Scholar
20. de Koning Gans, JM, Uiterwaal, CS, van der Schouw, YT, et al. (2010) Tea and coffee consumption and cardiovascular morbidity and mortality. Arterioscler Thromb Vasc Biol 30, 1665–1671.Google Scholar
21. Mineharu, Y, Koizumi, A, Wada, Y, et al. (2011) Coffee, green tea, black tea and oolong tea consumption and risk of mortality from cardiovascular disease in Japanese men and women. J Epidemiol Community Health 65, 230–240.Google Scholar
22. Harris, HR, Bergkvist, L & Wolk, A (2012) Coffee and black tea consumption and breast cancer mortality in a cohort of Swedish women. Br J Cancer 107, 874–878.Google Scholar
23. Gardener, H, Rundek, T, Wright, CB, et al. (2013) Coffee and tea consumption are inversely associated with mortality in a multiethnic urban population. J Nutr 143, 1299–1308.Google Scholar
24. Odegaard, AO, Koh, WP, Yuan, JM, et al. (2015) Beverage habits and mortality in Chinese adults. J Nutr 145, 595–604.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
25. Saito, E, Inoue, M, Sawada, N, et al. (2015) Association of green tea consumption with mortality due to all causes and major causes of death in a Japanese population: the Japan Public Health Center-based Prospective Study (JPHC Study). Ann Epidemiol 25, 512–518.Google Scholar
26. Stroup, DF, Berlin, JA, Morton, SC, et al. (2000) Meta-analysis of observational studies in epidemiology: a proposal for reporting. Meta-analysis Of Observational Studies in Epidemiology (MOOSE) Group. J Am Med Assoc 283, 2008–2012.Google Scholar
27. Wells, GA, Wells, B, O’Connell, D, et al. (2011) Newcastle-Ottawa Scale (NOS) for assessing the quality of nonrandomised studies in meta-analyses. http://www.ohri.ca/programs/clinical_epidemiology/oxford.htm (accessed September 2014).Google Scholar
28. Greenland, S & Longnecker, MP (1992) Methods for trend estimation from summarized dose-response data, with application to meta-analysis. Am J Epidemiol 135, 1301–1309.Google Scholar
29. Orsini, N, Bellocco, R & Greenland, S (2006) Generalized least squares for trend estimation of summarized dose-response data. Stata J 6, 40–57.Google Scholar
30. Mukhtar, H & Ahmad, N (2000) Tea polyphenols: prevention of cancer and optimizing health. Am J Clin Nutr 71, 1698S–1702S.Google Scholar
31. Harrell, FE (2001) Regression Modeling Strategies: With Applications to Linear Models, Logistic Regression, and Survival Analysis. New York, NY: Springer.Google Scholar
32. Orsini, N, Li, R, Wolk, A, et al. (2012) Meta-analysis for linear and nonlinear dose–response relations: examples, an evaluation of approximations, and software. Am J Epidemiol 175, 66–73.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
33. Jackson, D, White, IR & Thompson, SG (2010) Extending DerSimonian and Laird’s methodology to perform multivariate random effects meta-analyses. Stat Med 29, 1282–1297.Google Scholar
34. Graham, HN (1992) Green tea composition, consumption, and polyphenol chemistry. Prev Med 21, 334–350.Google Scholar
35. Halder, B, Pramanick, S, Mukhopadhyay, S, et al. (2006) Anticlastogenic effects of black tea polyphenols theaflavins and thearubigins in human lymphocytes in vitro. Toxicol In Vitro 20, 608–613.Google Scholar
36. Anderson, RF, Fisher, LJ, Hara, Y, et al. (2001) Green tea catechins partially protect DNA from (-)OH radical-induced strand breaks and base damage through fast chemical repair of DNA radicals. Carcinogenesis 22, 1189–1193.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
37. Lu, G, Liao, J, Yang, G, et al. (2006) Inhibition of adenoma progression to adenocarcinoma in a 4-(methylnitrosamino)-1-(3-pyridyl)-1-butanone-induced lung tumorigenesis model in A/J mice by tea polyphenols and caffeine. Cancer Res 66, 11494–11501.Google Scholar
38. Srivastava, S, Singh, M, Roy, P, et al. (2009) Inhibitory effect of tea polyphenols on hepatic preneoplastic foci in Wistar rats. Invest New Drugs 27, 526–533.Google Scholar
39. Yang, GY, Liu, Z, Seril, DN, et al. (1997) Black tea constituents, theaflavins, inhibit 4-(methylnitrosamino)-1-(3-pyridyl)-1-butanone (NNK)-induced lung tumorigenesis in A/J mice. Carcinogenesis 18, 2361–2365.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
40. Roy, P, Nigam, N, Singh, M, et al. (2010) Tea polyphenols inhibit cyclooxygenase-2 expression and block activation of nuclear factor-kappa B and Akt in diethylnitrosoamine induced lung tumors in Swiss mice. Invest New Drugs 28, 466–471.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
41. Patel, R & Maru, G (2008) Polymeric black tea polyphenols induce phase II enzymes via Nrf2 in mouse liver and lungs. Free Radic Biol Med 44, 1897–1911.Google Scholar
42. Kinjo, Y, Cui, Y, Akiba, S, et al. (1998) Mortality risks of oesophageal cancer associated with hot tea, alcohol, tobacco and diet in Japan. J Epidemiol 8, 235–243.Google Scholar
43. Mao, XQ, Jia, XF, Zhou, G, et al. (2011) Green tea drinking habits and gastric cancer in southwest China. Asian Pac J Cancer Prev 12, 2179–2182.Google Scholar
44. Tang, L, Xu, F, Zhang, T, et al. (2013) High temperature of food and beverage intake increases the risk of oesophageal cancer in Xinjiang, China. Asian Pac J Cancer Prev 14, 5085–5088.Google Scholar
45. Yuwei, Z (2013) Epidemiology of esophageal cancer. World J Gastroenterol 19, 5598–5606.Google Scholar
46. Tardy, F, Benghuzzi, H & Tucci, M (2011) The effects of thymoquinone and green tea extract on wi-38 fibroblasts exposed to low-density lipoprotein-biomed 2011. Biomed Sci Instrum 47, 246–251.Google Scholar
47. Pękal, A, Dróżdż, P, Biesaga, M, et al. (2011) Evaluation of the antioxidant properties of fruit and flavoured black teas. Eur J Nutr 50, 681–688.Google Scholar
48. Nakamura, K, Nagata, C, Wada, K, et al. (2011) Cigarette smoking and other lifestyle factors in relation to the risk of pancreatic cancer death: a prospective cohort study in Japan. Jpn J Clin Oncol 41, 225–231.Google Scholar
49. Cheng, TO (2007) Why is green tea more cardioprotective in women than in men? Int J Cardiol 122, 244.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Figure 0

Fig. 1. Flow diagram for the selection of studies in the meta-analysis.

Figure 1

Fig. 2. Relative risk (RR) of all cancer mortality for highest v. lowest category of (a) green tea consumption and (b) black tea consumption. Random-effects model was used to obtain the overall RR. The grey square stands for study-specific RR with the square size reflecting the corresponding weight and horizontal bars reflecting 95 % CI.

Figure 2

Fig. 3. Relative risk (RR) of CVD mortality for highest v. lowest category of (a) green tea consumption and (b) black tea consumption. Random-effects model was used to obtain the overall RR. The grey square stands for study-specific RR with the square size reflecting the corresponding weight and horizontal bars reflecting 95 % CI.

Figure 3

Fig. 4. Relative risk (RR) of all-cause mortality for highest v. lowest category of (a) green tea consumption and (b) black tea consumption. Random-effects model was used to obtain the overall relative risk. The grey square stands for study-specific relative risk with the square size reflecting the corresponding weight and horizontal bars reflecting 95 % CI.

Figure 4

Fig. 5. Dose–response analysis for non-linear associations between tea consumption and all-cause mortality: (a) green tea consumption; (b) black tea consumption.

Figure 5

Table 1 Sub-group analyses of green tea and black tea consumption with mortality of all cancers, CVD and all causes (highest v. lowest category)*(Number of cohorts, relative risk and 95 % confidence intervals)

Supplementary material: File

Tang supplementary material

Tables S1-S2 and Figures S4-S5

Download Tang supplementary material(File)
File 17.7 MB