Crossref Citations
This article has been cited by the following publications. This list is generated based on data provided by Crossref.
Tighe, Paula
Duthie, Garry
Vaughan, Nicholas
Brittenden, Julie
Simpson, William G
Duthie, Susan
Mutch, William
Wahle, Klaus
Horgan, Graham
and
Thies, Frank
2010.
Effect of increased consumption of whole-grain foods on blood pressure and other cardiovascular risk markers in healthy middle-aged persons: a randomized controlled trial.
The American Journal of Clinical Nutrition,
Vol. 92,
Issue. 4,
p.
733.
Jonnalagadda, Satya S.
Harnack, Lisa
Hai Liu, Rui
McKeown, Nicola
Seal, Chris
Liu, Simin
and
Fahey, George C.
2011.
Putting the Whole Grain Puzzle Together: Health Benefits Associated with Whole Grains—Summary of American Society for Nutrition 2010 Satellite Symposium1–3.
The Journal of Nutrition,
Vol. 141,
Issue. 5,
p.
1011S.
McKeown, Nicola M.
Crowninshield, Cindy A.
and
Jacques, Paul F.
2011.
Is Insulin Sensitivity Improved by Diets Rich in Whole Grains?.
Nutrition Today,
Vol. 46,
Issue. 2,
p.
54.
Ross, Alastair B.
Bruce, Stephen J.
Blondel-Lubrano, Anny
Oguey-Araymon, Sylviane
Beaumont, Maurice
Bourgeois, Alexandre
Nielsen-Moennoz, Corine
Vigo, Mario
Fay, Laurent-Bernard
Kochhar, Sunil
Bibiloni, Rodrigo
Pittet, Anne-Cécile
Emady-Azar, Shahram
Grathwohl, Dominik
and
Rezzi, Serge
2011.
A whole-grain cereal-rich diet increases plasma betaine, and tends to decrease total and LDL-cholesterol compared with a refined-grain diet in healthy subjects.
British Journal of Nutrition,
Vol. 105,
Issue. 10,
p.
1492.
McGrath, J.
Brown, A.
and
St Clair, D.
2011.
Prevention and Schizophrenia--The Role of Dietary Factors.
Schizophrenia Bulletin,
Vol. 37,
Issue. 2,
p.
272.
Ross, Alastair B
Bourgeois, Alexandre
Macharia, Harrison Ndung’u
Kochhar, Sunil
Jebb, Susan A
Brownlee, Iain A
and
Seal, Chris J
2012.
Plasma alkylresorcinols as a biomarker of whole-grain food consumption in a large population: results from the WHOLEheart Intervention Study.
The American Journal of Clinical Nutrition,
Vol. 95,
Issue. 1,
p.
204.
McKeown, N. M.
Hruby, A.
Saltzman, E.
Choumenkovitch, S. Furlong
and
Jacques, P. F.
2012.
Weighing in on Whole Grains: A Review of Evidence Linking Whole Grains to Body Weight.
Cereal Foods World,
Vol. 57,
Issue. 1,
p.
20.
McKeown, Nicola M.
Jacques, Paul F.
Seal, Chris J.
de Vries, Jan
Jonnalagadda, Satya S.
Clemens, Roger
Webb, Densie
Murphy, Lee Anne
van Klinken, Jan-Willem
Topping, David
Murray, Robyn
Degeneffe, Dennis
and
Marquart, Leonard F.
2013.
Whole Grains and Health: from Theory to Practice—Highlights of the Grains for Health Foundation's Whole Grains Summit 2012.
The Journal of Nutrition,
Vol. 143,
Issue. 5,
p.
744S.
Hopkins, Mark
Blundell, John E
and
King, Neil A
2014.
Individual variability in compensatory eating following acute exercise in overweight and obese women.
British Journal of Sports Medicine,
Vol. 48,
Issue. 20,
p.
1472.
Martínez-González, Miguel A
Sánchez-Tainta, Ana
Corella, Dolores
Salas-Salvadó, Jordi
Ros, Emilio
Arós, Fernando
Gómez-Gracia, Enrique
Fiol, Miquel
Lamuela-Raventós, Rosa M
Schröder, Helmut
Lapetra, Jose
Serra-Majem, Lluis
Pinto, Xavier
and
Ruiz-Gutierrez, Valentina
2014.
A provegetarian food pattern and reduction in total mortality in the Prevención con Dieta Mediterránea (PREDIMED) study.
The American Journal of Clinical Nutrition,
Vol. 100,
Issue. ,
p.
320S.
Ruxton, Carrie
and
Derbyshire, Emma
2014.
The health benefits of whole grains and fibre.
Nutrition & Food Science,
Vol. 44,
Issue. 6,
p.
492.
Pimenta, Adriano M.
Toledo, Estefanía
Rodriguez-Diez, Maria C.
Gea, Alfredo
Lopez-Iracheta, Roberto
Shivappa, Nitin
Hébert, James R.
and
Martinez-Gonzalez, Miguel A.
2015.
Dietary indexes, food patterns and incidence of metabolic syndrome in a Mediterranean cohort: The SUN project.
Clinical Nutrition,
Vol. 34,
Issue. 3,
p.
508.
Hollænder, Pernille LB
Ross, Alastair B
and
Kristensen, Mette
2015.
Whole-grain and blood lipid changes in apparently healthy adults: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled studies.
The American Journal of Clinical Nutrition,
Vol. 102,
Issue. 3,
p.
556.
Ross, Alastair B
Kristensen, Mette
Seal, Chris J
Jacques, Paul
and
McKeown, Nicola M
2015.
Recommendations for reporting whole-grain intake in observational and intervention studies.
The American Journal of Clinical Nutrition,
Vol. 101,
Issue. 5,
p.
903.
Ruxton, C. H. S.
and
Derbyshire, E. J.
2015.
The health benefits of whole grains and fibre: A review of published evidence (2007–2012).
Proceedings of the Nutrition Society,
Vol. 74,
Issue. OCE1,
Gómez-Donoso, Clara
Martínez-González, Miguel Ángel
Martínez, J. Alfredo
Gea, Alfredo
Sanz-Serrano, Julen
Perez-Cueto, Federico J. A.
and
Bes-Rastrollo, Maira
2019.
A Provegetarian Food Pattern Emphasizing Preference for Healthy Plant-Derived Foods Reduces the Risk of Overweight/Obesity in the SUN Cohort.
Nutrients,
Vol. 11,
Issue. 7,
p.
1553.
There is widespread acceptance that consuming whole grains is good for overall health(1). Evidence from epidemiological cohort studies suggests that greater whole-grain consumption is inversely related to total mortality, CVD and other diseases(Reference Jacobs and Gallaher2). Several observational studies also find that whole-grain consumption is inversely related to CVD risk factors, including excess body weight, abdominal obesity, hypercholesterolaemia and insulin resistance(Reference McKeown, Yoshida and Shea3, Reference Lutsey, Jacobs and Kori4). Some whole-grain supplement or feeding studies, which have varied in duration from weeks to months, support a beneficial effect of whole-grain consumption(Reference Pereira, Jacobs and Pins5–Reference Katcher, Legro and Kunselman8), while others do not(Reference Andersson, Tengblad and Karlstrom9, Reference Jenkins, Kendall and Augustin10).
In this issue of the British Journal of Nutrition, Brownlee et al. (Reference Brownlee, Moore and Chatfield11) present data from a large-scale intervention study that examined the effect of supplemental wholegrain foods on CVD risk factors in 316 overweight adults. Across the 16-week intervention, no significant improvements were observed in blood lipids, insulin sensitivity, inflammatory status, coagulation status, endothelial function, or blood pressure. Despite the many strengths of this study – the large sample size, the intervention length, and the intervention itself, which involved increasing whole-grain intake in non-consumers to approximately four to eight servings/d – the authors nevertheless observed no significant improvements in risk factors. With all these strengths, why were no changes observed in CVD risk factors?
First, concerning compliance with the intended study protocol, it appears that participants included wholegrain foods as additions, rather than substitutions, to their regular diets. Such a problem is not unique to this type of study; others have observed compliance difficulties in dietary regimens in free-living conditions. For instance, in a study designed to test whether consuming wholegrain foods in a hypoenergetic diet enhanced weight loss and improved CVD risk factors(Reference Katcher, Legro and Kunselman8), the initial nine study participants averaged only a 7 kcal (about 29 kJ) deficit from baseline, leading to 1·0 kg weight loss. When investigators emphasised to the subsequent fifteen participants to avoid refined grains and include only whole grains, participants averaged a 430 kcal (about 1800 kJ) deficit from baseline and a 5·3 kg weight loss. Thus, adding wholegrain foods while failing to compensate by omitting other foods may have affected the findings in Brownlee et al. (Reference Brownlee, Moore and Chatfield11).
Second, the 60 g and 120 g whole-grain intervention groups did not gain weight, despite increased reported average daily energy intake of approximately 900 and 650 kJ/d, respectively, relative to the control group. Assuming 32 238 kJ intake per kg body-fat gain, body-weight increases of 2–3 kg over 16 weeks were expected, yet no differences in body weight were observed(Reference Brownlee, Moore and Chatfield11). While unreliable energy intake estimates from self-report FFQ could be an issue, it is possible that decreases in several risk factors related to whole-grain intake would have been observed if the interventions had been isoenergetic.
Third, this study was specifically designed to test the impact of increasing whole-grain intake in overweight or obese (mean BMI 30 kg/m2) individuals who habitually consume refined grains, but who are otherwise relatively healthy (i.e. participants had no previous diagnosis of CVD or diabetes, and were not taking lipid-lowering medication). The question then becomes whether improvements in risk factors would have been observed if the participants had more pronounced metabolic abnormalities, such as hyperinsulinaemia or dyslipidaemia. Many metabolic risk factors improved in a large sample of older individuals with diabetes or CVD after supplementation of a Mediterranean diet with extra-virgin olive oil or tree nuts (walnuts, hazelnuts and almonds)(Reference Estruch, Martínez-González and Corella12–Reference Salas-Salvadó, Fernández-Ballart and Ros14); like whole grains, these foods are phytochemical-rich. Similarly, isoenergetic replacement of refined rice with whole grains and other plant products in powdered form improved risk factors in Koreans with CHD(Reference Jang, Lee and Kim6). These studies suggest that risk profiles of ‘at-risk’ individuals can be ameliorated through intake of phytochemical-rich foods or diets. It is possible that more pronounced effects of increasing whole grains would be observed in individuals with more severe metabolic challenges.
The epidemiological observational studies of whole-grain intake are numerous(Reference Jacobs and Gallaher2), consistent and impressive: whole grains appear to benefit health. Yet it is impossible to declare unequivocally that the observed benefits of whole grains are due to the whole grains per se, and not due to ‘the company they keep’. For example, individuals who eat more wholegrain foods tend to live healthier lifestyles and choose healthier foods(Reference McKeown, Yoshida and Shea3, Reference Lutsey, Jacobs and Kori4). As such, characteristics such as physical activity, smoking, socio-economic status and other dietary components are typically accounted for in observational studies, but residual confounding is nevertheless possible(Reference Kelly, Summerbell and Brynes15–Reference Priebe, van Binsbergen and de Vos17). However, observational studies of dietary patterns and clinical outcomes(Reference Hu, Rimm and Stampfer18–Reference Lockheart, Steffen and Rebnord22) may have less potential for residual confounding because dietary patterns include a wide variety of dietary behaviours. It follows that dietary or lifestyle confounding that might exist in nutrient- or food-specific studies, such as those investigating whole grains, may be minimised in studies of dietary patterns. In these types of studies, we consistently observe that certain patterns (typically called Mediterranean or ‘prudent’, and typically heavily weighting whole grains) are linked with fewer clinical events, while alternative, less healthy patterns (typically called Western) are linked with more clinical events. Mediterranean or prudent dietary patterns seem to emphasise quantity, abundance, and variety of biologically active phytochemicals, while the Western pattern seems to be oriented towards high animal food intake. These studies of dietary pattern are very attractive in terms of translating dietary recommendations because they capture the way food is eaten – in great variety, several times a day, throughout the lifetime. Furthermore, individual components in foods and individual foods in dietary patterns are likely to act synergistically(Reference Jacobs, Gross and Tapsell23). This synergy would seem to be especially pertinent for wholegrain foods, which contain a wide variety of biologically active constituents that are intentionally discarded in the refining process.
Randomised controlled trials (RCT) of foods or nutrients are considered insufficient to answer all the questions that need to be answered. RCT work well embedding a drug in a pill that can be mirrored in a placebo, with replication in different populations over long time frames. On the other hand, testing foods in RCT is much more difficult for several reasons: (i) ‘no exposure’ is typically not a possibility – everyone is exposed to some extent; (ii) the study requires a high degree of compliance, a large sample size and a long duration; and (iii) disease events, as outcomes, are rarely possible. Diet is not the same as treatment with isolated compounds found in diet(24, Reference Ebbing, Bønaa and Nygård25). While it would be imprudent not to consider results of RCT of foods and nutrients as we try to further understand their effects on intermediate risk factors, disease and health, it is important that we carefully interpret and recognise the power of observational cohort studies.
Do these new findings(Reference Brownlee, Moore and Chatfield11) ‘put a halt to our gallop’? Should we question the established belief of many nutrition and scientific experts that increasing whole-grain intake to three or more servings/d has a substantial and positive impact on health? Brownlee et al. (Reference Brownlee, Moore and Chatfield11) are reluctant to draw this conclusion. They suggest instead a note of caution concerning specific health claims. Nevertheless, we agree with them that their finding ‘does not undermine more general efforts to promote whole grains as part of a healthy diet for the general population across the life course, based on data from observational studies’. The concept of phytochemical-rich dietary patterns, in which whole grains are a natural fit, is an attractive paradigm on which to base dietary recommendations for the public. For now, let's hedge our bets with variety and abundance in whole grains as well as in other phytochemical-rich plant foods.
Conflicts of interest
N. M. M. holds research funding from the General Mills Bell Institute of Health. D. R. J. is an unpaid member of the Scientific Advisory Board of the California Walnut Commission.