The metabolic syndrome (MetS) is a highly prevalent condition where multiple cardiovascular risk factors aggregate, which is associated with increases in cardiovascular morbidity and mortality( Reference Mottillo, Filion and Genest 1 ). Studies in animal models can be relevant as they mimic the aspects of the human disease regarding the development and maintenance of the characteristics of the MetS, particularly obesity, type 2 diabetes, dyslipidaemia and hypertension. Experimental models of the MetS may be genetic, chemically induced or diet induced( Reference Lehnen, Rodrigues and Irigoyen 2 ). The neonate spontaneously hypertensive rat (SHR) subcutaneously administered monosodium glutamate is an animal model that presents a phenotype similar to that of the MetS that occurs in humans, making it useful for its study, as has been recently shown in our laboratory. SHR present several characteristics (obesity, hyperglycaemia, insulin resistance, hypertriacylglycerolaemia, reduced HDL-cholesterol levels and hypertension) of the MetS. Furthermore, reduced GLUT4 content in insulin-sensitive tissues and increased plasma concentration of inflammatory markers have been reported( Reference Leguisamo, Lehnen and Machado 3 ).
Due to the lack of a single drug for the treatment of the MetS, there is growing interest in the study of alternative substances, such as nutraceuticals. Green tea( Reference Richard, Kefi and Barbe 4 ) and curcumin( Reference Weisberg, Leibel and Tortoriello 5 ) are among some of the phytochemicals introduced in the diet as interventions that had been tested and had shown some benefits in the MetS. Capsaicin (8-methyl-N-vanillyl-6-nonenamide) is one of the most abundant capsaicinoid types present in red pepper fruit from the genus Capsicum, which belongs to the family Solanaceae( Reference Reyes-Escogido Mde, Gonzalez-Mondragon and Vazquez-Tzompantzi 6 ). Capsaicin is also responsible for the pungency of hot red pepper and other Capsicum plants and has shown multiple health-related benefits (protection against LDL oxidation by lowering oxidative stress and increases in diet-induced thermogenesis and lipid oxidation) in both animal studies and human trials( Reference Kempaiah, Manjunatha and Srinivasan 7 , Reference Yoshioka, St-Pierre and Suzuki 8 ). These benefits could account for its anti-inflammatory properties( Reference Kang, Kim and Han 9 ) and effects on diet-induced thermogenesis( Reference Yoshioka, St-Pierre and Suzuki 8 ) and lipid profile( Reference Ma, Zhong and Zhao 10 ). The daily intake of capsaicinoids has been estimated as 25–200 mg/person per d( 11 ). However, the acute and chronic effects of capsaicin on glycaemia and insulin resistance, main characteristics of the MetS, have not been studied yet. Blood pressure reduction has been reported to be related to its use( Reference Harada and Okajima 12 ), but some studies have observed high blood pressure effects( Reference Li and Wang 13 ). The use of capsaicin in an animal model that clusters many of the features of the MetS, as is SHR treated with monosodium glutamate, could throw light on these inconsistencies.
Considering these controversies and that most studies have evaluated the effects of capsaicin after acute administration, it is not possible to recommend the use of capsaicin. The aim of the present study was to investigate metabolic and cardiovascular changes induced by chronic oral administration of capsaicin in an animal model of the MetS.
Experimental methods
The investigation followed the ethical rules established by the Guide for the Care and Use of Laboratory Animals( 14 ) and the ARRIVE (Animal Research: Reporting In vivo Experiments) guidelines on animal research( Reference Kilkenny, Browne and Cuthill 15 ). The present study was approved by the Research Ethics Committee of our institution.
Animals
Neonate male SHR (n 55) were subjected to the subcutaneous administration of monosodium glutamate (5 mg/g per d; Sigma Chemical Company) diluted in a saline solution (0·9 % NaCl) for nine consecutive days; after 21 d, the rats were weaned and placed into plastic boxes, four rats per box. The rats were bred and kept under standard laboratory animal housing conditions at the Animal Production and Research Unit at our institution, receiving standard laboratory chow and tap water ad libitum. They were exposed to a 12 h light and 12 h dark cycle (06.00 hours/18.00 hours).
At 6 months of age, the rats were randomised into controls, which received a regular diet (C, n 18); a low-dose capsaicin group, which received a regular diet plus 0·5 mg/kg body weight (BW) of capsaicin (CAP05, n 18); and a high-dose capsaicin group, which received a regular diet plus 1 mg/kg BW of capsaicin (CAP1, n 19). The capsaicin used was synthetic N-vanillylnonanamide, with a chemical structure similar to that of pure capsaicin (Sigma Chemical Company), diluted in 10 % ethyl alcohol (20 ml of ethyl alcohol in 200 ml of water) and administered daily (2 ml/kg BW) at a concentration of 0·25 or 0·5 % for 14 d via orogastric administration. The controls received the same amount of an alcohol vehicle solution during the same period.
Metabolic evaluation
Weight and Lee's index (cube root of BW in g divided by nose-to-anus length in cm)( Reference Bernardis 16 ) were evaluated before and after the protocols.
At the end of the treatment with capsaicin or vehicle, all the rats were placed into individual metabolism cages for 24 h. An insulin tolerance test was performed the next morning using commercially available regular insulin (Biohulin; Biobrás). The rats were anaesthetised (sodium thiopental, intraperitoneally) after 3 h of food deprivation, and then insulin (0·75 U/kg; 5·4 pmol/kg) was administered into the penile vein. Later, six blood glucose measurements (Accu-Chek Advantage; Roche) were taken: at baseline and 4, 8, 12, 16 and 20 min after insulin administration. Glycaemias were then converted into the natural logarithm (Ln); the slope was calculated using linear regression (time × Ln (glucose)) and multiplied by 100 to obtain the glucose decay constant rate during the insulin tolerance test per min (%/min)( Reference Geloneze and Tambascia 17 ).
The rats were anaesthetised (90 mg/kg ketamine and 10 mg/kg xylazine, intraperitoneally) on the next day to implant a catheter filled with heparinised saline into the femoral artery for the direct measurements of arterial pressure. The end of the catheter was tunnelled subcutaneously and exteriorised at the top of the head. Cardiovascular evaluation was performed 24 h after the placement of the catheter.
Cardiovascular evaluation
The rats were conscious in their cages and allowed to move freely during the experiments. The catheter was connected to a transducer (P23Db; Gould-Statham), and arterial pressure signals were recorded for a 30 min period using a microcomputer equipped with an analogue-to-digital converter (CODAS, 2Kz; DATAQ Instruments). The recorded data were analysed on a beat-to-beat basis to quantify changes in systolic arterial pressure (SAP), diastolic arterial pressure and mean arterial pressure and heart rate.
Assessment of autonomic control – spectral analysis
The time series of pulse intervals (tachograms) and SAP (systograms) were obtained from arterial pressure records through the beat-to-beat pulse intervals and SAP values, respectively. Stationary fragments with about 300 beats, coincident in tachograms and systograms, were selected and a spectral analysis was performed using an autoregressive model. The spectral bands for rats (very low frequency (LF): 0·0–0·2 Hz; LF: 0·2–0·75 Hz; high frequency (HF): 0·75–3·0 Hz) were defined as described previously( Reference Malliani, Pagani and Lombardi 18 ). Tachogram and systogram spectra for each stationary fragment were evaluated quantitatively, obtaining the values of heart rate variability and SAP variability (SAPV). The spectral components of pulse intervals and SAP are expressed in both absolute (ms2 and mmHg2, respectively) and normalised units. These normalised units were obtained by calculating the power of LF and HF components and correlating them to the total power without the very-LF component( Reference Malliani, Pagani and Lombardi 18 , Reference Montano, Porta and Cogliati 19 ). Spectral decomposition estimates the centre frequency and power of each band associated with sympathetic/parasympathetic systems in the cardiovascular control. The ratio of LF:HF components was related to cardiac sympathovagal balance. Very-LF and LF components from SAPV were associated with renin–angiotensin and vascular sympathetic modulations, respectively. The α-index was obtained from the square root of the ratio of the R–R interval to the SAPV within the LF band, calculated only when the coherence of the LF band exceeded 0·5. This index was used to estimate the spontaneous baroreflex sensitivity( Reference Malliani, Pagani and Lombardi 18 – Reference Fazan, de Oliveira and da Silva 21 ).
The rats were again anaesthetised with the same amounts of anaesthetics mentioned above. Blood samples were drawn by cardiac puncture after 5 h of food deprivation. After centrifugation, the sera were aliquoted and frozen until assayed for glycaemia and TAG, cholesterol and HDL-cholesterol concentrations (enzymatic method; commercial kit Labtest); LDL-cholesterol concentration was calculated using the Friedewald formula( Reference Friedewald, Levy and Fredrickson 22 ).
Immunohistochemistry
Rats were killed by exsanguination; the thoracic aorta was removed, dissected and fixed in formalin and embedded in paraffin. Later, 4 μm sections were stained with haematoxylin and eosin. CD68 monoclonal antibodies were used to immunostain monocytes/macrophages (Millipore) at a dilution of 1:200. Staining was performed in the Experimental Pathology Unit, Hospital de Clínicas de Porto Alegre, following a routine protocol (deparaffinisation, rehydration, antigen retrieval, inactivation of endogenous peroxidase and blocking of non-specific reactions). The sections were incubated with primary antibodies for 12 h at 4°C, followed by application of the streptavidin–biotin–peroxidase complex (labelled streptavidin–biotin (LSAB), Dako Corporation) and staining with diaminobenzidine (DAB kit; Dako Corporation).
The thickness of the aorta was evaluated using the haematoxylin and eosin-stained sections, with a computerised image analysis (Image-Pro Express version 6.0 for Windows; Media Cybernetics, Inc.). The thickness of the intima and media of the wall assembly of the aorta was measured in pixels for each rat. The SHR (n 4) and Wistar–Kyoto (normotensive and non-obese, n 5) groups were also included for comparison with rats with the MetS (n 9).
The metabolic and haemodynamic/variability parameters and CD68 in monocytes were evaluated by blinded researchers.
Statistical analysis
All data are expressed as means with their standard errors. Statistical analysis was carried out using the Kolmogorov–Smirnov test to assess the normal distribution of variables. Data were compared using one-way ANOVA or Kruskal–Wallis test for comparisons of normal or non-normal continuous variables, respectively. Tukey's post hoc test or Dunn's method was used to detect whether differences existed. The differences between the groups were accepted to be significant at P< 0·05.
Results
Weight, Lee's index and metabolic parameters were not significantly changed by capsaicin treatment. These data are given in Table 1.
C (controls), regular diet plus 10 % ethyl alcohol given orally (2 ml/kg body weight (BW)); CAP05 (low-dose capsaicin), regular diet plus 0·5 mg/kg BW of capsaicin diluted in 10 % ethyl alcohol given orally (2 ml/kg BW); CAP1 (high-dose capsaicin), regular diet plus 1 mg/kg BW of capsaicin diluted in 10 % ethyl alcohol given orally (2 ml/kg BW); kITT, glucose decay constant rate during the insulin tolerance test.
* Numbers of rats are not the same because of dropouts.
Haemodynamic parameters and spectral analysis results are shown in Fig. 1 and Table 2. Mean arterial pressure, SAP and diastolic arterial pressure did not change by capsaicin treatment, but it led to an improvement in heart rate variability, which was higher in the group receiving the lower dose of capsaicin (CAP05; Fig. 1(d)). High-dose treatment with capsaicin (CAP1) was associated with an increase in the LF component of SAPV, indicating an increment of the vascular sympathetic drive (Fig. 1(f)); this was similar for the HF component of SAPV (synchronous with respiratory rate) (Table 2). Both groups receiving capsaicin had an increased α-index (spontaneous baroreflex sensitivity), which was more pronounced at higher doses (C: 0·69 (sem 0·12), CAP05: 1·54 (sem 0·26) and CAP1: 2·23 (sem 0·59) s/mmHg) (Fig. 1(e)).
C (controls), regular diet plus 10 % ethyl alcohol given orally (2 ml/kg body weight (BW)); CAP05 (low-dose capsaicin), regular diet plus 0·5 mg/kg BW of capsaicin diluted in 10 % ethyl alcohol given orally (2 ml/kg BW); CAP1 (high-dose capsaicin), regular diet plus 1 mg/kg BW of capsaicin diluted in 10 % ethyl alcohol given orally (2 ml/kg BW); MAP, mean arterial pressure; DAP, diastolic arterial pressure; HRV, heart rate variability; LF, low-frequency component; NU, normalised units; HF, high-frequency component; SAPV, systolic arterial pressure variability; VLF, very-low-frequency component.
* Mean value was significantly different from that of the control group (P< 0·05; one-way ANOVA and Dunn's method).
† n 16–19 for each group, except for the analysis of MAP and DAP. The numbers of rats evaluated for MAP and DAP were eighteen (C), eighteen (CAP05) and nineteen (CAP1). The spectral parameters of heart rate (tachograms) and systolic arterial pressure (systograms) were calculated from the time series using an autoregressive model.
Fig. 2 shows representative examples of the histological and immunohistochemical analyses of Wistar–Kyoto rats (Fig. 2(a) and (b)), SHR (Fig. 2(c) and (d)) and rats with the MetS (Fig. 2(e) and (f)). Fig. 2(a), (c) and (e) shows representative examples for each group of the haematoxylin and eosin-stained thoracic aorta tissue sections. Fig. 2(b), (d) and (f) shows the immunohistochemical expression of CD68 in the same tissue of representative examples from each group. The comparison between the groups indicated higher aortic wall thickness in the SHR (358·8 (sem 40·3) pixels) and rats with the MetS (401·5 (sem 29·7) pixels) v. Wistar–Kyoto rats (251·4 (sem 31·4) pixels) (P< 0·001). The number of stained cells with CD68 was not different between the groups (number of positive cells/twenty fields: SHR, 21·0 (11·5–28·2); rats with the MetS, 20·0 (8·0–30·0); Wistar–Kyoto rats, 5·0 (4·0–6·0), P= 0·188). There were no differences in aortic wall thickness (358·8 (sem 40·3), 365·1 (sem 40·0) and 374·4 (sem 40·8) pixels for the C, CAP05 and CAP1 groups, respectively, P= 0·718) and the number of stained cells with CD68 in immunohistochemical staining (number of positive cells/twenty fields: 20·0 (8·0–30·0), 17·0 (8·0–23·0) and 8·0 (4·5–25·0) for the C, CAP05 and CAP1 groups, respectively, P= 0·692) between the groups of MetS rats that received capsaicin.
Discussion
Capsaicin has potential beneficial cardiovascular( Reference Ma, Zhong and Zhao 10 , Reference Harada and Okajima 12 ) and metabolic( Reference Kempaiah, Manjunatha and Srinivasan 7 , Reference Yoshioka, St-Pierre and Suzuki 8 ) effects, which could be interesting for the management of the MetS, but the present results indicated that there was no benefit from using it for a short period of time with regard to the metabolic parameters evaluated. However, capsaicin promoted global improvement of cardiovascular autonomic control, which has a well-known role in better cardiovascular prognosis( Reference Lahiri, Kannankeril and Goldberger 23 , Reference Garruti, Giampetruzzi and Vita 24 ).
The doses of capsaicin used did not influence food/water intake and weight during the short period of the experiments, showing that in 2 weeks the rats exhibited good acceptance of the substance, which did not affect their welfare. These results are consistent with previous findings( Reference Manjunatha and Srinivasan 25 ), which showed that even when the supplement was added to the diet, its pungent flavour did not affect its palatability. However, mice fed a high-fat diet had reduced BW with no change in food intake( Reference Kang, Tsuyoshi and Han 26 ), suggesting that capsaicin can increase diet-induced thermogenesis, as has been shown with acute administration( Reference Yoshioka, St-Pierre and Suzuki 8 ).
The lipid profile also did not change by capsaicin use. Studies in dyslipidaemic( Reference Ma, Zhong and Zhao 10 ) or obese mice( Reference Kang, Tsuyoshi and Han 26 ) fed a high-fat diet supplemented with capsaicin showed reductions in serum TAG levels. However, no decrease in plasma cholesterol levels was observed( Reference Kawada, Hagihara and Iwai 27 ), as has also been shown in the present study. In longer-period treatments( Reference Kempaiah, Manjunatha and Srinivasan 7 , Reference Ma, Zhong and Zhao 10 ), capsaicin added to a hypercholesterolaemic or high-fat diet led to a reduction in serum cholesterol levels. We presume that there is thermogenic inefficiency in the animal model of the MetS, in which capsaicin does not have the same effect on the lipid profile as has been shown successfully in other studies. It is possible that in the combination of obesity( Reference Tsukahara, Uchida and Ohba 28 ) and hypertension( Reference Kirby, Sokoloff and Perdomo 29 ), an impaired metabolism occurs because of reduced amounts of brown adipose tissue, responsible for thermogenic activity. Moreover, it is known that the amounts of this specialised tissue decrease with age, and other authors( Reference Kempaiah, Manjunatha and Srinivasan 7 , Reference Manjunatha and Srinivasan 25 , Reference Kawada, Hagihara and Iwai 27 ) have used animals younger than those used in the present study. Although the amounts of brown adipose tissue in humans are low, this tissue is, in fact, very active. Defined regions of functionally active brown adipose tissue have been reported to be present in adult humans. Its amount is inversely correlated with BMI, suggesting a role of brown adipose tissue in the metabolism of adult humans( Reference Cypess, Lehman and Williams 30 , Reference Cypess and Kahn 31 ).
No changes in blood glucose levels and insulin resistance were induced by capsaicin. Other authors have shown that capsaicin increased glycaemia regardless of insulin levels, but evaluations have been performed acutely during the course of the oral glucose tolerance test in healthy subjects( Reference Dömötör, Szolcsányi and Mózsik 32 ). Similar to our findings, it has been reported that regular consumption of chilies did not change glycaemia in human subjects( Reference Ahuja, Robertson and Geraghty 33 ).
Recently, in the same animal model of the MetS, we have shown that autonomic dysfunction occurred over time, as we observed increased sympathovagal imbalance in MetS rats, as well as changes in SAPV. Autonomic dysfunction accompanied increased visceral fat and insulin resistance in these rats, providing information that cardiovascular autonomic modulation dysfunction evolves over time and is associated with higher amounts of visceral fat and insulin resistance, as observed in humans. Since cardiovascular autonomic dysfunction is associated with a high risk of incident cardiovascular events and death, these data support the use of this animal model in investigations into the pathophysiology of the MetS, especially that related to the cardiovascular system and its neural control( Reference Lehnen, Leguisamo and Casali 34 ).
An overall improvement in the autonomic control of SAP with increased heart rate variability and spontaneous baroreflex sensitivity was shown by the spectral analysis. Previous data indicated contrary results, but the animals studied were healthy and assessed after an acute oral administration of capsaicin, showing increases in heart rate and LF:HF ratio, supporting an increase in the sympathetic drive( Reference Ohnuki, Moritani and Ishihara 35 ). Other acute experiments, performed in healthy women, have shown an increased LF:HF ratio after red pepper ingestion( Reference Yoshioka, St-Pierre and Suzuki 8 ). Despite the beneficial effects of chronic treatment with capsaicin on cardiac autonomic control first shown by us, the sympathovagal balance did not change, as both groups that received capsaicin showed increased sympathetic modulation of the vascular tone, which was different only when capsaicin was administered in high doses.
Although paradoxical effects of improved autonomic modulation and increased sympathetic vascular modulation were observed, these did not influence arterial pressure and heart rate levels, results that are consistent with those reported earlier for humans who consumed red pepper for 4 weeks( Reference Ahuja, Robertson and Geraghty 36 ). However, after long periods of capsaicin treatment, decreased arterial pressure was observed in hypertensive patients( Reference Harada and Okajima 12 ). These contradictory effects have been reported, and they are supported by the ability of capsaicin to activate an ion channel, a transient potential vanilloid type 1 channel, which controls the endothelial expression of neuropeptides involved in NO release( Reference Szallasi and Blumberg 37 ). These imbalances in the expression of neuropeptides possibly explain why capsaicin through its effects on blood pressure led to vasorelaxation in some studies( Reference Yang, Luo and Ma 38 ), but to vasoconstriction in others( Reference Scotland, Chauhan and Davis 39 ).
Rats with the MetS had higher aortic wall thickness when compared with non-obese and normotensive controls, but capsaicin did not induce these structural changes or cause a reduction in inflammation. This negative result is probably related to the short period of treatment, as other authors have reported benefits in mice fed a high-fat diet with capsaicin supplementation for 10 weeks( Reference Kang, Tsuyoshi and Han 26 ). Moreover, capsaicin could be less potent in reducing inflammatory processes, as atorvastatin has previously been reported to cause reduction in macrophage infiltration in diabetic rats( Reference Linthout, Riad and Dhayat 40 ).
Capsaicinoids are powerful irritants, causing burning and pain at low concentrations on the skin and mucous membranes, and this could be a reason for the limitation of their use in daily practice. Given orally, they induce an increase in salivation and gastric secretion, a rapid change in sensation, and warm-to-intolerable burning, which is variably tolerated, depending on the individual( Reference Govindarajan and Sathyanarayana 41 ).
One important difference of the present study when compared with other studies was that capsaicin was orogastrically administered to the rats, adding strength to this part of the protocol. We were able to provide precise doses to the rats studied. We believe that in this way we excluded biases such as ad libitum intake and palatability and evaluated the effect of the 0·5 and 1·0 mg/kg BW doses for 14 d. Clearly, longer-duration studies could possibly contribute other information not provided here. Furthermore, to our knowledge, this is the first study in the literature to evaluate the effect of synthetic capsaicin in an animal model of the MetS.
We conclude that capsaicin cannot improve lipid and glucose abnormalities in an animal model of the MetS, but that this nutraceutical can exert beneficial cardiovascular effects. It is possible that the cardiovascular system is adapted to offset the acute increase in the sympathetic drive shown in other studies. This information opens an avenue to be explored, in future work, considering evaluation of the autonomic system in humans with the MetS given diets enriched with capsaicin.
Acknowledgements
The authors thank Melissa Markoski (Laboratory of Molecular and Cellular Cardiology, Instituto de Cardiologia/Fundação Universitária de Cardiologia, Brazil) for her technical assistance.
The present study was supported by Coordenação de Aperfeiçoamento de Pessoal de Nível Superior, Financiadora de Estudos e Projetos and Fundação de Amparo à Pesquisa do Estado do Rio Grande do Sul. They had no role in the design, analysis or writing of this article. B. D. S. was the recipient of a scholarship from CNPq (research productivity fellowship).
The authors' contributions are as follows: C. d. S. T., B. D. S., K. R. C. and L. M. participated in study concept and design; C. d. S. T. and B. D. S. participated in data search; C. d. S. T., K. R. C. and L. M. participated in data acquisition; C. d. S. T., B. D. S., K. R. C. and L. M. participated in data analysis and interpretation; B. D. S., K. R. C. and L. M. contributed to the statistical verification of the data; C. d. S. T., B. D. S., K. R. C. and L. M. contributed to the writing and revision of the report. All authors reviewed and approved the final version of the report.
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.