The nutrition transition describes major shifts in human diet, nutritional status and nutrition-related disease(Reference Popkin1). These shifts occur at a differential pace in different populations. Most high-income countries are experiencing both the ‘degenerative disease’ stage, characterised by overnutrition and the development of chronic diseases; and the ‘behavioural change’ stage, characterised by reduced obesity rates and healthier ageing. Most low-income countries are experiencing both the ‘receding famine’ stage, in which undernutrition decreases but persists in the maternal and child population groups, and the beginnings of the ‘degenerative disease’ stage(Reference Popkin1).
During pregnancy, women have increased nutrient requirements and an increased risk of undernutrition(Reference Abu-Saad and Fraser2). However, studies exploring the effects of the nutrition transition on pregnant women are limited. Simultaneous under- and overnutrition have been found among women in developing/low-income societies(Reference Madanat, Troutman and Al-Madi3–Reference Uauy, Kain and Corvalan5). While this has been determined primarily by anthropometric measurements, the evaluation of nutrient intake is also important, since during pregnancy adequate micronutrient intake and overall diet quality are essential for optimising the intra-uterine environment and preventing adverse outcomes(Reference Abu-Saad and Fraser2, Reference Allen6–Reference Godfrey and Barker8). Studies that accurately evaluate nutritional status and the adequacy of nutrient intakes among pregnant women are essential for the formulation of public health policy to improve maternal nutritional status during this critical life stage.
The Dietary Exposures and Pregnancy Outcomes in a Society In Transition (DEPOSIT) cohort study was designed to assess dietary intake and its association with birth outcomes among pregnant Bedouin Arab women in southern Israel. This traditionally semi-nomadic population is undergoing the nutrition transition in a context of sedentarisation and urbanisation(Reference Abu-Saad, Shai and Kaufman-Shriqui9). The effect of these changes on pregnant Bedouin women is unknown. The present article presents a cross-sectional report of the DEPOSIT participants' nutritional status and dietary intake during pregnancy.
Experimental methods
Subjects
The Bedouin Arabs in southern Israel based their livelihood on animal husbandry and agriculture before their sedentarisation and urbanisation over the past 60 years(Reference Abu-Saad, Shai and Kaufman-Shriqui9, Reference Groen, Balough and Levy10). At the time of the study, approximately half of the population lived in government-planned, urban-style towns. The other half lived in traditional villages and rural settings not connected to central infrastructures for the provision of many services (e.g. electricity, water, paved roads)(11, Reference Swirski and Hasson12). The socio-economic status (SES) of the Bedouin, as measured by education, income and dependency-ratio levels, was the lowest of any population group in Israel(13).
Sample
The DEPOSIT sample was recruited from among parous Bedouin women with singleton pregnancies attending Ministry of Health prenatal care (PNC) clinics, or the outpatient PNC clinic of the regional hospital, Soroka University Medical Center. Both services were provided for a relatively low co-payment (US$20–50 every 6 months) and were utilised by over 85 % of pregnant Bedouin women at the time of the study(Reference Weitzman, Shoham-Vardi and Elbedour14). All participants provided informed consent, and the study was approved by the Institutional Review Board (Helsinki Committee) of Soroka University Medical Center. The participants were interviewed at their PNC clinics.
Dietary assessment
We used repeat administrations (two) of a translated and modified United States Department of Agriculture (USDA) 24 hour recall (24HR) questionnaire to assess women's daily dietary intake during pregnancy(15, Reference Abu-Saad, Shahar and Abu-Shareb16). The first 24HR was administered on the date of recruitment, and the second 24HR was conducted during each participant's subsequent PNC appointment, approximately 1 month later. The 24HR method asks respondents to recall and report all foods and beverages consumed in the previous 24 h, using a standardised list of probes to improve the completeness of the recall(Reference Thompson and Subar17). The modification of the 24HR for this population has previously been described(Reference Groen, Balough and Levy10, Reference Abu-Saad, Shahar and Abu-Shareb16). Interviewers underwent extensive training in preparation for administering the 24HR in the local Arabic dialect, using locally adapted probes and a modified USDA food book and food models/portion-size booklet that included common Israeli and Bedouin foods, utensils and portion sizes. The interviewers also determined whether traditionally produced animal products (e.g. eggs, milk, yoghurt, cheese) were home-grown or store-bought. The dietary interviews were conducted over a 3-year period (2003–6) and were evenly distributed across the seasons.
Food database
Nutrient values were obtained from the database of the S. Daniel Abraham Center for Health and Nutrition, which is based on USDA Release SR19, and also includes common Israeli and Bedouin foods(Reference Abu-Saad, Shahar and Abu-Shareb16, Reference Shai, Vardi and Shahar18, Reference Abu-Saad, Shahar and Vardi19). Previous studies(Reference Abu-Saad, Shai and Kaufman-Shriqui9, Reference Groen, Balough and Levy10, Reference Abu-Saad, Shahar and Abu-Shareb16) in this population indicate that bread, which contains incomplete protein, is a major contributor to protein intake. Since lysine is the limiting amino acid in protein from wheat, we used the lysine values in the USDA database to calculate the lysine:protein ratio (mg lysine/g protein) as an indicator of protein quality(20). Refined grain products (e.g. white flour, bread, rice, pasta, cakes/cookies) are not fortified/enriched with micronutrients in Israel, and so unfortified USDA ingredients were used in all recipes. The nutrient composition of recipes was calculated using a computer program based on the concept of the American Food Information Analysis System program(21). Trained nutritional data entry coders used this system to enter data into a database. Quality control conducted by the study coordinator and a registered dietitian involved: (1) checking each questionnaire for missing data within 1–3 d of administration; (2) reviewing the data entry of each questionnaire for accuracy; (3) making cross-interview checks to detect unusual nutrient/portion size values.
Demographic, anthropometric, obstetric and socio-economic status covariates
Due to rural/urban differences in living conditions affecting the availability of perishable foods, we included residential status as a covariate in the statistical modelling of usual dietary intake (see the following text). Participants classified as urban lived in government-planned towns with access to service-provision infrastructures (e.g. mains electricity to power refrigerators); and those classified as rural lived in traditional villages/communities without such access. Participants' weight and height were measured at their PNC clinics using standardised equipment and procedures. Most participants did not have scales at home, and could not provide self-reported pre-pregnancy weight. Thus, pregnancy weight gained before PNC registration was estimated using Institute of Medicine (IOM) weight gain recommendations for a normal-weight woman per week and trimester of pregnancy (0·15 kg/week in trimester 1 and 0·42 kg/week in trimesters 2–3)(22), and subtracted from the participants' measured weight at PNC initiation. Trimester of pregnancy at the time of the 24HR interview was calculated and interviews at < 14, 14–27 and ≥ 28 weeks were coded as trimesters 1, 2 and 3, respectively. Husband's employment status (unemployed, employed) at the time of participant recruitment to the study was used as an indicator of SES.
Statistical analysis
The raw nutrient intake data of one 24HR were used to calculate mean nutrient intakes from food. Usual nutrient intakes were estimated from repeat 24HR questionnaires using the National Cancer Institute (NCI) method(Reference Tooze, Midthune and Dodd23, 24), which has the capacity to provide robust intake estimates of episodically consumed foods/nutrients. Use of this method was important because of the potential for episodic consumption of perishable foods among the Bedouin. The method is based upon a statistical model that represents usual intake as the product of the probability to consume a food/nutrient on a given day, and the usual consumption-day amount. Statistical models constructed for the probability to consume and the amount consumed describe the within-person and between-person variation, as well as any associations with covariates. These models were run using mixtran_macro_v1.1.sas and distrib_macro_v1.1.sas available on the NCI website(24). The mixtran macro fits a non-linear effects model to repeat 24HR using PROC NLMIXED. The distrib macro utilises a Monte Carlo method to estimate the distribution of usual intake from the parameter estimates produced by the mixtran macro. Usual intake estimates were obtained by using these programs on the DEPOSIT sample as a whole, and stratified by residential and SES status. The models took trimester at dietary interview (1st, 2nd, 3rd) into account, and were adjusted for repeat (1st or 2nd interview) and weekend (defined as Friday–Saturday) effects. Balanced repeated replication calculations (n 200) were used to obtain standard errors for the means of the usual intake distributions. The analysis was conducted using SAS 9.2. A level of P < 0·05 was used to indicate statistical significance.
Results
A total of 701 parous, pregnant women were recruited to the study. The refusal rate was low (n 8, 1·1 %), and due primarily to concerns about insufficient time for the interview before the PNC appointment. Of the 694 women enrolled, one woman withdrew from follow-up, and ten were excluded according to protocol for the birth outcomes study: eight due to non-singleton pregnancies, one due to miscarriage and one due to a non-nutrition-related major congenital anomaly in the index birth that affects fetal growth (Trisomy 18). The present analysis includes all remaining participants (n 683, 97·3 % of the women enrolled).
Table 1 presents selected characteristics of the study sample by residential status. The participants' mean age was 28 years. The proportion of underweight women was low, while 42 % were overweight or obese. Parity and unemployment rates were higher among rural than among urban participants, while educational levels were lower.
* P for t tests for continuous variables with normal distributions, Wilcoxon rank sum tests for continuous variables with asymmetric distributions, and χ2 or Fisher's exact tests for categorical variables.
† Estimated by calculating recommended weight gain for week of pregnancy(22), and subtracting from measured weight at first prenatal care visit.
A single 24HR was obtained for all participants, and a second 24HR was obtained for 426 (62 %) of the participants. The proportion of participants with two 24HR was higher among rural than urban women (66 v. 58 %, P = 0·019), but did not differ significantly by any other demographic or SES characteristic. Most 24HR were conducted during the 2nd trimester of pregnancy (71 %), while 7 and 22 % were conducted during the 1st and 3rd trimesters, respectively. Of the 1109 24HR, 8 % contained no protein from animal sources. Of those reporting animal-source foods, 43 % contained no Fe from haeme (meat) sources (Fig. 1).
Only 14 % of women reported consuming any home-produced animal products, and the proportion was significantly higher among rural than urban women (Table 1). Most participants (78 %) reported taking a standard Fe (100 mg)/folic acid (400 μg) supplement, which they generally initiated after registering for PNC (at a gestational age of approximately 19 weeks). Only 2·2 % reported taking any type of supplement periconceptionally.
Table 2 contains the means with their standard errors, medians and interquartile ranges and percentage below recommended levels for the intake of selected nutrients from univariate analysis on the first 24HR, and multivariate models using repeat 24HR and the NCI method to estimate usual intake (NCI-UI). The mean intake of participants with one 24HR did not differ significantly from those with two 24HR on energy (P = 0·794) or any of the other nutrients examined (data not shown). The NCI-UI mean for total protein met the Estimated Average Requirement (EAR), though less than half was from animal sources, and 76 % of the women were below the recommended amino acid requirement for lysine (51 mg/g protein). Mean NCI-UI estimates met or exceeded the EAR for carbohydrates, Mg and vitamin C, but fell below the EAR/Adequate Intake for Ca, both total and animal-source Fe and Zn, vitamin A and folate. Nutrient intakes did not differ by trimester of the 24HR.
EAR, Estimated Average Requirement; AI, Adequate Intake; NA, not applicable; RAE, retinol activity equivalent.
* Adjusted for selected dietary interview characteristics repeat effect (1st or 2nd 24HR), and weekend effect (weekday or weekend).
† No EAR/AI set for these parameters.
‡ EAR for protein calculated as 0·88 g/kg per d × mean weight of participants at interview (66·4 kg) = 58 g/d protein.
§ Half of protein EAR.
∥ Lysine score (51 mg lysine/g protein) serves as an indicator of the protein quality in diets in which wheat is a major source of protein(20).
¶ Daily Fe intake recommendation (EAR = 22 mg) is based on the assumption that 75 % (16 mg) is from haeme sources(31).
** Daily Zn intake recommendation (EAR = 9·5 mg) is based on the assumption that 75 % (7·13 mg) is from animal-food sources(31).
Bread and whole grains accounted for>33 % of the total protein intake (Fig. 2) and >40 % of the daily Fe and Zn intakes from food (Figs. 3 and 4). Only 10 % of the Fe and 30 % of the Zn intake came from haeme and animal-food sources, respectively.
Rural participants had significantly higher fibre and Mg intakes, but lower animal-source protein and haeme-Fe intakes than urban participants (Table 3). Haeme-Fe was the only nutrient to differ significantly by husband's employment status. In an NCI-UI model including both residential status and husband's employment status, the probability of consuming haeme-source Fe was higher among urban than rural participants (OR 1·68, 95 % CI 1·17, 2·41), and among those with employed v. unemployed husbands (OR 1·81, 95 % CI 1·27, 2·58; data not shown). Nevertheless, as the data in Table 3 indicate, the intake of animal-source nutrients was inadequate for most women, with 79 and 67 % of rural and urban women, respectively, obtaining less than 50 % of the protein EAR from animal-food sources, and over 90 % in both groups having an inadequate intake of haeme-source Fe.
EAR, Estimated Average Requirement; NA, not applicable; RAE, retinol activity equivalent.
* Adjusted for repeat effect (1st or 2nd 24 h recall), and weekend effect (weekday or weekend).
† P value from the amount model of the National Cancer Institute method for estimating usual intake.
‡ No EAR set for energy.
§ EAR for protein calculated as 0·88 g/kg per d × mean weight of participants at interview (66·4 kg) = 58 g/d protein.
∥ Half of protein EAR.
¶ Lysine score (51 mg lysine/g protein) serves as an indicator of the protein quality in diets in which wheat is a major source of protein(20).
** P value for probability model of the National Cancer Institute method for estimating usual intake of episodically consumed foods.
†† Daily Fe intake recommendation (EAR = 22 mg) is based on the assumption that 75 % (16 mg) is from haeme sources(31).
‡‡ Daily Zn intake recommendation (EAR = 9·5 mg) is based on the assumption that 75 % (7·1 mg) is from animal-food sources(31).
Discussion
The DEPOSIT findings suggest that this cohort of pregnant women is experiencing overlapping stages of the nutrition transition, in the wake of sedentarisation and urbanisation. Many participants had inadequate intakes of multiple nutrients, which is characteristic of the ‘receding famine’ stage(Reference Popkin1). At the same time, underweight appeared to be a minor problem, while overweight was relatively high, as is characteristic of the ‘degenerative disease’ stage.
At least 50 % of the DEPOSIT cohort had inadequate intakes of complete protein, dietary fibre, Zn and vitamin A, while over 95 % had inadequate intakes of Ca, Fe and folate. Since the statistical methods used reduced the risk of over-estimating the prevalence of inadequate intake, these results are robust. They are based on 24HR data, which are widely relied upon for reporting the average daily nutrient intakes of groups because the means provide estimates that are not greatly affected by day-to-day within-person variation in dietary intake. However, 24HR data may underestimate energy and nutrient intakes, and may provide less reliable estimates of nutrients concentrated in episodically consumed foods(Reference Thompson and Subar17). We therefore used the NCI method, which provides more accurate estimates of episodically consumed foods/nutrients than other methods of estimating usual intake(Reference Tooze, Midthune and Dodd23). For the DEPOSIT cohort, in which animal-source protein and haeme-Fe were episodically consumed, the NCI-UI estimates clearly reduced the influence of episodic zero-intake days as compared to the intake estimates from a single 24HR, reducing the likelihood of underestimating intake. Furthermore, we used the EAR to evaluate the population-level adequacy of nutrient intakes rather than using the Recommended Daily Allowance, which may overestimate the population-level prevalence of inadequate intake(Reference Murphy and Poos25).
Consideration of the food sources of key nutrients raised additional concerns about the adequacy of the DEPOSIT participants' intake. The mean daily protein intake reached the pregnancy EAR, and food groups containing complete proteins, such as poultry/eggs/fish (19 %), dairy products (12 %) and red/organ meat (7 %), were important contributors to protein intake. Nevertheless, over 50 % came from cereal/plant foods, which contain incomplete proteins that may not be of an adequate quality to meet all indispensible amino acid requirements(20). Bread, which was the main contributor to protein intake (38 %), is consumed in high amounts in this population, partly due to the practice of using bread as a utensil for eating from common plates, and partly due to the low SES level(Reference Abu-Saad, Shai and Kaufman-Shriqui9). Lysine is the limiting amino acid in wheat-source protein, which contains only 25 mg lysine/g protein; while the lysine requirement in protein of adequate quality is 51 mg lysine/g protein(20). Although the intake of complementary foods that are rich in lysine, such as legumes, was traditionally high in the Bedouin population(Reference Groen, Balough and Levy10), among the DEPOSIT participants, legumes provided only 4 % of the total protein intake. Our findings indicate that this did not compensate for the low level of lysine in the wheat-based protein staples, as the overall protein intake of 76 % of women did not meet the lysine requirement. The lysine EAR for pregnant women (41 mg/kg per d) is higher than that for other adults (31 mg/kg per d) due to the rapid growth occurring during this life stage(20). Animal and human studies have shown that inadequate lysine intake during rapid growth phases is detrimental to normal development(Reference Borum and Broquist26, Reference Hussain, Abbas and Khan27). Unfortunately, few contemporary studies of dietary intake during pregnancy distinguish between animal- and plant-source protein, or evaluate the intake of limiting amino acids, even in populations that rely heavily on cereals/wheat for their protein intake(Reference Belgnaoui and Belahsen28–Reference Khoushabi and Saraswathi30). An examination of protein sources and their limiting amino acids in the present study indicated that the intake of complete protein was suboptimal for the requirements of pregnancy.
High proportions of the participants' Fe and Zn intakes (90 and 70 %, respectively) came from bread and other plant sources. The EAR for Fe and Zn are based upon the assumption that the majority comes from haeme source/animal-source foods(31). The bioavailability of dietary Fe and Zn from wheat-based foods is inhibited by their phytate-content(Reference Brune, Rossander-Hulten and Hallberg32). Although 78 % of women reported taking Fe supplements, most initiated supplementation approximately midway through the pregnancy. There is evidence that maternal Fe deficiency anaemia before and in early pregnancy, and late initiation of Fe supplementation, increase the risk of preterm and low birth weight delivery(Reference Scholl33).
The DEPOSIT participants' nutrient intake was associated with living conditions and SES. The amount of animal-source protein and the probability of haeme-source Fe intake were significantly lower for rural than for urban women, probably due to rural living conditions that made perishable foods harder to access and preserve. The probability of haeme-Fe intake was also significantly lower among women with unemployed as compared to women with employed husbands. Poorer nutrient intake among rural v. urban and low v. high SES pregnant women is a common finding(Reference Belgnaoui and Belahsen28), though in some cases these disparities have been alleviated by food production in rural communities(Reference Hartini, Winkvist and Lindholm34). While traditionally the Bedouin produced milk and other animal products(Reference Groen, Balough and Levy10), a very low proportion of the DEPOSIT participants reported consuming home-grown animal-source foods. Reports from the Bedouin population undergoing sedentarisation and urbanisation in Jordan showed deficiencies of the micronutrients found primarily in animal products (e.g. Fe, Zn, vitamin A, Ca) among pre-school children(Reference Khatib and Elmadfa35). The authors suggested that the Bedouin's nutritional situation declined with the loss of home-produced animal products, given the persistence of poverty after sedentarisation and urbanisation. Similarly, the DEPOSIT participants' intake of animal-source/complete protein, Zn and haeme-Fe suggests that existing urbanisation amenities and employment levels fail to ensure adequate nutrient intakes for the majority ( ≥ 65 %) of pregnant women.
Despite high rates of inadequate nutrient intake, overweight/obesity emerged as a growing problem, as has been found in other low- and high-income populations(Reference Abu-Saad and Fraser2–Reference Uauy, Kain and Corvalan5, Reference Kalter-Leibovici, Atamna and Lubin36–Reference Satpathy, Fleming and Frey38). Maternal obesity during pregnancy is associated with numerous adverse outcomes, including pregnancy-induced hypertension, gestational diabetes, thromboembolism, congenital anomalies, spontaneous intra-uterine death, macrosomia and caesarean section delivery(Reference Satpathy, Fleming and Frey38). Children born to obese mothers are also at higher risk of obesity in adolescence and adulthood(Reference Satpathy, Fleming and Frey38). Since there is some evidence of a positive association between parity and obesity(Reference Davis, Stange and Horwitz39), the reproductive years may be a key period during which to intervene to reduce this phenomenon and its consequent increased risk for other chronic diseases.
Limitations
The present study has a number of limitations. The DEPOSIT sample did not include nulliparous women, among whom the prevalence of underweight and overweight may differ, especially if its development is linked to parity. Women not attending PNC clinics were also not represented in the sample. Available data indicate that approximately 15–20 % of Negev Bedouin women do not attend PNC clinics, due primarily to access, transportation and cost barriers(Reference Weitzman, Shoham-Vardi and Elbedour14, Reference Gottlieb40). These women may represent a subgroup with a lower SES and diet quality level than that found in the DEPOSIT cohort. We did not have a repeat 24HR for all participants. While it is ideal to have multiple 24HR repeats for each respondent, this is not always possible in practice. An advantage of the NCI method for estimating usual intake is that it can deal with a situation in which only one 24HR is available for a proportion of the participants, as long as there are enough participants with two or more repeats(Reference Dodd, Guenther and Freedman41). In our case, 62 % of the participants had a repeat 24HR (n 426), which is sufficient to reliably estimate usual intake distributions. Although there was a slight over-representation of rural women among those with two 24HR repeats, the within-person variance among rural and urban women was very similar, and therefore we would not expect this to bias the estimation of the usual distribution. We did not find further differences between respondents with one or two 24HR repeats in any of the variables we examined. Data from 24HR may underestimate intake. The literature reports energy intake underestimates from 24HR data ranging from 3 to 26 %(Reference Thompson and Subar17), and we reported an energy intake underestimation of 11–14 % in 24HR data collected from Bedouin women(Reference Abu-Saad, Shahar and Abu-Shareb16). Even allowing for an underestimation of this magnitude, the finding that a substantial proportion of the DEPOSIT cohort was at risk of inadequate intake of multiple nutrients persists. Measured pre-pregnancy weight was not available, but was estimated from measured weight at the first PNC visit. Our overweight/obesity prevalence estimate may be low, since we calculated pregnancy weight gain using the recommended weight gain/week for normal-weight women, which is higher than that for overweight/obese women(22). Given the substantial prevalence of overweight/obesity we observed, obtaining measured pre-pregnancy weight data in this population should be a public health priority.
While taking the study limitations into account, repeat 24HR and a robust method for estimating usual intake indicate that the diet of many parous Bedouin women who utilise PNC is inadequate in complete protein and important micronutrients (namely Ca, Fe, Zn, vitamin A and folate). Current public health recommendations for pregnant women in Israel, a high-income country, are suited for a population that has moved beyond the receding famine stage of the nutrition transition and is not at risk of an inadequate intake of multiple nutrients. These recommendations may thus not adequately address the needs of women who are experiencing overlapping nutrition transition stages, and the co-existing problems of inadequate nutrient intakes and an increasing risk of obesity.
Acknowledgements
This research was supported by a grant from the Israel National Institute for Health Services and Health Policy Research (grant no. 03/136/A), and funds from the S. Daniel Abraham International Center for Health and Nutrition, Faculty of Health Sciences, Ben-Gurion University of the Negev, Israel. The authors would like to thank Douglas Midthune of the National Cancer Institute for his invaluable programming and analysis support. The contributions of the authors to the present study were as follows: K. A.-S. and D. F. designed and conducted the research; K. A.-S., D. R. S., L. S. F. and M. F. developed and carried out the data analysis plan; K. A.-S., H. V. and A. B. performed the statistical analyses; K. A.-S., D. R. S. and L. S. F. wrote the paper; and K. A.-S. had primary responsibility for the final content. All authors read and approved the final manuscript. The authors declare that there are no conflicts of interest in relation to this study.